Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To describe my brother's actions as a sexual assault

85 replies

Stillanothernamechange · 12/07/2023 09:56

My brother lives with my family (me, DH, 2 small children). He is neurodivergent and sometimes finds life a challenge. But usually he is an extremely kind, selfless person.

Earlier this year we had an au pair who was romantically interested in him (at some point she drunkenly told him that she was falling in love with him). I made it pretty clear to him that it was not appropriate for him to be pursuing a romantic relationship with her; she's (early-mid-20s) over 10 years younger than him, the power imbalance obviously was huge, and frankly I didn't want to have to deal with the complications that could arise from a relationship turning sour between two people living in my house. They both told me they weren't interested in a relationship with each other (my brother was just coming out of a long and, in my opinion, horrible relationship).

They were often going out together or staying up late drinking together; I was happy for her that she had fun things to do but to be perfectly honest the late nights sometimes led to her being tired and grumpy when she was supposed to be working (and my brother's drinking has been a concern for a long time). What I didn't know was that when they were drunk they were - I guess the best term would be 'fooling around' (I have zero interest in learning the details; I know they weren't sleeping together). What I also didn't know was that at some point this did turn sour from the au pair's point of view, and that my brother didn't notice. (My best guess having spoken to her a bit is that she realised he also wasn't interested in a relationship with her, and given their continuing physical contact she felt a bit used and hurt - despite her saying the same about him. That's just my conjecture though.)

This all came to a head a month or so ago when they got home at 2am, my brother woke us up being loud and drunk, and the next morning we found out that one of his friends (I'm going to call him Jack) had slept on the au pair's floor. We had a serious conversation with my brother about his drinking, and spelled out that he had a choice to make between his current lifestyle and continuing to live in our home. AFTER having that conversation with him, the au pair (this is starting to feel a bit depersonalising; let's call her Sophie) said she needed to talk to us. She told us that the reason 'Jack' had slept on her floor is because he'd witnessed my brother's behaviour towards 'Sophie' and been horrified, and felt that she might need some security. Sophie told us that for some time she'd been avoiding my brother when he was drunk, because he was a bit handsy. She didn't tell us exactly what had been happening, and the conversation was clearly extremely difficult for her so I wasn't pressing her for details. The next day I spoke to Jack and he described what my brother had done as 'sort of tonguing her neck'. The important point here really is that an independent witness saw the behaviour, clearly understood that it wasn't consensual, and was appalled by it (Jack said many times that if he hadn't witnessed this himself he never would have believed my brother would have done something like this).

My husband and I were obviously completely horrified. This is a young woman we feel responsible for who didn't feel safe in her own living space because of predatory behaviour. My mum came down on the train and spent the evening talking to my brother, and he enrolled in an alcoholics programme. Sophie said she wasn't 'bothered' about it, but a week or so later she left giving us 3 days notice. There were, unrelated, issues with Sophie: we had noticed that things she said didn't always match up to her behaviour, and the day she gave us notice the manager of a local community centre had just contacted me and told me Sophie wasn't taking care of our toddler at all when they visited it together, to the point where he was at risk of seriously hurting himself (another parent on the school run has since told me he observed concerning behaviour by her around our children). But this is getting really long so I guess I'd better cut to my real issue, which is that I feel some of my family are massively minimising what my brother did. I spoke to my other brother about it recently and when I described it as sexual assault, he said "a lot of the rhetoric used regarding that incident has been completely over the top" and that Sophie "had given [my brother] reason on previous occasions to believe that she was consenting". I still can't believe that a member of my own family thinks like this about sexual assault - like, what the fuck is the relevance of her consenting on a previous occasion?

So: AIBU? Is this an extremely serious event which everyone in the family should be taking seriously? Or an understandable drunken mistake? For the record, the 'drunken octopus-hands' brother, as far as I know, is taking it seriously. It's the other one who doesn't seem to be.

OP posts:
3BSHKATS · 12/07/2023 13:19

We had an au pair and we also had my 20 something brother living in the house and actually she fancied him more than he fancied her. However, they would go out on the piss together because they were of a similar age group and nothing along these lines ever occurred ever. I’m not seeing any grey areas here it’s assault.

Jellycats4life · 12/07/2023 13:17

IkeaMeatballGravy · 12/07/2023 11:19

I know my post won't be popular but if they were fooling around, going on the piss together and she still contacts him, I think you are being unfair to label your brother as a sex pest, it very much sounds like blurred lines between the two of them. I wouldn't trust the word of a lad caught in your au pair's room either.

Really you should have ended the contract with her when you first found out professional lines had been crossed.

Absolutely agree with this.

I don’t see the point in fixating on one issue (sexual assault) when the REAL issue was that your au pair and your brother were in a romantic and sexual relationship under your nose which impacted upon her ability to care for your kids. That’s a massive boundary that shouldn’t have been crossed.

Iwasafool · 12/07/2023 13:07

zerofuchsgivenTBH · 12/07/2023 12:52

Agree. The fact that your family are telling you ALL FINE NOTHING TO SEE HERE NOT A SEXUAL ASSAULT is also quite telling.

Of course they want to tell you it's all good, stop making a fuss. They are happy with the status quo because it takes the weight off them.

You are the one who is more or less supporting the alcoholic in your family with housing and what sounds like a lot of emotional/social support. At the expense of your own wellbeing and that of your family.

The language/what actually happened/what your family is saying aren't the issue here. There's a big fat elephant in the room and that's what you need to be talking about.

The house is jointly owned so I don't see OP is supporting her brother with housing, presumably she is benefitting from living in a house that she hasn't had to pay full price for. The spelled out that he had a choice to make between his current lifestyle and continuing to live in our home. is worrying. The choice isn't him moving out it is selling up and all of them moving out unless they can buy him out and he agrees to that.

He's a vulnerable man and I think the OP needs to be careful about what she is saying and how it would come across to say a social worker.

Stillanothernamechange · 12/07/2023 13:04

AndEverWhoKnew · 12/07/2023 12:45

The big issue is living with your brother in a joint house but you don't want to address that because it impacts your standard of living so you're deflecting on to the terminology your mother and other brother use. The terminology doesn't make what your brother did any better or any worse. It won't make it easier or harder for him to identify such behaviour going forwards.
And tbh your insistence on the language seems performative since you didn't even discuss reporting the incident to the police.

With respect, this is bullshit (as are a number of other posts; the constructive posters on here know exactly which ones those are 😆). I have addressed it; reading even my first post let alone the rest of the thread makes that clear. Yes it affects my standard of living; it also affects my children's standard of living. Have you experienced losing your home as a child? It's not nothing.

The most important person where a report to the police is concerned is Sophie, and that is not what she wanted.

Quite an eye-opener here in terms of the assumptions people bring from their own lives when replying to someone else's problem.

To those asking, who hadn't got this from my original post: what I wanted from my post was a gauge of opinion on whether I'm being unreasonable in referring to this as sexual assault. I think that is important. I was expecting pretty much full consensus so getting the opinions from those who felt it wasn't, or that lines were blurred, has been helpful (at least from the people who actually bother to read and understand the thread before posting...)

Also to give some clarity: my children have not seen my brother drunk or hungover. His tolerance is pretty high and it's very rare for him to be very drunk as he was on this occasion. His drinking has previously been a concern to me because 1. it's way beyond the recommended guidelines and that can't be good for his long term physical health; 2. I believe it contributes to him waking up later than he plans to in the morning and being less productive than he needs to be at work, and most importantly 3. I believe that living with someone whose drinking is not under control will affect my children even if they never witness any drunken behaviour (and obviously now even more importantly 4. he has behaved completely unacceptably while drunk). He has found it difficult to get help for his drinking in the past, because if you go to a GP and ask for help with it they're expecting you to be having a bottle of vodka for breakfast (he drinks in the evenings only). HE IS ADDRESSING HIS DRINKING. He is following the programme set for him by a doctor who runs addiction clinics, who also happens to be a person I hugely respect. I fully understand how some people with bad experiences might find it difficult to believe that a person with a drinking problem can ever get it under control, but they do exist.

OP posts:
zerofuchsgivenTBH · 12/07/2023 12:52

Agree. The fact that your family are telling you ALL FINE NOTHING TO SEE HERE NOT A SEXUAL ASSAULT is also quite telling.

Of course they want to tell you it's all good, stop making a fuss. They are happy with the status quo because it takes the weight off them.

You are the one who is more or less supporting the alcoholic in your family with housing and what sounds like a lot of emotional/social support. At the expense of your own wellbeing and that of your family.

The language/what actually happened/what your family is saying aren't the issue here. There's a big fat elephant in the room and that's what you need to be talking about.

Iwasafool · 12/07/2023 12:49

SheRaaaaa · 12/07/2023 11:31

I didn't read all that op TL;DR, but this bit stands out to me

Earlier this year we had an au pair who was romantically interested in him (at some point she drunkenly told him that she was falling in love with him). I made it pretty clear to him that it was not appropriate for him to be pursuing a romantic relationship with her; she's (early-mid-20s) over 10 years younger than him, the power imbalance obviously was huge

If he's ND, I'd think the power balance was in her favour and I'd have told her to leave him the fuck alone or leave my house.

I agree with this, she sounds a bit dodgy to me.

The other thing is "They do not reasonably believe that the other person consents." Given the previous behaviour and the ongoing contact plus his issues with understanding social clues did he reasonably believe that she was consenting?

It sounds as if it could be interpreted in more than one way.

MatildaTheCat · 12/07/2023 12:46

@Stillanothernamechange what strikes me is that firstly you’ll never get entirely to the bottom of all this and secondly you have a very unstable alcoholic living with your very young children. He doesn’t understand boundaries, he’s clearly going to find reducing or stopping drinking very hard ( and probably doesn’t even want to).

You can’t change the past. However you can predict a whole lot more hassle in the future and I strongly recommend that you start looking at options for separate living accommodation and supporting him from a distance.

AndEverWhoKnew · 12/07/2023 12:45

The big issue is living with your brother in a joint house but you don't want to address that because it impacts your standard of living so you're deflecting on to the terminology your mother and other brother use. The terminology doesn't make what your brother did any better or any worse. It won't make it easier or harder for him to identify such behaviour going forwards.
And tbh your insistence on the language seems performative since you didn't even discuss reporting the incident to the police.

MzHz · 12/07/2023 12:42

DMLady · 12/07/2023 11:56

How on earth is this helpful? Honestly, the holier than thou attitude on here sometimes…

@DMLady you took the words from my mouth!

It's so easy to sit and hurl popcorn from the sidelines, but stuff unfolds and it's so hard to deal with at the time. The unsafe and concerning behaviour was reported to OP AFTER all of this crap, and of course, everyone wants to see the best in everyone.

Handsy brother (and other brother) do seem to need more clarity on consent/lack of it. While there clearly was some blurring of lines in this case, it is still an important message that previous consent doesn't represent permanent consent and it can be revoked at any point and must be respected. If this situation went tits up, Handsy brother could have had an enormous problem on his hands. he does need to untangle himself from her for both their sakes.

summerpuppy · 12/07/2023 12:38

What do you want from this thread ..
if Sophie thought it was a sexual assault she would contact the police ..she still went out drinking with him after the incident…which you didn’t see .
sophie is clearly a bullshitter ,and trouble maker and shit with your kids .
by the sounds of things she was happy with your brother untill she realised he wasn’t wanting a relationship..can you be 100% sure she made it clear she didn’t want him ….slobbering all over her kneck as you kindly put it …
why are u writing this post …what are you wanting out of it …your not Sophie ,you didn’t see what was going on at any point ..
your brother isn’t living with you out of the kindness of your heart ,he owns part of the house ,(so you can’t just kick him out …u said …)
is that what this thread is for
your trying to stir up trouble between family members so you can say you or your kids are not safe with your brother in the house …you want him out ?
if Sophie goes to the police and they investigate the matter ,your brother will have to face the consequences..
but other than that ….I really don’t see why you are posting ,
I think your trying to stir

Stillanothernamechange · 12/07/2023 12:24

Motnight · 12/07/2023 12:19

Of course the brother has been taken advantage of. By a younger woman living in his house, reliant on his family for a roof over her head and wages, whom he sexually assaulted. Yep - she had all the power.

Yeah, I wasn't going to even try engaging with this but thanks for stepping in! (I strongly suspect Sophie is ND too - not something I asked her about because absolutely NOMB, but also if she hasn't been diagnosed that still doesn't mean she's NT - so where does that leave that particular theory...?)

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 12/07/2023 12:23

The au pair was an employee. Your brother is your relative, The whole thing should have been nipped in the bud long before it got to this stage. They shouldnt have been conducting an affair under your roof if you think a criminal act has taken place report it to the police.0

Stillanothernamechange · 12/07/2023 12:19

PurplePansy05 · 12/07/2023 12:02

Really torn here. Could it be the case he was drunk and also misread her views on him because of his ND? Could it be Sophie is a bit of a bullshitter considering she wasn't even doing her job and displayed what other parents stated was concerning behaviour? The friend sleeping on the floor is extremely odd - was this in your house? Why didn't she or the friend inform you immediately? It doesn't add up tbh.

But my primary comment is that it was completely inappropriate for you to stand back and allow an au pair to develop this kind of relationship with your family member living in the same household. She's there to do her job and to be treated pretty much like family member where appropriate, but not to develop sexual or near sexual relationship with another household member. You've all brought this mess upon yourselves.

My gut instinct is that the truth is somewhere in between here. Your brother needs a good talking to re boundaries and also treatment for alcohol addiction which seems to be in place.

Is labelling behaviour a primary concern of yours in all this?

Could it be the case he was drunk and also misread her views on him because of his ND? Yes he definitely was and yes I believe he did. That doesn't make what he did ok.

Could it be Sophie is a bit of a bullshitter yes she definitely is, on some issues. I don't think she is on this one because her story is closely collaborated by the other person present (also because statistically when a woman reports an assault, is is about 500x more likely that she's telling the truth than making it up. Nearly every woman I know has been assaulted or harassed at some point; I don't know a single man who has been falsely accused).

But my primary comment is that it was completely inappropriate for you to stand back and allow an au pair to develop this kind of relationship with your family member living in the same household. Genuinely asking for advice here: what should I have done? They both told me it wasn't happening. What do I do, accuse them both of lying with absolutely no evidence? Kick her out in a foreign country on the basis of a hunch?

Is labelling behaviour a primary concern of yours in all this? The good talking to re boundaries has happened. The treatment for alcohol addiction is happening and my brother is showing every sign of being committed to it. The prevention of it happening again is taken care of as we have no intention of taking on another au pair for the moment (and if that changes, will not do so if brother's behaviour is still a concern). The labelling of behaviour (or, in my opinion, failure to label behaviour) by other family members is what I am finding very troubling. It will obviously feed into how those family members behave towards me, if they see me as blowing this all out of proportion. And could, as another poster pointed out, muddle Handsy Brother's recognition of the seriousness of his own behaviour (I don't think it will, but it is a possibility that should be acknowledged).

OP posts:
Motnight · 12/07/2023 12:19

SheRaaaaa · 12/07/2023 11:35

If he's too ND to work this out, he's the one been taken advantage of, IMO.

She's messed with a vulnerable person and now she can't easily fuck him off cos he don't take cues, can't deal withthe fall out. This is why you don't get involved with VP as a fuck buddy 🙄

Of course the brother has been taken advantage of. By a younger woman living in his house, reliant on his family for a roof over her head and wages, whom he sexually assaulted. Yep - she had all the power.

Flossiemoss · 12/07/2023 12:15

Polio pem is meant to say problem.

Flossiemoss · 12/07/2023 12:14

The au pair doesn’t give a shit about you or your family op. If she did, she’d have cared for your dc properly. She is looking out for herself - you can’t trust any of what she says. The fact she is still in touch with your brother, as pp says, speaks volumes.

the male “I slept on her floor to protect her” friend. Really? You have swallowed that old chestnut?? Come on now. Did he ever strike you as sir Galahad before this incident?

your brother- who knows how much the nd affects him. I certainly couldn’t give a verdict over the internet. But yes the problem drinking is an issue and I would suggest the shared living arrangements.

your dm. Now this is what stood out for me. You have a student halls drama going on in your home due to your brothers antics and your dm, who doesn’t live with you, is telling you that you can’t do anything about any of it. Well she’s got it made hasn’t she? Lifelong care of polio pem child has been foisted into her daughter . You.
I know that’s harsh but you aren’t allowed to resolve your own domestic issues.

essentially op , I feel you need boundaries with your family. Counselling and a house move would probably help at this point. As others say as the dc get older and db continues drinking induced scrapes this is going to get harder.

standardduck · 12/07/2023 12:14

To be honest, I would be selling up. Your brother is an alcoholic and I would not want my children to live with one.

Both him and Sophie sound awful and irresponsible, although the neck incident was definitely him crossing line. Again, I am not sure why you would want to have him living around your children.

thecatinthetwat · 12/07/2023 12:09

Your db needs to understand enthusiastic consent. You need a yes, you need it now (this time/every time) and it should be enthusiastic. Is the other person enthusiastic about the sexual activity? This is what all men need to understand, but your brother clearly needs to look this stuff up. It’s not difficult even for nd if you actually want consent.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 12/07/2023 12:05

Another way of looking at it is that it's what they routinely do.....but she was conscious of the fact there was another person present and you weren't happy about the situation so she said she wasn't into it to protect her job. The Au pair was also shit at her jobs and probably knew she had a flood of complaints coming her way, so chose to leave before being sacked.

Your brother being neurodiverse will be less aware and able to alter behaviour.

Labelling him as a sexual predator is OTT without the.full facts.

PurplePansy05 · 12/07/2023 12:02

Really torn here. Could it be the case he was drunk and also misread her views on him because of his ND? Could it be Sophie is a bit of a bullshitter considering she wasn't even doing her job and displayed what other parents stated was concerning behaviour? The friend sleeping on the floor is extremely odd - was this in your house? Why didn't she or the friend inform you immediately? It doesn't add up tbh.

But my primary comment is that it was completely inappropriate for you to stand back and allow an au pair to develop this kind of relationship with your family member living in the same household. She's there to do her job and to be treated pretty much like family member where appropriate, but not to develop sexual or near sexual relationship with another household member. You've all brought this mess upon yourselves.

My gut instinct is that the truth is somewhere in between here. Your brother needs a good talking to re boundaries and also treatment for alcohol addiction which seems to be in place.

Is labelling behaviour a primary concern of yours in all this?

AndEverWhoKnew · 12/07/2023 11:58

Are you going to report your brother to the police? Because yy it sounds as though it was sexual assault but from what I can tell, no-one investigated this. No-one reported it. Your other family members may think the terminology is related to a conviction rather than to an action.
Jack staying in Sophie's room doesn't mean Jack's description of events is impartial.
It obviously suited you to think there was nothing going on between your brother and Sophie but tbh you and your DH (as NT and as employers and as parents) left everyone at risk. Your DB is vulnerable. Sophie was vulnerable (as a staff member living in your house). Your DCs were vulnerable to Sophie being distracted as she 'fell in love with your brother'. You're not to blame for whatever happened between them but none of this would have passed any kind of cursory risk assessment.
Rather than getting caught up on terminology, you need to think hard about childcare, about your brother's attitudes to alcohol and his suicide ideation. It may be that it's time to sell the house or add an extension/remodel it to give DB a separate access/granny flat.

MinimalistMe · 12/07/2023 11:57

DMLady · 12/07/2023 11:56

How on earth is this helpful? Honestly, the holier than thou attitude on here sometimes…

I wasn't trying to be helpful, I was stating a fact.

DMLady · 12/07/2023 11:56

MinimalistMe · 12/07/2023 11:48

To be totally honest, the fact that you had both of these people around your children, both of which displayed concerning behaviour, is very neglectful. I would never in a million years have allowed my situation to end up in the one you were in.

How on earth is this helpful? Honestly, the holier than thou attitude on here sometimes…

WaitingForNothingGood · 12/07/2023 11:55

It's really pointless to be trying to analyse what happens and trying to apportion blame. What are you trying to achieve? What difference will it make?

Any 'talks' you think your brother needs should be happening anyway.

The OP has left and other than trying to help your brother with his alcohol problem and his difficulty with relationships and sexual boundaries nothing will change if you decide he committed a sexual assault.

Are you assuming that the OP left because of your brother or because she was reported for not looking after your kids?

This highlights one of the reasons I disapprove of people using Au pairs - (I'm not sure how they are even legal now?). They are always in a vulnerable situation.

liveforsummer · 12/07/2023 11:54

I think younger quote naive ti believe noting was going on given the circumstances but that's not really relevant. This all sounds very messy to be going on in a house with 2 young dc. It's very damaging growing up in a house with an alcoholic seeing them come home drunk/being hungover and this one isn't even a parent so even less justification to be there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread