Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inflation and interest rates

335 replies

Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 10:20

The BOE keep raising rates to curb inflation. I understand that is the only thing that the BOE can actually do and so they've got no choice. But isn't there anything else the govt can do? It's genuinely scary seeing articles on the BBC how 1 million mortgage holders will see their payments increase by £500pm by 2026. Literally nobody I know could afford that. And it doesn't even include renters in that number. Presumably loads of them are in the same boat or worse. If their LL mortgage costs go up, then so will their rents.
It seems to me the financial burden could be spread more fairly. Anyone who owns outright isn't feeling the pain. And for the most part that group is likely to be the ones who could most afford it. Especially if they have a load of savings that they're now getting a nice high rate of interest on. Surely things COULD be done differently if the will was there?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 13:44

@Thebestwaytoscareatory yes! I'd agree with pretty much all of that

OP posts:
Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 13:42

@Goldencup so not PAYE then. Tax wealth. Do it through council tax and inheritance tax. That would be way fairer anyway. And stop with all the extra benefits given to the over 60s. If they need them, then fine. But blanket benefits (other than state pension but without the triple lock) are wrong. Things should be means tested

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 12/07/2023 13:41

CranfordScones · 12/07/2023 11:31

Couldn't the govt do anything else to curb inflation? Yes, they could use fiscal policy instead of/as well as the Bank's monetary policy approach.

That means they could raise taxes or lower govt expenditure. So, which taxes would you like to pay more of? And which public services would you like to see cut?

Anyone who mentions prices and incomes policies gets a fail, and the 1970s would like a word with you...

Tax wise I'd like to see an increase in capital gains tax, VAT on luxury goods, VED on certain vehicles, council tax (re-banding rather than an across the board rise), and the introduction of a UHNW wealth tax. I'd also like to see the tax laws reviewed to close as many of tax avoidance loop holes as possible.

Service wise is a bit more difficult. I know this will set the touch paper on fire but, if I had to pick I'd focus on services for the over 65s. Partly because that is where spending is the highest but also partly because I don't think younger generations should be footing the bill, financially and physically, for the poor planning of the older ones while they are largely protected / isolated from the negative impacts.

I'd also like to see individual tories being punished for their utter ineptitude in running the economy and country over the last 13 years.

Smellslikesummer · 12/07/2023 13:39

TBH the issue in this country is that lenders almost exclusively offer variable rates / fixed only for x years.
In France you can fix for the whole length of the mortgage and most people do that. (Or at least did when I was still living there)

Goldencup · 12/07/2023 13:37

Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 10:40

Er no obviously I'm not suggesting that! I meant that the tax system could maybe be re-jigged in some way rather than just raising interest rates again and again and again. I don't have any ideas as to how though which is what I was wondering.

The tax system you say ? The PAYE system is punitive for salaries over £100,000 in all sorts of ways with a marginal tax rate of 60 odd %. Not sure any more can squeezed out TBH.

Sallywallywoowoo · 12/07/2023 13:36

@Circe7 great post. I really can't believe how unfair the current system is and the attitude of a lot on here. Implying that mortgage holders brought problems on themselves is actually horrible. FWIW we will be ok (I think) we bought in 2014 so have paid off a bit, and DH has been promoted so our earnings are about £20k more than when we took out our loan. But that doesn't mean I can't see the inherent unfairness of the policy. And I really do feel for those people who are worri d about losing their homes. I'd be happy to look at re-jigging tax to mean everything is shared out. It absolutely should happen.

OP posts:
Wimbo · 12/07/2023 13:32

@Circe7

The answer is what you said (and I did several posts ago). Increasing taxation, and it will be on everyone, tapered or otherwise.

But no government will as it’s political suicide.

Smellslikesummer · 12/07/2023 13:32

Isn’t the goal to stop people overspending? High rated also apply to credit cards in the view that it will stop people from using credit as
much.
For mortgages the idea is not to stop them but encourage people to be more reasonable in how much they borrow.

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 13:25

@Circe7 I agree with everything in your post.

