Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do some at The BBC have too much power?

59 replies

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:01

A young Welsh journalist with a promising career ahead of her graduated with a masters from Cardiff university. She proudly tweeted with excitement about her first piece being published in The Telegraph.

A BBC newsreader, not even a writer, who confirmed he had merely read no further that the opening paragraph branded it 'feeble'. Cue online threats including rape threats for the journalist.

I recall the stories of the amount of coverage an opinion is given by the very highly paid BBC presenters several months ago.

Perhaps time the BBC rained their presenters in a bit?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 20:42

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12292635/Now-Huw-Edwards-faces-fresh-allegations-inappropriate-behaviour-BBC-colleagues.html

Interesting that employees at the BBC have allegedly come forward with complaints now. One member of staff at the BBC alleges 'abuse of power', which was my point. Well now the BBC can investigate the staff members concerns as well as the young person(s).

Huw Edwards faces fresh allegations of 'inappropriate behaviour'

It came just minutes after his own wife Vicky Flind revealed him as being the presenter accused of paying £35,000 to a 'vulnerable' teenager in return for explicit photographs.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12292635/Now-Huw-Edwards-faces-fresh-allegations-inappropriate-behaviour-BBC-colleagues.html

OP posts:
gympiegympie · 12/07/2023 16:18

😂

Endlesssummerof76 · 12/07/2023 16:18

ExtraOnions · 12/07/2023 09:15

Seems like a fairly tragic attempt at a HE “pile on” … head off to Tattle Life if you want to partake in that.

MN is hardly any better than Tattle Life - both are purely entertainment fodder.

Bromptotoo · 12/07/2023 16:18

You don't need to be Einstein to work out why this has been posted today....

gympiegympie · 12/07/2023 16:16

a lot of Huw Edwards posts today🤔

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 16:16

Caradonna · 12/07/2023 13:49

It is covered by subscription true but the figures for Netflix for example
MUCH IS NETFLIX WORTH? FINANCIALS
Share Price, 52-Week Range $162.71-$700.99
Revenue in 2021 $29.7 billion
Profit in 2021 $5.17 billion
Profit in 2nd Quarter 2022 $1.44 billion
Outstanding Shares 444.24 million

A multitude billion pound company although cheaper than a bbc subscription -would you really want all your streaming and news to come via US multibillion companies. How much say and control do you have over their CEI,CFO,presenters etcetc salaries ? A letter complaining about some presenter’s comments ? Yeah that would go far!!

Good points.

OP posts:
Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 16:15

EffortlessDesmond · 12/07/2023 12:48

It should be "reined" in... my editorial background compels me to point out! The rain will fall on HE, just as it does on us all. Reins, as in equine tack, used for steering and braking purposes.

Yes, my mistake. Although maybe he should be rein as in equine tack in. Put the brakes on him and steer him in the right direction. Who knows.

OP posts:
Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 16:13

DreamItDoIt · 12/07/2023 12:05

Hopefully this young, clearly talented, journalist will have lots of opportunities very soon to write some more pieces and will be able to smile to herself and move onwards in her career 🙂

Very likely she will.

OP posts:
Caradonna · 12/07/2023 13:49

It is covered by subscription true but the figures for Netflix for example
MUCH IS NETFLIX WORTH? FINANCIALS
Share Price, 52-Week Range $162.71-$700.99
Revenue in 2021 $29.7 billion
Profit in 2021 $5.17 billion
Profit in 2nd Quarter 2022 $1.44 billion
Outstanding Shares 444.24 million

A multitude billion pound company although cheaper than a bbc subscription -would you really want all your streaming and news to come via US multibillion companies. How much say and control do you have over their CEI,CFO,presenters etcetc salaries ? A letter complaining about some presenter’s comments ? Yeah that would go far!!

EffortlessDesmond · 12/07/2023 12:48

It should be "reined" in... my editorial background compels me to point out! The rain will fall on HE, just as it does on us all. Reins, as in equine tack, used for steering and braking purposes.

DreamItDoIt · 12/07/2023 12:07

And hopefully very soon we will see the dismantling of the BBC and it's overpaid, often with little talent, staff.

DreamItDoIt · 12/07/2023 12:05

Hopefully this young, clearly talented, journalist will have lots of opportunities very soon to write some more pieces and will be able to smile to herself and move onwards in her career 🙂

araiwa · 12/07/2023 11:00

Punch down? Hardly

A national broadcaster criticized an article in a national newspaper

newnamethanks · 12/07/2023 10:52

Frankly, many Telegraph and Spectator writers make feeble contributions to the daily 'news'. She needs to toughen up if she wants to continue in journalism. If she wants to put her views out there she must expect criticism. And, given the time is which we sadly find ourselves, she must not expect critiques that consider her feelings.

tigger1001 · 12/07/2023 10:51

Do some bbc staff have too much power? Undoubtedly the answer to that is yes.

Is this shown by tweeting an opinion on an article printed? No. Bbc staff have got the right to their opinion like any one else.

Did that opinion incite others to make threats of rape/violence? No. Sadly Twitter is full of keyboard warriors who hide behind their keyboards and make threats. More needs to be done about these kinds of comments.

RaidFlySpray · 12/07/2023 10:42

I think your comment about karma getting him is pretty disgusting. I wonder whether you'd say the same about the female journalist for the offense she caused? Because that too would be horrible. Stop wishing ill on people.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 10:36

tttigress · 12/07/2023 10:33

BBC news readers might start of as journalists.

But by the time they are reading the news, they are just presenting.

Why not get new people in with a good voice and good presentation skills to read the news / read the auto cue.

Make it clear the salary will be £100k absolute tops and the presenter cannot express opinions on social media. The BBC would get a lot of applicants, many capable of doing the job to the current standard or higher.

Well it is funded by licence payers so this seems reasonable. I'm sure if the salaries weren't as big as they are they would still get a huge number of applicants.

OP posts:
tttigress · 12/07/2023 10:33

BBC news readers might start of as journalists.

But by the time they are reading the news, they are just presenting.

Why not get new people in with a good voice and good presentation skills to read the news / read the auto cue.

Make it clear the salary will be £100k absolute tops and the presenter cannot express opinions on social media. The BBC would get a lot of applicants, many capable of doing the job to the current standard or higher.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 10:11

babbscrabbs · 12/07/2023 10:03

Just happened that the first paragraph he DID read - in your own words OP - was reductive.

I'd say that's feeble, lazy writing too. I can't argue with that.

Yes another poster made that point. I agreed, it does feel a bit reductive that way when compared to her post about China etc. I hadn't originally read it that way. As others have said Huw is entitled to an opinion.

I still feel that some at the BBC have too much power. They can use it to thrown scorn on up and coming individuals, or other ways. I realise that not everyone agrees with me.

OP posts:
babbscrabbs · 12/07/2023 10:03

Just happened that the first paragraph he DID read - in your own words OP - was reductive.

I'd say that's feeble, lazy writing too. I can't argue with that.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:56

StefanosHill · 12/07/2023 09:54

‘Bash China’

Or Wales.. of course people can write articles on what’s not good

Both paragraphs quoted look fine

Indeed that's what writers do. Huw didn't read further than the first paragraph and sneered at 'feeble writers'. He couldn't help himself.

OP posts:
Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:55

fuchiaknickers · 12/07/2023 09:48

I am proud to come from China. It’s the land of Jackie Chan, The Big Wall, martial arts and dragons. Other than rice – we eat over twice as much rice as people in the UK – its food may not be universally admired, but few other parts of the world are as beautiful. My homeland has always enjoyed a good reputation; and certainly Chinese people are known for being friendly and welcoming…

Bit reductive, wouldn't you say? Especially if the rest of the article went on to bash China. Stating “but I started by saying how much I love the dragons and the rice” would sound a bit…feeble, don’t you think??

And trying to bring Trans ideology into this to garner support for your Huw Edwards pile-on is equally feeble. Get a life.

Yes a bit reductive, then she states what she feels is wrong with the current Welsh government and their range of policies.

As a nobody on MN I don't think I have any power for a pile on. My AIBU was about some at the BBC having too much power. You don't agree with me, that's fine, that's the point of AIBU.

OP posts:
StefanosHill · 12/07/2023 09:54

fuchiaknickers · 12/07/2023 09:48

I am proud to come from China. It’s the land of Jackie Chan, The Big Wall, martial arts and dragons. Other than rice – we eat over twice as much rice as people in the UK – its food may not be universally admired, but few other parts of the world are as beautiful. My homeland has always enjoyed a good reputation; and certainly Chinese people are known for being friendly and welcoming…

Bit reductive, wouldn't you say? Especially if the rest of the article went on to bash China. Stating “but I started by saying how much I love the dragons and the rice” would sound a bit…feeble, don’t you think??

And trying to bring Trans ideology into this to garner support for your Huw Edwards pile-on is equally feeble. Get a life.

‘Bash China’

Or Wales.. of course people can write articles on what’s not good

Both paragraphs quoted look fine

fuchiaknickers · 12/07/2023 09:48

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:29

@Peacoffee "It was an incredibly inflammatory, bordering on anti-Welsh article. He was allowed to have an opinion. Why is he obligated to read to the end?"

The first paragraph is above. The bit he read. She say she loves her country. I wonder why he felt the need to punch down.

I am proud to come from China. It’s the land of Jackie Chan, The Big Wall, martial arts and dragons. Other than rice – we eat over twice as much rice as people in the UK – its food may not be universally admired, but few other parts of the world are as beautiful. My homeland has always enjoyed a good reputation; and certainly Chinese people are known for being friendly and welcoming…

Bit reductive, wouldn't you say? Especially if the rest of the article went on to bash China. Stating “but I started by saying how much I love the dragons and the rice” would sound a bit…feeble, don’t you think??

And trying to bring Trans ideology into this to garner support for your Huw Edwards pile-on is equally feeble. Get a life.

Countdowntowinter · 12/07/2023 09:45

OrwellianTimes · 12/07/2023 09:39

does anyone have a link to the article?

Calling an article feeble is an opinion. Everyone can have an opinion.

Rape threats are illegal but there’s no mention of that in the article you posted.

This is the bit he could read:

'For context this is the bit that he was able to read (as he said):

"I am proud to come from Wales. It’s the land of Richard Burton, Snowdonia, male voice choirs, Dylan Thomas and dragons. Other than lamb – there are twice as many sheep in Wales than the whole of the US – its food may not be universally admired, but few other parts of the UK are as beautiful. My homeland has always enjoyed a good reputation; and certainly Welsh people are known for being friendly and welcoming – unlike the people of another devolved nation I shan’t" ... then the paywall comes in'

Article in the Telegraph https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/08/10/drakeford-has-turned-wales-laboratory-terrible-ideas/

Drakeford has turned Wales into a laboratory for terrible ideas

Lockdown restrictions, trans ideology, excessive speed limits. The country's devolved government can be counted on to get things wrong

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/08/10/drakeford-has-turned-wales-laboratory-terrible-ideas

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread