Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel defeated by school reports?

169 replies

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 16:59

I feel so sad at all three school reports and can't help but feel it's on me, as their primary parent, that i've let them fail badly.

DS is at expected level on all academic subjects, but the report is full of "he doesn't apply himself enough", "he lets others do it for him", "if he actually expressed it on paper....", he needs to improve his presentation", "He needs to improve his output / stamina" etc. I feel like this is obv about how we've parented him, that he doesn;t feel he needs to push himself or strive to do his best, that he's happy to sit back and just let everyone else do the work. I don't know how to get him to improve his productivity at school. On the occasions he does, school are so positive about it, but then the next day he just doesn't.
Then there's the twins who are at emerging on EVERYTHING, not a single thing at excpected level - is it because they're second borns and twins so i've just not tried enough with them? There isn't one area they're at the right level for.

They all go to the same school and the head teacher obviously reads all the reports, its a small school so she'll def clock the poor attainment is all from the same family.

I just feel so inadequate. I'm a SAHM so i don't even have an excuse of being busy with work.

OP posts:
Dorisbonson · 12/07/2023 22:01

Try giving him more sport, perhaps a football team or swimming will help and also potentially help self esteem and purpose etc? That may end up helping in the classroom eg sports field discipline of taking instructions, listening to a coach/teacher, practicing tasks etc

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 12/07/2023 22:00

Eh, I’d ignore the 3 year olds’ report. At nursery I reckon they just tick random boxes. My eldest was always way ahead in speech and things like dressing himself, behind in other areas, and his nursery reports gave him the same grade across the board. They tried to explain it, I didn’t get it….honestly, at that age, it’s meaningless.

The 8 year old- he’s in year 3. It’s the cohort that was hit hardest by covid. They missed the first two years of schooling and didn’t do all the learning to apply themselves and sit still stuff that they should have done. Honestly, your report could describe 90% of the boys in my - also year 3 - ds’s son’s class. The teachers at our school are tearing their hair out with our year 3s and I’m hearing that it’s the same in other local schools.

PurpleParrotfish · 12/07/2023 21:43

I’m not sure I’ve ever seen someone on MN beat themself up about something so much with so little cause. Your older child is likely autistic but is achieving at expected. Your twins have speech delay, not unusual with twins. They are still tiny, they’ll get there. You want to support all your children to do as well as they can.

None of that makes you a shit parent, so why do you think it does? Do you often struggle with anxiety? Be kind to yourself.

Mustreadabook · 12/07/2023 21:39

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 17:11

eldest is 8, so going into yr 4 September.
Twins are 3, they have another year at nursery from September and we'd put them in full time cos of Uni / their speech delay

parents evening tomorrow

I wouldn't worry too much about the 3 year olds, they all develop so very differently at that age. Twins are often speech delayed (they don't know why but it's a known thing, perhaps because they are obsessed with each other instead of someone who can speak!) but they get there. My twins didn't walk or talk till they were 2 and had speech therapy for a few years from age 3. By SATS year 6 they were in top 10%.

mrwalkensir · 12/07/2023 21:30

3 as in 36 months, or 3 as in 47? Huge difference at that age

CocoPlum · 12/07/2023 21:29

When is their birthday? If the twins are summer born, you could consider delaying their school start for a year.

But none of them seem to be "failing badly"! Reports at 3 are just a vague guideline. They are babies. And your 8yo is at expected. That's great!

If you want some ideas, I love mrsmillersaidso on Instagram. She has some fab ideas and info for workbooks etc.

BeverlyHa · 12/07/2023 21:25

either the school is too picky or the kids are not that academic and not that ambitious to impress anyone. I come from a family of people who would pay their last penny so I had private tuition, married with a teacher and to this day have not done amazing amount of work with the kids, but they just get on with it and want to impress their teachers. Depends also is a school attached to an estate or gathers larger community with professional parents who take pride in their children's achievements. Beating yourself is not good. If this is my kids school, the SENCO or teachers already would have asked me what I think should be done for the progress lacking to be made or inform me what they are planning etc. Has this been communicated to you, or happy go lucky, every year bad report but nobody taking care of it????

MumblesParty · 12/07/2023 21:19

Hang on - you say they had virtually no English at home? Does that mean that English isn’t your first language, and your kids are being brought up bilingual? Because that puts a totally different spin on it.

DappledThings · 12/07/2023 21:11

DC2 is only a year out of nursery and I have no memory of anything in her reports. If there was anything about targets she was measured against I can't imagine I would have taken any notice of it, not at 3.

PumpkinPie2016 · 12/07/2023 20:49

Please don't feel you've failed - you haven't. As a teacher, I can assure you we don't judge families on academic attainment.

For your eldest, he is at the expected level which is great! Maybe he doesn't 'push himself' but perhaps he doesn't know how? I would maybe ask the school what they can do to support him further. It may be that if he is a good, middle of the road kid, he gets overlooked in a class of 30 kids?

