Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Speaking to a guy on a post graduate visa - family disapprove

108 replies

Evieanne · 11/07/2023 22:10

So I have been talking to a guy who is on a graduate visa for a while, and in that time, we have taken to each other and seem to have a lot in common. He has told me he would like to get married by next year and would like to meet my family to inform them he has intentions of turning our relationship into a marriage and would appreciate their support, well wishes and blessings.

My family think he’s a nice guy but are sceptical in case he’s using me to secure a permanent residency here in the UK.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wishihadagoodone · 13/07/2023 09:30

Ginger1982 · 12/07/2023 20:16

Don't go to your grandparents country in December. Sounds incredibly suss to me, like they intend marrying you off out there.

This in spades. This immediately jumped out to me when you said you were travelling with your father.

Ginger1982 · 12/07/2023 20:16

Don't go to your grandparents country in December. Sounds incredibly suss to me, like they intend marrying you off out there.

HereForTheFreeLunch · 12/07/2023 19:40

OP, I would say forget the guys. Work on your future.
What do you do? Study? Work?
If you are going to take a traditional view of life but still want to be free then work on your financial emancipation rather than the sexual/relationship.
Get on your own two feet, earn your living, move into your own house share with other girls and grow your own wings.
Then see how you feel about guys, marriage, patriarchy, religion and choose the life you want for yourself.

Rainbowshit · 12/07/2023 14:20

Oh FGS. He clearly is just after a visa. Bin him off.

user01082312345 · 12/07/2023 14:16

Christ, don't do it. Block all contact and find someone who wants to be in a normal, happy relationship with you, and who will pop the question because he genuinely loves you and wants to spend the rest of his life with you, not because he needs a visa!

Blueuggboots · 12/07/2023 14:07

Your family, whilst they believe they are doing the "right thing" are controlling you.

You do not have to live like this. You don't have to go to the other extreme either.

You are an adult female in the UK so you have legal rights.

I would not be going away to your home country - that shouts of being married off.

Please seek help from appropriate people and get out. You can have a happy, fulfilling life. No family member ever died because their relative didn't do exactly what they were told to by their family, NO ONE.

RampantIvy · 12/07/2023 13:29

I feel so sad after reading your recent posts @Evieanne. They reminded me of a book I have recently read - A Thousand Splendid Suns by Khaled Hosseini.

Your family are controlling and abusive. This is not how most people live. Please follow up the resources that other posters have posted on here and make your escape from them. Perhaps you could lodge with a family if you can't afford a flat share?

thecatwiththesilveryfur · 12/07/2023 13:13

GarlicGrace · 12/07/2023 02:03

You're dead right, @Evieanne, in a deeply patriarchal culture girls are a liability. There's no global epidemic of parents killing their sons; only daughters. It's a massively fucked-up system, not least because girls could become assets to their families if they were fully educated, encouraged into careers and permitted independence.

Can't change that in people who've fully internalised those values, unfortunately, but you are free to opt out of it over here. Marrying some geezer whose visa just happens to be expiring, according to the rules of this patriarchal culture, will lock you right into it.

Your choice. If it were me, I'd ditch the parents and the visa-hunting patriarch, move into a flat-share with some independent minded women, and start dating like the normal British woman you are.

Dear OP, please read this post. It says everything you need to know.

You are worth more than this - more than your family say, but also more than to throw yourself on the mercy of the man who only wants a visa.

You are a real person. Be brave. Contact some of the help services above and go and live your life. Flowers

magma33 · 12/07/2023 12:55

Yes OP your best bet is talking to these organisations, even if you don’t do anything just yet they can advise regarding housing, can put you in touch with women who have been through the same and help you build you self esteem etc don’t tell anyone within the family or community you can’t trust them. Stay safe.

laplaland · 12/07/2023 12:55

Please listen to your family. Alarm bells are ringing here.

historyrepeatz · 12/07/2023 12:52

It's very hard in your position to know whether this man is genuine or not. I'm not Pakistani but met a Pakistani man at uni. He was very different from the other young Pakistani men in behaviour and attitudes. It wasn't his intention to stay here long term he wanted a UK degree and work experience on his CV. He stayed for a while after uni on a work visa. After a few years together we changed it to a spouse visa. We are now together 17 years with children. Our biggest marriage challenges have been due to in-laws. Another thing you have to factor in as they can make you miserable.

We obviously spent a lot of time together before marriage which you haven't. We got to know each other and communicated very clearly and realistically about how our lives would look if we stayed together. How we would behave, raise our children, live financially etc.

It's all very well saying he wants to take you travelling but is it realistically possible for you two to have a good life together financially?

Although ours worked out, I have personally met people from Pakistan who have married for visas. One says he was upfront and it was an agreed temporary arrangement, his wife says otherwise. The other was deceitful.

As pp have said be careful you aren't going from the frying pan to the fire because you think life will be better with him than as it currently is.

JorisBonson · 12/07/2023 12:49

Absolutely don't go away in December with them OP.

Speak to Women's Aid asap or Saheli.

https://www.saheli.org.uk/help

Contact 1 — Saheli

https://www.saheli.org.uk/help

Evieanne · 12/07/2023 12:49

I just can’t trust what they say, because I don’t believe they’re acting in my best interests, it’s more what they want to happen and their fears that are impacting my life, so that’s why I created the thread to get an impartial perspective from people who don’t have any motive

OP posts:
cheezncrackers · 12/07/2023 12:46

In December I am booked to go to my grandad’s country with my dad and aunt, people have told me they don’t think it’s a good idea but I’m tired of overthinking, I must see if I can trust my family.

This makes me wonder if they plan to marry you off while you're over there OP. I've read/heard so many similar stories to this, where a daughter from a controlling family is trying to break free and the family persuade her to go on a holiday to their home country, usually for some spurious, family-related reason (grandma is ill, cousin is getting married, etc). But the real reason for the trip is to marry her off when she's in country where no support network can help her to resist. It sounds to me like your instincts are screaming at you not to make this trip, but you're determined to try and keep your family on-side, despite your many, many misgivings and growing realisation that the controlling and physically abusive way you were raised is not right and not normal.

As for this man off the internet, look he could be kind and genuine and perfectly nice, or he could be mean and abusive and controlling himself. You have no way of knowing and to marry a stranger like this is incredibly dangeous. You have no idea who he is or what his intentions are. I bet his mother back in Bangladesh is desperate for him to marry a girl who has UK citizenship, so he can stay here and either bring her and the rest of the family over, or support them with a UK salary. You'd be crazy to allow yourself to be drawn into such a potentially dangerous and abusive situation. The best thing you can do is get out of the awful situation you're in, not swap it for a different one. Contact some of the organisations listed above OP. Please. You sound like a spirited woman who is being crushed. I think I remember this organisation https://karmanirvana.org.uk/ being mentioned in the excellent and really horrifying BBC drama 'Honour' (which I recommend you watch, if you haven't seen it).

Karma Nirvana

Our goal is to end Honour Based Abuse in the UK. We run a national helpline, offer training to professionals, gather data to inform policies and services, and campaign for change.

https://karmanirvana.org.uk

Evieanne · 12/07/2023 12:46

WaitingForNothingGood · 12/07/2023 12:02

Do you have control of your own money?

You are being abused by your family.

If any woman was treated like this by a man in the UK I wonder if they would be guilty of coercive controls

I know plenty of women who are from all sorts of religions who are not subjected to this type of treatment.

You need to save your money and leave.

Why are the males allowed to sleep around but you aren't even allowed out on your own? It's because they think of you as an object or a piece of property not as a human.

Why sacrifice you happiness and life for them. They don't like you .

I have control of my own money, I did plan to move away eventually once I have saved up enough but I suppose I felt defeated and just accepted it. I wish I never came back to the house, when I left I felt a huge relief and now I’m feeling the same I am before I left the first time. they said I could only move out when I get a husband and jointly buy a house with him. I’m only allowed to go to local areas within an hour north wards during day light hours but anywhere else they make some excuse about why it’s not a good idea. They look at all the women getting abused and killed and they said it makes them terrified that the same could happen to us. They just switch up a lot, I never know where I stand with them.
I wish I knew how to change their minds, how to convince them but looks like there’s no point.

I’ll get in contact with the charities and organisations and ask for some clarity because my head is fucked.

OP posts:
TheEverdelightfulsamantha · 12/07/2023 12:36

You don’t have to live under these conditions - save enough money to raise a deposit on a flat and move out. If you don’t have access to your own money to do that, then that’s financial abuse and the organisations listed above will help you. Learn to drive so you can get to work by yourself, or take taxis, get a bike or walk - you need to take control of your own life and happiness.

your parents can’t physically stop you from visiting friends, going to social events, going to Germany because that would be illegal - imprisonment - they might be disappointed if you do them, but as your view of the world is very different from theirs, you are currently not compatible so need to start living your own life.

Evieanne · 12/07/2023 12:22

My friend was allowed to go to see our other friend in Preston for a week, but I wasn’t even allowed for a night or two. My mum said no but wouldn’t even give me a proper reason. I don’t know how much longer I can cope tbh. Not many other Muslim families have more than one child that isn’t straight, I have so much to stress about. I have nobody to talk to about this, I have failed MH referrals despite having complex illnesses I’m just done. Maybe this is a sign.

OP posts:
Evieanne · 12/07/2023 12:18

My family tell me just because other people don’t follow the rules doesn’t mean the rules don’t say what they’re telling me and they say they don’t care what other parents do or don’t do that has nothing to do with us. This was said when I said to her other parents allow theirs so why can’t we. Then they try and find soft legitimate excuses and are now using the cost of living excuse. My parents had an issue with my younger sister wanting to leave for uni to another part of the north and my parents were weird about it and were saying she can’t and that my sister wouldn’t be able to afford it, my sister fought back and said she’s doing it regardless which still caused a fuss. But I don’t know if I can do it because I’m scared that if I do something, what if it affects my sisters negatively. I’m bi, my sister is gay, I am having to be the one that gets trapped just so she can live her life. It’s hard. But I always said to myself, if one of us lives normality according to their rules then my sister will maybe get away with it 😭

OP posts:
Evieanne · 12/07/2023 12:13

*fears

OP posts:
Evieanne · 12/07/2023 12:12

No unfortunately it’s not fake. Believe it or not this is how it is in my family. This is really my life and I’m from a Pakistani potwari speaking background. My family are like this. None of my other friend’s are restricted in the way I am, nor is my second cousin. My parents are paranoid about everything and we can’t live our lives because of their tears. I didn’t realise it wasn’t normal, I didn’t realise being hit the way I was growing up wasn’t normal either, all I know is I feel suffocated.

OP posts:
WaitingForNothingGood · 12/07/2023 12:02

Do you have control of your own money?

You are being abused by your family.

If any woman was treated like this by a man in the UK I wonder if they would be guilty of coercive controls

I know plenty of women who are from all sorts of religions who are not subjected to this type of treatment.

You need to save your money and leave.

Why are the males allowed to sleep around but you aren't even allowed out on your own? It's because they think of you as an object or a piece of property not as a human.

Why sacrifice you happiness and life for them. They don't like you .

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 12/07/2023 11:37

Oh well, at least he is honest about his motives.

GoogleMeNot · 12/07/2023 11:35

I suspect this is fake! None of it sounds real and full of stereotypes about ethnic minorities.

eurochick · 12/07/2023 11:34

The only thing making you obey these awful rules is your own head. It's not the law or cultural norm in the uk. You have a job. You are an adult. You can walk away if you want.

If you go on the planned trip I expect you are very likely to be married off.

This is so sad.

GoogleMeNot · 12/07/2023 11:26

Evieanne · 12/07/2023 00:36

We don’t date as such, we don’t move in together before marriage, we don’t meet alone before marriage, plenty do but we aren’t allowed to do that. My mum is very much a “if he likes you he’d contact me and your dad expressing his interest”, doesn’t matter how old we are, whether we are 17 or 47, it’s never completely our decision as our close relatives must agree for the marriage to be finalised and accepted. We can’t date independently, we can’t meet alone, it has to be run through the family.

He’s 27, he is on an after studies work visa, rather than a student visa. I think he’s feeling some pressure from his family to get married, his mum is incredibly religious and possibly could be the driving force behind it.

We spoke on the phone, he was saying his mum was wanting to see a picture of me, which is normal, I sent him a couple to send to her but he was asking for a forward facing passport style picture which I said no to due to security reasons, and that if she wants to see me she can call me, he agreed. He said he was looking to see if his employer could sponsor him, I said this would be a great idea because if he has this opportunity then he could under the skilled visa route, although difficult wouldn’t be impossible.

When he talks about all the places he will take me “when we get married” it makes me more drawn to him, he is a source of freedom for me, we have a lot in common, he wants to travel and the only way I can do that is if I have a husband and go with him.

Sometimes I think, what’s the point? It is almost as though us daughters are a liability, we belong to our fathers and later our husbands are our allocated guardians, our lives are governed and oversaw by men because they’re our protectors and have responsibility towards us, like keeping us sheltered, fed, clothed, warm. We have to be constantly chaperoned, our bodies objectified, our locations questioned. And If he hits me? Well, not much different to being a child, we got hit a lot.

Is this a joke? I'm from an ethnic minority and don't know of any family with such archaic practices.