Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my friend isn’t actually a lone parent?!

267 replies

butterlo · 12/07/2023 08:30

My friend describes herself as a lone parent and whilst her dd doesn’t see her dad so obviously she has no practical help, she has hundreds a month from her ex which means she has more flexibility than me… who I consider is a real lone parent. No contact with the father and has never paid a penny! Surely that’s the definition of a lone parent, not someone who has significant financial input for their child?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sarah419 · 13/07/2023 01:11

why does her bank account matter to you? if she’s bringing out feelings of jealousy and bitterness, maybe don’t befriend her and work on bettering your own circumstances or starting to accept your financial situation without comparing to others

Dotcheck · 12/07/2023 22:28

Screwballs · 12/07/2023 16:18

My story is that I terminated a baby rather than be tied to a violent cheat for the rest of my life. It isnt hard to make the right decisions for your own life and that of your future child.

And dont mistake passion for anger. I am passionate that people are accountable for their lives. I am sick of life being everyone elses fault. Victim blaming is such a bloody cop out.

But @Screwballs some people are very good at being deceitful. It’s awful what you went through, but sometimes people/men wait until after children arrive to show their dark side.

Rummikub · 12/07/2023 22:09

@Manthide well done for having a speech ready. Maybe text it to her.

Dies she ask you? If so she’s v cheeky. Pre-empt her and say your skint. At the very least bug yourself time and day you’ll let her know if you have spare funds.

I am skint and would never ask friends. I just don’t buy luxuries or go out unless it’s a walk.

Manthide · 12/07/2023 21:58

Rummikub · 12/07/2023 21:03

@Manthide I’d stop bailing your friend out! Make it clear she has more disposable income than your household. I’m amazed you do this.

I know, I'm not very good at asserting myself. I have a little speech ready for next time but I don't know if I'll be able to do it!

Rummikub · 12/07/2023 21:03

@Manthide I’d stop bailing your friend out! Make it clear she has more disposable income than your household. I’m amazed you do this.

celticprincess · 12/07/2023 20:16

You’re probably one of those who will tell me I’m not a long parent as my ex does see the kids - meant to be EOW but reality is it varies and can be months between. He currently doesn’t pay maintenance but has done. He’s skint and you can’t get blood from a stone. I live alone with my children. I do all the school runs, parent evenings, assemblies, awards nights, performances, fill in the Forms, fill in the DLA for one, I get the tax credits and child benefit as a single parent. I’m a long parent. We attempt to cO parent but we don’t really as far as I’m concerned.

I’d say you’re both lone parents. Even with financial support she’s alone at home with her kids making decisions day in day out and doesn’t have the other parent there to support with that.

Mamabear48 · 12/07/2023 20:10

You sound jealous and not a friend I would want to have

Manthide · 12/07/2023 20:06

Speedweed · 12/07/2023 10:02

I'm with you op, that would be frustrating.

We don't really have the terminology to describe the situations properly, everyone gets lumped in under the 'single parent' category, when there is a world of difference.

It's maddening too when someone claims the same status as you but you know there is a hidden advantage, such as receiving a lot of financial support. So anyone looking at the both of you from the outside would think she's magically doing 'better'.

As others have said though, you can't think about it too much as it will drive you mad, but I don't think that means you can't point it out to her when it's just the both of you talking.

A friend of mine is always short of money though she works full time and has no children. I am also short of money, am on a zero hours contract and normally get about 10 shifts a month. Dh is unemployed and I have one dc at home. I often lend her money as though my household income is about half of hers I manage it better. I do sometimes wonder if she ever thinks of my situation.

BBYBjorn · 12/07/2023 19:52

I am proud that I was strong enough not to be ruled by my heart.

That's one of many reasons why people have children in bad situations. You're not smarter than anyone else because you had an abortion. Someone could come along and say if you were super smart, you'd have doubled up. But that wouldn't be helpful, would it?

