Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To allow my son to do this on holiday?

342 replies

HistoryRepeat · 12/07/2023 10:18

4 years old. Loves the water. But can't swim. We go every week in the kids pool and he's leaning to kick, use a float.

We are on holiday. There is a big slide and it goes into a deep plunge pool. The pool is only as wide as a bath. Very small but v deep.

DH saying DS not allowed to go as deep and he can't swim. I say he should be able to go and I stand at the bottom and catch him. The kids do go under but I would be right there. Its such a small pool, you can touch each side. I know he can't swim but if someone is literally stood there to catch him? He did go down one slide and went under for 2 seconds, he was a bit shocked but again I was right there scooped him up and he wanted to again.

Anyway turned into a big thing as DS is obsessed with going and DH insistingjust paddle pools. DH is safety obsessed imo but he says I'm being ridiculous and that I need to trust him and respect his viewpoint and I'm not presenting a united front.

Kids currently watching screens, DH off in a huff and me wandering why I work all year to afford to take them on holiday.

Would you let your kid who can't swim on the big slides if you were at the bottom? Am I being lax?

OP posts:
OMG12 · 12/07/2023 12:30

No if he hits you or you slip and you go under, even if you manage to grab hold of him you would find it b difficult to get him out the water and you to stand up.

Im all for giving kids confidence in the water but I’m with your DH on this. Use it as an incentive to get him to swim

Use this as a lesson to DS how water needs to be respected, if there’s any situation to err on the side of being risk averse it’s water. Use the time in the pools to practice swimming.

Does your DH not work? You say you’re paying for the holiday, you seem to think that this gives you reason to control everything that goes on there. Is there something else going on here you’re using the slide issue to raise

squirelnutkin11 · 12/07/2023 12:26

I would tell DS that he needs to be able to doggy paddle to the side of the pool to be able to use the big slide. Then spend a day teaching him to do this with arm bands on.
Once he is capable of this he is safe in the water anywhere. Which should be the first priority of any child.

His safety comes first and you don't need swimming lessons, just take him out of his depth with arm bands and show him how to doggy paddle to the side repeatedly, you can walk along side but he must do it, stress he must learn this first.
Once he has he hang of it gradually let the air out of the arm bands little by little until he can paddle to the side without the flotation effect, and then without arm bands.

I grew up with no money for luxuries as swimming lessons, but we lived on the coast so it was seen as imperative for safety that you could sea swim as early as possible. All of my friends, and my brother and l, learnt this way by 3/4 years old.
My father used to carry my brother and l out to chest deep (on him) and tell us to doggy paddle until we could stand up, he just walked alongside.

The allure of the big slide should motivate DS, and he should nail it fast.

TeenLifeMum · 12/07/2023 12:24

Put a life vest on him. But I’d happily wait at the bottom and scoop him up just be very strict that he’s only allowed on in when you know and can be there as I’d worry he’d run off on his own otherwise.

doingthehokeykokey · 12/07/2023 12:20

Dotjones · 12/07/2023 10:23

I wouldn't allow it. Suppose you suffer a medical emergency at the crucial moment and were unable to retrieve your child?

It just feels like an unnecessary risk to me. Tell him that once he learns to swim properly he'll be allowed to use water equipment like this. He needs to learn to respect water though, it is deadly, many swimmers drown every year, and throwing someone who can't swim properly into the mix is asking for trouble.

What if you get struck by a meteorite?
What if you are shot by a stray bullet?

Do you ever travel by car?

I think of all the likely outcomes getting smacked in the face by a stray foot is the one I'd be concerned about.

MagpiePi · 12/07/2023 12:15

Why not get your son to practice jumping into a pool so he gets used to going under water? And get him some armbands or a flotation vest.

Both my kids graduated from swimming with flotation devices to swimming without when we were on holiday with a pool. It’s the ideal time to improve swimming skills.

GuardTheGate · 12/07/2023 12:14

I used to let Ds2 aged 3 jump off the side of a pool 1.2m deep every week. He would "swim" underwater, surface and I would be there to grab him. He was incredibly water confident but couldn't swim on the surface and no lessons because he was 3. He knew to hold his breath just before he jumped. Because the pool was only 1.2m deep I could very easily stand up in it. But there was a lifeguard at the pool which was reassuring in case I had some sort of tv appearance worthy medical emergency.

He is 5 and can listen to instruction, I honestly don't see the harm in letting him try it.

Dutch1e · 12/07/2023 12:13

Good lord, the flapping on this thread is unbelievable. Yes I'd do this. Sounds like fun, and if the landing spot is basically a plunge pool it can't be a slide that produces a lot of velocity (needing a long landing strip so to speak). Just a slide and a plop at the end.

Schum · 12/07/2023 12:11

Some of the replies on here are way OTT and some are absolutely bonkers. If the mum is right there to catch the child and she’s well able to stand in the water, it wouldn’t even enter my head to say no, especially if he’s wearing some sort of floatie.
My kids have all loved waterparks since they were toddlers, they’ve gone down slides and under the water at the end, three of them loved it, one wasn’t keen so didn’t go on it again. I didn’t even actually catch them but was there to help if needed.

ErrolTheDragon · 12/07/2023 12:09

So what this thread shows is that there's a variety of opinion. Some agree with the OP, some don't.

It almost doesn't matter at this point which of them is more right than the other. Their disagreement is spoiling the holiday; the DH, believing it's unsafe, is unlikely to back down.

So pragmatically, the OP should let this one go. Tell her DS no, the big slide is for big kids who can swim. Then go and do something fun, and get on with his swimming lessons.