With the twins - they are very little. All children are different and do things at different paces. They may well catch up by reception. Apologies if I have missed this but were they born at term or premature? It can make a difference.

It's worth remembering that while we all have high hopes for our dc, we can't all be really academic. They will have their talents!

CrazyHedgehogLover · 12/07/2023 20:48

Try not to worry! I was the exact same with my first, had his first school report and it was great! Second school report was hmm ok, next one after that was more focused on what he needed to do to improve such as “writing sentences clearly” etc etc.

I also got very down feeling guilty that maybe I’d let something slip as I was pregnant with our second!
my eldest will be 8 in Aug so he’s in year 3, moving into year 4 September.

he will be receiving his school report this week! However during parents evening they said about his strengths such as artwork, literacy but he needed to improve on maths.

ill be proud of him no matter what the school report says, I know he’s still struggling in some areas, I know we’re doing all we can to support him, I was also told by his teacher that usually it just clicks and they all catch up to the same point eventually!

ask the school what you can do/how you can help him improve, ask what steps they are taking with this aswell, ask them for tips on how to encourage motivation (my son was and still does struggle being motivated if it’s a subject he doesn’t particularly like I.e maths) we just make it fun for him and then he’s all ears!

look for educational places to take them all during the summer holidays, we always go to see museums and old houses where they lived in the war, this sparked a huge interest in my sons for history and loves seeing how they lived during them times.

put maths/literacy songs on for them so they sing along, visits to the library so they can pick there own stories for bedtime.

don’t beat yourself up! You’ve got three children, twins! Your doing the best you can, it will naturally just click into place for them all, also my second son is moving into reception and I’m not worried at all about his report, he’s in nursery and to me there still incredibly young! I’ll be proud of both of them no matter what areas need improvement, everything is fixable.

SusiePevensie · 12/07/2023 20:46

It isn't always a morality play. Goodness doesn't always win and doing badly doesn't mean being bad. 'Working hard' and 'trying your best' can be hard for a kid who needs to move or struggles to write. Being an involved, caring mum doesn't always mean a glowing school report - and someone has to be average.

Flip it round - your autistic 9 year old is coping in mainstream. He's learning, achieving, and gets along with his peers. Your severely speech delayed twins are now speaking. That's not bad. It really, really isn't. It's kids will be fine adults territory, just might not be the smoothest ride there

Oh, and chuck the reward charts. They don't work.

Sugargliderwombat · 12/07/2023 20:39

If you're school is making you feel this how are they making your children feel ? I would have serious doubts about a report so full of negativity. It should be reporting on progress and giving actual next steps/ targets.

There are no age bands in the EYFS now. They are emerging until they achieve the ELG at the end of reception.

Gilmorehill · 12/07/2023 20:35

MumblesParty · 12/07/2023 18:16

My primary school reports always said I talked too much and didn't put enough effort in. I got As and Bs in my O levels, As in my A levels, and now I'm a doctor. So all that chatting and not looking keen enough wasn't really a problem.

I had one teacher for two years in primary school and she called me lazy constantly. I have a first degree from a good university and graduated first in my faculty. Screw you Miss McNeill!!

Serena73 · 12/07/2023 20:32

You need to stop worrying about it, there is so much time for your kids to reach their potential. You also can't make them be a certain way. My son was like this - didn't apply himself properly until at least 16. Just graduated with a Masters in a very difficult subject that he hadn't once been in the top set for throughout school.

Verano · 12/07/2023 20:25

THREE?!!! It means little. My three year old couldn't write like the others, staff weren't sure if he'd cope at primary. He got all 9s in GCSE and 3 A* at A level. Nursery staff are looking at a small area of their abilities.

JonSnowedUnder · 12/07/2023 20:19

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 17:36

well yes buts thats the ponit isnt it? but he won't see that. And what happens when its gets harder and he goes up to high school, and he ends up in bottom set for everything because that requires least effort and then he leaves school with no exams because its too late.

school have done an inclusion assessment which i'm hoping we get back this term for the new school teacher next year and that that will help, but star charts and rewards stickers don't work. even saving up for a toy, it works if i'm there to say "do this and get a sticker" but soon as he's not with me, it just falls by the wayside. and when it comes to writing, he just loses focus

This post stood out to me, he's 8 and you've already got him in the bottom sets in high school and leaving with no exams. That's quite a leap.

I'm not saying there aren't things you can't do to get him more engaged but please don't get so wound up. It won't help him.

How is he at school socially? Does he have friends, what lessons does he enjoy? Maybe a reward chart of some kind?

The twins I would ask their teacher for their view. Are they just developing slowly, not uncommon for twins at this age. Does he/she have any concerns? Please don't frame either them or yourself as failing though.

