Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are with a man who took on your child as his own?

82 replies

sighu · 12/07/2023 21:16

I really would like a relationship and perhaps even more children, but I’m already 37 and have one dc (3). I can’t imagine meeting someone who will be a family with me and dc? I can’t imagine someone embracing that or even wanting it. It’s so often referred to as baggage isn’t it. And obviously I couldn’t be with someone who didn’t treat ds like their own. Are there men out there like this? If so where did you find them? I feel I am destined to be on my own now. I hate the lack of connection with another adult in a romantic loving way.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
familyissues12345 · 14/07/2023 08:55

QueenofallIsee · 13/07/2023 22:35

The father of my 3 sons came on the scene when my DD was 3. Her Dad was very much in her life and was remarried. DD was loved by all concerned, treated as a child of the family and equally by all the adults. When she turned 25 last year in attendance and enjoying ourselves was me, her father, my husband, my ex (the boys dad) and wife, her fathers new girlfriend, her fathers ex wife and her fella, multiple grandparent type figures, step siblings/bio siblings. We are all joined in love for her. Taking a child on ‘as their own’ isn’t exactly how it went. We all love her for herself and are proud to be parents and trusted adults in her life.

That is so lovely

QueenofallIsee · 13/07/2023 22:35

The father of my 3 sons came on the scene when my DD was 3. Her Dad was very much in her life and was remarried. DD was loved by all concerned, treated as a child of the family and equally by all the adults. When she turned 25 last year in attendance and enjoying ourselves was me, her father, my husband, my ex (the boys dad) and wife, her fathers new girlfriend, her fathers ex wife and her fella, multiple grandparent type figures, step siblings/bio siblings. We are all joined in love for her. Taking a child on ‘as their own’ isn’t exactly how it went. We all love her for herself and are proud to be parents and trusted adults in her life.

AmaraTamara · 13/07/2023 22:21

It's very hard for men to treat a child as their own. In fact about 50 children a year are killed and countless tortured by, step parents mostly, in the UK. I'd never take the risk by taking a stranger to my child in my home no matter how much I fancied him, as I love my child more. Of course all generalisations etc... So op, these things have been discussed countless times here on MN, after child murders especially. You can have relationships without living together. Unfortunately it's a bitter pill to swallow...

Simonjt · 13/07/2023 22:07

It’s good that you seem to be fairly sure in what you need in a relationship, just remember its better to be single than it is to settle.

I met my husband when my son was three, he adopted him when he was seven.

WandaWonder · 13/07/2023 21:58

You can't promise a relationship with a child if a couple splits, biological or not

People are not robots where promising a decision now will be the same in the future whether that is staying in contact or going on to have more children or not

Tarkan · 13/07/2023 21:54

DH is stepdad to my two DC (19 and 15). We've been together almost 10 years (just met in a local pub and met through a mutual friend) but he didn't meet the kids straight away. He did admit to me that he never saw himself being with someone with kids but as soon as we met we had an amazing connection and he didn't mind that I had kids and was happy for me to pick when he met them etc and even said if the kids didn't like him then he understood that they had to come first for me. He still knows that and we've now been married for 5 years.

He's never tried to be their dad. Until covid they saw their dad regularly and then his home situation meant he couldn't see them as much and he's now moved further away and hasn't actually seen them since sometime last year now. He's still their dad despite this and no matter what I think of his lack of contact with them.

However DH has been there in a parenting role, especially over the last few years when their dad didn't see them as much. We have had a lot of various mental health issues with DC2 and DH was amazing at speaking to the school and doctor at times when I couldn't and tbh he's probably pushier than I am at getting things like that done. It's something he and DC have been happy with though, not something I forced either into.

This year both DC drew cards for him (something they've always loved doing) for Father's Day and instead of writing "Stepfather's Day" they left off the "step" for the first time ever. At no time did I ever ask or expect the kids to do that or even to call him Dad or anything like that, they've always known him by his first name, although DC1 has referred to him as her dad to some people at her work.

