Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Speaking to a guy on a post graduate visa - family disapprove

108 replies

Evieanne · 11/07/2023 22:10

So I have been talking to a guy who is on a graduate visa for a while, and in that time, we have taken to each other and seem to have a lot in common. He has told me he would like to get married by next year and would like to meet my family to inform them he has intentions of turning our relationship into a marriage and would appreciate their support, well wishes and blessings.

My family think he’s a nice guy but are sceptical in case he’s using me to secure a permanent residency here in the UK.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
BritinDelco · 12/07/2023 03:15

OP when my now DH of 3 years proposed after 3 days together properly everyone thought we were crazy and still going strong. DH is Italian American and I white British so different cultures to yours but on a similar wavelength.

If you really want to know if it's visa related then state your preference for settling and bringing up kids in Bangladesh As you're sick of the UK for whatever reason you choose,

Then you'll know for sure

JeandeServiette · 12/07/2023 03:11

Evieanne · 11/07/2023 23:01

How can you tell the difference between someone who is sincerely wanting to get married and just happens to be from a different country compared to someone who is using for a visa ? @HereForTheFreeLunch

By only considering suitors who have a legal right to reside in your jurisdiction.

magma33 · 12/07/2023 03:06

Evieanne · 12/07/2023 00:36

We don’t date as such, we don’t move in together before marriage, we don’t meet alone before marriage, plenty do but we aren’t allowed to do that. My mum is very much a “if he likes you he’d contact me and your dad expressing his interest”, doesn’t matter how old we are, whether we are 17 or 47, it’s never completely our decision as our close relatives must agree for the marriage to be finalised and accepted. We can’t date independently, we can’t meet alone, it has to be run through the family.

He’s 27, he is on an after studies work visa, rather than a student visa. I think he’s feeling some pressure from his family to get married, his mum is incredibly religious and possibly could be the driving force behind it.

We spoke on the phone, he was saying his mum was wanting to see a picture of me, which is normal, I sent him a couple to send to her but he was asking for a forward facing passport style picture which I said no to due to security reasons, and that if she wants to see me she can call me, he agreed. He said he was looking to see if his employer could sponsor him, I said this would be a great idea because if he has this opportunity then he could under the skilled visa route, although difficult wouldn’t be impossible.

When he talks about all the places he will take me “when we get married” it makes me more drawn to him, he is a source of freedom for me, we have a lot in common, he wants to travel and the only way I can do that is if I have a husband and go with him.

Sometimes I think, what’s the point? It is almost as though us daughters are a liability, we belong to our fathers and later our husbands are our allocated guardians, our lives are governed and oversaw by men because they’re our protectors and have responsibility towards us, like keeping us sheltered, fed, clothed, warm. We have to be constantly chaperoned, our bodies objectified, our locations questioned. And If he hits me? Well, not much different to being a child, we got hit a lot.

Oh OP you sound quite beaten, i’m quite old and born here and from what I’ve seen many of our communities have progressed so much over the years as they have integrated more, the women have had the opportunity to be educated, they are ‘allowed’ to go on holidays with their sisters and friends without men, earn their own money, are ‘allowed’ to marry men on the same level as them, it’s really sad to read there are still some families that haven’t moved on from tribal village mindsets because that’s what this is and this level of control is abuse. I bet the men in your family are not controlled like this, that surely makes you more angry to not want to conform further by marrying someone from back home who won’t be too different to marrying a random cousin from back home! There is nothing stopping you keeping your culture and being ‘respectable’ you don’t need to rush to get married and to some random visa hunter. This is your life and when shit hits the fan and you break up, you’ll be on your own as nobody else will be there to help pick up the pieces and they’ll say ‘I told you so’
if you’re not allowed to study, you’re worried you’ll be forced to marry someone else, you don’t have much freedom to do basic things what many of us Pakistani girls have been doing for years then I’m going to leave these organisations’ names in case you ever want to have a chat with them,

women’s aid: do amazing work and have helped many Asian women when their own families and communities turned their backs on them for not staying in abusive relationships (including parent child abuse)

southhall black sisters
karma nirvana

pink ladoo

I’m sure there are lots others.

you might not need them now but you might do someday.

there is also a south Asian mumsnetters section here but I guarantee you’ll get similar responses that you are getting here as like I said most women nowadays refuse to put up with this nonsense in this country not matter their cultural background.

CecilyP · 12/07/2023 02:48

GarlicGrace · 12/07/2023 02:06

While you're getting yourself together, how about this? Make some fake profiles on the dating sites you're using. Put in search criteria that perfectly match him. Wait and see how many likes he gives your other profiles.

Sounds like a plan!

Ponderingwindow · 12/07/2023 02:44

Of course he is looking for a visa.

even though you face strong cultural mores to comply with a patriarchal system, if you live in the UK, you do have the choice to claim more freedom for yourself. Securing an education and employment will give you financial freedom. If you have money, you can’t be constrained to the demands of your family or a husband. That doesn’t mean that you have to reject your culture, but there can be balance. You can live your life and marry when you are ready.

every single person I know that has a good marriage has a marriage where either party has the power to leave. They married by choice and they stay together by choice, not because of culture or money. The degree of romance may vary, but the mutual respect has to be there and that can only truly happen when both parties have equal power. If you don’t have that, the person with more power, almost always the man, will take advantage.

CecilyP · 12/07/2023 02:42

We don’t date as such, we don’t move in together before marriage, we don’t meet alone before marriage, plenty do but we aren’t allowed to do that.

No one’s suggesting you move in together; that would be equally daft. You don’t even have to meet alone. You could even take your aunt on your dates as a poster upthread suggested.

MintJulia · 12/07/2023 02:36

Op, you need to realise that you are a woman in a modern age. You have legal rights, no matter what your family want, and one of them is to choose your own life.
I know going against tradition is scary but unless you do, your daughters will be caught in the same cruel practice.

Find a compromise. Talk to your mum and look for a way to meet potential partners in the U.K, which they can accept. There will be a way, you just need to find it.

CecilyP · 12/07/2023 02:32

Evieanne · 11/07/2023 23:01

How can you tell the difference between someone who is sincerely wanting to get married and just happens to be from a different country compared to someone who is using for a visa ? @HereForTheFreeLunch

You can’t but as you’ve never actually met, I’d err on the side of caution!

CecilyP · 12/07/2023 02:28

Evieanne · 11/07/2023 22:59

So yes I am baffled because my family and many people in this culture believe that if someone loves you they will approach your family and make attempts to marry you and that people who just date you for a while and not marry you, are not trustworthy. And this is also the way a lot of people approach people when they want a visa. So it’s not me being naive or off my fucking head for asking. Would you speak to your own children this way?

Yes I absolutely would. Although it would be unthinkable for them to ask. If someone dates you and decides not to marry you, it means that they’ve got to know you and know that you are not the one they want to spend the rest of their life with. That actually makes them more trustworthy than someone who proposes marriage to someone they don’t know and who they’ve never met. Pretty sure he wants a visa!

magma33 · 12/07/2023 02:27

GarlicGrace · 12/07/2023 02:06

While you're getting yourself together, how about this? Make some fake profiles on the dating sites you're using. Put in search criteria that perfectly match him. Wait and see how many likes he gives your other profiles.

Great idea!

MintJulia · 12/07/2023 02:26

ClementWeatherToday · 11/07/2023 22:12

A guy you've never actually met who will shortly be in need of a visa has TOLD you he wants to marry you within a year? Yeah, listen to your family.

This. He's looking for a spouse's visa. Don't be a fool.

magma33 · 12/07/2023 02:22

OP i’m Pakistani and the general consensus is men from abroad usually want the visa yes they’ll send you little gifts and be sweet but the reality is different when they’re over here, it’s been happening for decades to women who have been pressured in some way and felt that’s the best they were gona get, I know this isn’t the case with you but think carefully before you ruin your life and happiness, he has plenty to gain by marrying you but you have much to lose, unless you’re gona tell me he’s highly educated and will have a well paying job once he’s here to pay his own way properly. I’m older than you and the younger girls are more clued up on this because of what they’ve seen happen in the past to women from over here. They come from over there, with their male privilege and entitlement in tact refusing to be equal partners, and then also sending huge amounts of cash back home. I’ve seen so many women complain about this. Yes, you get bad men everywhere but at least when there isn’t a visa on offer, you’re sort of on an equal footing at the start. Not just south Asians, it happened to my friend and the man was from a America, happened to countless women who have met men abroad.

Why don’t you say to him that you want to move to Bangladesh with him, instead of living in the U.K. see how long he keeps his interest. You have to keep it going for a few months, not tell him the next day you were only joking. If you were my daughter I’d tell you to stay well clear but I also wouldn’t want you to marry your cousin either 🤷‍♀️

CecilyP · 12/07/2023 02:18

we don’t date the traditional way because our family don’t agree with free mixing between men and women and the family have to meet to see if the person is well suited.

And how would they be able to judge that exactly? You do sound naive and, yes, he is after a visa!

SleepingStandingUp · 12/07/2023 02:06

Evieanne · 11/07/2023 22:54

I understand constructive comments but there’s no need to be so harsh and make jabs at me! I don’t appreciate being called naive Different cultures have different ways of doing things and in ours and my family, we don’t meet the opposite sex alone, we don’t date the traditional way because our family don’t agree with free mixing between men and women and the family have to meet to see if the person is well suited.

Op are you basically saying you want an arranged marriage with this guy from Bangladesh hence needing their support but they're saying no?

GarlicGrace · 12/07/2023 02:06

While you're getting yourself together, how about this? Make some fake profiles on the dating sites you're using. Put in search criteria that perfectly match him. Wait and see how many likes he gives your other profiles.

GarlicGrace · 12/07/2023 02:03

You're dead right, @Evieanne, in a deeply patriarchal culture girls are a liability. There's no global epidemic of parents killing their sons; only daughters. It's a massively fucked-up system, not least because girls could become assets to their families if they were fully educated, encouraged into careers and permitted independence.

Can't change that in people who've fully internalised those values, unfortunately, but you are free to opt out of it over here. Marrying some geezer whose visa just happens to be expiring, according to the rules of this patriarchal culture, will lock you right into it.

Your choice. If it were me, I'd ditch the parents and the visa-hunting patriarch, move into a flat-share with some independent minded women, and start dating like the normal British woman you are.

fridaynight1 · 12/07/2023 00:59

How can you tell the difference between someone who is sincerely wanting to get married and just happens to be from a different country compared to someone who is using for a visa ?

You listen to your family.

HoneySoyChickenCrisps · 12/07/2023 00:51

Why does this have to be your reality? Do you have an education? A job? If you're at risk of violence from your family if you refuse to go along with this arrangement there are many women's organisations out there that can help. It's not 'we', it's 'you'.

Evieanne · 12/07/2023 00:37

From the moment we were born to the day we die our lives are never truly ours, freedom is just an illusion. We don’t have freedom. Freedom is at the stake of losing family and getting killed and abused by people

OP posts:
Evieanne · 12/07/2023 00:36

We don’t date as such, we don’t move in together before marriage, we don’t meet alone before marriage, plenty do but we aren’t allowed to do that. My mum is very much a “if he likes you he’d contact me and your dad expressing his interest”, doesn’t matter how old we are, whether we are 17 or 47, it’s never completely our decision as our close relatives must agree for the marriage to be finalised and accepted. We can’t date independently, we can’t meet alone, it has to be run through the family.

He’s 27, he is on an after studies work visa, rather than a student visa. I think he’s feeling some pressure from his family to get married, his mum is incredibly religious and possibly could be the driving force behind it.

We spoke on the phone, he was saying his mum was wanting to see a picture of me, which is normal, I sent him a couple to send to her but he was asking for a forward facing passport style picture which I said no to due to security reasons, and that if she wants to see me she can call me, he agreed. He said he was looking to see if his employer could sponsor him, I said this would be a great idea because if he has this opportunity then he could under the skilled visa route, although difficult wouldn’t be impossible.

When he talks about all the places he will take me “when we get married” it makes me more drawn to him, he is a source of freedom for me, we have a lot in common, he wants to travel and the only way I can do that is if I have a husband and go with him.

Sometimes I think, what’s the point? It is almost as though us daughters are a liability, we belong to our fathers and later our husbands are our allocated guardians, our lives are governed and oversaw by men because they’re our protectors and have responsibility towards us, like keeping us sheltered, fed, clothed, warm. We have to be constantly chaperoned, our bodies objectified, our locations questioned. And If he hits me? Well, not much different to being a child, we got hit a lot.

OP posts:
PinkDreamsMum · 12/07/2023 00:35

PinkDreamsMum · 12/07/2023 00:29

You can’t which is why your family are being sceptical and why people are advising you to be cautious.

Sorry, this was my reply to your question about how you can tell the difference between a genuine suitor and someone who is just after a visa.

PinkDreamsMum · 12/07/2023 00:29

You can’t which is why your family are being sceptical and why people are advising you to be cautious.

NeverThatSerious · 11/07/2023 23:47

Evieanne · 11/07/2023 22:59

So yes I am baffled because my family and many people in this culture believe that if someone loves you they will approach your family and make attempts to marry you and that people who just date you for a while and not marry you, are not trustworthy. And this is also the way a lot of people approach people when they want a visa. So it’s not me being naive or off my fucking head for asking. Would you speak to your own children this way?

No, my child is under two, but i would speak to a friend that way if I thought it might knock some sense into them.
With the cultural context, I feel I was maybe on the harsher side, but the same sentiment stands. He isn’t it.

determinedtomakethiswork · 11/07/2023 23:33

My son married a girl from another country and applying for a visa was actually really difficult. They had to prove that they had met each other's families, how much time they had spent together physically, and he had to prove that he could support her financially.

I think you'll probably find this guy is talking to a number of people in the hope that he can get someone to marry him.

OddsOn · 11/07/2023 23:21

I would never have married a citizen from another country and I write that as a woman whose origins are not British though I was born here. You have children and then split up, read up what has happened to some women when their husbands have taken the kids back home for a holiday.