StopStartStop · 12/07/2023 20:09

Deep breaths.
Let this be a lesson to you - take whatever appears on school reports with a pinch of salt. Learn - and teach your children - not to set store on what is said by people who think they are in authority. Make your own assessments based on your more detailed knowledge and deep love for each other.
I was a teacher for 21 years.
Love your babies. Have ice cream or go to the playground. You're a great mum. It will all be fine.

I haven't read the full thread (I'm such a rebel!) but is your eldest who is neurodivergent and 'not pushing'? Listen to grandma here. I came in the top three every year in primary school and every report said 'Could try harder!' No we (nd people) can't. We can do what we can do, and no more.

ToWhitToWhoo · 12/07/2023 20:01

Goodness- I had assumed that your older child was at secondary school, and the twins at least 5 or 6. But 8 and 3? No child should be seen as 'failing' at 3! They are twins; you mention that they have some speech delay (not unusual in twins); AND they are essentially still toddlers. If the nursery really is treating them as though they are failing the 'three-plus', then perhaps it's time to find a new nursery! But very likely the nursery is just looking constructively for ways of helping them to progress. As for the older child- even at 8, many intelligent children are not yet very dedicated to academic pursuits (in some countries children don't even start formal school until 6 or 7) and he's apparently achieving adequately, so definitely not 'failing'. And after all, he will have spent his first year or two of schooling under 'lockdown' conditions followed by restrictions and frequent school closures. Perhaps you could talk to the school about possible ways to help him along. And as pp have said, encourage him to join the library and develop the 'reading habit'. But please don't let any of them feel that they're failures: that really could put them off school and learning before they've really even begun.

User68253 · 12/07/2023 20:01

God those poor kids. One with a diagnosis of autism is meeting all expected levels, and THREE year old preschoolers and you consider them failing for not being above average?

babbscrabbs · 12/07/2023 19:58

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 17:55

it isn;t that he is or isn't a genius, its that its full of comments like "A now needs to share that knoweledge in discussions, does not apply knowledge to written work, needs to work on presentation, needs to write more during lessons, needs to be more independent" etc

Lots of autistic people struggle with theory of mind eg understanding what level of detail they may be expected to share to others. My DC is very logical so he wouldn't see the point of telling the teacher the answer to something he knows the teacher already knows, for example.

He may be struggling with executive function which would affect independence and it also sounds like he struggles with pencil grip which of course will impact presentation.

In other words yes he may need a bit more support but it's not down to you not doing some magical thing other parents are doing. You're probably doing MORE without knowing it. It's just he needs more support than others. And you're not at fault for not magically knowing what that is.

Honestly, as the parents of a child who has ACTUALLY done badly, I think you're worrying and beating yourself up way too much and your time would be better spent trying to figure out what support your children might benefit from.

Wildspace · 12/07/2023 19:55

Firstly don’t worry about it. Secondly - parents evening - just have a honest conversation about it - say you’re concerned and if there’s any strategies that they can advise to support. You might just be surprised and be reassured that this is all entirely normal and expected.

WhiskersPete · 12/07/2023 19:54

Flockameanie · 12/07/2023 17:01

I think you need to turn this around - as in start asking what the school is/isn’t doing to support them to improve.

Rubbish. If they aren't bothered about pushing themselves, there is very little the school can do.

It's easier to blame the school than your own parenting though I guess.

ZairWazAnOldLady · 12/07/2023 19:39

So you have an autistic 8 year old and three year old prem twins with language delay and you are worried that they aren’t flying through nursery/primary?

I think the reason you quest ds1’s dx which a Dr saw “easily” is you probably support him so well he is doing exceptionally well given his disability. I would imagine the detailed listing of where he is not doing so well is to highlight clearly that he does have difficulty and where so he can get support in the future. I would also imagine they are Uber aware that language delay can also be seen in younger autistics and they want the twins to have a clear history of where they are. Significant language delay can be caused by extreme neglect (think kept away from all stimulation), it sounds unlikely you did that. So it’s far more likely something else. Some children talk later, prem babies can struggle (my twins were born early too), autistic children can struggle to gain language in line with their peers. I’d poddle over to the SN board and find some company.

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 19:08

Superdupes · 12/07/2023 18:57

Is there anyone ND in your families? Dyslexia, dyspraxia, ASD, ADHD?

I know people hate people suggesting this sort of thing but if older one is really struggling with pencil grip/and writing has anyone considered he might be dyspraxic? How is he with using a knife and fork, tying shoe laces, riding a bike etc?

With the twins as soon as anyone says 'doesn't like transitions' I always immediately think - could be ASD. Obviously they're not much more than babies so absolutely might just be their very young age.

I say this just on the basis that DS has ASD and is dyspraxic and these were the early signs for him - but equally it absolutely might not be the case. We have a lot of ND family members.

we've had a autism diagnosis for eldest but i'm unsure about it. everyone else seems to have had to jump through hoops to get it but our specialist paediatrian diagnosed him. mild and atypical. there is some issues with processing speed too

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread