Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel defeated by school reports?

169 replies

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 16:59

I feel so sad at all three school reports and can't help but feel it's on me, as their primary parent, that i've let them fail badly.

DS is at expected level on all academic subjects, but the report is full of "he doesn't apply himself enough", "he lets others do it for him", "if he actually expressed it on paper....", he needs to improve his presentation", "He needs to improve his output / stamina" etc. I feel like this is obv about how we've parented him, that he doesn;t feel he needs to push himself or strive to do his best, that he's happy to sit back and just let everyone else do the work. I don't know how to get him to improve his productivity at school. On the occasions he does, school are so positive about it, but then the next day he just doesn't.
Then there's the twins who are at emerging on EVERYTHING, not a single thing at excpected level - is it because they're second borns and twins so i've just not tried enough with them? There isn't one area they're at the right level for.

They all go to the same school and the head teacher obviously reads all the reports, its a small school so she'll def clock the poor attainment is all from the same family.

I just feel so inadequate. I'm a SAHM so i don't even have an excuse of being busy with work.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 12/07/2023 23:33

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 17:36

well yes buts thats the ponit isnt it? but he won't see that. And what happens when its gets harder and he goes up to high school, and he ends up in bottom set for everything because that requires least effort and then he leaves school with no exams because its too late.

school have done an inclusion assessment which i'm hoping we get back this term for the new school teacher next year and that that will help, but star charts and rewards stickers don't work. even saving up for a toy, it works if i'm there to say "do this and get a sticker" but soon as he's not with me, it just falls by the wayside. and when it comes to writing, he just loses focus

You are catastrophising here.

You have turned a normal situation (i.e. DS not getting As across the board in Yr3) into one that is make or break.

It's quite likely that your child has realised they have disappointed you or has sensed that this is a high stakes thing and has lost any joy in learning he may have ever had as a result.

My advice is to start dealing appropriately with your own anxiety.

HapptobeTHATparent · 12/07/2023 23:29

Flockameanie · 12/07/2023 17:01

I think you need to turn this around - as in start asking what the school is/isn’t doing to support them to improve.

How? With what funding? Simply, no. The question needs to be why aren't the government funding schools adequately to ensure children get what they need to succeed.

Oldtiredfedup · 12/07/2023 23:29

I continuously got report cards like that ‘so laid back shes horizontal’ etc right through my school years, despite very often my best efforts.

it was echoed at home and drilled into me just how ungrateful I was…except I didn’t fit in, I was being bullied at school…and 20 years later I have a dusnosdx ASD child and one that’s showing some signs.

Schools have a habit of blaming kids until crisis point. And nothing seems to have changed.

I can’t tell you the effects it had on me. And there are plenty of forums out there full of adults who were undiagnosed who experienced similar

You know your child. You know if they’re doing their best or not. Stick to what you know, and if a professional is telling you you’re wrong and your kid is just lazy and you knis dufferent, don’t let them bully you into bullying your child. Advocate for them - that’s what actual support is. Not this thinly veneered ‘support’ offered in schools which 9 times out of 10 is nothing more than forcing a square peg into a refund hole.

Ask for constructive feedback - follow that. If it’s not working, there’s a reason and it’s generally not just a ‘lazy’ child.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 12/07/2023 23:25

*I mean forming letters, not writing letters to send to people but he could do that too. Postcards to Granny, letter to someone he looks up to, letter complaining about something to MP etc.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 12/07/2023 23:22

Get your 8yr old to start touch typing at home, he will find it less frustrating and can get used to telling stories without worrying about letter formation. He could also do five minutes a day letter writing over the holidays. My eldest was in a similar position at his age, currently waiting to see if have the grades for medical school. A lot can change with time, maturity and the right support. Even if at the end of secondary he is in a similar position there are lots of jobs which do not require lots of qualifications which pay as well, sometimes better, than some graduate roles. The twins are 3 so I really wouldn't worry at this stage.

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 23:20

i need to go t bed but thank you for the comments and i'll finish reading tomorrow.

to say i let him read his report, he agreed with it and he got a colouring book linked to his current obsession as a reward for his report so he only knows we're proud but he has stuff to work on next year. The 3 yos live in perpetual assumption that they're epic.

OP posts:
Finchgold · 12/07/2023 23:19

I can’t believe you even get written reports in nursery. My child struggles in many aspects of school but the most important thing I took from their report was that they have friends, are happy and they are progressing albeit slowly. The teacher told me they are behind but they are on their own learning journey.

