Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my friend isn’t actually a lone parent?!

267 replies

butterlo · 12/07/2023 08:30

My friend describes herself as a lone parent and whilst her dd doesn’t see her dad so obviously she has no practical help, she has hundreds a month from her ex which means she has more flexibility than me… who I consider is a real lone parent. No contact with the father and has never paid a penny! Surely that’s the definition of a lone parent, not someone who has significant financial input for their child?!

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 12/07/2023 18:32

butterlo · 12/07/2023 08:33

I guess I wonder what it makes me then? I would love some financial support and if I had that in the amounts she has, I would definitely feel less alone!

It's not a race to the bottom

Rummikub · 12/07/2023 18:11

Lone ⬆️

Rummikub · 12/07/2023 18:11

Can someone post a definition of line v single parent from a valid source?

As far as I can see organisations use lone and single parent interchangeably.

Nothing to do with child maintenance or access arrangements.

I agree with op it’s not a race to the bottom. Child maintenance enforcement should be happening but doesn’t. It’s frustrating and soul destroying.

BBYBjorn · 12/07/2023 18:00

A lone parent also has minimum child maintenance, my ex only pays £30.43 a month

Yep, I was really shocked to find out the state of the CMS. It's insulting, really. Isn't the flat rate £27? Not even a full pound a day!

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 17:44

BBYBjorn · 12/07/2023 16:12

A LONE parent has no help from the other parent.

A SINGLE parent is not in a relationship with the other parent but is in a co parentimg arrangement

Not sure why people are having a go.

A lone parent also has minimum child maintenance, my ex only pays £30.43 a month

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 17:41

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 16:12

She got the settlement from the last week or the week before and has a period of time to move it into property which is the only way she won’t lose her universal credit apparently. She is taking advice I believe. You are right that normally you can’t have over that amount in the bank. The situ with my ex SIL is extremely messed up - she tells everyone how poor she is. She quit her job just at the right point before the court proceedings so she is “unemployed” versus my brother who has worked hard and has a well paid professional job. She got 75% of the equity in the house due to her being “unemployed” and the “primary carer” for their child.
I’d appreciate it if you could apologise for the pretty unpleasant / aggressive response. I’m on MN all the time and normally people try to be nice than that.

Of course she will lose her universal credit if she has more than £16,000 pounds in her current or saving account

Kafkaland · 12/07/2023 17:35

And often, as copious research demonstrates, a father does not become abusive until after children are born. Or walks out on his family many years later. Aborting a child that has been born already isn't really an option, is it?

MilitantMommyBFArmy4Life · 12/07/2023 17:31

*My story is that I terminated a baby rather than be tied to a violent cheat for the rest of my life. It isnt hard to make the right decisions for your own life and that of your future child.

And dont mistake passion for anger. I am passionate that people are accountable for their lives. I am sick of life being everyone elses fault. Victim blaming is such a bloody cop out.*

It's best not to judge. You had an abortion, that's fine.

Not everyone can access an abortion. This one is for girls and those in abusive family or relationship situations.

Not everyone knows their male counterpart is abusive or an idiot.

Not everyone can do something about it even if they do know.

Sometimes men are normal in a relationship but realise they can have freedom and don't want to pay or see a child.

Sometimes none of these things are true, and a woman just makes a misguided choice. Still not her fault if she's the one laying everything out for the child.

What good does punishing a woman for having sex years ago do? It's too late to make a child not exist.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 16:27

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 16:23

PS I just checked and I’m right in the info I mentioned - she has 6 months to invest the settlement money into property before it affects her Universal Credit.

“…there are capital disregards that can be taken into account when calculating your UC eligibility. For example, if you were to receive a lump sum under the terms of a financial agreement which was to be used specifically for a house purchase, then these funds would be disregarded from any UC calculation for six months, or longer if the sale did not complete.”

I guess in that she lives with her child 61% of the time and my brother lives with the child 39% of the time, they are both “single parents” for the time they each have DC. I just don’t think of her or my brother as “lone parents” as they have a co-parenting agreement in place and both contribute their parts to their child’s life. Different interpretations of the term.

There is no need to get unpleasant in posts on here, I don’t think we are coming from all that different perspectives on the matter in hand re the OP. 👍🏻

PPS I’m fairly sure she isn’t currently single as I think she has a new partner. But that wasn’t mentioned either way in my post as I don’t know and it isn’t relevant to their custody arrangement and parenting together. Just as you said “she is single”. Her relationships aren’t any of my business, I hope she is happy as the two of them sure weren’t happy being married.

LieInsAreExtinct · 12/07/2023 16:24

A lone parent IMO is one who is the primary carer, who might have some support either financial or practical or both, but basically the buck stops with you. You do the parents' evenings, the homework help, the laundry and uniform buying, all the admin, etc. Having a small financial contribution and the odd weekend 'off' on high alert because of problems doesn't make you less of a lone parent. Some people have a lot of help or support from a parent or two, or a sibling, or their new partner might help out with lifts for example, without being a full step parent. So there are all kinds of 'lone' parents but I think it's that mental load as much as anything which makes it tough.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 16:23

Beezknees · 12/07/2023 15:02

Also, she IS a single mum. She is single, and she's a mum. She's not a lone parent, as she has help, but she is a single mum and I say that as someone who's ex is not involved at all.

PS I just checked and I’m right in the info I mentioned - she has 6 months to invest the settlement money into property before it affects her Universal Credit.

“…there are capital disregards that can be taken into account when calculating your UC eligibility. For example, if you were to receive a lump sum under the terms of a financial agreement which was to be used specifically for a house purchase, then these funds would be disregarded from any UC calculation for six months, or longer if the sale did not complete.”

I guess in that she lives with her child 61% of the time and my brother lives with the child 39% of the time, they are both “single parents” for the time they each have DC. I just don’t think of her or my brother as “lone parents” as they have a co-parenting agreement in place and both contribute their parts to their child’s life. Different interpretations of the term.

There is no need to get unpleasant in posts on here, I don’t think we are coming from all that different perspectives on the matter in hand re the OP. 👍🏻

Keeva2017 · 12/07/2023 16:19

I have some financial support and ex has children 2 nights a month. I am absolutely a lone parent. I parent 330 nights out of the year alone. A but of support doesn’t replace the sharing of the load if I had their dad with me full time.

You’re jealous of money so trying to belittle your friend. Says more about you than it does about her parenting status.

Screwballs · 12/07/2023 16:18

willWillSmithsmith · 12/07/2023 15:48

So what is your story? This anger must come from somewhere?

My story is that I terminated a baby rather than be tied to a violent cheat for the rest of my life. It isnt hard to make the right decisions for your own life and that of your future child.

And dont mistake passion for anger. I am passionate that people are accountable for their lives. I am sick of life being everyone elses fault. Victim blaming is such a bloody cop out.

Kafkaland · 12/07/2023 16:16

You realise Im not just sat here waiting for a response?

Even given lots of time to think you have no answer that justifies your ridiculous assertions.

You still married a fucking idiot. Such a model partner of perfection, Im sure there wasnt a hint of a sign that entire time. And losing that amount of money? Where were you when this was happening?

I don't deny he is "an idiot". My point is that there was no way to tell this in advance, given none of the purported "red flags" were present. How would I know what money he had run up on credit cards? Do you demand copies of your husband's credit record to see if he's running up debts behind your back? If so, my bad.

Im sorry for your situation, but projecting doesnt change OP's situation. Being bitter that her friend didnt procreate with a dickhead is ridiculous.

I don't need and didn't ask for your sympathy. My children have a beautiful home and a loving parent and a very nice life, provided by me. What you need to do is stop stereotyping people and making judgements about them when you know nothing, as your posts make crystal clear.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 16:12

Beezknees · 12/07/2023 14:58

Bullshit. You cannot claim Universal Credit if you have more than £16k in the bank. I am a claimant myself so I know how it works. You are either lying, or she is lying to you about her finances.

She got the settlement from the last week or the week before and has a period of time to move it into property which is the only way she won’t lose her universal credit apparently. She is taking advice I believe. You are right that normally you can’t have over that amount in the bank. The situ with my ex SIL is extremely messed up - she tells everyone how poor she is. She quit her job just at the right point before the court proceedings so she is “unemployed” versus my brother who has worked hard and has a well paid professional job. She got 75% of the equity in the house due to her being “unemployed” and the “primary carer” for their child.
I’d appreciate it if you could apologise for the pretty unpleasant / aggressive response. I’m on MN all the time and normally people try to be nice than that.

BBYBjorn · 12/07/2023 16:12

A LONE parent has no help from the other parent.

A SINGLE parent is not in a relationship with the other parent but is in a co parentimg arrangement

Not sure why people are having a go.

willWillSmithsmith · 12/07/2023 15:48

Screwballs · 12/07/2023 14:02

You realise Im not just sat here waiting for a response?

You still married a fucking idiot. Such a model partner of perfection, Im sure there wasnt a hint of a sign that entire time. And losing that amount of money? Where were you when this was happening?

Im sorry for your situation, but projecting doesnt change OP's situation. Being bitter that her friend didnt procreate with a dickhead is ridiculous.

So what is your story? This anger must come from somewhere?

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/07/2023 15:45

RoseAdagio · 12/07/2023 15:37

Jeeeeez....that makes heartbreaking reading. I don't have anything constructive to say but I didn't want to read and just ignore this.

Massive amount of hugs and solidarity to you. Life dealt you a rough hand that you plainly did not deserve.

Hope you and your kid are doing great now xxx

Thank you, that's very kind of you to say. I really do appreciate it.

menopausalbloat · 12/07/2023 15:42

This is a wind-up post, right?

RoseAdagio · 12/07/2023 15:37

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/07/2023 15:18

I wholeheartedly agree.

I was married for nearly 20 years before the violence started because he couldn't deal with a disabled child.

But my fault entirely apparently as I should have seen from the beginning that a deputy head would attempt to strangle someone. I castigate myself every day for not reading the tea leaves properly.

Jeeeeez....that makes heartbreaking reading. I don't have anything constructive to say but I didn't want to read and just ignore this.

Massive amount of hugs and solidarity to you. Life dealt you a rough hand that you plainly did not deserve.

Hope you and your kid are doing great now xxx

RoseAdagio · 12/07/2023 15:34

She's still a lone parent.

Nobody's saying the money doesn't make it an easier lone parent gig than yours, but where her kid or kids are concerned she still has to make all the packed lunches, do all the school runs, help them with their home work, take them to their swimming lessons etc come what may, even if she feels ill or is having a super stressful shitty time at work.

Please don't turn on your friend over this. Her life might seem easier than yours but even as a comparatively financially comfortable lone parent, its still going to be tough enough for her. You should have solidarity with one another rather than turn on each other imho.

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 15:30

Beezknees · 12/07/2023 14:58

Bullshit. You cannot claim Universal Credit if you have more than £16k in the bank. I am a claimant myself so I know how it works. You are either lying, or she is lying to you about her finances.

True

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/07/2023 15:18

Kafkaland · 12/07/2023 13:47

The blame is on the father not paying, that does not remove blame from procreating with a fucking idiot. Christ, does no one take any responsibility these days, or is it perpetually everyone elses fault for stupid life decisions.

What is wrong with you? Why is there always at least one of these muppets on every thread about single/ lone parents?

Do you actually think that it's possible to predict the future?

I lived with my children's father for years before I married him. We were married for years before we had children. He really wanted children. We had many discussions about it. I only agreed to it based on him committing to 50/50 parenting: sharing childcare, sick days, all split down the middle. He was a model husband, friends' husbands used to say he made them look bad. Thoughtful, kind, respectful, did over 50% of household chores, stable and well-paid career with good progression prospects, very hard worker. He cared for me when I was unwell, he made lovely meals to cheer me up if I'd had a bad day or went out to buy me flowers. Booked surprise holidays for my birthday.

Then, when our children were babies, he walked out and has no contact with them. Turns out he'd been having affairs and had run up six figure gambling debts without my knowledge? Later, he messed his life up so badly he lost his job and career, now lives in a shared house I believe. Hasn't seen his children in years.

Please explain exactly how this is my fault and I should have predicted it?

I wholeheartedly agree.

I was married for nearly 20 years before the violence started because he couldn't deal with a disabled child.

But my fault entirely apparently as I should have seen from the beginning that a deputy head would attempt to strangle someone. I castigate myself every day for not reading the tea leaves properly.

Beezknees · 12/07/2023 15:02

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 14:56

My ex SIL describes herself as a “single mam” despite having £3k per month to live on plus another £80k lump sum in the divorce… (she won’t work more than the hours permitted so she still gets Universal Credit!) AND my brother fought and fought in the courts to get shared custody so he has their DD 39% of the calendar year. Essentially she has “child free time” 10 nights per month most months and 4 weeks completely child free in July-August. I would Not describe her as a single parent!!

Also, she IS a single mum. She is single, and she's a mum. She's not a lone parent, as she has help, but she is a single mum and I say that as someone who's ex is not involved at all.

Beezknees · 12/07/2023 14:58

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 14:56

My ex SIL describes herself as a “single mam” despite having £3k per month to live on plus another £80k lump sum in the divorce… (she won’t work more than the hours permitted so she still gets Universal Credit!) AND my brother fought and fought in the courts to get shared custody so he has their DD 39% of the calendar year. Essentially she has “child free time” 10 nights per month most months and 4 weeks completely child free in July-August. I would Not describe her as a single parent!!

Bullshit. You cannot claim Universal Credit if you have more than £16k in the bank. I am a claimant myself so I know how it works. You are either lying, or she is lying to you about her finances.

Swipe left for the next trending thread