Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To show you what the police actually face in the course of their duty

261 replies

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 20:40

fb.watch/lKKA2uMzFn/?startTimeMs=40000

This is already in the public domain .

I see a lot of negative comments about police and some of it , rightly so.

But this sums up for me what the job is about .
And why normal everyday men and women , like me , join the police service .

The bravery shown here is commendable .

Thanks for taking the time to watch .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 10:13

Noduckpicsplease · 13/07/2023 09:54

Just because they've passed a DBS doesn't mean they aren't a sex offender. Just means they haven't been convicted. Jimmy Saville had passed checks.

The point is potential officers DO have sex convictions and are STILL recruited - and many offend when on the job but keep their jobs. This wouldn’t happen in teaching. I’m not arguing the pros and cons of DBS checks I’m arguing about the different standards held for people whose profession is to protect the vulernable

Hereinthismoment · 13/07/2023 10:10

No, I think it was me, I was trying to say that I don’t think (ime anyway) that covering for colleagues’ dodgy behaviour does happen in schools. A lot of the time you might see something that’s probably totally harmless but then the person needs some sort of appropriate guidance or advice. Whereas on here I tend to see ‘poor teacher, no wonder men don’t want to be teachers, no wonder they are leaving in droves’ sort of comments. Anyway sorry - I digress!

OneTC · 13/07/2023 10:08

Sorry, it's probably me Blush

Hereinthismoment · 13/07/2023 10:06

@OneTC that was sort of my point! Clearly not very well expressed Grin

OneTC · 13/07/2023 10:05

Hereinthismoment · 13/07/2023 09:53

Tbh, I find MN more in denial about teachers than actual teachers are.

In RL we have It Could Happen Here drummed into us (unfortunately at my school it is It Has Happened Here, Multiple Times!)

On MN kids are all lying and poor teacher.

Did everyone else cover up for them?

LimeLimeLime · 13/07/2023 10:00

Caradonna · 13/07/2023 06:37

I was a nurse and no I never felt that people would view me like Beverly Allit but then nursing does not have a culture of covering up for colleagues who should not be in the job.

^^
from a previous post . There are actual tv programmes about how badly people are treated who whistleblow in the NHS. There’s definitely not enough whistleblowing - see recent appalling midwifery deaths.

Midwives are a very different breed from nurses. That "All for one and one for all" coverup culture that the Morecambe Bay midwives had, doesn't exist in nursing.

carpetedbathroom · 13/07/2023 09:59

Lots of opinions here, let me chuck mine in!

I was in the job. I did a fair old stint (a good 12-13 years). For the most part it's crap. No employee rights, bad hours, poor pay, being a whipping boy for the public, the media, your own senior officers. Much like a referee, there are no good decisions for every person who approves of one you make, another hates you for it.

As for the misogyny etc it's obviously there. Can't say I saw too much of it - this speaks to my next point.

The real issue in the plod is apathy. I was smart enough to keep my friends, hobbies and life outside the job going. That kept me sane - but other than my immediate teammates in any unit I was on I knew little of the other officers. I would say hello and make small talk, but a lot of them weren't my sort of people. I can see how the issues raised took root - a lot of proto-wannabe-alpha male attitudes coupled with a them and us attitude borne of the whipping boy status. The police attracts a lot of unsuitable people - the training and selection is nowhere near rigorous enough to root them out. When the law changed to make almost anything arrestable as long as you could prove necessity, what brain was used shut down. Common assault suitable for reporting at best? Bring them in and hand it over. Affray in street 20 minutes ago (used to be found commiting type offence) with no allegations or injuries by the time you turn up? Fuck it nick them all. Discretion went out the window.

I was totally apathetic by the end. I would book off weekends as much as possible, late shifts. I was a DC by that point who could not get any time to do any detecting as the pressure was on to race from scene to scene.

All in, glad I left. I earn three times what I used to, I work 9-5 mon-fri half WFH and am much happier.

It's just a job. Do you know the attitudes of all your coworkers? People being sexist, yeah the dumb ones will speak in public but the real nasty ones will have their inner circle and that's it.

TLDR - the issues are blatant, from experience it's a shit job with not great pay but provides a modicum of perceived power - we are shocked to find it attracts the wrong sort of people!

The poster who commented about rape victims having their phone and medical records scrutinised - you can thank the CPS and defence firms for that one. Most rapes, subjects have been either known or have spent some time in each others company beforehand (be it friends or met in a club or spoken over OLd or whatever) the case hinges on the argument over consent. A defence wants to introduce the slightest hint of reasonable doubt on the victims testimony that it was non consensual. They claim that the victim lives a lavcious life,vthat maybe they have a medical condition making them prone to memory lapse or whatever. They lean on the CPS, state that not all evidence has been properly examined and chuck out the case. The CPS for their part (who make the decision to charge or not in the first place) won't run a case unless it's a slam dunk so they wanna know if there are places a defence could attack so tell the police to check victims phone etc. It's a shit situation but for that (and that only) I will defend the plod a little and say that if you want rape convictions to change you need a root and stem change in the criminal justice system.

Right, that was all very cathartic. Back to staring at word docs and watching YouTube.

As you were.

Noduckpicsplease · 13/07/2023 09:54

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:52

No I don’t think anyone who has a DBS check show they’re a sex offender, or offends whilst a teacher, is recruited to a teaching job.

Just because they've passed a DBS doesn't mean they aren't a sex offender. Just means they haven't been convicted. Jimmy Saville had passed checks.

DoristheDuchess · 13/07/2023 09:54

superplumb · 13/07/2023 07:32

Sadly on mumnet you will get the anti police mob. People assume that all police are racist rapists. Because no other criminals work in other sectors like the NHS, murdering gps, nurses who kill babies, consultant who molest children with cancer...but yeah..it's only the police who are wrong uns.

Pretty sure Harold Shipman's colleagues didn't have a nice little nickname for him like 'killer'', in the same way that Wayne Couzens mates nicknamed him 'the rapist'. It was a well known and shared joke amongst his colleagues. They knew and did nothing. That's the difference.

Isolated incidents of criminality in trusted professions are horrific and need to be dealt with to the maximum penalty of the law. Enabling others to continue to commit criminal acts through a toxic culture is a rot that needs to be called out and dealt with, without fear or favour.

Hereinthismoment · 13/07/2023 09:53

Tbh, I find MN more in denial about teachers than actual teachers are.

In RL we have It Could Happen Here drummed into us (unfortunately at my school it is It Has Happened Here, Multiple Times!)

On MN kids are all lying and poor teacher.

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:52

Noduckpicsplease · 13/07/2023 09:51

Sorry do you honestly believe that there aren't any sexual offenders who are teachers?!

I have personally known of a few, just in my area. I know my partner has dealt with many. Doesn't mean they think all teachers are or that our children shouldn't go to a school.

No I don’t think anyone who has a DBS check show they’re a sex offender, or offends whilst a teacher, is recruited to a teaching job.

Noduckpicsplease · 13/07/2023 09:51

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:42

How many sex offenders are teachers?

Sorry do you honestly believe that there aren't any sexual offenders who are teachers?!

I have personally known of a few, just in my area. I know my partner has dealt with many. Doesn't mean they think all teachers are or that our children shouldn't go to a school.

Hereinthismoment · 13/07/2023 09:51

superplumb · 13/07/2023 07:32

Sadly on mumnet you will get the anti police mob. People assume that all police are racist rapists. Because no other criminals work in other sectors like the NHS, murdering gps, nurses who kill babies, consultant who molest children with cancer...but yeah..it's only the police who are wrong uns.

Not quite. It isn’t about them being ‘criminals’ or otherwise, it is more a set of attitudes which firstly in the most extreme cases allow criminal behaviour to go unchallenged (the Sarah Everard murder perhaps being the most extreme) but on a more low level sort of way inherent values which have led to huge problems and things being ‘shaken up’ except they never are.

Both the defensive ‘the police are HEROES’ (and I feel like I had a pisshead following me around with a phone slurring watch the video) and the ‘the police are arseholes’ are dogmatic and not helpful. I know two serving policemen who I know are good eggs. I also know I’ve been fortunate enough never to have had a bad encounter with the police although admittedly and luckily that’s fairly limited. But I’m not black and I’ve never reported a sexual crime, to be blunt. I honestly don’t know how anyone can start whataboutery because of Shipman or whoever, unless we seriously think the NHS is routinely hiring serial killers. However, many of us have a similar view with the NHS: individuals in it are good, as a system, it’s breaking down. In that case it’s more to do with funding and layers of complex bureaucracy than attitudes within but still illustrates the point. You can be against a system without thinking everyone in that system is some sort of evil fucker.

OneTC · 13/07/2023 09:45

Noduckpicsplease · 13/07/2023 09:40

Totally baffled by the idea you don't think police go through safeguarding checks.
My partner is way more thoroughly checked then I am, as a teacher. They also checked out his parents, step parents and me.

It's because of all the fucking weirdos that have been working for them for decades despite being known wronguns

OneTC · 13/07/2023 09:43

The way too many police react to criticism tells you everything you need to know about them. Say anything bad about any of them and most of them are clamouring but NAPALT. Same rules apply, as the bad ones don't wear any extra badges, it's right for people to wonder if the one they're dealing with is one of the racist, misogynist, corrupt or dishonest ones.

Yes it matters in other professions and people would be equally suspicious of any organisation that closed ranks like this and minimised it's criminal behaviour.

The police have known for years about this sudden slew of convictions. The organisation as a whole needs to accept it's lost the confidence of much of the public and needs to accept that's going to take some time to heal, if they're bothered about healing it at all

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:42

Noduckpicsplease · 13/07/2023 09:40

Totally baffled by the idea you don't think police go through safeguarding checks.
My partner is way more thoroughly checked then I am, as a teacher. They also checked out his parents, step parents and me.

How many sex offenders are teachers?

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:41

Very odd that OP sees all Northerners as working class. I live in the North in one of the most MC places in England.

I am laughing at the thought OP being like Julio Geordio to fit in with da kidz though

Noduckpicsplease · 13/07/2023 09:40

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 12/07/2023 22:19

If only David Carrick's victims had known of this mythical PSD. Perhaps the first would have been the last. Or perhaps not...

You are totally missing the point, which is that the combination of powers of arrest and professional reputation as a "sworn officet" make it very easy for a wrong'un to harm a lot of women and very easy to convince said women that they won't be believed.

Such a job attracts wrong'uns, in the same way that teaching attracts paedophiles. It will take reforms as big as the baked-in safeguarding introduced for teachers to restore public confidence in the police. And that isn't a reflection on you as an individual officer.

Totally baffled by the idea you don't think police go through safeguarding checks.
My partner is way more thoroughly checked then I am, as a teacher. They also checked out his parents, step parents and me.

StellaAndCrow · 13/07/2023 09:38

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:04

Can I just point out I work in ex pit villages up north .

Not the Home Counties .

People here do not understand police speak . Being from a rather cosmopolitan bit city that's got a reputation for being a bit posh I learned to use the language I hear around me and swear - a lot .

Because that's the environment I work in . Ex pit villages . Northern . They didn't like my posh accent or my inability to use local language initially so now I say "eh up" like a local and swear without flinching.

That's the reality of where I work . I relate to my audience . I relate to the people I work with in the community I work in . I forget Mumsnet is full of middle class women who
Haven't heard any northern terms .

I saw a Catherine rate sketch the other day about an agency nanny being from "The North" and the horror that instilled .

Soz .!

I really don't know if you're being deliberately offensive here, or genuinely don't realise how you sound or how skewed your views are.

I live and work in Northern ex-mining villages, and work in a role where I am dealing with all manner of the public. I don't use offensive terms in order to fit in. If someone I was working with used the term "kiddy porn", I wouldn't use the term myself.

Funnily enough northerners from pit villages don't all say "eh up" and swear. But even if they did, it wouldn't mean that I would too. I swear fine in my private life, but would rarely swear at work because it's not professional.

Honestly, you seem to see Northerners as "other", and it's a bit off.

Naunet · 13/07/2023 09:34

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:18

Look, there are good police and there are bad police. As individuals. But there IS a well documented culture problem in the police which has made many of us distrust them as a whole. It would be nice if rather than getting ultra defensive or challenging people to change careers, police on here would say “I do the best job I can and don’t get sucked into that toxic culture, it I recognise it’s there and it needs to change”. But they don’t. They just cry saying “I can’t believe people think I’m a racist!”

They think they’re entitled to the public’s respect and awe and are angry that they’re no longer being given it so are demanding it, rather than actually trying to regain the public’s trust.

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:19

HereToo · 12/07/2023 23:52

You also referred to black people as 'coloured' a few weeks ago.

You really don't do yourself or your profession any favours OP.

Wow!! Seriously?

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:18

Look, there are good police and there are bad police. As individuals. But there IS a well documented culture problem in the police which has made many of us distrust them as a whole. It would be nice if rather than getting ultra defensive or challenging people to change careers, police on here would say “I do the best job I can and don’t get sucked into that toxic culture, it I recognise it’s there and it needs to change”. But they don’t. They just cry saying “I can’t believe people think I’m a racist!”

StellaAndCrow · 13/07/2023 09:13

Slightly off track, but has the meaning of the phrase "bad apple" changed? It seems to be used to mean "it's only one bad apple" i.e. a one off.

I've always known it to mean "one bad apple spoils the barrel", from when apples used to get stored for winter, people would carefully check that all the apples were "good" i.e. not bruised/rotten because that would spread to the other apples.

I first read it in an Enid Blyton story, where a boy was asked by his mum to check the apples as he was putting them into winter storage; he thought it would be ok to let one bad one in, and all the apples ended up spoiled.

I appreciate though that Enid Blyton might not be the best primary source!

What does "one bad apple" mean in today's use?

WeetabixTowels · 13/07/2023 09:07

baggiesmalls · 12/07/2023 23:04

Can I just point out I work in ex pit villages up north .

Not the Home Counties .

People here do not understand police speak . Being from a rather cosmopolitan bit city that's got a reputation for being a bit posh I learned to use the language I hear around me and swear - a lot .

Because that's the environment I work in . Ex pit villages . Northern . They didn't like my posh accent or my inability to use local language initially so now I say "eh up" like a local and swear without flinching.

That's the reality of where I work . I relate to my audience . I relate to the people I work with in the community I work in . I forget Mumsnet is full of middle class women who
Haven't heard any northern terms .

I saw a Catherine rate sketch the other day about an agency nanny being from "The North" and the horror that instilled .

Soz .!

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Actually it’s not funny that people this ridiculous and up themselves are serving in our forces and think they do a good job around the Northern thickos

Alexandra2001 · 13/07/2023 08:48

DdraigGoch · 12/07/2023 21:02

Indeed

There are 10s of '000s of excellent Police officers but that should not take away from the '000s who let the force down.

Burying your heads in the sand and pretending the Police in the UK don't have very serious (& unresolved) problems is just the other side of the coin that says they are all racist pigs etc etc.

Yet again, under funding over the last decade or so has wrecked public confidence in the Police, not least the closure of so many 'stations, making the police feel remote from the communities they serve.