Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There should be more partial-private options in health and education

186 replies

Middlelanehogger · 12/07/2023 21:28

People often say that for social mobility reasons we should abolish private schools or private hospitals as it's unfair that there's "one system for the rich, one for the poor".

However I think this thinking is backward. We should encourage more gradual step-ups that enable people to slowly inject more of their own personal money into the system as they move up the income ladder and become able to do so.

For example, currently I have the choice to go to my underfunded, busy NHS GP, or a completely private GP and pay the full costs. Likewise I could send my kids to state school or go completely private.

Great if you can afford the "completely private" option.

But there isn't an intermediate option. In Australia for example, you get a govt rebate of say $30 for every GP appt. This covers a basic GP, or you could apply it towards a more expensive GP with a nicer waiting room or late operating hours etc that costs say $50 (i.e. you only pay the $20 difference, vs $0 in the free option).

In the UK you either pay £0 or £50. There's no £20 option.

In the Australian system, the health system overall gets an extra $20 that wasn't there before (from the extra top-up), and more people are able to access the nicer services (because more people can afford $20 than $50).

There's a similar argument to be made for private education. Why can you not "move" your state school funding to a private school to offset the costs? It would allow a smoother mixing along income levels instead of the harsh cutoff/separation we have today.

Eliminating inequality is completely impossible due to human nature, but keeping a harsh separation between "the rich" and "the poors" also isn't the answer. It just keeps "the rich" even more in their bubble.

OP posts:
StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 08:46

One way to look at is there’s an amount of money sloshing around that people spend on holidays, food, going out whatever

And a healthcare budget which is via the state

Incentives that pull more money from those with disposable income to health care can work, other countries do it. Not really impacting on inequality

People are more resistant here as we’re not used to it, but successful approaches from o/s can be emulated without full reform

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 08:41

But yes, essentially we come to the core ethical dilemma which is

A) treat more people, but you have an unequal chance of being the one to receive treatment

B) treat fewer people, but everyone equally has the chance to be the one to receive it

Which one is preferable depends on the actual hard difference in numbers. We all lean one way or the other based on gut instinct. But I'd argue the NHS can adequately treat so few people now that we need to move the system more towards A, even if that does mean an increase in absolute inequality at the boundaries.

OP posts:
jgw1 · 15/07/2023 08:38

Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 08:32

@jgw1 i am not going to join you in your rabbit hole. The reality acknowledged by pretty much everyone is that the nhs is pretty chronically underfunded, has crumbling infrastructure and outside of a few flagship investments, is massively behind its neighbours when it comes to innovative medicine being available to those that would benefit.

The question is how to fix this. Some of us believe better integration of public and private, alongside active revenue generation in the form of nominal fees and an ability to purchase benefits that matter to you (like a gp appointment you can put in your work diary or a private room or a better knee replacement) is going to be a critical element in addressing the funding gap. It doesn’t have to be any more unfair than the current setup - loads of people would have access to better care instead of just the top 10% and state resources could be prioritised for the truly vulnerable.

The reality is the UK is well on the road to privatisation - increasing numbers are taking up private health insurance or paying full whack when they realise how dire things are. The real question is whether the public system can take advantage of an increasing willingness to pay for healthcare.

Its not a pretty train of thought to follow is it, because allowing someone to pay for surgery has meant that a newborn whose clinical need was greater died when they could have survived and led a fulfilling life. Such though is the world that those who advocate private healthcare aspire to.

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 08:35

In my proposed universe more people stay as doctors because they actually have a chance of earning a decent salary in a private system.

"The private system would steal all the NHS-trained doctors"

Sorry, but where do you think NHS-trained doctors go today? Not into the NHS, they all quit after 2 years and go work for bloody management consultancies. I know, because I work with them! At least if they got poached by a private hospital, they'd still be available to do surgeries for people, relieving pressure off the waiting lists!

OP posts:
Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 08:32

@jgw1 i am not going to join you in your rabbit hole. The reality acknowledged by pretty much everyone is that the nhs is pretty chronically underfunded, has crumbling infrastructure and outside of a few flagship investments, is massively behind its neighbours when it comes to innovative medicine being available to those that would benefit.

The question is how to fix this. Some of us believe better integration of public and private, alongside active revenue generation in the form of nominal fees and an ability to purchase benefits that matter to you (like a gp appointment you can put in your work diary or a private room or a better knee replacement) is going to be a critical element in addressing the funding gap. It doesn’t have to be any more unfair than the current setup - loads of people would have access to better care instead of just the top 10% and state resources could be prioritised for the truly vulnerable.

The reality is the UK is well on the road to privatisation - increasing numbers are taking up private health insurance or paying full whack when they realise how dire things are. The real question is whether the public system can take advantage of an increasing willingness to pay for healthcare.

jgw1 · 15/07/2023 07:52

sleepyscientist · 15/07/2023 07:20

@jgw1 as you have paid the baby goes first on the morning list but your 10k is used to staff the operating theatre out of core hours with the ST8 performing one or more of the surgeries from that day.

To get the PICU bed you can look to bring in extra staff to either step down one the patients that isn't ready for a normal ward ratio but could say go to PHDU if more staff were available. If you can't do that offer out a locum shift to run one of the recovery beds as a ITU or if you have an adult bed free someone goes to ITU with appropriate staffing cover from the 10k.

The NHS is the master of doing more with less resources, doing more with more resources would be a walk in the park.

@sleepyscientist could you just help me with a few details. Who is going to staff the operating theatre outside of core hours?

The surgical team has been operating on the patient for 7 hours. The lead surgeon and consultant anaesthetist started work around 7am, they were able to hand over to PICU at 4.30pm. Around 7pm they spend some time with the family of the patient explaining what they have and haven't been able to achieve. Are you suggesting that at this point they start surgery on the next patient on the list?

Where are you finding the extra PICU staff from?

Unfortunately the theatres and hence recovery room is on a different floor from PICU, so using the recovery room as an auxillary PICU, would not just require two additional suitably qualified nurses, but also an additional consultant intensivist. So that is non starter.

There is a spare suitable adult ICU bed in the next city 70 miles away. When is there a KIDS/NTS ambulance available for the transfer? Presumably you have to move a non-paying patient, they will then need to be returned to the children's hospital for futher ongoing care on the ward as their condition improves.

sleepyscientist · 15/07/2023 07:20

@jgw1 as you have paid the baby goes first on the morning list but your 10k is used to staff the operating theatre out of core hours with the ST8 performing one or more of the surgeries from that day.

To get the PICU bed you can look to bring in extra staff to either step down one the patients that isn't ready for a normal ward ratio but could say go to PHDU if more staff were available. If you can't do that offer out a locum shift to run one of the recovery beds as a ITU or if you have an adult bed free someone goes to ITU with appropriate staffing cover from the 10k.

The NHS is the master of doing more with less resources, doing more with more resources would be a walk in the park.

jgw1 · 15/07/2023 06:43

Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 00:56

@jgw1 the exact stats you are looking for are difficult to collect, which I suspect is the straw man behind your argument. Can’t precisely prove you wrong, so maybe you are right?

But then most developed countries are better resourced than the uk. The UK has one of the lowest ratios of cardiologists per million population amongst developed countries. Getting basic diagnostics done in the uk takes weeks or months, while in other countries it is more typically weeks or days. Other countries operate with far more slack in the system than the UK - we can quibble over exactly how to measure paediatric cardiac capacity, but in most developed countries there wouldn’t have to be a choice between patients in need.

My daughter was a patient in the UK in a hybrid cardiac operating theatre 11 years ago. Spain's first similar operating theatre opened in 2020 (Barcelona) Israel's 2022.

I will ask you again which countries (noting there are some of our near neighbours who don't have the facilities at all) have such theatres that are usable on demand by a paying customer, without the need for clinicians to make a choice between patients?

Phineyj · 15/07/2023 06:27

I think the insight missing from this thread is that you can have a public commitment to e.g. universal access to healthcare without it having to be provided directly by a government funded monopoly. There are examples of this round the world that we could adapt.

I think the previous poster(s) nailed it though when they said the UK is now too poor to make such a change.

We have got too many people who wouldn't be able to pay anything at all into e.g. a social insurance system and without the time or skills to handle a system where you need to shop around a bit, so we are stuck with what we've got. Especially as politicians don't dare touch it.

Nat6999 · 15/07/2023 04:00

I pay in to Benedon, £12.95 a month, which means if I need a common operation other than joint replacement or heart surgery & have to wait longer than 5 weeks on the NHS, I can go private.

ThinWomansBrain · 15/07/2023 01:39

private schools get charitable tax relief.

Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 00:56

@jgw1 the exact stats you are looking for are difficult to collect, which I suspect is the straw man behind your argument. Can’t precisely prove you wrong, so maybe you are right?

But then most developed countries are better resourced than the uk. The UK has one of the lowest ratios of cardiologists per million population amongst developed countries. Getting basic diagnostics done in the uk takes weeks or months, while in other countries it is more typically weeks or days. Other countries operate with far more slack in the system than the UK - we can quibble over exactly how to measure paediatric cardiac capacity, but in most developed countries there wouldn’t have to be a choice between patients in need.

ZiriForEver · 15/07/2023 00:40

The issue is, that the health care is very expensive to set up, operate, scale and keep ready even when noone needs it. We can speak about costs of having the health care ready and cost of using it at the specific moment.

At veterinary medicine it is clearer. In human medicine lots of the "going private" is in reality only about bribing the doctor for jumping the queue, using the very same resources as everyone else, when the base costs for having them are already paid from the shared pot.

I understand that current state of NHS is terrifying and people would like to find a way how to get something better, but the only way which would really lead to something better is pressuring government to get something better for everyone.

jgw1 · 15/07/2023 00:28

Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 00:08

@jgw1 you see it as a fixed pie of healthcare, which makes sense in a state monopoly like the UK, but there are plenty of other countries where there is enough slack in the system to treat everyone in an emergency health crisis. The slack comes from some people paying more for luxury elements (choice of physician vs. assigned, scheduling at convenience vs assigned, choice of implant, extra rehab, on demand access to consultations, etc) which means there are always extra beds, surgeons, surgical theatres, nurses, diagnostic equipment, etc. you don’t choose between the child who needs heart surgery, the newborn or the car accident victim because you can treat them all. Some might have private rooms, some might have better rehab packages, or better aftercare follow up, but all receive critical treatment when they need it.

at the moment we have stroke victims waiting hours for ambulances when every minute counts

A paedicatic cardiac hybrid operating theatre costs millions of pounds to build.

You seem to be proposing having several spare, with the associated surgical teams so that people can choose when they have their operation. This would be close to doubling the current capacity in the UK.

I would be interested to learn which countries you think have such spare capacity?

Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 00:08

@jgw1 you see it as a fixed pie of healthcare, which makes sense in a state monopoly like the UK, but there are plenty of other countries where there is enough slack in the system to treat everyone in an emergency health crisis. The slack comes from some people paying more for luxury elements (choice of physician vs. assigned, scheduling at convenience vs assigned, choice of implant, extra rehab, on demand access to consultations, etc) which means there are always extra beds, surgeons, surgical theatres, nurses, diagnostic equipment, etc. you don’t choose between the child who needs heart surgery, the newborn or the car accident victim because you can treat them all. Some might have private rooms, some might have better rehab packages, or better aftercare follow up, but all receive critical treatment when they need it.

at the moment we have stroke victims waiting hours for ambulances when every minute counts

Labraradabrador · 14/07/2023 23:53

@schooloflostsocks we already have a two tier system. I had a minor foot surgery done privately (via insurance paid by my employers). If I went NHS I would have had to wait YEARS, and it would have had to degrade significantly, with long term impact on my mobility, restrictions on ability to exercise, and significant pain.

instead I went private and had it done within weeks, scheduled at my convenience around work commitments with a surgeon I chose. It was done in a private hospital where I had a private room, catering on demand and concierge services available. Follow up visits and physiotherapy (which NHS would not have offered) were also readily available and scheduled at my convenience. I missed a couple days of work, but otherwise no disruption- definitely worth it for my employer.

the NHS option is absolutely unacceptable for anyone, but what 90% of people in my situation would have had to accept. Not everyone needs (or wants) the platinum option that I received (I didn’t either really), but increasing the number of people getting adequate care surely is a good thing?

jgw1 · 14/07/2023 23:40

Labraradabrador · 14/07/2023 23:34

@Augend23 but in your example, the less fortunate person has a 2 year wait in any case - all the negative consequences are STILL true under our current system. At the moment you can get it done on demand privately for a cost of £10k.

Healthcare is not a finite resource, it responds to the forces of supply and demand. More people paying higher prices would increase the supply, as well as general investment in facilities, tech and staff that benefits all. State resources can then be focused on the smaller subset that really need it.

what the OP suggests doesn’t make it worse in the absolute sense for the poorest, and in fact proper policy would ensure improvements for all, even the poorest. So the person with no financial means gets surgery in 12 months instead to 24, and a whole bunch of others get surgery within 3 months instead of 24, and the wealthy continue to schedule surgery at their convenience with a surgeon and hospital of their choosing.

I asked this earlier in the thread, but no one answered, perhaps you would be so good as to give it a go.

My daughter needs heart surgery. There is a waiting list. Currently those in greatest need get treated first.

If the system proposed existed I could pay for her to have surgery sooner. Lets say I have booked the surgery for next Thursday. The surgeons are booked, the multi-million pound operating theatre, the team of medical professionals, the PICU bed she will be in afterwards is reserved, everything is ready.

On Tuesday of next week a baby is born with a heart defect that needs life saving treatment. Since I have paid for the surgery next Thursday, do they operate on my daughter, or on the newborn?

On the way to school on the Thursday of the surgery there is a bad car accident and a couple of children need intensive care. I have paid for a bed, so presumably my daughter still gets it and her surgery goes ahead? So which of the other two children who need an ICU bed does not get one?

Labraradabrador · 14/07/2023 23:34

@Augend23 but in your example, the less fortunate person has a 2 year wait in any case - all the negative consequences are STILL true under our current system. At the moment you can get it done on demand privately for a cost of £10k.

Healthcare is not a finite resource, it responds to the forces of supply and demand. More people paying higher prices would increase the supply, as well as general investment in facilities, tech and staff that benefits all. State resources can then be focused on the smaller subset that really need it.

what the OP suggests doesn’t make it worse in the absolute sense for the poorest, and in fact proper policy would ensure improvements for all, even the poorest. So the person with no financial means gets surgery in 12 months instead to 24, and a whole bunch of others get surgery within 3 months instead of 24, and the wealthy continue to schedule surgery at their convenience with a surgeon and hospital of their choosing.

Augend23 · 14/07/2023 22:38

sleepyscientist · 14/07/2023 15:23

That not necessarily true as the NHS is so regulated by government with no share holders. The government could allow the NHS to offer upgraded service such as out of hours routine appointments with a set premium for staff providing them like now that comes out of the money and the rest invested back into free services. It's also things like minor cosmetic services I got two moles removed but GP isn't allowed remove the skin tag within the same area at the same time as it's cosmetic. I got it removed privately for £450 most of which would be profit that could have been fed back into the system.

Longer term you could look at things like hotel services and for non cancer/life saving surgery the option to run two lists side by side so if it's a 24 month wait for X you could say charge a set fee of maybe 2k to go on the fast track list from which 2 patient are on the theatre list per day vs 1 from the standard list. Those small amounts soon add up to money that can be reinvested back into services.

Our dentist now offers both NHS and private services. I rang for an appointment for DS first one she offered was in school hours 7 weeks from now or I could pay £55 for one on a Saturday 8 days later saving me a mornings annual leave and him missing school so was happy to pay. They never used to be open on a Saturday when I was a kid as it was a total NHS practice so no one is losing out.

Schools is the same they already largely select by house price so allowing top ups or allowing parents to use the money that would have been sent to that outstanding school as a part payment on fees only enhances the experience of poor pupils. They either benefit from the investment of wealthier parents or get a place they wouldn't have been in catchment for if like Harry who is now off to private went to that outstanding school down the road from his parents house.

Longer term you could look at things like hotel services and for non cancer/life saving surgery the option to run two lists side by side so if it's a 24 month wait for X you could say charge a set fee of maybe 2k to go on the fast track list from which 2 patient are on the theatre list per day vs 1 from the standard list. Those small amounts soon add up to money that can be reinvested back into services

The trouble with this though is you're back to it screwing over the poor.

If you and person A both need a knee replacement. You have 2k so you get yours done in 2 months instead of 2 years. Person A can't afford that. They also have a manual job where they're on their feet all day. They end up having to take time off such, increasing their financial instability. Maybe they have to leave the workforce - their job would have sucked up their being ill for a month or two but not for two years.

Obviously that's an imaginary example, but can you see how what you're proposing is likely to increase the health inequalities experienced by those members of the population who are already suffering the most deprivation?

schooloflostsocks · 14/07/2023 21:32

“Illness is neither an indulgence for which people have to pay, nor an offence for which they should be penalised, but a misfortune the cost of which should be shared by the community.”

A two or three tier system would deepen inequality and simply allow those with financial advantage to put themselves first. It already happens but any further attack on the free at point of use principle is unforgivable and must not be allowed to happen.

sheeplikessleep · 14/07/2023 20:51

Look up Benenden.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 20:48

Don’t think..

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 20:47

NumberTheory · 14/07/2023 20:33

From what I recall of my economics courses, though I can’t quote the papers etc. - In general, where state provision allows people to add on or where it only covers a minority of people, the base provision by the state goes down over time.

Of course there are also lots of other things that can influence state provision and wealth inequality. If you want to tackle those things you need to look at the whole system. But since we are only talking about this one lever, it is not likely to decrease inequality.

Thanks for this. I know a few countries used a mixed system and charge varying amounts. They also have a variety of levels in inequality.

People seem ok with state plus private if in PFI form, I do t think that’s coming back for good reason. But a mixed model has been used.

As a way to get more disposable income into the system I’d look at other countries. The biggest issue is even if they were better parties likely won’t propose it and people won’t vote for it.

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 20:40

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 20:16

Also if you’re going to do private and state mix you’re probably better off not lumbering people for decades with increased costs as PFI did

...as does all Govt borrowing, Blair faced the choice of adding to national debt, increased taxes, PFI or not making up for the lack of investment in health by the previous Tory govt... which is what the current lot have done too, underfunded the NHS.

Swipe left for the next trending thread