Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pay school for accidental damage

120 replies

Mumofboys2023 · 12/07/2023 13:19

my DS is 14 and today I have received a phone call from his head of year. They have viewed cctv of my DS lining up for class with his form group, another boy (apparently a friend “messing about”) has grabbed DS from behind and in response my DS has grabbed him back, the other child has then kicked out and smashed a glass panel in a door- accidentally. School have put DS in isolation and are asking myself and the other child’s parents to pay for any damage caused. AIBU to to state my son did not kick the door so should not pay for these damages or should I pay as he was involved in the incident? Should school not claim on their insurance?

OP posts:
bellsandwhistles333 · 12/07/2023 16:39

I'd pay only half but it would be coming out of pocket money / extra jobs to pay me back.
It's an accident yes but hopefully will teach to stop silly behaviour.

My nephew slammed a door shut which broke and his parents got a bill. I do think it should happen

starfishmummy · 12/07/2023 16:35

Hufflemuff · 12/07/2023 13:32

What sort of glass panel is this in a door? I would be going back and suggesting their doors are not strong enough for a school environment and pointing out that they may pose a significant health and safety risk.

Schools have a budget for repairs, I suggest they use it.

I must admit I was also thi King those doors don't sound very safe!!

CasperGutman · 12/07/2023 16:31

AdobeWanKenobi · 12/07/2023 14:52

It's really not.

Have a look at the Workplace Safety Regulation 14. Specifically the bit that requires the upgrading of all glazing in critical areas to that of safety glass, including Doors and side panels 1500mm above floor level and 300mm either side of the door

Workplace safety regulation 14 is similar to the building regulations in requiring that glazing in critical locations is either of safety material or protected against breakage. Safety glass doesn't imply it won't break but that, when broken, it will break in such a way as to not present an excessive hazard - basically because it breaks into pieces which are "small enough" (as defined in the relevant standard).

It might be sensible to use glass which is also difficult to break (no glass is unbreakable) but this glass will cost more and budgets are tight. The minimum requirement is for the glass to break safely.

noblegiraffe · 12/07/2023 16:08

Just joining in with the people queuing up to try to dodge responsibility.

AdobeWanKenobi · 12/07/2023 16:03

noblegiraffe · 12/07/2023 15:34

It’s the school’s fault for having windows.

Yes that’s exactly what I said isn’t it 🙄

Anyport · 12/07/2023 15:44

The other child "kicked " it off, so I wouldn't be paying.

noblegiraffe · 12/07/2023 15:34

It’s the school’s fault for having windows.

AdobeWanKenobi · 12/07/2023 15:32

angstridden2 · 12/07/2023 15:20

I can’t believe people are going from two teenagers messing around and breaking a glass panel to a discussion about the type of glass. The boys broke it and should pay for it. What will they learn from this otherwise? No wonder teachers are leaving in droves when everyone excuses poor behaviour.

I don’t think I said they shouldn’t pay for it, in fact I didn’t comment on that either way if you check my posts I simply expressed surprise that a school building, bound by endless safety regulations, would have a panel of glass low enough to be shattered by a kick.

momtoboys · 12/07/2023 15:31

You should pay half.

angstridden2 · 12/07/2023 15:20

I can’t believe people are going from two teenagers messing around and breaking a glass panel to a discussion about the type of glass. The boys broke it and should pay for it. What will they learn from this otherwise? No wonder teachers are leaving in droves when everyone excuses poor behaviour.

ElFupacabra · 12/07/2023 14:59

He’s admitted he was dicking about in the corridor. The window wouldn’t have broken if they were both behaving sensibly. Look, it’s what some teenage boys do, but it’s a life lesson, pray about and damage something, you pay for it. Pay half and make him earn back the money to pay you back.

As PPs said insurance wouldn’t cover this.

AdobeWanKenobi · 12/07/2023 14:52

justteaching · 12/07/2023 14:10

This is a ridiculous comment. Schools aren't institutions that require strengthened glass. People of ALL ages should be able to act responsibly and not break things. And, when things are broken, it's because something happened.

It's really not.

Have a look at the Workplace Safety Regulation 14. Specifically the bit that requires the upgrading of all glazing in critical areas to that of safety glass, including Doors and side panels 1500mm above floor level and 300mm either side of the door

Mischance · 12/07/2023 14:51

Ah - school insurance - I wonder what they might use to pay the premiums? Certainly not enough in their government allocation.

Maddy70 · 12/07/2023 14:48

I would ask to see the footage of your son causing damage if he did then you pay and he pays you back

ActDottie · 12/07/2023 14:41

Split it between the both of you and teach your child not to get into fights like this. The school should not have to pay or claim on their insurance as this just increases costs for the school or increases the insurance premium. Schools are in financial crisis atm.

noblegiraffe · 12/07/2023 14:36

The boy has admitted he was pissing around.

What is the lesson to DS? That if you piss around and stuff gets broken, mum will argue that you don’t need to pay because getting away with pissing around is more important than finding out that actions have consequences?

mrsm43s · 12/07/2023 14:35

Doesn't the safety glass in schools have the grid running through it? To stop it from leaving big jagged edges, and to stop it falling out entirely and sending shards through the air etc? If so, It's perfectly possible that it could be school appropriate safety glass, but still be broken/damaged by a sharp kick. I don't think safety/reinforced glass means its unbreakable, just that the way it breaks is safer and less likely to hurt the breaker or bystanders.

BaconMassive · 12/07/2023 14:34

I would pay half and not place the financial burden for your child messing around onto other taxpayers.

Bookworm20 · 12/07/2023 14:32

The other kid started it and the other kid kicked the door and broke the glass.

I would refuse to pay anything until you have been shown the cctv footage so you can ascertain your sons part in it all. Considering he wasn't the one who kicked the glass. That way you can see what happened and whether he played a big part in the door being broken.

I would also be asking how a glass door in a school was fragile enough to break when kicked. Must of been kicked pretty hard surely! Or it was not fit for purpose.

Accidents happen in schools, but I would ask to see the footage, perhaps along with the other parent if they won't show it just to you so you can see what went on.

Stillcantbebothered · 12/07/2023 14:32

listsandbudgets · 12/07/2023 13:27

So CCTV shows.yoir son being attacked, trying to defend himself and the attacker kicking out a pane of glass.. and now they are punishing him and want you to pay!!

They should be reviewing their health and safety.

Pay if you like but I'd be arguing about it myself

Hahaha now that’s some escalation, are you a lawyer by chance?

Sounds more like school boys playing rough but somehow you spin as he was “attacked” lol

toomuchlaundry · 12/07/2023 14:27

If the door didn't have strengthen glass it should have had a covering of some sort on the glass

LakeTiticaca · 12/07/2023 14:27

Years ago when my son was at school he leapt in the air and touched the ceiling with his hand. He dislodged a small piece of plaster which fell to the floor of the elderly, soon to be demolished school building.
Head master informed me he would have to pay for the damage. I responded that they should pay my son as he has helped with the demolition.
Never heard from them again 🤣🤣🤣

Dixiechickonhols · 12/07/2023 14:26

I’d ask to see cctv then decide.
I’d also ask if it’s a like for like replacement, a glass panel door that breaks with a kick probably can’t be fitted these days for safety reasons so a replacement may be expensive.

toomuchlaundry · 12/07/2023 14:24

What does your DS think, he is old enough to think about consequences?

mrsm43s · 12/07/2023 14:24

If the door was broken during a mates mucking around tussle, then they are both responsible, regardless of who's leg went through the glass.

If the door was broken because your son was attacked, and he acted in self defence because he genuinely feared that he was in danger/at risk of harm, then it's a different situation, and worth raising (for far bigger reasons than the glass - Police involvement would be needed etc too if a child was really being viciously attacked to the point he feared real physical harm and he felt he had to counter attack physically in self defence).

I strongly suspect its the former though - so yes, pay half. If the roles had been reversed between your son and his mate, I expect you'd want them to pay half.