Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do some at The BBC have too much power?

59 replies

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:01

A young Welsh journalist with a promising career ahead of her graduated with a masters from Cardiff university. She proudly tweeted with excitement about her first piece being published in The Telegraph.

A BBC newsreader, not even a writer, who confirmed he had merely read no further that the opening paragraph branded it 'feeble'. Cue online threats including rape threats for the journalist.

I recall the stories of the amount of coverage an opinion is given by the very highly paid BBC presenters several months ago.

Perhaps time the BBC rained their presenters in a bit?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:44

OrwellianTimes · 12/07/2023 09:39

does anyone have a link to the article?

Calling an article feeble is an opinion. Everyone can have an opinion.

Rape threats are illegal but there’s no mention of that in the article you posted.

It was published on the Telegraph so behind a paywall anyway, which was the whole reason he only read the opening part.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:43

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:35

@Peacoffee

My AIBU was 'Do some at the BBC have too much power?' Not was the word feeble nasty. I think you missed my point. I feel that some at the BBC have too much power. Some don't agree.

Your finishing question was "Perhaps time the BBC rained their presenters in a bit?" along with the context of this tweet.

So you don't think a newscaster should be able to tweet opinions on political articles?

Who defines "too much power"? Power and influence is due to the public, someone's opinion can't have power and influence if no one cares so obviously there are enough people who cares about what he tweets to read it. Exactly the same as any tv personality.

OrwellianTimes · 12/07/2023 09:39

does anyone have a link to the article?

Calling an article feeble is an opinion. Everyone can have an opinion.

Rape threats are illegal but there’s no mention of that in the article you posted.

pickledandpuzzled · 12/07/2023 09:38

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:26

For context this is the bit that he was able to read (as he said):

"I am proud to come from Wales. It’s the land of Richard Burton, Snowdonia, male voice choirs, Dylan Thomas and dragons. Other than lamb – there are twice as many sheep in Wales than the whole of the US – its food may not be universally admired, but few other parts of the UK are as beautiful. My homeland has always enjoyed a good reputation; and certainly Welsh people are known for being friendly and welcoming – unlike the people of another devolved nation I shan’t" ... then the paywall comes in

Responding that the above is feeble is remarkable. Why would he bother?

If that is all there is, then it's unreasonable.

If she was attacked by others for the rest of the content of the article that's a separate issue imo.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:35

@Peacoffee

My AIBU was 'Do some at the BBC have too much power?' Not was the word feeble nasty. I think you missed my point. I feel that some at the BBC have too much power. Some don't agree.

OP posts:
Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:33

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:29

@Peacoffee "It was an incredibly inflammatory, bordering on anti-Welsh article. He was allowed to have an opinion. Why is he obligated to read to the end?"

The first paragraph is above. The bit he read. She say she loves her country. I wonder why he felt the need to punch down.

So again, do you think a professional can only pass comment on a peer's work if they are in the exact same point in their career?

Is it acceptable to call an article feeble if the author had been working for 20 years? Is is only unacceptable if they've been working less than 5?

"Feeble" is hardly a nasty review. Surely every writer knows reviews are par of the course and they won't always be praise.

OP posts:
Aaron95 · 12/07/2023 09:30

Caradonna · 12/07/2023 09:02

Which bbc newsreader? Why was he even commenting? - he’s a newsreader.

Most BBC newsreaders are journalists before the move into presenting.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:29

@Peacoffee "It was an incredibly inflammatory, bordering on anti-Welsh article. He was allowed to have an opinion. Why is he obligated to read to the end?"

The first paragraph is above. The bit he read. She say she loves her country. I wonder why he felt the need to punch down.

OP posts:
StefanosHill · 12/07/2023 09:26

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:21

"The article was a critique of the Welsh Labour government and its left-wing first minister Mark Drakeford. His government was, in Kennedy’s estimation, too fond of lockdowns, transgender ideology and universal basic income, the latter of which she warned would ‘universalise welfare dependency and sap what is left of Wales’s enterprise economy’. Kennedy also objected to England having to subsidise Drakeford’s lavish spending plans.
Welsh devolution, much like its Scottish counterpart, has institutionalised a grievance culture and fortified a political, civic and media establishment allergic to scrutiny or even the mildest criticism."

She criticised the Welsh government, and many of the policies including transgender ideology. His response was to punch down. Karma will come back at him.

Well that paragraph you’ve quoted sums up the issues well

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:26

For context this is the bit that he was able to read (as he said):

"I am proud to come from Wales. It’s the land of Richard Burton, Snowdonia, male voice choirs, Dylan Thomas and dragons. Other than lamb – there are twice as many sheep in Wales than the whole of the US – its food may not be universally admired, but few other parts of the UK are as beautiful. My homeland has always enjoyed a good reputation; and certainly Welsh people are known for being friendly and welcoming – unlike the people of another devolved nation I shan’t" ... then the paywall comes in

OP posts:
Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:26

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:21

"The article was a critique of the Welsh Labour government and its left-wing first minister Mark Drakeford. His government was, in Kennedy’s estimation, too fond of lockdowns, transgender ideology and universal basic income, the latter of which she warned would ‘universalise welfare dependency and sap what is left of Wales’s enterprise economy’. Kennedy also objected to England having to subsidise Drakeford’s lavish spending plans.
Welsh devolution, much like its Scottish counterpart, has institutionalised a grievance culture and fortified a political, civic and media establishment allergic to scrutiny or even the mildest criticism."

She criticised the Welsh government, and many of the policies including transgender ideology. His response was to punch down. Karma will come back at him.

Are you only allowed to pass comment on an article if the writer is at the same point in their career as you then?

His response was to punch down. Get a grip.

doorstopper123 · 12/07/2023 09:22

He is an arse but suspect this is all great for her career advancement

Her name is well and truly out there

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:21

"The article was a critique of the Welsh Labour government and its left-wing first minister Mark Drakeford. His government was, in Kennedy’s estimation, too fond of lockdowns, transgender ideology and universal basic income, the latter of which she warned would ‘universalise welfare dependency and sap what is left of Wales’s enterprise economy’. Kennedy also objected to England having to subsidise Drakeford’s lavish spending plans.
Welsh devolution, much like its Scottish counterpart, has institutionalised a grievance culture and fortified a political, civic and media establishment allergic to scrutiny or even the mildest criticism."

She criticised the Welsh government, and many of the policies including transgender ideology. His response was to punch down. Karma will come back at him.

OP posts:
babbscrabbs · 12/07/2023 09:20

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:14

This is the important bit for me:

"The BBC’s social media guidelines instruct staff to ‘always treat others with respect’ and state: ‘People who work for the BBC should set an example for civilised public debate.’

Unfortunately for Edwards, the section of the guidelines specifically directed at ‘colleagues working in news and current affairs’ stipulates: ‘Do not link to anything you haven’t read fully.’ In sharing Kennedy’s original tweet in order to express his disapproval, Edwards was also sharing the link to the article contained in her tweet."

He however made it very clear in his tweet that he had not been able to read the whole article, due to The Telegraph paywall. I think that's a fair caveat.

And I agree with him that the links with sheep and Richard Burton are old fashioned and clichéd tropes at best, and sly digs at Wales at worst.

Gymgo · 12/07/2023 09:19

He was probably sending bank payments at the time for pictures

He all over twitter

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:16

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:14

This is the important bit for me:

"The BBC’s social media guidelines instruct staff to ‘always treat others with respect’ and state: ‘People who work for the BBC should set an example for civilised public debate.’

Unfortunately for Edwards, the section of the guidelines specifically directed at ‘colleagues working in news and current affairs’ stipulates: ‘Do not link to anything you haven’t read fully.’ In sharing Kennedy’s original tweet in order to express his disapproval, Edwards was also sharing the link to the article contained in her tweet."

So his only error was tweeting an article he claims not to have finished. Wow crime of the century. He better lose his job over it, get your pitchforks out!

maddening · 12/07/2023 09:16

I agree - the bbc journalists seem to think they are celebs - eg the fucking Newscast programme that appears on sometimes after the news - idiot journos thinking they are something special - arses - I always switch over as I can't abide that shite

fuchiaknickers · 12/07/2023 09:15

I do realise that having a dig at HuwEdwards is the mood right now, and quite possible some at the BBC have too much power, I wouldn’t know.

However, if there is an article about his homeland with which he disagrees and which he feels takes a stereotypical view, he is within his right to critique it and call it feeble, if that is his opinion.
He can’t be held responsible for all the cave-dwellers who crash the ghastly party that is Twitter comments with rape threats, that’s on them.

ExtraOnions · 12/07/2023 09:15

Seems like a fairly tragic attempt at a HE “pile on” … head off to Tattle Life if you want to partake in that.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:15

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:09

Perhaps he could have read the entire article before he commented? The BBC (IMO) needs a total overall. Men paid more than women. Men protected.

You disagree, that's fine. It's just my opinion.

It was an incredibly inflammatory, bordering on anti-Welsh article. He was allowed to have an opinion. Why is he obligated to read to the end?
Occasionally I see an article and don't read past the first paragraph because it is utter horseshit.

This isn't a male vs female thing, let's not turn it into something it isn't.

Your grievance seems to be man at the height/end of his career disagrees with article written by women at the start, gives it mild criticism, the other people make outrageous and dangerous threats but its the journalist's fault for reviewing the article as "feeble"? Some mega backflips you've done there to try and make that suit your narrative.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:14

This is the important bit for me:

"The BBC’s social media guidelines instruct staff to ‘always treat others with respect’ and state: ‘People who work for the BBC should set an example for civilised public debate.’

Unfortunately for Edwards, the section of the guidelines specifically directed at ‘colleagues working in news and current affairs’ stipulates: ‘Do not link to anything you haven’t read fully.’ In sharing Kennedy’s original tweet in order to express his disapproval, Edwards was also sharing the link to the article contained in her tweet."

OP posts:
babbscrabbs · 12/07/2023 09:13

He only needed the opening para to see the references to sheep and Richard Burton, presumably?

And unless you're hard of reading, you'll also notice he called some Telegraph WRITERS feeble, not the article itself.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:12

I think it's seen as punching down. To me it feels in poor taste I understand that others feel it is ok.

"One of the most senior broadcasters in the country publicly venting his disdain at a young female journalist might strike some as punching down. Mr Steerpike is just impressed that Edwards can find the time. As the Times reported in May, the taxpayer-funded News at Ten presenter was the number one ‘moonlighter’ on the BBC’s staff in the first quarter of 2022. ‘The corporation’s highest-paid news anchor, who has a salary of up to £430,000, took on four external speaking engagements in March,’ the paper reported. The outside events earned him £25,000.
In response, Kennedy accused Edwards of ‘encouraging a pile-on that has already seen my DMs filled with people telling me to get raped’.
The BBC’s social media guidelines instruct staff to ‘always treat others with respect’ and state: ‘People who work for the BBC should set an example for civilised public debate.’ Unfortunately for Edwards, the section of the guidelines specifically directed at ‘colleagues working in news and current affairs’ stipulates: ‘Do not link to anything you haven’t read fully.’ In sharing Kennedy’s original tweet in order to express his disapproval, Edwards was also sharing the link to the article contained in her tweet. He has now, however, removed his Tweet and said he’s appalled at the abuse Kara has received."

Huw Edwards is top BBC moonlighter, paid £25,000 extra in a month

Huw Edwards made at least £25,000 in one month moonlighting outside of his BBC News presenting duties.The corporation’s highest-paid news anchor, who has a sala

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/huw-edwards-is-top-bbc-moonlighter-paid-30-000-extra-in-a-month-fkn562dgw

OP posts:
RaidFlySpray · 12/07/2023 09:11

The article was hateful, anti-Welsh and unsupported by fact. I read it at the time and was really surprised that it was published, seeing as the writing was so poor and that it was just a clumsy rant.
How do you propose the BBC controls their presenters? Would you like them to have to relinquish their freedom of speech in order to have to honour of working for Auntie?