Screwballs · 12/07/2023 19:43

JusthereforXmas · 12/07/2023 18:51

I'm sorry you regret your decision so much you have internalized the guilt and turned it into hate and now use it to aggressively attack on any woman that choose different but therapy will likely help your more than misplacing blame in an attempt to justify it to yourself.

Give it a rest. I respect my own decision not to find myself in OPs position. I regret nothing, I am proud that I was strong enough not to be ruled by my heart.

EasterBreak · 12/07/2023 19:29

butterlo · 12/07/2023 08:33

I guess I wonder what it makes me then? I would love some financial support and if I had that in the amounts she has, I would definitely feel less alone!

Jealous. That's what it makes you. You are both single parents. Obviously.

momonpurpose · 12/07/2023 19:23

It's unfortunate you don't get financial help but that in no way makes you more single parent then anyone else.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 19:10

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 19:01

Omg no point responding to you anymore, whatever you think 🙄

I have supplied the source material as applies to capital disregards. I cannot do much more to explain the argument at hand. It admittedly is a technical point and most appropriately explained and understood by lawyers or accountants working within this field. I think this conversation has run its course. Thank you for the lovely discourse.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 19:04

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 19:00

Yes it does cut your universal credit if you have £16,000 more in your bank to splash out on yourself, you even googled the points and still came up with that conclusion 🤣

Unsurprisingly I was not in the relevant meeting with her solicitor and/or accountant but she has said she has been given advice and presumably advised the relevant government department re her ongoing UC entitlements. Whether she follows through on what she has declared or follows the advice is up to her. If she doesn’t she may end up owing the gov money. She has also said she wants a new Audi in recent times so who knows! Was demanding that my brother buy her one not that long ago as part of the divorce. Hopefully it all works out for her and everyone can move on happily, for the sake of the little child involved.

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 19:01

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 19:00

She hasn’t been told by the court what to spend the money on. If she doesn’t spend it on property then she will lose her UC. She could technically spend it on whatever she wants but then she wouldn’t be able to utilise this “capitals disregards” clause. The court agreement just dictated the % of the split from the house sale and my brother transferred that amount to her upon the completion of the sale.

Omg no point responding to you anymore, whatever you think 🙄

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 19:00

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 18:55

The way you stated it was that she got the money to splash out on herself when in reality that isn't the case, so you can google information for the yourself, you made out like if you have over £16,000 in your bank you can still claim universal credit which is bs.

She hasn’t been told by the court what to spend the money on. If she doesn’t spend it on property then she will lose her UC. She could technically spend it on whatever she wants but then she wouldn’t be able to utilise this “capitals disregards” clause. The court agreement just dictated the % of the split from the house sale and my brother transferred that amount to her upon the completion of the sale.

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 19:00

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 18:57

Ps the court has made no order as to What she spends the money on but my understanding is that she has been advised to put the money into property within 6 months in line with UC regulations. Who knows, that’s her business. I was just highlighting that having money over £16,000 in an account didn’t automatically cut UC payments.

Yes it does cut your universal credit if you have £16,000 more in your bank to splash out on yourself, you even googled the points and still came up with that conclusion 🤣

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 18:57

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 18:54

Hi, I was just replying to PP who said I was talking “Bullshit” regarding the UC system and was seeking to set out the info for them as it stands with the UC system. It’s an interesting theoretical situation but must be fairly common upon divorce.
It’s relevance only extends to my view in a previous post that where parents have shared custody of a child and the mother isn’t working but is receiving a court allocated per month on top of child maintenance etc it wouldn’t be a situation I would see as involving a “lone parent”.

There seems to be a fair amount of subjectively when it comes to the terms “single parent” and “lone parent”. I had always abstractly thought of them as interchangeable but perhaps not? Either way, if there is shared custody of a child then both parents would equally be considered “lone parents” or not. But one could not whilst the other was in this situation.

To my mind it is a combination of financial support and physical shared custody that defines a situation as Not being a “lone parent” situation. I only referenced my brother’s situation by way of example - it seems to have hit a nerve. All I can say is that he has fought and fought to ensure his child isn’t taken away from him, the mother initially (in multiple recorded interviews) stated that she wouldn’t “ever let him see” the child if he continued to pursue a divorce. It was all very sad and difficult for the whole family, doubtless on both sides. Now hopefully things are moving forward towards everyone being happier.

Ps the court has made no order as to What she spends the money on but my understanding is that she has been advised to put the money into property within 6 months in line with UC regulations. Who knows, that’s her business. I was just highlighting that having money over £16,000 in an account didn’t automatically cut UC payments.

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 18:55

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 18:45

Here is the relevant section from the UC regulations that governs capital disregards i.e. money over £16,000 that is ignored for the purposes of claiming UC (Chapter H2):

“H2119 Where a person has received an amount within the past 6 months which is to be used to purchase premises that the person intend to occupy as their home, that amount can be disregarded from the calculation of that person’s capital where it

  1. is attributable to the proceeds of the sale of premises formerly occupied as their home or
  2. has been deposited with a housing association (see H2045) or
  3. is a grant made to the person for the sole purpose of purchasing a home1.
1 UC Regs, Sch 10, para 13 Is it reasonable to disregard for longer H2120 The DM may decide it is reasonable to disregard the amount for a longer period if, for example
  1. people have tried but not found premises which are suitable for their or a member of their family's needs (in particular, if one of them is disabled and needs a certain type of accommodation)
  2. the person has found premises and the
2.1 sale has not been completed or 2.2 seller later decides not to sell.”

The way you stated it was that she got the money to splash out on herself when in reality that isn't the case, so you can google information for the yourself, you made out like if you have over £16,000 in your bank you can still claim universal credit which is bs.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 18:54

JusthereforXmas · 12/07/2023 18:44

so theirs a legal court order that the money from the divorce is tied up in a housing chain... shes not just splashing £80k on nails and girls nights not that that is anything to do with anything.

Its utterly irreverent to both her income or status as a single parent.

Why are you so bitter over a relationship thats not your own, talk about boundary stomping and being out of your lane.

Hi, I was just replying to PP who said I was talking “Bullshit” regarding the UC system and was seeking to set out the info for them as it stands with the UC system. It’s an interesting theoretical situation but must be fairly common upon divorce.
It’s relevance only extends to my view in a previous post that where parents have shared custody of a child and the mother isn’t working but is receiving a court allocated per month on top of child maintenance etc it wouldn’t be a situation I would see as involving a “lone parent”.

There seems to be a fair amount of subjectively when it comes to the terms “single parent” and “lone parent”. I had always abstractly thought of them as interchangeable but perhaps not? Either way, if there is shared custody of a child then both parents would equally be considered “lone parents” or not. But one could not whilst the other was in this situation.

To my mind it is a combination of financial support and physical shared custody that defines a situation as Not being a “lone parent” situation. I only referenced my brother’s situation by way of example - it seems to have hit a nerve. All I can say is that he has fought and fought to ensure his child isn’t taken away from him, the mother initially (in multiple recorded interviews) stated that she wouldn’t “ever let him see” the child if he continued to pursue a divorce. It was all very sad and difficult for the whole family, doubtless on both sides. Now hopefully things are moving forward towards everyone being happier.

JusthereforXmas · 12/07/2023 18:51

Screwballs · 12/07/2023 16:18

My story is that I terminated a baby rather than be tied to a violent cheat for the rest of my life. It isnt hard to make the right decisions for your own life and that of your future child.

And dont mistake passion for anger. I am passionate that people are accountable for their lives. I am sick of life being everyone elses fault. Victim blaming is such a bloody cop out.

I'm sorry you regret your decision so much you have internalized the guilt and turned it into hate and now use it to aggressively attack on any woman that choose different but therapy will likely help your more than misplacing blame in an attempt to justify it to yourself.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 18:45

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 17:41

Of course she will lose her universal credit if she has more than £16,000 pounds in her current or saving account

Here is the relevant section from the UC regulations that governs capital disregards i.e. money over £16,000 that is ignored for the purposes of claiming UC (Chapter H2):

“H2119 Where a person has received an amount within the past 6 months which is to be used to purchase premises that the person intend to occupy as their home, that amount can be disregarded from the calculation of that person’s capital where it

  1. is attributable to the proceeds of the sale of premises formerly occupied as their home or
  2. has been deposited with a housing association (see H2045) or
  3. is a grant made to the person for the sole purpose of purchasing a home1.
1 UC Regs, Sch 10, para 13 Is it reasonable to disregard for longer H2120 The DM may decide it is reasonable to disregard the amount for a longer period if, for example
  1. people have tried but not found premises which are suitable for their or a member of their family's needs (in particular, if one of them is disabled and needs a certain type of accommodation)
  2. the person has found premises and the
2.1 sale has not been completed or 2.2 seller later decides not to sell.”
JusthereforXmas · 12/07/2023 18:44

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 16:23

PS I just checked and I’m right in the info I mentioned - she has 6 months to invest the settlement money into property before it affects her Universal Credit.

“…there are capital disregards that can be taken into account when calculating your UC eligibility. For example, if you were to receive a lump sum under the terms of a financial agreement which was to be used specifically for a house purchase, then these funds would be disregarded from any UC calculation for six months, or longer if the sale did not complete.”

I guess in that she lives with her child 61% of the time and my brother lives with the child 39% of the time, they are both “single parents” for the time they each have DC. I just don’t think of her or my brother as “lone parents” as they have a co-parenting agreement in place and both contribute their parts to their child’s life. Different interpretations of the term.

There is no need to get unpleasant in posts on here, I don’t think we are coming from all that different perspectives on the matter in hand re the OP. 👍🏻

so theirs a legal court order that the money from the divorce is tied up in a housing chain... shes not just splashing £80k on nails and girls nights not that that is anything to do with anything.

Its utterly irreverent to both her income or status as a single parent.

Why are you so bitter over a relationship thats not your own, talk about boundary stomping and being out of your lane.

JusthereforXmas · 12/07/2023 18:34

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 14:56

My ex SIL describes herself as a “single mam” despite having £3k per month to live on plus another £80k lump sum in the divorce… (she won’t work more than the hours permitted so she still gets Universal Credit!) AND my brother fought and fought in the courts to get shared custody so he has their DD 39% of the calendar year. Essentially she has “child free time” 10 nights per month most months and 4 weeks completely child free in July-August. I would Not describe her as a single parent!!

What utter crap you spout.

What you say can't even be factually true.

Also having 10 nights off while doing 21 nights and 31 days doesn't change being a single parent, neither does income.

Hatty123 · 12/07/2023 18:33

Nousername4now · 12/07/2023 17:41

Of course she will lose her universal credit if she has more than £16,000 pounds in her current or saving account

Look it up, there are capital disregards that can be taken into account when calculating your UC eligibility. For example, if you were to receive a lump sum under the terms of a financial agreement which was to be used specifically for a house purchase, then these funds would be disregarded from any UC calculation for six months, or longer if the sale did not complete.

She has been given advice by her solicitor. She is living in a house owned by her Dad so likely she will buy the house from him or out the financial settlement (from divorce) money into property elsewhere. She essentially has 6 months to dispose of it within the UC rules. Doesn’t seem fair to me tbh but that’s the system.

Source: See the section in this link entitled “How does a lump sum received on divorce affect Universal Credit?”

https://www.birketts.co.uk/legal-update/will-divorce-affect-my-universal-credit/#:~:text=How%20does%20a%20lump%20sum,UC%20will%20not%20be%20affected.

Will my divorce affect my Universal Credit?

The Universal Credit (UC) reforms were announced over a decade ago, but to this day they remain a topic of criticism and confusion.

https://www.birketts.co.uk/legal-update/will-divorce-affect-my-universal-credit/#:~:text=How%20does%20a%20lump%20sum,UC%20will%20not%20be%20affected.

Swipe left for the next trending thread