Circe7 · 12/07/2023 13:19

Increasing interest rates is a very blunt and unfair way to reduce inflation (though it may well be necessary given that this is a worldwide issue and everyone else is increasing interest rates).

Increasing taxation would be a much fairer way to take money out of the economy and target those who are more able to afford it. Our tax rates on income are so high for high earners though that they probably couldn’t be pushed much higher. A major issue with Liz Truss’ budget was that it cut tax at a time of high inflation and therefore put money back into the economy fuelling more inflation.

If someone posted to say that they had prudently studied and got themself a high paying job so why should they subsidise the low paid via taxation, mumsnet would come down on them like a tonne of bricks. But for some reason the conversation is completely different when mortgages are involved and people who have bought a totally normal house are characterised as reckless and extravagant.

By far the biggest factors in having a small or no mortgage are how old you are, whether you had family help or inherited and where in the country you live. There will be a group who took on a £400k mortgage when they could have had a £200k one who should arguably bear the consequences of taking that risk but I doubt that’s a significant proportion.

So we are fighting inflation by taking money off young families who probably haven’t had family help to buy whilst older people or those who have inherited are relatively unaffected. This is unfair and regressive when inflation is an issue for everyone and comes on top of a lot of policy which has on average benefitted older people. And curtailing the spending power of people in loads of debt isn’t very effective at fighting inflation anyway because this group doesn’t have loads of discretionary spending. So you have to raise interest rates really high in order to make a tiny dent in inflation and the consequence is that some people are financially destroyed by it. A progressive tax policy would never have this affect as it would take a little bit off a lot of people.

I don’t know what the answer is but it feels like there must be a better one!

rosetintedmemories2023 · 12/07/2023 13:19

Londongent · 12/07/2023 10:52

Not sure it is fair to tax people more who have been diligent when taking out a mortgage, bought a smaller property and not overstretched themselves to bail out people who have mortgaged themselves to the hilt on cheap credit.
It's definitely a problem, but I do not agree that this is the solution.

I suspect majority of the stress would be felt by people who bought smaller properties because they couldn't afford more. or in the commuter belt of cities where houses were more affordable. Further up the ladder, the purchases tend to be funded by equity or inheritance (thats the case in London where i am).

My increased mortgage payment is not funded by prudence but through salary rises. Also they mainly looked at DH's income when we were buying our flat as I was still on my visa. I don't have student loan and am on the cusp of higher rate tax so now my take home isn't that dissimiliar to DH even though he earns more than £20k more.

DandelionBurdockAndGin · 12/07/2023 13:18

We spent 10 years renting saving a deposit and bought not long before financial crash - we fixed the rate to watch them drop like a stone then we lost our jobs and had to pay mortgage from savings - and house prices in our area crashed and still hadn't recovered by time we sold. We came a hair breath of losing 10 years saving - we were terrified.

Took time and moving to improve our financial circumstances and as soon as we could we started overpaying - so we weren't as vulnerable again despite "advice" to do other things with the money.

We've had the time to get ourselves into a better financial situation though we are starting to struggle as everything goes up in price seemingly every month.

A customer just burst into tears about how she would not be able to afford her mortgage payments.

I was a teen and remember my parents fears - they also had job worries - Dad being in a badly hit industry.

Private renting in this country isn't a great experience - we bought when we did for stability as eldest child was near to school age - it's much worse now as are house prices.

At least there are some considerations being made this time - but even so it will be people just on the housing ladder often with young kids who will be worse affected.

Wimbo · 12/07/2023 13:17

Both the above posts can’t be true.

The BoE is independent of the government so the government has done zero (although I agree this is on purpose).

If it’s then the case that most houses don’t have mortgages (I don’t know), interest rates can’t then be used as a tool to curb demand broadly because it’s only impacting a small number of people.

NewForest111 · 12/07/2023 13:13

The interest rate rises are effectively the government intervention. It’s on purpose so it wouldn’t make sense for the government to then try to help people, it’s raised the rates to stop over spending.

