Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There should be more partial-private options in health and education

186 replies

Middlelanehogger · 12/07/2023 21:28

People often say that for social mobility reasons we should abolish private schools or private hospitals as it's unfair that there's "one system for the rich, one for the poor".

However I think this thinking is backward. We should encourage more gradual step-ups that enable people to slowly inject more of their own personal money into the system as they move up the income ladder and become able to do so.

For example, currently I have the choice to go to my underfunded, busy NHS GP, or a completely private GP and pay the full costs. Likewise I could send my kids to state school or go completely private.

Great if you can afford the "completely private" option.

But there isn't an intermediate option. In Australia for example, you get a govt rebate of say $30 for every GP appt. This covers a basic GP, or you could apply it towards a more expensive GP with a nicer waiting room or late operating hours etc that costs say $50 (i.e. you only pay the $20 difference, vs $0 in the free option).

In the UK you either pay £0 or £50. There's no £20 option.

In the Australian system, the health system overall gets an extra $20 that wasn't there before (from the extra top-up), and more people are able to access the nicer services (because more people can afford $20 than $50).

There's a similar argument to be made for private education. Why can you not "move" your state school funding to a private school to offset the costs? It would allow a smoother mixing along income levels instead of the harsh cutoff/separation we have today.

Eliminating inequality is completely impossible due to human nature, but keeping a harsh separation between "the rich" and "the poors" also isn't the answer. It just keeps "the rich" even more in their bubble.

OP posts:
StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:12

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:08

% GDP is meaningless.
Funding on a per capita basis is very low. (US is an outlier)

You’d better let the people who included it as relevant.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:08

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:02

Which metric are you using?

% of GDP is slightly above OECD average

This is quite good, latest that came up

https://www.oecd.org/unitedkingdom/health-at-a-glance-UK-EN.pdf

% GDP is meaningless.
Funding on a per capita basis is very low. (US is an outlier)

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:02

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 13:52

They work well because they are better funded by their governments, there is no other cause/reason.

Which metric are you using?

% of GDP is slightly above OECD average

This is quite good, latest that came up

https://www.oecd.org/unitedkingdom/health-at-a-glance-UK-EN.pdf

https://www.oecd.org/unitedkingdom/health-at-a-glance-UK-EN.pdf

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:02

@StefanosHill
’They’ve researched why people miss appointments it is often due to work or childcare, next is unable to afford cost of transport/or even get transport anc 10% never getting the notification they had an appointment.’
U.K. research on missed NHS appointments

‘If you had to pay for an appointment it would be payment after the appointment so, there wouldn’t be a situation where you’d pay £20 to book and then lose the money if you no show. That’s not how the model works. You pay when you attend the appointment. If you no show, you don’t pay.’
Every copay system in OECD for general practice

‘So if we had copays, people would have an appointment and be forced to miss it due to not having the money for the copay as an additional reason to the known ones above.’ logical outcome for U.K. when many are already missing appointments due to not having the money for transport to the appointment, plus cost of living crisis

’There might be fewer appointments in total though as a recent survey showed that 1 in 4 Americans did not even make appointments because of the cost of the copay. They simply deferred seeking medical care. Which as you know can result in an increase in A&E due to conditions not being treated in time. So this idea of £20 to see the GP would actually cost more money in 3rd order impacts that it would generate.’ What happens in the US due to human behaviour. Human behaviour that would apply to U.K. if we made GPs cost money to see. You would have people not seeking healthcare because they don’t have the £20. So we would end up with more A&E patients dependent on the NHS to step in because patients let mild conditions progress to serious/life threatening before seeking healthcare.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 13:53

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 13:52

Are you basing your views only on the US system?

No.

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 13:52

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 13:51

I think it would increase the % of missed appointments.

They’ve researched why people miss appointments it is often due to work or childcare, next is unable to afford cost of transport/or even get transport anc 10% never getting the notification they had an appointment.

If you had to pay for an appointment it would be payment after the appointment so, there wouldn’t be a situation where you’d pay £20 to book and then lose the money if you no show. That’s not how the model works. You pay when you attend the appointment. If you no show, you don’t pay.

So if we had copays, people would have an appointment and be forced to miss it due to not having the money for the copay as an additional reason to the known ones above.

There might be fewer appointments in total though as a recent survey showed that 1 in 4 Americans did not even make appointments because of the cost of the copay. They simply deferred seeking medical care. Which as you know can result in an increase in A&E due to conditions not being treated in time. So this idea of £20 to see the GP would actually cost more money in 3rd order impacts that it would generate.

Are you basing your views only on the US system?

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 13:52

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 13:38

Other systems do work well. It’s worth looking at those to see how they do it

They work well because they are better funded by their governments, there is no other cause/reason.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 13:51

grass321 · 15/07/2023 13:35

I'm confident that a part-pay system would cut the number of missed appointments. That's an advantage to everyone, including the doctors.

I think it would increase the % of missed appointments.

They’ve researched why people miss appointments it is often due to work or childcare, next is unable to afford cost of transport/or even get transport anc 10% never getting the notification they had an appointment.

If you had to pay for an appointment it would be payment after the appointment so, there wouldn’t be a situation where you’d pay £20 to book and then lose the money if you no show. That’s not how the model works. You pay when you attend the appointment. If you no show, you don’t pay.

So if we had copays, people would have an appointment and be forced to miss it due to not having the money for the copay as an additional reason to the known ones above.

There might be fewer appointments in total though as a recent survey showed that 1 in 4 Americans did not even make appointments because of the cost of the copay. They simply deferred seeking medical care. Which as you know can result in an increase in A&E due to conditions not being treated in time. So this idea of £20 to see the GP would actually cost more money in 3rd order impacts that it would generate.

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 13:38

Other systems do work well. It’s worth looking at those to see how they do it

grass321 · 15/07/2023 13:35

I'm confident that a part-pay system would cut the number of missed appointments. That's an advantage to everyone, including the doctors.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 13:08

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 09:45

What I'm trying to propose is a system that allows and enables "small reaches" for everyday people, to avoid some of the situations in this thread.

For example take someone who works as a manual labourer, i.e. someone working class but not on the bones of their arse. He injures his knee and is told it's a 2 year wait on the NHS, no physio etc. 2 years without income (or significantly reduced for him as he needs a working knee for his job) would be devastating for his family.

He doesn't have full-scale private insurance and can't afford the full-freight price of his treatment. He has a bit of savings and could withdraw a bit on the mortgage, and treating this is a major priority for him and his family so they're prepared to pay what they can.

I want to live in a system where he has options. There are many many more people in this category than people who literally have nothing. If these people had an avenue to put in what money they can, yes for a bit of advantage to themselves, state support could be directed to the people who really don't have anything.

The system where he gets full perfect treatment immediately on the NHS completely for free doesn't exist, so stop talking about a dream world

Yeah. This doesn’t work. It’s ok for a utopia one off injury to one person where the family has savings to then opt to go a private pay route. But what about the second injury? Or third? Or what if their child breaks their arm? Or is diagnosed with leukaemia? Or the mother gets breast cancer? What then? What savings are left? And “Withdraw on the mortgage”- what if they are one of the millions of families that private rent because they are not even well enough off to own their home?

All you would be doing is creating more tiers of inequality with those least able to pay shut even more out. Right now private pay rich folks jump the queues and never even go into an NHS hospital. Your idea is to have the government subsidise less rich, middle class people to jump the queue in the NHS by paying copays.

Combine this with the fact that the sickest and the most chronically ill, most in need of healthcare (the disabled) are the most likely demographic to be in poverty and completely unable to do any “every day reach” like you envision. They’ll be quite simply left to die while on a waitlist that everyone not disabled and able to work a bit of overtime or have a pot of savings steams ahead of them in the NHS queue by paying their £20 or whatever. Keep in mind while a healthy person may need that £20 once or twice a year, this can quite often be several times a week when you are disabled and fighting numerous life limiting, chronic health conditions.

Kazzyhoward · 15/07/2023 12:08

Alexandra2001 · 15/07/2023 10:16

Imagine how much more there would be to spend on the NHS without the costs of PFI

You think the Tories would have been spending the difference on the NHS ? really???

If Blair had not used PFI, the borrowing would have gone to national debt or it would never have been done and we'd have an even worse NHS.

The cock up was in negotiating the contracts, not PFI itself, borrowing for improvements is a common way of funding.

To an extent, yes, but some of the spending wasn't actually "necessary". Such as the huge 3 story building which replaced a small GP surgery near us. The idea was for it to be a "health centre" with out patients, x-rays, audiology, podiatry, etc. The top two floors have never been used and are basically empty. Half the ground floor is barriered off and never used. It's basically just the same number of GP treatment rooms as the tiny building it replaced, and none of the promised extra services have even happened. It's a monumental cost that simply wasn't needed - a sheer waste of taxpayers' money. A replacement "like for like" size of GP surgery would have been a fraction of the cost. I think a lot of the "shiny" new hospitals and schools was because they could, rather than because of need - all down to vanity rather than necessity.

ZiriForEver · 15/07/2023 10:36

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 09:45

What I'm trying to propose is a system that allows and enables "small reaches" for everyday people, to avoid some of the situations in this thread.

For example take someone who works as a manual labourer, i.e. someone working class but not on the bones of their arse. He injures his knee and is told it's a 2 year wait on the NHS, no physio etc. 2 years without income (or significantly reduced for him as he needs a working knee for his job) would be devastating for his family.

He doesn't have full-scale private insurance and can't afford the full-freight price of his treatment. He has a bit of savings and could withdraw a bit on the mortgage, and treating this is a major priority for him and his family so they're prepared to pay what they can.

I want to live in a system where he has options. There are many many more people in this category than people who literally have nothing. If these people had an avenue to put in what money they can, yes for a bit of advantage to themselves, state support could be directed to the people who really don't have anything.

The system where he gets full perfect treatment immediately on the NHS completely for free doesn't exist, so stop talking about a dream world

But what options?
The copay system called private care works only because only a small proportion of the population enters it. The moment majority would, it would transform a simple queue to a queue of "jump the queue ticket holders".

Previously you suggested 20£, now we are getting to withdrawing from the mortgage, which can be more substantial sum.
Won't it be better to slightly increase the taxes and rise the money together, than to deplete all savings and equity from the working class guy from you example, so when his child needs treatment for allergies two years after that, they would be in the bones of their arse situation?

Alexandra2001 · 15/07/2023 10:16

Imagine how much more there would be to spend on the NHS without the costs of PFI

You think the Tories would have been spending the difference on the NHS ? really???

If Blair had not used PFI, the borrowing would have gone to national debt or it would never have been done and we'd have an even worse NHS.

The cock up was in negotiating the contracts, not PFI itself, borrowing for improvements is a common way of funding.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2023 09:55

Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 09:31

@jgw1 i think you need to work on either reading comprehension or critical thinking. The scenario you describe is a fever dream of your own creation.

It’s a situation that could easily occur. And does. Check this out.

http://digitaleditions.telegraph.co.uk/data/1397/reader/reader.html?social#!preferred/0/package/1397/pub/1397/page/67/article/NaN

The Telegraph

http://digitaleditions.telegraph.co.uk/data/1397/reader/reader.html?social#!preferred/0/package/1397/pub/1397/page/67/article/NaN

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 09:45

What I'm trying to propose is a system that allows and enables "small reaches" for everyday people, to avoid some of the situations in this thread.

For example take someone who works as a manual labourer, i.e. someone working class but not on the bones of their arse. He injures his knee and is told it's a 2 year wait on the NHS, no physio etc. 2 years without income (or significantly reduced for him as he needs a working knee for his job) would be devastating for his family.

He doesn't have full-scale private insurance and can't afford the full-freight price of his treatment. He has a bit of savings and could withdraw a bit on the mortgage, and treating this is a major priority for him and his family so they're prepared to pay what they can.

I want to live in a system where he has options. There are many many more people in this category than people who literally have nothing. If these people had an avenue to put in what money they can, yes for a bit of advantage to themselves, state support could be directed to the people who really don't have anything.

The system where he gets full perfect treatment immediately on the NHS completely for free doesn't exist, so stop talking about a dream world

OP posts:
ZiriForEver · 15/07/2023 09:40

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 08:41

But yes, essentially we come to the core ethical dilemma which is

A) treat more people, but you have an unequal chance of being the one to receive treatment

B) treat fewer people, but everyone equally has the chance to be the one to receive it

Which one is preferable depends on the actual hard difference in numbers. We all lean one way or the other based on gut instinct. But I'd argue the NHS can adequately treat so few people now that we need to move the system more towards A, even if that does mean an increase in absolute inequality at the boundaries.

No. Your are still ignoring the issue of costs proportion. Current going private doesn't cover full care with it's full costs. It's just a glorified copay for jumping the queue.

Let's make a model here. Let's take large dog's veterinary medicine as a good approximation of the real commercial costs of health care.
Simple consultation is about 60£.
Any actual treatment starts at higher hundreds for minor things.

Private human GP appointment costs about 60£ as well. Any actual trearmenent costs more and unless it is something easy and easy to profit on, it goes back to the NHS.
If the treatment costs 1200£, saving NHS 60£ for the initial consultation means getting better (more timely) care with your costs 95% publicly funded. Your suggestion you should be able it get it with your meagre 20£, meaning 2,5% of the costs is absurd.

Labraradabrador · 15/07/2023 09:31

@jgw1 i think you need to work on either reading comprehension or critical thinking. The scenario you describe is a fever dream of your own creation.

Ginmonkeyagain · 15/07/2023 09:11

A lot of people already have this option through work group health plans.

Through a, free to me, plan I can access private GP appointments, physio, annual health checks ups, scans, private rooms. It is not designed to replace NHS treatment but supplement it, although I can choose to pay more for an enhanced plan.

I think a scheme that makes that kind of stuff more accessible to individuals would be good. I love the NHS but it is generally very shit at minor or preventstive stuff. I have had persistent but manageable lower back pain but manage since lockdown. I could not access my NHS GP to talk about it. I spoke to a private doctor through work, was referred the next day to a physio and was diagnosed with a spasming piriformis muscle and I have a course of physio exercises.

It is now getting better

grass321 · 15/07/2023 08:54

It depends on your point of view. I'd see a part pay system as pulling up the experience and standards for everyone, including those that can't pay.

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 08:52

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 08:49

No. Any system that requires the sick & disabled to contribute more to the costs of their healthcare is unacceptable. These are the ones least likely to be able to afford the additional costs of a private-public mix. And we know from the excess deaths rates in other countries solely do to being unable to afford healthcare that such a system literally means condemning innocent children, women and men to a painful and lingering death due to their illness/disabilities.

These systems are only better for those who are blessed with good health and a good income.

Can you say which countries you mean?

I don’t think all private plus state systems are as such, are they

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 08:52

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 08:41

But yes, essentially we come to the core ethical dilemma which is

A) treat more people, but you have an unequal chance of being the one to receive treatment

B) treat fewer people, but everyone equally has the chance to be the one to receive it

Which one is preferable depends on the actual hard difference in numbers. We all lean one way or the other based on gut instinct. But I'd argue the NHS can adequately treat so few people now that we need to move the system more towards A, even if that does mean an increase in absolute inequality at the boundaries.

A= pay £££ to skip to the head of the queue and fuck the poor, sick and disabled.

No thanks, I’d rather we all agree to pay a bit more tax and not just we individuals but also businesses so that the NHS were properly funded.

jgw1 · 15/07/2023 08:50

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 08:46

One way to look at is there’s an amount of money sloshing around that people spend on holidays, food, going out whatever

And a healthcare budget which is via the state

Incentives that pull more money from those with disposable income to health care can work, other countries do it. Not really impacting on inequality

People are more resistant here as we’re not used to it, but successful approaches from o/s can be emulated without full reform

Sounds like a strong arguement to me for taxing wealth.

Why is that the Prime Minister pays a lower rate of tax on his income than an NHS nurse?

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 08:49

No. Any system that requires the sick & disabled to contribute more to the costs of their healthcare is unacceptable. These are the ones least likely to be able to afford the additional costs of a private-public mix. And we know from the excess deaths rates in other countries solely do to being unable to afford healthcare that such a system literally means condemning innocent children, women and men to a painful and lingering death due to their illness/disabilities.

These systems are only better for those who are blessed with good health and a good income.

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 08:48

Actually replace food with restaurants etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread