Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of social media kangaroo court

114 replies

Minerva38 · 12/07/2023 19:34

Not here to discuss specifics of BBC presenters case or get on my high horse about the morality of it. Bottom line is no crime is deemed to have been committed and so far allegations have come vía the gutter rag that is The Sun and endless speculation on social media.

Before the police had even looked into things, the Sun and social media were already rife with speculation and it seems this is now the modern Court where we judge and condemn anyone famous who might have had something happen in their private lives. It's a sick feeding frenzy and everyone has to have an opinion.

Now the family are forced to identify the man and news and social channels are feasting on this endlessly.

Caroline Flacks death clearly hasn't taught us anything and I won't be surprised if this or other cases go that way too.

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 13/07/2023 08:07

Does only the law set someone’s moral compass

I never hit on young adults, I do not pester young (or any) colleagues with flirty text message or messages of a sexual nature - I don’t want to and when it has been done to me I have found this extremely uncomfortable

C8H10N4O2 · 13/07/2023 08:04

PoePoePoePoe · 13/07/2023 07:46

Boris Johnson and the government being in contempt of a high court order.

Home Office taking actions to stop traumatised children feeling just a little bit less terrified.

At least 8 Tory MPs suspended and/or under investigation for harassment or sex offences.

UK reneging on its climate change commitments.

Government restricting citizens’ rights and looking to pull out of our human right commitments.

But yes, let’s keep people busy arguing over how much we should know about the life of a sleazy bloke. Suits Murdoch and the government perfectly. Not saying it’s not news, but the top story for the best part of a week really?

Yes who cares if tax payer funded public figures abuse their status and power to pursue very young men and women? Unless they are politicians.

It is possible to object to more than one bad thing at a time. There has been no shortage of coverage of those items you list in my news feeds - perhaps you follow the wrong accounts/news journals.

violetcuriosity · 13/07/2023 08:02

People bring up Caroline Flack because it was somebody else who hadn't actually - yet- been convicted of a crime who was found guilty by the media and ended up dead.

HRTQueen · 13/07/2023 08:00

So it keeps being repeated we have only heard one side

yet more colleagues are coming forward about inappropriate behaviour- now why did they feel they couldn’t report this before

when do men who have acted inappropriately (crime committed or not) put their hands up and say well yes I was sexually inappropriate and abused my position of authority

how many have got to come forward until they are believed we don’t need to see the evidence but we know that this is a pattern of behaviour many men follow and get away with for far too long

SummerSunSoon · 13/07/2023 07:59

I’m sick of people trotting out Caroline Flack at times like this.

A 60 year old bloke preying on very young adults is sick. These men usually keep it just legal. It doesn’t stop them being predatory, unethical and immoral.

gogomoto · 13/07/2023 07:59

@LakeTiticaca

The law says it's not illegal. Young people aren't passive in this, they are choosing to sell said pictures. Seedy doesn't mean illegal and the Sun implied illegal to set off the feeding frenzy. He won't be back on our screens, but they'll be another for sure because exploitation goes both ways

EarringsandLipstick · 13/07/2023 07:58

In the U.K. there is no law forbidding the exchange of images between adults as far as I'm aware, no law against infidelity - this is a personal tragedy for his family nothing more

Legal, yes.

Morally & ethically right, it would appear not.

It is more than a personal tragedy (and I'd dispute the use of the word 'tragedy' given how deliberate his actions were). He's a public figure of trust - he represents a venerable institution & can no longer to do with any authority.

With sounding overly moralistic, he's also a role model, and has failed in that regard.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 13/07/2023 07:56

gogomoto · 13/07/2023 07:54

Sex sells, always has, always will.

Sad but true.

In the U.K. there is no law forbidding the exchange of images between adults as far as I'm aware, no law against infidelity - this is a personal tragedy for his family nothing more. Time to let it rest

Unfortunately this looks like another consequence of homophobia in the past, where men felt they had to suppress feelings and marry - he's far from alone, yes we know about Philip Schofield but for every "celebrity" there's hundreds of private tragedies in normal society where women (and it's normally women) in what they thought was happy marriages find out their middle aged husband has a secret life with men. I know one personally.

Let's hope the younger generations can be true to themselves from the start.

I’m not clear if you are inviting sympathy for the men who behave in this way but to the extent you are, I think my store is empty - or I should say, reserved for the women who waste their lives on this dishonesty.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/07/2023 07:54

the ever whining Vine).

Love this! (Don't have a huge amount of exposure to Vine, as am in Ireland, bar knowing who he is etc)

gogomoto · 13/07/2023 07:54

Sex sells, always has, always will.

Sad but true.

In the U.K. there is no law forbidding the exchange of images between adults as far as I'm aware, no law against infidelity - this is a personal tragedy for his family nothing more. Time to let it rest

Unfortunately this looks like another consequence of homophobia in the past, where men felt they had to suppress feelings and marry - he's far from alone, yes we know about Philip Schofield but for every "celebrity" there's hundreds of private tragedies in normal society where women (and it's normally women) in what they thought was happy marriages find out their middle aged husband has a secret life with men. I know one personally.

Let's hope the younger generations can be true to themselves from the start.

Superdupes · 13/07/2023 07:53

What we learnt from Caroline Flack was that women are capable of DV too. I have no idea why people are desperate to present her as some sort of saint. If you live your life in the media then don't be hitting people with lamps or buying sexual pictures of young people and be expecting to get away with it and no one to hear about it. The women excusing these things are the ones spouting bekind as a way to shut others up.

I thought the pictures were supposed to be of a male not a female - didn't the Sun start by saying 'he' and then change it to gender neutral later?

C8H10N4O2 · 13/07/2023 07:53

EarringsandLipstick · 13/07/2023 07:28

I was fully against the frothing speculation of who the presenter was, before he was named. The threads here, the rabid SM naming - completely wrong.

Not however because of Huw Edwards, but because of all the innocent named individuals who had to publicly deny the allegations. It's disgraceful that thanks to an action of another, that these men get placed in the position.

I'm shocked by the volume of high level, well-known personality support of someone who at a minimum has exercised really poor judgment and behaved unethically, with particular reference to his public role. He may have done more than this, in terms of his treatment & engagement of young vulnerable people. I'm shocked at the 'private life' 'not criminal' line of defence that's being trotted out. If you enjoy the privileges of a public role, your right to utter privacy in every matter cannot be guaranteed. Equally, behaviour can be shameful, damaging & wrong, without being criminal.

Finally, the hiding behind MH defence is wrong for those who genuinely experience such issues and for whom their exposure in the public eye is a cause of MH difficulties. Huw Edwards' problems are directly of his own making.

Yes I agree with all of this (although tbh, my sympathy is moderated for the ever whining Vine).

Since the publication other people have come forward including members of BBC staff to complain about his behaviour. Some may be jumping on a bandwagon but junior members of staff put their jobs on the line when they complain about star talent.

What we have even without the Sun spin is a 61 year old male celeb on a tax payer funded £450k salary, the voice of a great public institution and whilst in position he is pursuing young men for sexual gradification. The power disparity is far too great for it to be any meeting of equals.

The young men might be the right side of "legal" but how many posters here would be happy with their own late teen/early 20s DC being pursued in this way?

I've known a lot of men and women with mental health issues and severe depression, I've yet to meet one who behaved in this way as a result (and they lacked celeb resources to private treatment).

The BBC are still investigating his behaviour - an investigation which is now going to be very difficult in the face of the PR campaign running heavily on the sympathy card. I can have sympathy for someone with mental illness and still have more for their victims.

PoePoePoePoe · 13/07/2023 07:46

Boris Johnson and the government being in contempt of a high court order.

Home Office taking actions to stop traumatised children feeling just a little bit less terrified.

At least 8 Tory MPs suspended and/or under investigation for harassment or sex offences.

UK reneging on its climate change commitments.

Government restricting citizens’ rights and looking to pull out of our human right commitments.

But yes, let’s keep people busy arguing over how much we should know about the life of a sleazy bloke. Suits Murdoch and the government perfectly. Not saying it’s not news, but the top story for the best part of a week really?

Againstmachine · 13/07/2023 07:42

violetcuriosity · 13/07/2023 07:20

Have we learnt nothing from Caroline Flack.

Why does everyone bring Caroline Flack out everytime, like she's some sort of angel.

This is about a seedy man.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 13/07/2023 07:33

I wonder what his contract of employment says. Something about not bringing the BBC into disrepute? If I were the Beeb I think I’d want that in exchange for the thick end of half a mill

EarringsandLipstick · 13/07/2023 07:28

I was fully against the frothing speculation of who the presenter was, before he was named. The threads here, the rabid SM naming - completely wrong.

Not however because of Huw Edwards, but because of all the innocent named individuals who had to publicly deny the allegations. It's disgraceful that thanks to an action of another, that these men get placed in the position.

I'm shocked by the volume of high level, well-known personality support of someone who at a minimum has exercised really poor judgment and behaved unethically, with particular reference to his public role. He may have done more than this, in terms of his treatment & engagement of young vulnerable people. I'm shocked at the 'private life' 'not criminal' line of defence that's being trotted out. If you enjoy the privileges of a public role, your right to utter privacy in every matter cannot be guaranteed. Equally, behaviour can be shameful, damaging & wrong, without being criminal.

Finally, the hiding behind MH defence is wrong for those who genuinely experience such issues and for whom their exposure in the public eye is a cause of MH difficulties. Huw Edwards' problems are directly of his own making.

3BSHKATS · 13/07/2023 07:24

violetcuriosity · 13/07/2023 07:20

Have we learnt nothing from Caroline Flack.

She was a deeply troubled individual who would have ended her own life whether she was on TV or working in waitrose. She was ill.

3BSHKATS · 13/07/2023 07:23

When the real courts wont act tgis is the result

Florissante · 13/07/2023 07:22

If you're sick of social media kangaroo courts, you might want to close down your MN account.

There are countless threads about MNs' partners, siblings, parents, in-laws etc in which the MNer is totally blameless while the other person is toxic, abusive, unreasonable etc. The MN chorus then chimes in, agreeing with the OP about how terrible the other person is.

violetcuriosity · 13/07/2023 07:20

Have we learnt nothing from Caroline Flack.

Olleochalex · 13/07/2023 07:19

The only reason I can see that he's done wrong is use licences payers money.

Has he? Hasn't just spent his wages? Doesn't matter who he gets paid by. He can spend his money how he likes.

This is an old-fashioned sex scandal. But we like to think we have moved on from that and so are reaching for new angles to justify outrage and interest.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/07/2023 07:19

AngeloMysterioso · 12/07/2023 19:54

I’m tired of people invoking Caroline Flack as the reason we should let shitty celebrities get away with doing shitty things.

👏

EarringsandLipstick · 13/07/2023 07:17

WhereTheSuburbsMeetUttoxeter · 12/07/2023 19:43

YANBU. I hope Huw gets well soon and is able to enjoy life in a way that suits him and his family.
He's made some terrible errors of judgement. He shouldn't be ashamed of being gay, or having severe mental health problems.
And... I know the two don't go hand in hand before anybody twists my words 🙄

I just hope that this doesn't end in another tragedy.

Good God.

Talk about wilful ignoring of facts & apologism

Againstmachine · 13/07/2023 07:13

Whilst not saying he has commited a crime, it's not surprising the MET can't find any wrong doing, they can't find it within their own force nevermind elsewhere.

avocadotofu · 13/07/2023 07:08

I absolutely agree. It's modern equivalent of the mob.