Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To show you what the police actually face in the course of their duty

261 replies

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 20:40

fb.watch/lKKA2uMzFn/?startTimeMs=40000

This is already in the public domain .

I see a lot of negative comments about police and some of it , rightly so.

But this sums up for me what the job is about .
And why normal everyday men and women , like me , join the police service .

The bravery shown here is commendable .

Thanks for taking the time to watch .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Horrox · 12/07/2023 23:53

I don't dispute the issues with the CPS and the defence at all, but countless rape survivors describe being let down by the police at every stage.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 12/07/2023 23:52

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:47

Because the real problem is the cps and courts . That's just the truth .

Court is awful . The cps do not help us get rapes to court.

I've worked with rape victims . I've never had a single instance where I didnt believe the victim . But getting g the jobs to court is a battle with cps first and then the defence are allowed to rip the VIXTIM.to pieces. And that's wrong .

I'm stating facts however unpalatable that might be to read .

Because the real problem is the cps and courts

A fifth of victims who make a police report retract it when faced with the police demanding access to cell phones and medical records. But the real problem is other agencies... Hmm

HereToo · 12/07/2023 23:52

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 22:48

Omg .

Really ? Child pornography then . Child sexual exploitation.

Indecent images.

I often use layman's terms .

You also referred to black people as 'coloured' a few weeks ago.

You really don't do yourself or your profession any favours OP.

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:47

Horrox · 12/07/2023 23:43

OK, OP, I hear you about the positive contributions you believe you personally have made. In that context how can you begin to justify this quite astounding claim:
The police are least of your worries in a rape case

Because the real problem is the cps and courts . That's just the truth .

Court is awful . The cps do not help us get rapes to court.

I've worked with rape victims . I've never had a single instance where I didnt believe the victim . But getting g the jobs to court is a battle with cps first and then the defence are allowed to rip the VIXTIM.to pieces. And that's wrong .

I'm stating facts however unpalatable that might be to read .

OP posts:
Dogandbabymama · 12/07/2023 23:44

I have utmost respect for you and your colleagues- thank you for everything you do.

As others have pointed out - there are bad apples in every walk if life. What

powershowerforanhour · 12/07/2023 23:44

"I've worked in housing for 30 years. Workers I've know have gone through every single thing in that video. Ditto nurses, paramedics and some fire fighters. Social workers, shit even Council employees.

It's rough, it's traumatising, it's dangerous and people in those jobs are brave."

Where I am from:
-Nurses and paramedics, social workers etc, like most of those types of jobs, sometimes get sworn at and occasionally spat at (mental health care workers more than others).
-Firefighters get stoned in certain areas

  • and police officers get all of the above, plus petrol bombs and big lumps of masonry thrown at them on occasion, and sometimes shot. Like DCI Caldwell who was shot multiple times at close range by two gunmen, when he was off duty, in front of children, including his own son, at a football session he had been coaching. He lived, unlike poor Ronan Kerr (who was also in my home town when he suffered the attack- by car bomb- that killed him).
I don't know of any social workers or medics, bar the late great Dr John Hinds, from this neck of the woods who have died at work.
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 12/07/2023 23:44

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:34

I hardly thin using the term kiddy porn is akin to taking photos of murder victims and sharing them .

I've railed against the dinosaurs I came up against in the job . I've reported wrong doing if I've seen it . My language may be - decisive - but in my work I can hand in heart say I've always been empathetic, kind , neutral and did my best .

I have over the years given a lot of support and advice to people on here , which I now choose not to do because it's too fraught . I name change every couple of weeks and now I've outed myself I will again .

I relate to the people in my community and I've done some great work for domestic violence victims, victims of sexual assault and abuse and rape . I dont really care what a bunch of strangers think of my use of language.

I know in my heart I've done a lot for victims because of my common sense approach and my willingness to empathise and listen . If that doesn't come across here then that's fine .

One of my dance friends is a copper. She went into policing after over a decade in social work. I have no doubt that she will be a credit to her profession and do a lot of good. But this doesn't negate the points I and others have made about distrusting the police as an institution and why we distrust them.

I suggested a moratorium on hiring men as a means of busting the frat boy culture that encouraged Couzens and continues to encourage those like him because I believe that the police is still worthy of reformation and retention, not disbanding.

