Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There should be more partial-private options in health and education

186 replies

Middlelanehogger · 12/07/2023 21:28

People often say that for social mobility reasons we should abolish private schools or private hospitals as it's unfair that there's "one system for the rich, one for the poor".

However I think this thinking is backward. We should encourage more gradual step-ups that enable people to slowly inject more of their own personal money into the system as they move up the income ladder and become able to do so.

For example, currently I have the choice to go to my underfunded, busy NHS GP, or a completely private GP and pay the full costs. Likewise I could send my kids to state school or go completely private.

Great if you can afford the "completely private" option.

But there isn't an intermediate option. In Australia for example, you get a govt rebate of say $30 for every GP appt. This covers a basic GP, or you could apply it towards a more expensive GP with a nicer waiting room or late operating hours etc that costs say $50 (i.e. you only pay the $20 difference, vs $0 in the free option).

In the UK you either pay £0 or £50. There's no £20 option.

In the Australian system, the health system overall gets an extra $20 that wasn't there before (from the extra top-up), and more people are able to access the nicer services (because more people can afford $20 than $50).

There's a similar argument to be made for private education. Why can you not "move" your state school funding to a private school to offset the costs? It would allow a smoother mixing along income levels instead of the harsh cutoff/separation we have today.

Eliminating inequality is completely impossible due to human nature, but keeping a harsh separation between "the rich" and "the poors" also isn't the answer. It just keeps "the rich" even more in their bubble.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
grass321 · 17/07/2023 19:29

Disgraceful idea. Reducing social mobility. Everyone has the right to decent education and healthcare, tax the rich more and get rid of the loopholes now.

How do you define the 'rich'? Those people already paying 45% tax on their six figure salaries? Or the multi millionaires that are internationally mobile and likely to head elsewhere if the tax rate is any higher?

The top 1% pay 30% of all income tax revenue according to LSE, the highest in 20 years. That equates to 300,000 individuals paying 30% of all tax revenue. And that's before VAT, CGT, IHT and the rest.

At what point does higher tax act as a disincentive to work or an incentive to move to another country? Or earns less than it costs to administer, as it did when George Osborne introduced the top rate?

We need to look beyond 'taxing the rich' as it's too simplistic and some of our public services need fundamental change to support a higher population.

Watchagotch72 · 17/07/2023 17:36

a really hierarchical system where people with choice get better service and people with no choice get none and get the worst service

by choice, you mean money - right? Because the bottom line is that money buys advantage - whether that’s more choice, better education, better healthcare. And more money = more advantage.

what we are doing here is arguing about how much advantage should people with money be allowed to buy, and in what circumstances.

we are already in a hierarchical system, and the hierarchy of choice is set by how much money one has.

Alexandra2001 · 17/07/2023 16:32

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:41

Ok sounds easy, if people are static and comparative attractiveness doesn’t matter.

R of Ireland is doing incredibly well from lower corporation tax. Starting to talk about a sovereign fund from those wealthy US multinationals.

Unearned income for starters, quite why Sunak gets away with paying 20% CGT on millions from investment income is beyond me.

The UK had very low levels of Corporation tax for over 7 years, we attracted little to no new FI, political stability matters and the UK suffered during that time period, not great now.

ROI has excellent infrastructure, educated workforce and most importantly, has a certain romantic connection with the USA.... then there is Brexit, which made the ROI the only English speaking country with full access to mainland Europe, something we used to enjoy.

Its not their CT rate alone that has driven the economy.

NeedToChangeName · 17/07/2023 16:30

Kazzyhoward · 13/07/2023 19:50

How would you do away with the private options completely?

Ban them? Make them illegal?

So how would you stop people going abroad for private education/health services then? We, in the UK, can't stop people going abroad can we? Or would you ban that too!

The "rich" would just educate their children abroad and, as many already do, travel abroad for health treatments (don't a lot of people go abroad for dental work in the old Eastern European countries, Turkey, etc??).

Look at euthanasia - we can't stop people going to Switzerland to end their lives can we?

In reality, what would happen with your idea is that everyone gets the same crap services. I can guarantee that service levels etc won't increase as you seem to think.

@Kazzyhoward my ideal scenario would be public services used by everyone, and good enough that there is no perceived advantage in going private

I understand that in eg Denmark, private schools exist but aren't widely used as public system is so good

Middlelanehogger · 17/07/2023 16:20

We have a hierarchical system today (it just only has two levels, very far apart).

OP posts:
Cutlosses · 17/07/2023 13:46

I like this idea in theory. But would it cause a really hierarchical system where people with choice get better service and people with no choice get none and get the worst service?

Could we instead get a thing where we can donate as box/ randomly whatever towards the NHS? Schools? Choosing certain parts of it? but maybe not a certain geographical area?

piesforever · 17/07/2023 12:28

Disgraceful idea. Reducing social mobility. Everyone has the right to decent education and healthcare, tax the rich more and get rid of the loopholes now.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 20:48

London always gets more money because cost of living is so high. The wages for all the healthcare professionals has to be higher and that is what is driving a higher per capita spend.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2023 15:32

You need an account to see that chart. My guess is that spending in London is a combination of specialist hospitals and London weighting.

Kazzyhoward · 15/07/2023 15:27

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:24

And this
https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/healthcaresystem/articles/howdoesukhealthcarespendingcomparewithothercountries/2019-08-29

  • “However, of the G7 group of large, developed economies, UK healthcare spending per person was the second-lowest, with the highest spenders being France (£3,737), Germany (£4,432) and the United States (£7,736).”

Actual spending per capita is actually higher in London (£3,811) than other parts of the UK (average £3,236). It'd be interesting to know why spending in London is 18% higher than the UK average!

https://www.statista.com/statistics/651514/uk-health-spending-per-person-by-region/#:~:text=In%202021%2F22%2C%20health%20spending,per%20capita%20in%20East%20England.

UK health spending per capita by region 2022 | Statista

In 2021/22, health spending in the United Kingdom was 3,236 British pounds per capita, ranging from 3,811 pounds per capita in London, to 2,889 pounds per capita in East England.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/651514/uk-health-spending-per-person-by-region#:~:text=In%202021%2F22%2C%20health%20spending,per%20capita%20in%20East%20England.

Kazzyhoward · 15/07/2023 15:22

@AP5Diva

If you had to pay for an appointment it would be payment after the appointment so, there wouldn’t be a situation where you’d pay £20 to book and then lose the money if you no show.

Why? I have to pay in advance for all kinds of appointments, such as for earwax removal/hearing aid consultation, private physiotherapy, vet consultations, etc. Not sure why you'd automatically think that payment upon making an appointment wouldn't be the norm at all? It's happening more and more these days, especially now that most people pay by card.

Middlelanehogger · 15/07/2023 15:16

Please do tell where the extra money is going to come from to just fund more from taxes.

It's always "someone richer than me".

OP posts:
StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:41

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:36

Who will you tax more?

The corporations and wealthy.

Ok sounds easy, if people are static and comparative attractiveness doesn’t matter.

R of Ireland is doing incredibly well from lower corporation tax. Starting to talk about a sovereign fund from those wealthy US multinationals.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:36

Who will you tax more?

The corporations and wealthy.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:35

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:30

I found that link pretty good actually at setting out where we sit against OECD

If we’re spending OECD average for % of GDP where’s the issue?

Our GDP is lower per capita overall?

In which case trying to get more money from people for healthcare will be tough. Real healthcare spending has gone up over the last decade or so but our needs outstrip it.

Ageing population will mean we need higher than real terms funding. Who will you tax more?

The issue is that GDP measures the gross domestic product of a nation. It has nothing to do with how many people are in the country or how much healthcare is needed.

If you are a poor country with 100m people you will have a lower GDP and so need to spend a higher % of GDP to get the same level of healthcare as a rich country with 50m people and a higher GDP. Healthcare is relatively inelastic except that poor people tend to need more of it than rich people due to the health impacts of poverty.

The stat is mostly for economists to measure the financial stability of a country. It’s not meant to be used to ascertain how healthy the populace is.

Alexandra2001 · 15/07/2023 14:33

BeverlyHa · 15/07/2023 14:23

we only pay for what we can afford, it is the same all over the world, no matter the labels put on any given system

even very great professionals who charge thousands lose patients, so there is no a recipee for success in any human made system.

Thats simply not correct, Govt's have choices to make, so an obvious one would be "Build a railway to save 20mins on a 3hr journey or buy new scanners, build more hospitals and train more staff"

Another, Have Austerity for 10 plus years or have it for 5 years and then borrow (at almost 0% rates) to improve growth and productivity" which is what almost all european countries did.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:30

There is this analysis of spending vs performance
https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2021/08/05/the-nhs-is-suffering-from-underfunding-and-its-showing/

“The NHS has little spent on it, but delivers above average performance for that, still. This is highlighted in this chart:”

”So what to conclude? First, the NHS remains good at very many levels.
Second, it is not as good as it was. A decade of underfunding is now showing.
Third, we are paying a price in health care outcomes for not spending enough on healthcare. The absence of slack in our system; the absence of a culture of caring in government and the failure to act in preventative healthcare, so apparent during the Covid crisis, all impose a considerable cost on the U.K.
And, quietly unspoken behind all this is the fact that the U.K. has pockets of dense poverty and pervasive inequality throughout the country which in reality denies access to healthcare. That may be because people cannot afford time off to attend a surgery. But it also impacts through many aspects of lifestyle, including diet as well as decent housing. Fuel poverty is another issue: people do not die of flu in the U.K. any more than they do elsewhere, which is almost not at all. They die from pneumonia, most of it linked to poorly heated houses. This is the scandal behind this data.
Covid has revealed the underfunding of the NHS, as well as government refusal to do anything about it. But the bigger issue is that we tolerate poverty in the U.K. in a wholly unacceptable way, condemning many to poor health and early death. Government indifference to that is now beginning to show in the data. The Labour investment in the NHS has worn off. What is left is a sorry shadow of what we need.
It would be really good to have new commitments to the NHS, and the commitment to fund them. Investment in health care by government is known to have a rate of return well in excess of the sums spent. Why won't this government spend in the NHS in that case?”

There should be more partial-private options in health and education
StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:30

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:17

% GDP is only relevant to economists, it’s not a measure that is relevant to whether a healthcare system is adequately funded for the population it serves or how “good” a system it is.

I found that link pretty good actually at setting out where we sit against OECD

If we’re spending OECD average for % of GDP where’s the issue?

Our GDP is lower per capita overall?

In which case trying to get more money from people for healthcare will be tough. Real healthcare spending has gone up over the last decade or so but our needs outstrip it.

Ageing population will mean we need higher than real terms funding. Who will you tax more?

BeverlyHa · 15/07/2023 14:23

we only pay for what we can afford, it is the same all over the world, no matter the labels put on any given system

even very great professionals who charge thousands lose patients, so there is no a recipee for success in any human made system.

Alexandra2001 · 15/07/2023 14:20

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:02

Which metric are you using?

% of GDP is slightly above OECD average

This is quite good, latest that came up

https://www.oecd.org/unitedkingdom/health-at-a-glance-UK-EN.pdf

No point looking at the very recent post Covid funding settlements when analysing issues with the NHS.

The long term underfunding of the NHS is very well researched, compared to the best funded EU health systems, the NHS suffered an approx real terms £40bn per year shortfall in the first few years after 2010, there is a very clear reason why we have so few staff/equipment/scanners.

Now what we are having is throwing money at the problems with no long term plan, hard of course for the Tories as they may well be in their last year of office.

Yes @Kazzyhoward Some stupid decisions on funding made in the Blair years, money wasn't always well spent, as it often isn't who ever is in power... i see that now in defence.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:18

Besides, we should be looking at G7, not OECD for our comparators.

AP5Diva · 15/07/2023 14:17

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:12

You’d better let the people who included it as relevant.

% GDP is only relevant to economists, it’s not a measure that is relevant to whether a healthcare system is adequately funded for the population it serves or how “good” a system it is.

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 14:13

People know at oecd.org