Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inflation and interest rates

335 replies

Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 10:20

The BOE keep raising rates to curb inflation. I understand that is the only thing that the BOE can actually do and so they've got no choice. But isn't there anything else the govt can do? It's genuinely scary seeing articles on the BBC how 1 million mortgage holders will see their payments increase by £500pm by 2026. Literally nobody I know could afford that. And it doesn't even include renters in that number. Presumably loads of them are in the same boat or worse. If their LL mortgage costs go up, then so will their rents.
It seems to me the financial burden could be spread more fairly. Anyone who owns outright isn't feeling the pain. And for the most part that group is likely to be the ones who could most afford it. Especially if they have a load of savings that they're now getting a nice high rate of interest on. Surely things COULD be done differently if the will was there?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
StarDolphins · 12/07/2023 20:44

*had

StarDolphins · 12/07/2023 20:42

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 20:37

@StarDolphins

I massively resented lockdown and working with a 1 year old at home while paying people to get furlough but hey, we're all in this together to get this fixed now right? Right?

Both resentful then! I has to home school while wfh.

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 20:42

@Wimbo

I don't understand the views on this thread. There seems to be no awareness whatsoever about why interest rates are rising or that there are additional/alternative measures that could be taken.

People seem perfectly happy for an ineffective tool to be used, as long as it's not against them.

Wimbo · 12/07/2023 20:40

If taxes are raised it’s not to ‘help the financial burden of people with mortgages’, since you know, people with mortgages also pay tax 🤔

It’s because those are the instruments governments use to try to curb inflation.

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 20:37

@StarDolphins

I massively resented lockdown and working with a 1 year old at home while paying people to get furlough but hey, we're all in this together to get this fixed now right? Right?

StarDolphins · 12/07/2023 20:32

I own my property outright. In my early 20’s I started out in a mobile home with nothing, I saved, I did without & then bought a flat, then a small house etc. I hammered overtime where I could to do this. Have never had a well paid job.

I would massively resent my taxes being raised in order to spread the financial burden.

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 20:30

RainRains · 12/07/2023 20:26

So because I have paid off my mortgage - I have to pay pff your mortgage? No thanks. I went through the high interest rates of the 2000’s. Not going to pay for you to.

Well that's good because literally no one here has suggested that you pay anyone else's mortgage.

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 20:29

Why are posters assuming that op thinks others should be paying off her mortgage? This isn't what she said.

The point is that raising interest rates doesn't seem to be an effective approach so far and it's having a disproportionate impact on people who recently bought.

RainRains · 12/07/2023 20:26

So because I have paid off my mortgage - I have to pay pff your mortgage? No thanks. I went through the high interest rates of the 2000’s. Not going to pay for you to.

StormShadow · 12/07/2023 19:51

We definitely need to merge income tax and NI contributions. The way NI functions is grossly unfair. Pensioners being exempt is obviously part of that, but there are other problems too. Like the way it's disproportionately levied on income from work rather than unearned income.

SueVineer · 12/07/2023 19:40

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 13:50

A family we know are in the process of buying a £1.2m house with cash.

They have also bought a new car and are going on holiday a few times this year.

They own several mortgage free rental properties and run a property business that took a bounce back loan they didn't need. They used the money to do up a house that they then sold to a FTB last year.

And they aren't alone. 3 houses on my road have sold to cash buyers so far this year.

These are the people who need to stop overspending, not a middle income family with a £400k house and two kids in nursery.

A £400k house might seem ordinary to you but actually that’s way above average. Any taxing that just affects people who are cash buyers of million pound properties won’t curb inflation or raise money as very very few families are in that position.

interest rates work by generally discouraging borrowing and increasing saving. It’s not all about mortgages.

LlynTegid · 12/07/2023 19:17

The government can do things other than interest rates to reduce the inflation rate. There are things subject to regulation such as water charges, that could be reduced. Then there could be laws about rip-off charges, which I think at least to begin with could reduce the growth in inflation. A final suggestion would be to restrict the gap between savings and mortgage rates, which I think would lead to lower increases in mortgage rates.

LakieLady · 12/07/2023 19:16

Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 13:49

@Wimbo but if they're not taxed on their earnings but on their wealth then there's no reason for them to quit working. But actually I liked the NIC idea a PP suggested

I support the abolition of NIC, too. It means that wealthy pensioners with good pension incomes would pay more, and I think that's fair.

It seems very wrong to me that a pensioner with pension income of £30k a year gets to keep more of their income than someone who works for £30k a year. If the existing tax thresholds were maintained, or even raised slightly, that would protect poorer pensioners. At the moment, someone with less than £200 a month private pension + SRP will be paying tax on a bit of it.

Wimbo · 12/07/2023 19:11

Blossomtoes · 12/07/2023 18:20

If increasing the base rate had the desired effect why do the BoE need to keep putting it up?

Because with people coming off fixes at different times the rises take longer to work through. The last time raising rates was used to tackle inflation everyone was on a variable mortgage and the effect was most immediate. Obviously people reducing credit card use and loan applications will cut in straight away.

Well even accounting for that the point is overall it doesn’t work well as a measure to tackle to nature of inflation we have.

LakieLady · 12/07/2023 19:04

I have very similar recollections, @Lincslady53 . The day they announced that big rise, colleagues kept coming in to my office asking me to work out how much more it would cost them (I worked with a bunch of innumerates!).

One woman completely broke down. They had a big mortgage, because they'd released equity to start a business a few years earlier, when he was made redundant. They'd tried to sell and downsize, but at that time there were loads of people in negative equity, interest rates were high, there were loads of cheap repossessed properties on the market and they just couldn't get a price for it that would have made it feasible.

I know loads of people who lost their homes in those few years. Some of them are still renting now, and their pensions are mostly going on rent.

LakieLady · 12/07/2023 18:41

MidnightMeltdown · 12/07/2023 11:49

But is it fair that people who have had to take out a mortgage to buy a home should shoulder the burden of fighting inflation, while those who have had their houses bought via bank of mum and dad, or inheritance, don't?

The problem with increasing interest rates is that it disproportionately affects the young, and least well off.

A lot of those mortgage-free people will be old farts like me, who paid crippling interest rates in the '80s and '90s. I know that mortgages were smaller then, but incomes were lower too, and interest rates were well into double figures.

Many of us had families in social housing, so no inheritance for us. The few grand I inherited wouldn't have paid for a decent 2nd hand car, never mind the deposit on a house. Most of my friends and colleagues are/were in the same position.

Bananaman123 · 12/07/2023 18:35

my mortgage is paid off and I’m certainly not in a position to feel the pain again with a mortgage and why should I? Are you suggesting I pay more tax even though I’m on a low wage, illness that means I can’t work longer than 30hrs a week, I can’t afford to heat my home or splurge on anything. People who have paid off their mortgage aren’t always well off, I have no savings.

Blossomtoes · 12/07/2023 18:20

If increasing the base rate had the desired effect why do the BoE need to keep putting it up?

Because with people coming off fixes at different times the rises take longer to work through. The last time raising rates was used to tackle inflation everyone was on a variable mortgage and the effect was most immediate. Obviously people reducing credit card use and loan applications will cut in straight away.

BabylonianChild · 12/07/2023 18:00

Doh! Net result.

BabylonianChild · 12/07/2023 18:00

Ner result, not new.

BabylonianChild · 12/07/2023 17:57

It’s not strictly true to say the BOE can’t do anything else, they can do Quantitive Tightening by selling bonds, which they actually have been doing to some extent. However, the new result is the same as selling bonds also increases innterest rates.

That said, the government could choose to increase Income Tax which would hit everyone, or increase VAT which would hit those who bought stuff most.

The Tories aren’t likely to do either, as they are the party of lower taxation and spending cuts. It is more likely that Labour would increase taxation.

For example in 1985 the Personal Allowance (zero income tax band) was proportionally lower than now and the low rate of income tax was 30%

So would you rather have mortgages £500 a month higher or £500 less take home pay due to income tax rises?

I’d prefer the latter as it would balance the countries books more and give less profit to the banks. Sunak is actually talking about cuttting the low income tax band to 19% which is bonkers (but would actually be good for me).

The crap started with Thatcher.

ArtimisGame · 12/07/2023 17:57

I think the inflation might get worse if mortgage rates are higher. In my experience and my own life it’s just making us more aggressively determined to get pay rises to deal with the higher costs.

Wimbo · 12/07/2023 17:56

I don’t have a lot of good things to say about the govt and Rishi but when I read these threads I can see why he thinks everyone should do maths until they’re 18.

Philosophically (and to a small degree financially) whether IHT should be reduced etc. is totally irrelevant to the issue and your question OP which is INFLATION in the short-term. It would raise a fraction of extra taxes relatively and in any case will not sufficiently reduce demand or increase supply THINGS THAT IMPACT INFLATION. What is so hard about this to understand? people have repeatedly said what the issues are and it’s not having a go at anyone who bought, or older people or anyone else FFS.

If increasing the base rate had the desired effect why do the BoE need to keep putting it up? Clue - because it is a blunt tool that doesn’t work to curb the nature inflation we have in the UK.

ShanghaiDiva · 12/07/2023 17:54

Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 17:08

No I don't mean increasing the tax rate on inheritance (except to include the increase due to removing NIC) but it should have a lower amount that is tax free IMO. I believe it's £375,000 that can be passed on without paying tax no matter what, and can be up to £1 million if passed to direct descendants after the 2nd parent dies, if the first didn't use their allowance. That's £1million tax free. While another family is worrying about losing their 2 bed semi because they can't afford the mortgage increase due to rate rises. Doesn't seem fair or even sensible to me

It’s £325K and has been since 2009.
I don’t really understand your logic and you need to check your facts. The inheritance threshold is frozen at the time the spouse dies so in my case when my father died it was £231k not the current £325k which clearly affects the amount of the estate which is tax free when my mother dies.
So I should pay more tax because another family is struggling with their mortgage? Where does this logic end? Nobody should be allowed to earn a six figure salary because someone else can’t pay their mortgage? What if this person with a mortgage spent their disposable income on luxury goods and holidays when rates were 0.99%. So they still ‘deserve ‘ a handout. What about pensioners without the triple lock (as you want to remove that) who cannot afford to put the heating on? Are they less worthy?

Twiglets1 · 12/07/2023 17:37

Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 17:12

Also @Zebedee55 if you read my post you'll see that I am also concerned about renters anyway! Lucky you, that you have SH property. Most people don't as there aren't enough to go around

You sound angry with people who have SH now, as well as older people!

As @Zebedee55 says, the age war is pointless. What's the point in us all blaming each other when it's government policy that's to blame?

Swipe left for the next trending thread