IMO if you meet the right person then it'll work, but I would never expect someone new to be immediately thrust into a parenting position and would certainly never force it. Your priority should always be your DC, I see too many people rush into relationships and immediately introduce the kids and expect the new man to be called Dad which I think is almost always a recipe for disaster further down the line.

BalletBob · 13/07/2023 21:40

peachgreen · 13/07/2023 15:33

So what exactly is the alternative @BalletBob? Bereaved kids like mine never get to have a father figure again? Widowed and divorced women don’t get to have a full relationship until their children are adults?

I can only speak for myself and I’m sure not everyone takes it as seriously as I did, but I didn’t introduce DP and DD until I was very certain about him AND was certain that I would value his input into her life regardless of what happened in our relationship (i.e. I would happily continue to facilitate their relationship if we ever split up). I communicated this to him clearly so he understood what would be expected of him should they ever reach that level of relationship, and he agreed. We won’t live together until DD is old enough to be part of the decision to do so. And I have also made it very clear that I won’t have a child with him biologically until he and DD’s relationship is secure, solid and I’m confident that she won’t be second best – and if that doesn’t happen in time, we won’t have a child. I’ve done as much as I can to make sure she doesn’t get hurt. It’s not foolproof – but nothing is. You no more know that your kids’ biological father won’t fuck them over than you do a stepfather.

I'm not saying mothers shouldn't have new relationships. I'm saying that mothers shouldn't encourage their children to view an unrelated man as their father because it leaves their children extremely vulnerable to lasting emotional damage.

It's unrealistic to ask a man to promise that he'll treat an unrelated child exactly the same as a biological child he hasn't had yet, because until that child arrives he has no notion of whether he can fulfill that promise. And neither does anyone else.

The logic of "but their biological dad might be crap" just doesn't hold up. We don't (or shouldn't) take unnecessary risks for our kids surrounding one particular issue just because there are other, unrelated, risks we can't mitigate. I definitely don't agree that it's equally as likely that a child's actual father will "fuck them over" as a man who isn't related to them, who just happens to be their mother's romantic partner. A biological father generally retains parental responsibility in the case of divorce for a start, whereas a stepfather may very well just walk out of that child's life. Don't the stats say that something like 65% of second marriages end in divorce? It's no small possibility. But of course nobody thinks it will happen to them.

I'm sure a well-managed step-father/step-child relationship can be a positive thing (not that I've actually ever seen a truly successful "blended family" personally), but it's not a parent/child relationship and I absolutely maintain that it's reckless and selfish to tell a child that an unrelated man is a father to them simply because it suits a romantic ideal for the adults involved.

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 15:39

OP go on the Stepparent board and read about lived experiences of blended families. You’d have to be utterly bonkers to want that kind of life.

To me men who ‘take on kids of their own’ and men who meet a single mum when her DC is very young and effectively everyone makes out they’re the dad. I’m alarmed by how many people I know who’ve done this, and I’ve seen what it does to a child when they find out. That is an even LESS attractive prospect

oddwellingtonboots · 13/07/2023 15:37

My DP moved in with me and DS (who sees his Dad 3 days a week). Maybe we would have had children but we are both too old now.

DP and DS get on amazingly and I'm sure he's very similar around him as he was with his two (grown up now) DS's when they were little.

DS knows that his Dad is his Dad and DP is my partner.

peachgreen · 13/07/2023 15:33

So what exactly is the alternative @BalletBob? Bereaved kids like mine never get to have a father figure again? Widowed and divorced women don’t get to have a full relationship until their children are adults?

I can only speak for myself and I’m sure not everyone takes it as seriously as I did, but I didn’t introduce DP and DD until I was very certain about him AND was certain that I would value his input into her life regardless of what happened in our relationship (i.e. I would happily continue to facilitate their relationship if we ever split up). I communicated this to him clearly so he understood what would be expected of him should they ever reach that level of relationship, and he agreed. We won’t live together until DD is old enough to be part of the decision to do so. And I have also made it very clear that I won’t have a child with him biologically until he and DD’s relationship is secure, solid and I’m confident that she won’t be second best – and if that doesn’t happen in time, we won’t have a child. I’ve done as much as I can to make sure she doesn’t get hurt. It’s not foolproof – but nothing is. You no more know that your kids’ biological father won’t fuck them over than you do a stepfather.

BalletBob · 13/07/2023 14:50

Honestly it's completely selfish and reckless to allow your child to consider a new partner/husband to be "like a father" to them. What happens when you split up, as is the case in the majority of second marriages, and this "like a father" just disappears from your child's life? Or he still wants to be involved but you aren't up for sending your child for visitation with your ex boyfriend and his new girlfriend? What happens when you do have another child and suddenly this hypothetical man realises "oh hang on, this is what it feels like to be a dad" and can't fulfill a silly promise to love your child as much as his own? So many pitfalls and the person at risk of hurt in every scenario is your child.

Kids aren't little props to validate your love life. You had your children in the circumstances you had them in. You can't rewrite history now and play make believe that they are someone else's. If you decide to start a new relationship, involving your child should be something that comes way down the line. And then you need to be realistic and honest about the role that's appropriate for that person to play in your child's life, for your child's sake.

cruisingabout · 13/07/2023 14:36

a friend of mine actully was like this with his ex's dd. the relationship started when the dd was just an infant and he was so in love with her after a while. he innitially really loved the mother, but in the end when the relationship didn't work out, he missed being a dad to the dd more. tbh he was a way better dad than most of the birth dads mentioned here on mn

DinoDaddy · 13/07/2023 12:40

My DH met my eldest kids when they were 2 and 4. We have another 2 children now and my eldest are in secondary school. He treats them all the same. Some people have been shocked after knowing us for years to realise he isn't the eldest's bio dad.

tommika · 13/07/2023 12:30

As most have probably said - don’t expect this of another man, but it can happen naturally - everyone’s situation is different

My sisters first marriage ended when she was pregnant with her second child (son)
Her first husband visited the first child (daughter) probably twice, and was not seen again

She had another son with her second husband
Throughout their relationship he treated the first two as children would be & had no difference between them

The daughter announced on her birthday that she had legally changed her name to his, and then applied for her first passport as she had deliberately avoided doing so in her birth fathers name

They have since divorced, all of the children are now adults and parents.
He remains the father to all three and grandfather of their children

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 13/07/2023 12:16

I met my DH when DS was 3. He took him on as his own and we went on to have DD as well.

It was a blind date set up by my cousins husband!

aSofaNearYou · 13/07/2023 12:16

pikkumyy77 · 13/07/2023 12:08

Woah Asofanearyou! Should women be grateful men put up with them at all because being with another person is so much trouble and infringes on the right to be perfectly selfish at all times? Mothers and children are a package deal—as are fathers and children ideally. The children aren’t pets you tolerate so you can have sex with the owner.

We're plainly not going to agree. Like it or not when you come with kids, they are doing you a huge favour by putting in the effort that renders necessary. Yes you are a package deal but that package is more complicated and difficult than a conventional one that doesn't include children. I don't think there should be anything controversial about acknowledging that, and would do so about someone "taking on" my kids. Hopefully they will enjoy it, and they will likely need to for the relationship to work, but that doesn't change the fact that they've done a huge amount for me by taking it on.

I don't have a lot of time or patience for precious and defensive parents that expect people to be grateful for the honour of looking after their kids.

IncomingTraffic · 13/07/2023 12:09

I think of people were describing themselves and their role as a stepmother in the terms people are using to discuss stepfathers here, there’d be outrage. The sense of replacing fathers in children’s lives that comes across in many posts would not be well received if it were mothers rather than fathers.

pikkumyy77 · 13/07/2023 12:08

Woah Asofanearyou! Should women be grateful men put up with them at all because being with another person is so much trouble and infringes on the right to be perfectly selfish at all times? Mothers and children are a package deal—as are fathers and children ideally. The children aren’t pets you tolerate so you can have sex with the owner.

pikkumyy77 · 13/07/2023 12:03

one of my favorite teachers was a widow with five children when she met and married another teacher who indeed became their father 👨i n every sense of the word. Yes you should expect that frim anyone you were with.

violetcuriosity · 13/07/2023 12:01

My dp is step dad to my older daughter (her dad suffered a brain injury) we got together when she was 5 and she's 8 now. We also have a baby together. Their relationship isn't father/daughter but it is lovely and special and exactly the way they both want it. The only issues we have is that I am very much her default parent and am the one who tells her off etc and sometimes I would like him to step in more but, it's never been that way between them and you can't force things to be a way that hasn't organically grown. I think the most he's ever done discipline wise is tell her to have 3 more mouthfuls at dinner 🤣.

I don't think you will find someone who will become your child's father but you will find someone who is willing to be a special person in your child's life and it work for your family.

bobby81 · 13/07/2023 11:56

I met DP through mutual friends when I was 39. He has a great relationship with my DC (he doesn't have any of his own.) My DD doesn't have any contact with her biological father so she has a particularly close relationship with DP, he's brilliant with her & I couldn't ask for anymore.

sighu · 13/07/2023 11:31

So happy to read some of these posts. Even if it never happens for me, I genuinely feel so much more positive that good and decent people are out there. My ex sadly is an awful, neglectful and nasty piece of work. (And no, he didn’t behave that way prior to my pregnancy!)

OP posts:
familyissues12345 · 13/07/2023 11:16

I met mine online, I was very open and honest from day one that I had this two year old at home who was my number one- if he couldn't cope with that, then walk away.

I never expected him to take DS on as his own. As it is, he did and has been the best step dad I could have ever wished for. We also have a son together but you wouldn't know there is any difference between the two boys. I was just very lucky to find him and get told that often!

He's currently supporting DS financially through Uni whilst his Dad is couldn't wait to stop paying. No questions asked, what DS wants/needs he gets. He's so very proud of him

AccidentallySuckedTheStrippersDick · 13/07/2023 10:49

My DH took on my two age 3 and 2. Then we went on to have 2 more. The eldest two never knew their dad growing up so he's all they know. They adore him and he them. They are 25 and 24 now and last night we slept with our 3yo grandson between us for our first sleep over. We lay there whispering about how amazing it was being grand parents, he really is a an excellent grandad. And these days he's probably closer to my our eldest than I am, they have always had a very close bond and have called him dad since we got married and he got a residency order and charged their names via the courts. He would have adopted them but their biological father refused even though he knew he would never see them again. But thankfully the cuourts gave them our married name so we were a proper family on paper . People are always amazed when I say we are a blended family and we've had several people assume I'm their step mum 😂🤷🏼‍♀️

aSofaNearYou · 13/07/2023 10:24

RachelNoire · 12/07/2023 22:47

I hate that phrase “took on” someone else’s kids like they are some saviour doing you a favour!

And of course it is possible to meet someone who will like you for you

Well you're not a saviour but you are doing them a favour, yes. I think people need to be realistic about that and stop assuming it's a privilege that the step parent should be grateful for.

I don't think it's impossible to find what you're looking for OP but don't go into it assuming everyone should feel that way and trying to force it/guilt every man you meet into seeing your child as their own because you feel that's how it should be. Many will not feel that way and that's perfectly natural, don't drag it out, just move on if you require that.

Your other alternatives are to date but live separately, or to date a man with kids of his own so things are more equitable, or to have another baby on your own if that's the priority.

Swipe left for the next trending thread