Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There should be more partial-private options in health and education

186 replies

Middlelanehogger · 12/07/2023 21:28

People often say that for social mobility reasons we should abolish private schools or private hospitals as it's unfair that there's "one system for the rich, one for the poor".

However I think this thinking is backward. We should encourage more gradual step-ups that enable people to slowly inject more of their own personal money into the system as they move up the income ladder and become able to do so.

For example, currently I have the choice to go to my underfunded, busy NHS GP, or a completely private GP and pay the full costs. Likewise I could send my kids to state school or go completely private.

Great if you can afford the "completely private" option.

But there isn't an intermediate option. In Australia for example, you get a govt rebate of say $30 for every GP appt. This covers a basic GP, or you could apply it towards a more expensive GP with a nicer waiting room or late operating hours etc that costs say $50 (i.e. you only pay the $20 difference, vs $0 in the free option).

In the UK you either pay £0 or £50. There's no £20 option.

In the Australian system, the health system overall gets an extra $20 that wasn't there before (from the extra top-up), and more people are able to access the nicer services (because more people can afford $20 than $50).

There's a similar argument to be made for private education. Why can you not "move" your state school funding to a private school to offset the costs? It would allow a smoother mixing along income levels instead of the harsh cutoff/separation we have today.

Eliminating inequality is completely impossible due to human nature, but keeping a harsh separation between "the rich" and "the poors" also isn't the answer. It just keeps "the rich" even more in their bubble.

OP posts:
EmeraldFox · 14/07/2023 15:07

In Australia I used to go to a GP who took some bulk-billed patients (i.e. free) and some who paid extra. I paid extra (and got some conveniences like late appointments) but the money went to the overall practice which was used by people from a range of walks of life.

How long ago and where? I have family unable to find any surgery nearby that still offers bulk billing to adults without a healthcare card. Seeing a doctor is something they only do when desperate as they can't afford it.

EmeraldFox · 14/07/2023 14:58

Do88byisfree · 13/07/2023 07:09

In Australia I paid $99.50 for a GP appointment this week (2 week wait as non urgent) I only get $41 back from the government. But have to pay the full amount and the refund comes back 24-48 hours later.
No GPs in my area offer bilk billing (fully funded) to new patients.
I can afford it -- but I wonder what happens to the patients who can't.

They don't go, unless they are healthcare card holders and offered bulk billing so they don't have to pay. I imagine it would result in more people showing in to the emergency dept instead.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 14:54

LolaSmiles · 14/07/2023 14:41

It’s always a price worth paying when other people have to pay it
Exactly this.

I'm not a fan of the politics of envy and think it's right that people have the option to make a range of choices for their own situations, but feel very very uncomfortable with any suggestion that basic services should be stripped back more and more in order to increase privatisation.

It has a nasty undertone of the undeserving poor attached to it.

‘Other people’

Those that take the tax burden, that is true many posts offering up rises for other people.

jgw1 · 14/07/2023 14:52

LolaSmiles · 14/07/2023 14:41

It’s always a price worth paying when other people have to pay it
Exactly this.

I'm not a fan of the politics of envy and think it's right that people have the option to make a range of choices for their own situations, but feel very very uncomfortable with any suggestion that basic services should be stripped back more and more in order to increase privatisation.

It has a nasty undertone of the undeserving poor attached to it.

And invariably comes from people who pay a lower proportion of their income in taxes than the underserving poor. See for example the current Prime Minister.

LolaSmiles · 14/07/2023 14:41

It’s always a price worth paying when other people have to pay it
Exactly this.

I'm not a fan of the politics of envy and think it's right that people have the option to make a range of choices for their own situations, but feel very very uncomfortable with any suggestion that basic services should be stripped back more and more in order to increase privatisation.

It has a nasty undertone of the undeserving poor attached to it.

jgw1 · 14/07/2023 14:28

Notinmynamethx · 14/07/2023 08:41

What you're describing is what already happens! More income = higher rate of tax and NI which is meant to fund these things. They aren't free, they're free at point of use, and we're all being shafted into thinking ideas like this would help.

If more income = higher rate of tax, could you explain how the Prime Minister pays a lower rate of tax on his income than nurses and teachers do?

Badbadbunny · 14/07/2023 11:27

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2023 11:17

Never understood why the NHS and schools aren't free to offer "private" services alongside the state services.

Because one of the basic tenets of the NHS is “free at the point of use”.

Our local hospital has a private wing used by its clinicians for their private patients. The profits from the hotel element are used to subsidise its main work. It’s a tiny amount though.

That doesn't stop "subsidised" services/treatments in dentists and opticians though, does it, nor does it stop GPs from charging for "extras" such as insurance letters, death certifications, etc. Allegedly, none of that affects the "free at point of use" services they also offer.

GPs also aren't shy about referrals to private healthcare providers, such as podiatry, consultants, physiotherapy etc.

It's just political ideology that "everything" has to be free at the point of use. I think if we want to save the NHS, we need to a move towards a system where the basics are free at point of use, but enhanced services (such as a private room or a standing/open MRI scan or hearing aids with more functions or a white filling or choice of convenient appointment times etc) are available at a cost to generate revenue into the NHS instead of private firms fat cat owners!

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2023 11:25

It’s always a price worth paying when other people have to pay it.

LolaSmiles · 14/07/2023 11:23

This is what the op is suggesting - a minimum level that effective and appropriate for all, but also options to ‘upgrade’.
No, what they're suggesting is that if current services are a 3/10 then it's acceptable for services to drop to 1/10 for those at the very bottom, those who are the poorest, those who are the most marginalised, those who are least likely to have the ability to fight for appropriate services.

Apparently that's fine and a price worth paying.

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2023 11:17

Never understood why the NHS and schools aren't free to offer "private" services alongside the state services.

Because one of the basic tenets of the NHS is “free at the point of use”.

Our local hospital has a private wing used by its clinicians for their private patients. The profits from the hotel element are used to subsidise its main work. It’s a tiny amount though.

Badbadbunny · 14/07/2023 10:56

Never understood why the NHS and schools aren't free to offer "private" services alongside the state services. They could actually make "profit" themselves which they could use to subsidise the "free" services to all.

Take hearing aids. On the NHS you get bog standard ones, that are fine for some people but pretty useless for some too! If you want better, you have to go private, and then some fat cat somewhere makes a few hundred pounds in profit for basically doing sod all. Why can't the NHS audiology dept "sell" those better hearing aids at a price between cost and private price, thus making a profit, albeit smaller, which would go into NHS coffers? What's worse is that you don't know the NHS ones are going to be pretty poor for you until you've gone through the NHS audiology consultations etc and issued with NHS hearing aids - if they're useless, that's NHS money wasted as they won't take them back. Then you go private, and you have another hearing test, consultation, etc., and get a better quality hearing aid, which IS on "sale or return" so if it works, you pay, if it doesn't, you hand it back and they "sell" it to someone else. No waste!

Same with, say, private rooms in NHS hospitals. OK, over-riding factor has to be patient in greatest "need" for a private room, i.e. mental or clinical or safeguarding "need". But when there's no one in particular "need", rather than it being a random free for all as to who gets a private room, why not make a charge for it, so that the NHS gets some income, all on the proviso, that you have to vacate (and get a refund) if someone else has a greater "need" for the room.

After all, look at dentists and opticians - you get "basic" NHS treatment/services at modest cost (or free if you qualify due to benefits, age, etc), but you can "trade up" to a better colour/quality of filling or dental bridge, or better quality of spectacle lens/frame, etc., by paying more.

In education, we already have "extras" paid for privately, such as musical instrument tuition, extracurricula sports, additional languages, etc., where parents pay for the casual/part time teachers but often still use the school's facilities such as classrooms, gym, hall, etc. Some schools charge third parties for facilities rental, i.e. gyms and halls for local dance clubs or sports clubs, etc.

I just don't think we, as a country, have properly explored letting and encouraging public service bodies such as schools, hospitals, etc to actually act more like businesses and make better use of their facilities, staffing, etc., to offer and charge for "extras" which can bring in valuable revenue used to supplement and subsidise their "free" public services. If people are going to pay privately, then far better for them to pay, say, your school or the NHS directly, so the school/NHS makes the profit!

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 10:37

@LolaSmiles Private companies are most definitely not interested in "running the services nobody wants". Do you have any idea of how capitalism works...?

Currently we are trapped in a system where 90% of the population is the underclass receiving subpar service with no way to improve it for themselves. The rich ALREADY HAVE THE SUPERIOR SERVICE RIGHT NOW.

@Notinmynamethx I have a high income which is purely personal income (i.e. no companies or offshore accounts involved) so I pay a high rate of tax for... the exact same service. I'm talking about paying more to actually get more service.

OP posts:
Labraradabrador · 14/07/2023 10:34

@LolaSmiles There should be a minimum level of public services that is effective and appropriate. Anyone deciding that this should be ripped up and the most marginalised should be trapped in a system with an offer that's substantially worse than current services is either naïve or heartless in my opinion

This is what the op is suggesting - a minimum level that effective and appropriate for all, but also options to ‘upgrade’. The revenue from people willing to upgrade partially subsidises the basic option, and you end up with better facilities, better equipment, properly paid professionals who stay in service (and more of them). I understand the scepticism, but there are mechanisms to ensure this happens - lots of countries do so with varying levels of success, and some do it very well.

I think the bigger issue is a cultural one - the British would have to accept inequality. Yes, inequality already exists, but we don’t accept it. The principle of equality is sacred, especially around healthcare. The brits would rather have a shit system for all / raise barriers to private until only the mega wealthy can find alternatives than accept that inequality is inevitable.

Notinmynamethx · 14/07/2023 08:41

What you're describing is what already happens! More income = higher rate of tax and NI which is meant to fund these things. They aren't free, they're free at point of use, and we're all being shafted into thinking ideas like this would help.

LolaSmiles · 14/07/2023 08:38

So what's the point in being "rich" then? Why would people work hard to get qualifications, promotions, to get higher paid jobs, often with stress and longer hours if they couldn't benefit?
People who are already rich, even higher middle income, have plenty of benefits and options.

It doesn't mean it's a great idea to deliberately design a system like the OP proposes on the principle that entrenching an underclass is an acceptable thing to do.

There should be a minimum level of public services that is effective and appropriate. Anyone deciding that this should be ripped up and the most marginalised should be trapped in a system with an offer that's substantially worse than current services is either naïve or heartless in my opinion.

The very rich, like the current government, really do not care about middle and lower income families. Dismantling public services might sound good to those who will probably get by ok, but they'll be next in the firing line when other services, working terms and conditions, union participation etc become the next target of attack.

I also suspect we'd also end up seeing price increases to match the taxpayer voucher value and then private companies (probably with links to the right people) charging extortionate amounts to the taxpayer to run the services nobody else wants. It would be yet another way of redistributing taxpayer money into the pockets of very rich political donors.

Phineyj · 14/07/2023 08:10

Healthcare in the UK isn't a zero sum game. I've had about 6 procedures with private docs (endometriosis, varicose veins). Both docs are well beyond state retirement age. They each do a list a week in NHS which I have no hope of getting onto without waiting years. If they hadn't operated on me, my place would have been taken by another private patient; not an NHS one. Care was all in private hospitals.

If they were forbidden from working privately I guess they'd retire (or work privately in their countries of origin).

Private adds to the overall capacity.

phoenixrosehere · 14/07/2023 07:46

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 07:07

US is an extreme case and it's annoying that it's so often trotted out as the alternative instead of looking at all the other countries who don't have an NHS but also nothing like the US system.

Agree and never understood why it’s always used to compare considering the vast difference of population and the differing laws and practices between each state other as than another moan about the country especially by posters who have never stepped one foot there or have experienced the system themselves.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 07:22

Middlelanehogger · 13/07/2023 21:12

There isn't a world where there's only one system that the rich have to participate in. Ban public schools and people will just go back to private governesses...

My employer was so irritated by staff absences involving the NHS that they brought in a private GP just for our staff who sits in our building and we just email for an appointment that we can get within hours, same day.

This is the kind of thing that's available already today... for some.

In Australia I used to go to a GP who took some bulk-billed patients (i.e. free) and some who paid extra. I paid extra (and got some conveniences like late appointments) but the money went to the overall practice which was used by people from a range of walks of life.

In the UK I just ignore the existence of the NHS GP and wouldn't be affected if they went away tomorrow.

I don't think that makes for a better more caring more integrated society.

Other countries do manage it and avoid some of the negatives mentioned below

If it effectively brings more into education or healthcare overall as more people add extra then it can be a good thing

People want to strip this away atm by making private harder to access so similar tax rebates would go down badly. Basically even if it works well they wouldn’t vote for it.

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2023 07:16

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 07:06

So what's the point in being "rich" then? Why would people work hard to get qualifications, promotions, to get higher paid jobs, often with stress and longer hours if they couldn't benefit?

They can. There’s this thing called private healthcare those of us who can afford it can use if we choose. It’s particularly useful if you need an operation because you can jump the queue and get operated on more quickly than the people who can’t afford it by the same doctor.

AuntieJune · 14/07/2023 07:15

Because the people who couldn't afford to top up would be left with shitter service. Worse schools. Worse doctors. Wider inequality.

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 07:07

User98866 · 13/07/2023 21:22

I wouldn’t want private care being normalised. I think we are moving into dangerous territory in thinking that private healthcare is ‘better’. Obviously the NHS is in a state but healthcare being profit driven can never truly work in the best interests of the patients. You end up with up with unnecessary prescriptions/treatments/ testing and unscrupulous medics. Just look at the USA.

US is an extreme case and it's annoying that it's so often trotted out as the alternative instead of looking at all the other countries who don't have an NHS but also nothing like the US system.

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 07:06

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/07/2023 21:18

The problem is that if only the poor use the free service, it no longer matters to politicians and it will quickly become sub standard. While those who are slightly better off get a much better service that is subsidised.

The poor are already disadvantaged in so many ways - we need to be getting the rich to use the same services as everyone else, not getting rid of the poor to their own rubbish service.

So what's the point in being "rich" then? Why would people work hard to get qualifications, promotions, to get higher paid jobs, often with stress and longer hours if they couldn't benefit?

NumberTheory · 13/07/2023 22:23

Middlelanehogger · 13/07/2023 21:49

@SnackSizeRaisin Purposely deciding to give poor people worse healthcare and education than they currently get, so that better off people benefit, is a disgusting attitude frankly.

That's... not what I suggested?

"Allow people to inject some of their own money into the system to get additional marginal benefit for themselves at their own cost" doesn't map to what you're saying at all.

whether it’s what you want or not, it’s what happens. If you can get current average education from the state, or supplement by £200 a month and get 30% better education then the people who can afford it and can get accepted pay the £200 a month and the education that’s left for those who can’t pay goes down hill. In part because the harder to educate kids won’t be accepted for just £200/month so far more of them are left for the state to educate. But also because, once you’re getting a subsidy of X to buy the education you want, there’s more incentive to pressure politicians to cut funding and taxes by X and just pay for what you want yourself. This leaves behind those who can’t afford to pay.

Eventually, in real terms the subsidy from the state goes down and the privately funded proportion goes up and those who can’t afford to pay are screwed over.

snowdropparty · 13/07/2023 22:03

Benenden has served us well for health and only 11 pounds a month.

jgw1 · 13/07/2023 22:00

Middlelanehogger · 13/07/2023 21:49

@SnackSizeRaisin Purposely deciding to give poor people worse healthcare and education than they currently get, so that better off people benefit, is a disgusting attitude frankly.

That's... not what I suggested?

"Allow people to inject some of their own money into the system to get additional marginal benefit for themselves at their own cost" doesn't map to what you're saying at all.

If I paid for my daughters heart surgery to happen sooner than it would otherwise, what happens to the person who is due to have surgery whose place she has taken?
If I someone is paying for that heart surgery, what happens if someone is born needing heart surgery, since we have paid do we keep the date and let them take their chances?
If I've paid for an intensive care bed for my daughter for the night, then she gets to use it and never mind the victim of the hit and run who comes in?

Yup a hugely well thought out plan.

Swipe left for the next trending thread