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 23:18

@OMG12 we did lots before covid, less since covid lifted and we had twins but they all love our local art gallery, eldest is a huge reader and knows Daddy and Mommy read lots too, DS goes through phases of his topic of interest so we get little choice but to participate 😂 as he gets obsessed. he's a sensitive kid so i'm wary of what news etc he sees but he loves science, non fiction books are given out at school as part of the reading scheme and he has a bedroom fit for a bookshop of fiction and non-fic. It's just sometimes hard to squeeze anything else in alongside his current obsession

OP posts:
ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 23:12

@JonSnowedUnder he has friends but no "firm friendships", he def has some social issues around reading other people and understanding their emotions etc. He loves anything practical, its the actual writing he struggles with, getting it down on paper

@Sugargliderwombat i don't think for a minute they're telling the kids stuff, and the report is full of lots of positives and cute anecdotes.
There are no age bands in the EYFS now. They are emerging until they achieve the ELG at the end of reception. this is interesting, thanks

@MumblesParty alas no, they just speak in their own twin language.

@BeverlyHa Depends also is a school attached to an estate or gathers larger community with professional parents who take pride in their children's achievements.. Both - estate, full on working class deprived area, with parents who take pride in their children's achievements.

@CocoPlum no December, so will be oldest eventually, but started January this year

OP posts:
JiffLemon · 12/07/2023 23:11

If the twins have another year left in nursery then it wouldn't be all that unusual to mark them as emerging currently it they are being graded against the end of nursery year markers. Being twins as well will often mean that language and social skills will be seen as lower if they have their own twin methods of communication which lots of twins do. Maybe discuss the most important things that you can do over the summer to support them with the teachers, but also remember they are the covid cohort who are generally coming through nursery at a lower level than previous cohorts.

picturethispatsy · 12/07/2023 22:58

Mischance · 12/07/2023 22:54

They are not failing - they are simply being themselves. They are just small people adjusting to the world at their own speed and in their own way.

You are not failing - your children are loved and cared for.

Children are asked to achieve levels and tick boxes that have nothing at all to do with humanity.

"They are at emerging for everything" - it is such bollocks - such meaningless claptrap - they are 3 FGS!

Your job is to tell them how wonderful they all are - and stick the reports on the bin - right now!

👏 well said.

Mischance · 12/07/2023 22:54

They are not failing - they are simply being themselves. They are just small people adjusting to the world at their own speed and in their own way.

You are not failing - your children are loved and cared for.

Children are asked to achieve levels and tick boxes that have nothing at all to do with humanity.

"They are at emerging for everything" - it is such bollocks - such meaningless claptrap - they are 3 FGS!

Your job is to tell them how wonderful they all are - and stick the reports on the bin - right now!

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 22:53

@ToWhitToWhoo tbf the one thing i know we've done right with him is he's a bookworm. they've always been a safe space. he reads tons, and is slightly ahead of his age. has mature vocab, and an amazing imagination

@StopStartStop thank you. yes, even if the autism diagnosis turns out to be wrong, we've known he's not exactly NT.

OP posts:
Icedlatteplease · 12/07/2023 22:45

Somehow your replies do not come as a surprise.

I suspect you need a much better OT

Can you afford private OT?

mrwalkensir · 12/07/2023 22:43

A classroom assistant at our primary told the youngest's mother in reception that he was "immature" - he was 11 months younger than the oldest. Also, twins have a lot going on intellectually with their sibling - relax!

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 22:42

@NoSquirrels certainly at DSs age i was top of the class, knew it and liked it. i see myself in him in so many ways but this, he's def more his rather. i loved having extra home work and pushing myself and although i didn't excel in a selective school, i still went to Uni, and am currently studying for a 2nd undergrad degree. So i'm academically minded i guess. Dad was less inclined but smarter than me, got a scholarship to a selective school

OP posts:
ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 22:38

@Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals i think low self worth / esteem and over-thinking rather than anxiety per se.

@Mustreadabook they'd def rather talk in twin to each other. they have whole conversations in their own language. they also use sentences more at home than school .

@mrwalkensir 42

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 12/07/2023 22:38

You sound so excessively hard on yourself, OP. Fwiw, I think you sound amazing just for coping with twins plus an older child. Give yourself a break!

