Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There should be more partial-private options in health and education

186 replies

Middlelanehogger · 12/07/2023 21:28

People often say that for social mobility reasons we should abolish private schools or private hospitals as it's unfair that there's "one system for the rich, one for the poor".

However I think this thinking is backward. We should encourage more gradual step-ups that enable people to slowly inject more of their own personal money into the system as they move up the income ladder and become able to do so.

For example, currently I have the choice to go to my underfunded, busy NHS GP, or a completely private GP and pay the full costs. Likewise I could send my kids to state school or go completely private.

Great if you can afford the "completely private" option.

But there isn't an intermediate option. In Australia for example, you get a govt rebate of say $30 for every GP appt. This covers a basic GP, or you could apply it towards a more expensive GP with a nicer waiting room or late operating hours etc that costs say $50 (i.e. you only pay the $20 difference, vs $0 in the free option).

In the UK you either pay £0 or £50. There's no £20 option.

In the Australian system, the health system overall gets an extra $20 that wasn't there before (from the extra top-up), and more people are able to access the nicer services (because more people can afford $20 than $50).

There's a similar argument to be made for private education. Why can you not "move" your state school funding to a private school to offset the costs? It would allow a smoother mixing along income levels instead of the harsh cutoff/separation we have today.

Eliminating inequality is completely impossible due to human nature, but keeping a harsh separation between "the rich" and "the poors" also isn't the answer. It just keeps "the rich" even more in their bubble.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 14/07/2023 20:33

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 20:14

Is this based on outcomes from other countries?

Quite a few have mixed systems does it move them towards higher inequality?

From what I recall of my economics courses, though I can’t quote the papers etc. - In general, where state provision allows people to add on or where it only covers a minority of people, the base provision by the state goes down over time.

Of course there are also lots of other things that can influence state provision and wealth inequality. If you want to tackle those things you need to look at the whole system. But since we are only talking about this one lever, it is not likely to decrease inequality.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 20:16

Also if you’re going to do private and state mix you’re probably better off not lumbering people for decades with increased costs as PFI did

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 20:14

NumberTheory · 14/07/2023 19:41

Your proposed approach will increase the number of people who can buy their way better but it will decrease the resources for those with low incomes. So it would, overall increase inequality.

Is this based on outcomes from other countries?

Quite a few have mixed systems does it move them towards higher inequality?

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 20:07

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2023 20:05

PFI being used to pay for all those shiny new schools and hospitals that our children will be paying for.

Most of them are 30 year contracts so unlikely.

Thank God we have them, imagine the state the NHS would be in now, if they d never been built?

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 20:06

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 20:03

Bluntly, I'm solving for "stable and fair society", not "society with the lowest absolute inequality".

As it happens I believe that very high levels of inequality, combined with a sense that one's personal situation is impossible to change within the existing system, does contribute to instability in society (if people feel the only way out is riots & revolution).

So I don't want to increase inequality just to be a bitch.

But I do want to increase mobility up the scale (and yes, this does imply the possibility of slides down). That is how to address the italic part of the statement above. Which is just as important as the first.

Best way and its widely acknowledged to do so, is to improve educational attainment for all & that means spending the sorts of money on state as is spent in the private sector.

Even now, the most likely to missing out on an education are the kids on free school meals.

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2023 20:05

PFI being used to pay for all those shiny new schools and hospitals that our children will be paying for.

Most of them are 30 year contracts so unlikely.

drspouse · 14/07/2023 20:05

In the UK you can top up state education with paid tuition or move close to a very good school or pay for 11+ tuition.

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 20:03

RainRains · 14/07/2023 19:53

Because the people who pay for private schools also pay the tax? But sorry, I forgot - this is MN, so cannot possibly have the ‘rich’ people benefitting from any of the tax they pay….

No one is suggesting we get rid of private schools or private hospitals & not everyone who uses private schools pay tax in the UK either, my brother never did, yet his wife and family benefitted greatly from what other tax payers here in the UK paid.

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 20:03

Bluntly, I'm solving for "stable and fair society", not "society with the lowest absolute inequality".

As it happens I believe that very high levels of inequality, combined with a sense that one's personal situation is impossible to change within the existing system, does contribute to instability in society (if people feel the only way out is riots & revolution).

So I don't want to increase inequality just to be a bitch.

But I do want to increase mobility up the scale (and yes, this does imply the possibility of slides down). That is how to address the italic part of the statement above. Which is just as important as the first.

OP posts:
RainRains · 14/07/2023 19:53

Maireas · 13/07/2023 05:55

Why should taxpayers fund private schools? They're not for the benefit of everyone.

Because the people who pay for private schools also pay the tax? But sorry, I forgot - this is MN, so cannot possibly have the ‘rich’ people benefitting from any of the tax they pay….

NumberTheory · 14/07/2023 19:41

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 19:23

@Chocolatefreak Division within society is what creates discontent. The most volatile countries in the world are where inequality is highest - this can be money, but also opportunity, power etc.

My point is that we already have this division and are simply entrenching it even further by insisting that the two systems stay worlds apart from each other.

Your proposed approach will increase the number of people who can buy their way better but it will decrease the resources for those with low incomes. So it would, overall increase inequality.

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 19:30

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 19:23

@Chocolatefreak Division within society is what creates discontent. The most volatile countries in the world are where inequality is highest - this can be money, but also opportunity, power etc.

My point is that we already have this division and are simply entrenching it even further by insisting that the two systems stay worlds apart from each other.

They are not worlds apart, the private insurance sector leach off the NHS for staff and experience and take the easiest and most profitable treatments, they don't do AE, wont treat chronic conditions and stay well away from majority of cancers... and when they screw up, its the local NHS they send their patients to be fixed, in our local Nuffield's case, they don't even have their own MRI scanners, using the NHS ones instead.

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 19:23

@Chocolatefreak Division within society is what creates discontent. The most volatile countries in the world are where inequality is highest - this can be money, but also opportunity, power etc.

My point is that we already have this division and are simply entrenching it even further by insisting that the two systems stay worlds apart from each other.

OP posts:
jgw1 · 14/07/2023 18:59

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 18:57

Yes, but the costs are spread out over many years, so basically kicking the can down the road instead of paying up front and thus avoiding the costs adding to the national debt. As I say, like PFI being used to pay for all those shiny new schools and hospitals that our children will be paying for.

I am glad we are in agreement that the poster who said that the taxpayer didn't pay for modern stock of trains is mistaken.

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 18:57

jgw1 · 14/07/2023 16:10

The taxpayer did pay for the trains though, but in addition also paid billions in dividends to private companies that could have been further invested in the UK railways, rather than being a subsidy to the Italian and German railways.

Yes, but the costs are spread out over many years, so basically kicking the can down the road instead of paying up front and thus avoiding the costs adding to the national debt. As I say, like PFI being used to pay for all those shiny new schools and hospitals that our children will be paying for.

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 18:14

NamelessNancy · 14/07/2023 15:30

Paying more for better seems perfectly fine to me when it comes to transport, leisure, housing etc. For health and education? No thanks. Just entrenches inequality imo.

These things in the main are not publicly funded though.

Wealthy folk can already by-pass the state systems and these private concerns contribute little/nothing towards the costs of the staff the state sector has trained and given experience too.

All a bit one sided, lets see the private sector fund the training of their own staff and then see if their economic model is sustainable?

Inequality is there because the average person has to wait 2 years for new hip, give up work and go on benefits because the wealthy simply do not pay enough tax or in the case of companies, decent wages, favouring the shareholder instead.

bellsbuss · 14/07/2023 18:13

Yes I think that would be a good system , we've taken out private health care because I truly believe you cannot rely on the NHS anymore.

Chocolatefreak · 14/07/2023 17:58

The whole idea of public health and education is not just for the education and health part, it is for the social benefit. Inclusive, well-funded services benefit everybody, leading to stable, productive, peaceful societies. Division within society is what creates discontent. The most volatile countries in the world are where inequality is highest - this can be money, but also opportunity, power etc.

Ideally, education, health, water and transport would be properly funded, serving the population and leaving no real incentive to opt for private except for vanity.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 16:31

I can’t compare old state services but to other countries that do different models, they can benefit from extra money pumped in to the overall system via incentives like tax rebates

The opposite to trying to burden the state system more by making private more inaccessible.

jgw1 · 14/07/2023 16:10

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 16:03

Railways is an outsider with that list as pre-privatisation, we had a very old "fleet" of trains which needed replacement as not only were they old, they were non compliant with health & safety, and disability laws. Had it not been privatised, the taxpayer would have had to pay for the modern stock with wider/sliding doors, larger toilets, on board display screens, etc., which costs millions per carriage. Privatising it all was a way to get that cost off the Govt balance sheet and paid for using private monies. It was basically similar to the PFI for schools and hospitals - just smoke and mirrors to get debt of the govt's balance sheet to make our huge borrowing deficit to look better than it really is.

The taxpayer did pay for the trains though, but in addition also paid billions in dividends to private companies that could have been further invested in the UK railways, rather than being a subsidy to the Italian and German railways.

Kazzyhoward · 14/07/2023 16:03

jgw1 · 14/07/2023 15:31

Can we all stop and pause a moment to consider whether the cost to us and generally to taxpayers of various privatised industries is better or worse than before privatisation? Is the quality of service better or worse?

Water?
Gas?
Electricity?
Railways?

What does history tell us will be the result of privatising healthcare?

Railways is an outsider with that list as pre-privatisation, we had a very old "fleet" of trains which needed replacement as not only were they old, they were non compliant with health & safety, and disability laws. Had it not been privatised, the taxpayer would have had to pay for the modern stock with wider/sliding doors, larger toilets, on board display screens, etc., which costs millions per carriage. Privatising it all was a way to get that cost off the Govt balance sheet and paid for using private monies. It was basically similar to the PFI for schools and hospitals - just smoke and mirrors to get debt of the govt's balance sheet to make our huge borrowing deficit to look better than it really is.

jgw1 · 14/07/2023 15:31

Can we all stop and pause a moment to consider whether the cost to us and generally to taxpayers of various privatised industries is better or worse than before privatisation? Is the quality of service better or worse?

Water?
Gas?
Electricity?
Railways?

What does history tell us will be the result of privatising healthcare?

NamelessNancy · 14/07/2023 15:30

Paying more for better seems perfectly fine to me when it comes to transport, leisure, housing etc. For health and education? No thanks. Just entrenches inequality imo.

sleepyscientist · 14/07/2023 15:23

LolaSmiles · 14/07/2023 11:23

This is what the op is suggesting - a minimum level that effective and appropriate for all, but also options to ‘upgrade’.
No, what they're suggesting is that if current services are a 3/10 then it's acceptable for services to drop to 1/10 for those at the very bottom, those who are the poorest, those who are the most marginalised, those who are least likely to have the ability to fight for appropriate services.

Apparently that's fine and a price worth paying.

That not necessarily true as the NHS is so regulated by government with no share holders. The government could allow the NHS to offer upgraded service such as out of hours routine appointments with a set premium for staff providing them like now that comes out of the money and the rest invested back into free services. It's also things like minor cosmetic services I got two moles removed but GP isn't allowed remove the skin tag within the same area at the same time as it's cosmetic. I got it removed privately for £450 most of which would be profit that could have been fed back into the system.

Longer term you could look at things like hotel services and for non cancer/life saving surgery the option to run two lists side by side so if it's a 24 month wait for X you could say charge a set fee of maybe 2k to go on the fast track list from which 2 patient are on the theatre list per day vs 1 from the standard list. Those small amounts soon add up to money that can be reinvested back into services.

Our dentist now offers both NHS and private services. I rang for an appointment for DS first one she offered was in school hours 7 weeks from now or I could pay £55 for one on a Saturday 8 days later saving me a mornings annual leave and him missing school so was happy to pay. They never used to be open on a Saturday when I was a kid as it was a total NHS practice so no one is losing out.

Schools is the same they already largely select by house price so allowing top ups or allowing parents to use the money that would have been sent to that outstanding school as a part payment on fees only enhances the experience of poor pupils. They either benefit from the investment of wealthier parents or get a place they wouldn't have been in catchment for if like Harry who is now off to private went to that outstanding school down the road from his parents house.

ZiriForEver · 14/07/2023 15:12

It is a very slippery slope. The result would be that the current quality would be available at the co-paid level, and the free level would turn to be much worse than now.