Horrox · 12/07/2023 23:43

OK, OP, I hear you about the positive contributions you believe you personally have made. In that context how can you begin to justify this quite astounding claim:
The police are least of your worries in a rape case

Moominprincess · 12/07/2023 23:42

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:34

I hardly thin using the term kiddy porn is akin to taking photos of murder victims and sharing them .

I've railed against the dinosaurs I came up against in the job . I've reported wrong doing if I've seen it . My language may be - decisive - but in my work I can hand in heart say I've always been empathetic, kind , neutral and did my best .

I have over the years given a lot of support and advice to people on here , which I now choose not to do because it's too fraught . I name change every couple of weeks and now I've outed myself I will again .

I relate to the people in my community and I've done some great work for domestic violence victims, victims of sexual assault and abuse and rape . I dont really care what a bunch of strangers think of my use of language.

I know in my heart I've done a lot for victims because of my common sense approach and my willingness to empathise and listen . If that doesn't come across here then that's fine .

But noone is attacking you. If you have upheld moral and legal standards and treated people humanely I don't know why you feel so personally attacked. I don't blame you for the way I was treated. The only thing I have questioned is that not everyone is like you say you are and my experience (and others on the thread) suggest noone they experienced was like you say you are. So how do you expect us to champion you all as an institution of good when that isn't our experience personally?

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:39

Daphnis156 · 12/07/2023 23:34

I never see a policeman so don't really know what they do.
Round here they may not come out even for a murder.
There do seem to rather a lot of rapists, perverts and murderers in the police.
Not to mention institutional racism, misogyny and homophobia.

Trust me - the police would come out for a murder . And much less .

OP posts:
Greenshake · 12/07/2023 23:39

Daphnis156 · 12/07/2023 23:34

I never see a policeman so don't really know what they do.
Round here they may not come out even for a murder.
There do seem to rather a lot of rapists, perverts and murderers in the police.
Not to mention institutional racism, misogyny and homophobia.

Your second line is ridiculous and I don’t believe it for a second.

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:34

I hardly thin using the term kiddy porn is akin to taking photos of murder victims and sharing them .

I've railed against the dinosaurs I came up against in the job . I've reported wrong doing if I've seen it . My language may be - decisive - but in my work I can hand in heart say I've always been empathetic, kind , neutral and did my best .

I have over the years given a lot of support and advice to people on here , which I now choose not to do because it's too fraught . I name change every couple of weeks and now I've outed myself I will again .

I relate to the people in my community and I've done some great work for domestic violence victims, victims of sexual assault and abuse and rape . I dont really care what a bunch of strangers think of my use of language.

I know in my heart I've done a lot for victims because of my common sense approach and my willingness to empathise and listen . If that doesn't come across here then that's fine .

OP posts:
Daphnis156 · 12/07/2023 23:34

I never see a policeman so don't really know what they do.
Round here they may not come out even for a murder.
There do seem to rather a lot of rapists, perverts and murderers in the police.
Not to mention institutional racism, misogyny and homophobia.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 12/07/2023 23:31

powershowerforanhour · 12/07/2023 23:23

"we don't hear of bus and taxi drivers, retail and hospitality workers, doctors, firefighters, or MR and RNLI volunteers using the power to arrest that is invested in them by virtue of their jobs to rape and murder, because these people don't have the power of arrest."
Hmmm
Harold Shipman
Beverley Allitt
Lucy Letby
used the trust placed in them and the tools of their trade to kill. No handcuffs needed.
Colin Howell also used the tools of his trade to kill and his profession lent him an air of respectability. He also used his job to drug and sexually assault trusting patients in his workplace l.
John Worboys didn't need handcuffs to get trusting victims into his vehicle either.

Did they have colleagues egging them in via WhatsApp? Did Worboys use his position as a taxi driver to intimidate his victims into not reporting? Are the papers reporting that there are hundreds of undetected rapists working as taxi drivers, nurses,or doctors? No, but they report that about the police.

Hundreds of police officers accused of sexual misconduct - with few charged

Wayne Couzens and David Carrick may be the most high-profile examples - but hundreds more officers have faced allegations of wrongdoing in recent years.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1787284/police-sexual-misconduct-couzens-carrick

Moominprincess · 12/07/2023 23:28

powershowerforanhour · 12/07/2023 23:23

"we don't hear of bus and taxi drivers, retail and hospitality workers, doctors, firefighters, or MR and RNLI volunteers using the power to arrest that is invested in them by virtue of their jobs to rape and murder, because these people don't have the power of arrest."
Hmmm
Harold Shipman
Beverley Allitt
Lucy Letby
used the trust placed in them and the tools of their trade to kill. No handcuffs needed.
Colin Howell also used the tools of his trade to kill and his profession lent him an air of respectability. He also used his job to drug and sexually assault trusting patients in his workplace l.
John Worboys didn't need handcuffs to get trusting victims into his vehicle either.

I don't understand your argument. Just because other professions that we trust can't always be trusted doesn't mean we shouldn't criticise the genuine abuses of position we have encountered in the police. All you are suggesting is that we should be able to fight these abuses more easily everywhere surely.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 12/07/2023 23:28

I forget Mumsnet is full of middle class women who Haven't heard any northern terms.

Could you be more classist?

I am from Liverpool and we don't call child sexual abuse images "kiddy porn". And my cousin and grandmother and aunt from the Durham coalfields do not say "eh up", nor do they call CSA images "kiddy porn".

powershowerforanhour · 12/07/2023 23:23

"we don't hear of bus and taxi drivers, retail and hospitality workers, doctors, firefighters, or MR and RNLI volunteers using the power to arrest that is invested in them by virtue of their jobs to rape and murder, because these people don't have the power of arrest."
Hmmm
Harold Shipman
Beverley Allitt
Lucy Letby
used the trust placed in them and the tools of their trade to kill. No handcuffs needed.
Colin Howell also used the tools of his trade to kill and his profession lent him an air of respectability. He also used his job to drug and sexually assault trusting patients in his workplace l.
John Worboys didn't need handcuffs to get trusting victims into his vehicle either.

Sunsetandsunrise · 12/07/2023 23:22

Happyandyoudontknowit · 12/07/2023 21:14

Those slagging off the police, are you going to hesitate phoning these racist, homophobic pigs if you are in trouble? I thought not.

Firstly, my taxes go towards them so yeah I’ll ring them if I need /want to irrespective of my view on them, but the few times I have asked them for help after suffering threats and racist abuse on two occasion they were deliberately useless so I may or may not bother calling them.

BodegaSushi · 12/07/2023 23:22

Tangledbaby · 12/07/2023 23:08

@baggiesmalls that doesn’t wash. Are you honestly saying when a member of the public reports the crime of child sexual abuse, you refer it back to them as ‘kiddy porn’?

If you don’t, then where would you use it? Why would that ever need to be in your vocabulary? Who is it used to and why?

Well, given the language that MET officers used in leaked WhatsApps discussing Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman, I can believe it.

Once again, OP proves the point she's trying to argue against.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 12/07/2023 23:20

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Criticism of the police as an institution does not mean criticism of individual officers. Criticism of institutional failings that allowed men like Wayne Couzens and David Garrick to not only go unchallenged for so long, but to be encouraged by colleagues, is not blaming you as an individual for what these men did.

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:17

Horrox · 12/07/2023 23:14

The OP is making massive and often incorrect assumptions there about where posters are from. They are also showing their prejudices about Northerners and about certain women too.

Child pornography
Not this either. Child Sexual Abuse images.

Oh purleeeease .

Yes all that .

Please just watch the video . Thank you .

fb.watch/lKT-s7fIgQ/?startTimeMs=140000

OP posts:
Horrox · 12/07/2023 23:14

The OP is making massive and often incorrect assumptions there about where posters are from. They are also showing their prejudices about Northerners and about certain women too.

Child pornography
Not this either. Child Sexual Abuse images.

Florenz · 12/07/2023 23:14

I support the police 100%. I absolutely despise criminals. Whenever I hear about the police shooting a criminal, regardless of the circumstances, I think "good".

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:13

Ok . I've wobbled my head . Sorry .
Of course I meant indecent images involving children .

Well actually pseudo indecent images. He made them on his computer and kept them in his desk at the surgery .

If that's any better.

OP posts:
DoristheDuchess · 12/07/2023 23:10

I forget Mumsnet is full of middle class women who Haven't heard any northern terms

Are you kidding?? what a load of patronising clap trap.

You think we all use the term kiddy porn in the North. Give your head a serious wobble.