YouWhatYouWhat · 12/07/2023 12:07

A big slide into a bath sized pool you can stand in? Sounds like no other slide I've come across. Are you downplaying it?

If the place is lax about safety and doesn't have lifeguards (basic) then I'm completely with your husband.

Kids have to learn that they can't do everything all of the time. For good reason.

Seamsthesame · 12/07/2023 12:06

Wow, i knew childhood around the area I live (national park near coast) was unconventional, but half the people in this thread would have a fit of they saw the activities that parents regularly do with their kids here.

My 5 year old goes rock climbing (real rock outside), she rides red mountain bike trails on a shotgun seat on either DH or my bike, I stick her in a bouyancy aid (with crouch straps) and we jump off a swimming pontoon into the local lake together (obviously it's deep because it would be dangerous to jump into shallow water), last summer when the lake really warmed up she would jump off the paddleboard in the middle of the lake, she climbs trees with the older kids from school etc.

And I'm quite tame really, friend of a friend took their toddler paragliding with them.

OP YANBU to catch your kid at the bottom, assuming they enjoy going under the water, it's a quick way to build water confidence if they like it.

fridaynight1 · 12/07/2023 12:05

I would be using this holiday to teach him how to swim.

12RedRoses · 12/07/2023 12:05

Part of learning to swim and the confidence is that you can go under water and make your way back up. Floatation devices give false security.
So if he knows at the end of the slide he goes under water and you scoop him up/he learns to kick to the surface then there is no issue and it can only be a good thing for his confidence?

ShoesoftheWorld · 12/07/2023 12:03

Sorry, OP, but you remind me rather of those parents at playgrounds who insist on allowing their small children to go on equipment designed for bigger ones and get in the way of age-appropriate users by hovering or even going on it with them. Your ds really doesn't have to be allowed to do everything that's not suitable for his age/stage yet. Plus far too many things can go wrong with your catching him plan. He could knock you sideways coming down at speed. He could slip out of your arms. Then there's the risk of him swallowing too much water. I really don't think that's histrionics. Water can be very unpredictable. It's safe until it isn't.

Turfwars · 12/07/2023 12:02

Can he put his head under water and is he good at holding his breath when he goes under? Then maybe, with you there at the bottom. But if he's not, then the fright of the plunge could cause him to inhale water. Use it as the incentive for DS to get swimming lessons when you get home from holiday.

My DS refused to learn, then we went to a water park in Spain but he was only confident enough to go into the babiest of slides and hated seeing other kids younger than him have fun. He insisted on lessons when we got back and worked his arse off passing all the swim levels.

He's like a fish now but even so, our family still always supervise each other and be within grabbing distance at all times. It only takes an accidental bump to shock you into inhaling water and getting into difficulty, even if you are a lifelong experienced swimmer. .

Catspyjamas17 · 12/07/2023 12:02

YeCannaeChangeTheLawsOfPhysics · 12/07/2023 11:56

The histrionics on this thread are hilarious

It's actually mostly sensible advice and comments.

StillWantingADog · 12/07/2023 12:01

Btw when you get back get lessons sorted for September so that he can swim a bit next summer. Round here they all start at 3.5/4

justaweenamechange · 12/07/2023 12:01

Haven't rtft, but if DH is so concerned about safety why aren't they down at the pool together teaching him to swim?

Seems like a perfect opportunity.

sleepyscientist · 12/07/2023 12:00

Does he not have a floaty device? Would he hold his breath as he went under and not panic? If so I would just go down with him and make sure DH was at the bottom if needed. Wait until it quad bikes and horses then your DH has a reason to be scared.

We took DS in the deep end (DH is over 6 foot and could still touch the bottom) with his floaty on and left go. He scrambled for a couple of seconds then start to practice his swimming by the end of the holiday he was confident. He had hours of lessons in the shallow end before that and wasn't making progress.

BadNomad · 12/07/2023 12:00

I don't think I would risk it. This is a new slide to him. He will be coming down it on his own and entering the water on his own. If the experience doesn't go how he expects it to go (could be faster than he expects), it might give him a fright and put him off being in the water. For the first time it would be better if someone is with him.

Ihatepickingausername3 · 12/07/2023 11:59

Eh. We had arm bands on the kids and we stood at the bottom or they came on our laps down the slide.

Catspyjamas17 · 12/07/2023 11:59

YeCannaeChangeTheLawsOfPhysics · 12/07/2023 11:54

Mum is in the water to FUCKING catch him.

And how safe will that be with other big kids and adults crashing down into a not very big pool? If other parents are standing there catching small children then it's probably ok, as I said. If it's all bigger kids who can swim and you aren't allowed to stand at the bottom then it's probably not.

Parents need to be very careful around water, small children (whether or not they can swim) and non-swimmers. People get really reckless on holiday.

SchoolShenanigans · 12/07/2023 11:58

Caravanvirgin · 12/07/2023 11:56

Go down with him on your knee.

Even worse. So if he flies off her lack, she then runs the risk of knocking him out or landing on him.

How about just waiting until he's older? Kids don't HAVE to do everything.

Mirabai · 12/07/2023 11:58

YeCannaeChangeTheLawsOfPhysics · 12/07/2023 11:54

Mum is in the water to FUCKING catch him.

Which may nor may not be successful depending at what angle he exits the slide. If he finds himself landing in deep water alone and he doesn’t know how to tread water or regulate his breathing and he panics - which can all happen in a split second - then what?

YoYoYo8eech · 12/07/2023 11:57

P.S. meant to add - Google secondary drowning.

Nopeity Nope.

Swipe left for the next trending thread