Are you academically high achieving, and so this bothers you more than it might?

picturethispatsy · 12/07/2023 22:37

And yet another reason why I home educate. To avoid this ridiculous system of expecting children (even toddlers at nursery now it seems!) to all develop at the same rate, to all follow a particular line on an arbitrary graph and meet such rigid expectations at a set time.
All this does is put pressure on children and their parents and make those who are ‘emerging’ or ‘expected’ (what bullshit terminology) feel like they are somehow failing or falling behind some imaginary timeline. Children are not robots. They all develop at different rates and in different ways.
OP you need to take those reports with a huge pinch of salt and step back and look at the bigger picture.

Gunpowder · 12/07/2023 22:37

OP you have got twin preschoolers. You are already winning at parenting! I’ve got twins too and it is a battle just getting everything done let alone the extra stuff and you are at uni as well. You need to have some compassion for yourself. They are loved and looked after and going to school. You are not lazy. You are doing your best.

My DTs are finishing reception now but DTS had a severe speech delay/disorder
at 3. DTD and I were the only ones who could understand him. I was so worried about him going to school but he’s caught up in everything now except for writing and fine motor skills (he has DCD/dyspraxia.) Don’t underestimate how far they come on during the reception year. You are clearly intelligent and also give a shit. I really think your kids will be fine. If they need more outside help you will advocate for them.

Re: your DS1, have OT given him a handwriting assessment and course? This really helped my DD10 (also has dyspraxia). They also flagged to the school that she should have a writing slope as well as pencil grips and more importantly be allowed to use a chrome book for any sustained pieces of writing. This has really helped as she doesn’t get so bogged down in presentation which is better for her self esteem so she works harder.

I hope things get easier for you. You sound like a great parent.

AuditAngel · 12/07/2023 22:35

For a bit of perspective my sister has twins who are about to turn 4, when I was there in October I could hardly understand a word one of them said, I was asking his twin to “interpret” for me. It wasn’t much different at Easter,

I have been there a lot recently, about 2.5 weeks across the last month, they have been at a different nursery and what a difference, I have only had to ask for interpretation a couple of times. It has been amazing.

Your twins may improve in a bound.

Were your twins premature? My sister’s were, and their development has been behind.

ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 22:35

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 12/07/2023 22:00

Eh, I’d ignore the 3 year olds’ report. At nursery I reckon they just tick random boxes. My eldest was always way ahead in speech and things like dressing himself, behind in other areas, and his nursery reports gave him the same grade across the board. They tried to explain it, I didn’t get it….honestly, at that age, it’s meaningless.

The 8 year old- he’s in year 3. It’s the cohort that was hit hardest by covid. They missed the first two years of schooling and didn’t do all the learning to apply themselves and sit still stuff that they should have done. Honestly, your report could describe 90% of the boys in my - also year 3 - ds’s son’s class. The teachers at our school are tearing their hair out with our year 3s and I’m hearing that it’s the same in other local schools.

thanks, that's interesting. our class has a rep for being hard work, two kids with confirmed autism - one waiting for special school, another couple with def behaviour / impulse issues, plus DS. They're a lovely class, but they've had extra staff in until next year - hadnt considered it a covid thing, just an out kids thing

OP posts:
ToddlerIs2 · 12/07/2023 22:33

Dorisbonson · 12/07/2023 22:01

Try giving him more sport, perhaps a football team or swimming will help and also potentially help self esteem and purpose etc? That may end up helping in the classroom eg sports field discipline of taking instructions, listening to a coach/teacher, practicing tasks etc

he honestly couldn't be less interested in football etc. we did dance for a while then swapped to gymnastics, but his lack of progress over several years put him off. he just couldn't progress past forward rolls. part dexterity, part willingness to take the metaphorical and literal leaps. we now do Beavers, Cubs soon and that's it. Hoping for Drama after school club which will inc dancing.

OP posts:
Sunnysunbun · 12/07/2023 22:14

My ds got 3 A grades at A Level. He’s dyslexic and never got expected in primary school - not even once!! Parents evenings and reports were always a disaster. Now he’s at university and flying.
I stopped going to parents evenings in primary school because it was so depressing.
Don’t worry. Read to him, hear him read and just don’t worry.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 12/07/2023 22:05

Hadalifeonce · 12/07/2023 17:11

DS has only ever 'done enough'. It is so frustrating, he is now 23, and still does enough. When I ask him why he doesn't want to achieve more, he says he can't see the point in working any harder, when enough us enough!!

I kind of see his point tbh. And at least he won't suffer burnout from overdoing it! My daughter is the same - always takes the easy option!