Anyone taking out a mortgage should also be very aware of what payments would be should rates increase and have a plan…

ginghamstarfish · 12/07/2023 13:11

Taxpayers should not have to subsidise those with mortgages! Firstly, it is a minority of homes which have mortgages, secondly, mortgage holders have not always borne in mind that interest rates could and would rise after being so abnormally low for such a long time. I do agree that some taxation rules which have not kept up with inflation etc need to change, such as stamp duty bands, with much higher rates for second homes/BTL/holiday lets, and inheritance tax etc, . Also higher VAT on luxury items.

Lincslady53 · 12/07/2023 13:08

In the early 90s, we had a mortgage and also a business loan on our new business, when interest rates shot up. I remember the day when they hit 15%, I was in our shop, and it was announced on the radio news. A customer just burst into tears about how she would not be able to afford her mortgage payments. Fortunately, we had a 10 year fix on our mortgage at 'just' 9%, which was a bargain compared to rates over the previous few years, but our business loan payments soared and our customers stopped buying. A horrible time and I feel for anyone facing similar issues today. The rise had been due to money market speculation as we prepared to enter the Euro, but this increase put paid to that, the UK pulled out of the exchange rate mechanism, and interest rates dropped rapidly. A couple of years later, we paid to get out of our 9% mortgage, and rates have not been anywhere near that since. Hopefully, rates will start to drop soon, I suppose one benefit may be a reduction in house prices, which will help anyone looking to buy.

MidnightMeltdown · 12/07/2023 13:06

@PepperJacksBestHo

You don't think that 2011 was a long time ago?!

No wonder that you've paid your mortgage off - you've benefited from more than a decade of low interest rates AND much lower house prices, and now your berating others who don't get that same opportunity?

It's not the people who bought 10 plus years ago who are going to be hit hardest by this.

Wimbo · 12/07/2023 13:06

Also the government could review our policy on immigration. The UK (and globally) there is high demand relative to supply, plus the UK has a productivity issue. We need more people or a step change in productivity via technology (AI), these will ease supply side issues and tax rises would curb demand.

Has the government done any of that? Big fat no.

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 13:06

@MsMoody

We bought in Dec 21 and I remember reading about the possibility of negative interest rates at the time. 🙃

Ontheroadyetagain · 12/07/2023 13:03

Our interest rate is currently 1.2%, there’s now way it will be back down to that in two years time. We’ll likely be selling up and downsizing

MsMoody · 12/07/2023 13:02

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 12:41

@PepperJacksBestHo

But FTB couldn't 'make hay', because they had to save for a deposit during a time of historic low interest rates and buy when prices were high (or spend their lives renting).

Exactly. I just went and checked- the savings account I saved for my deposit in had an interest rate of 1%!! Bought in Jan 22.

wutheringkites · 12/07/2023 13:02

@PepperJacksBestHo

Why is it always homeowners who suggest that renting is a good option?

For what it's worth, my mortgage payment is currently only 66% of what we're were paying on rent before buying so I'm actually perfectly used to going without to service a mortgage - at least it will be my own this time.

Wimbo · 12/07/2023 13:01

To answer your question - if the government were serious about curbing inflation they would increase the rate of tax. But they will not do that as it’s political suicide for any party.

Instead they can hide behind the BoE increasing interest rates.

PepperJacksBestHo · 12/07/2023 13:00

MidnightMeltdown · 12/07/2023 12:54

@PepperJacksBestHo

Yes but you obviously bought your house a long time ago. Congratulations on being born a decade or two earlier 🙄

It's luck, stop pretending that it's some kind of personal achievement.

"obviously" bought a long time ago? How so?
Nice to assume I'm some sort of retiree with heaps of cash and a semi detached I bought in the 70s for £3k.
I bought in 2011 and I'm almost mid-thirties now with two small children. So what if I'm proud of what I have achieved. Knock me down all you like.

HolyGuacamole28 · 12/07/2023 12:58

The smugness of here from ALOT of people is so sad. Good for you. No mortgage or a small one. Great. So you didn’t have to pay childcare at todays rates, you could have a single income, it must have been a lovely time. Not so now. It’s hugely unfair of those of us who have done all this because WE HAD NO CHOICE. Be kind.