Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NSPCC: Children under 12 shouldn't be home alone

84 replies

roses2 · 11/07/2023 22:09

https://www.theargus.co.uk/news/23646867.age-child-can-stay-home-alone-uk-nspcc-advises/

Seems a bit old to me. I started leaving DS home for 1-2 hours age 9. He's now 10 and has walked to school by himself, gone to the local Sainsbury and the park. All within a 10 minute walk. He'll be 11 when he starts secondary school and I fully expect him to get the tube to school by himself (I'll train him of course).

12 seems a bit old to me. I know every child is different but surely this advice just makes parents with capable children feel like they are bad parents?

NSPCC issues advice to parents thinking of leaving their kids alone this summer

The summer holidays can present a challenge for parents from cost of living to childcare. Here's the NSPCC advice if you're considering leaving…

https://www.theargus.co.uk/news/23646867.age-child-can-stay-home-alone-uk-nspcc-advises

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
superplumb · 15/07/2023 19:16

My son is 10 in Oct. No way would I leave him alone. He's way too immature. He still forgets to look at the road before crossing. I walked home from school alone at 9, started dinner, with my mum getting home at 5. Depends on the child.

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 15/07/2023 09:29

I'm lucky to have been able to keep my dc with me all day when they were younger as I work on our farm, but how do they expect employees to manage during the school holidays and random strike days. Once they are at senior school there is no way on earth most would go to day camps.

HorseyMel · 12/07/2023 20:26

Whatever you do, wherever you go, there is no shortage of government bodies and charities wanting to tell you what to do..............or else.............

I suppose if they can make out that there is loads of parental abuse going on, they can justify their big salaries and leased cars.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 12/07/2023 20:23

As others have pointed out there is little choice as childcare for 12 year olds is non existent in some areas, mine being one of them so unsure what they expect parents who need to work to do during the holidays of there is no childcare available and there is only so much AL you can take

lanthanum · 12/07/2023 19:10

Context is everything, and that's partly why there is no legal ruling on this.
There's clearly a difference between leaving a child for 10 minutes while you pop to the corner shop, and leaving them for an entire working day in the school holidays. I think 12 is a reasonable minimum for the latter (although some children aren't happy until a little older), and I think most of us work up to this gradually. If the NSPCC is asked this question, I think they have to stick to an answer which is reasonable for the "whole day" scenario, or they risk their answer being taken out of context.

CurlewKate · 12/07/2023 18:52

@MysteryBelle "CurfewKate" 🤣🤣

Sidking · 12/07/2023 10:24

OH and I had this discussion last week, eldest had a PD day so was home from school and OH had a GP appointment I needed to take him to. Eldest (10) didn't want to come and asked to stay home, OHs initial reaction was no while I thought about it a bit more then put forth the arguement that he'll be allowed to walk to and from school alone as of September, and we allow him out to play at the park down the road without worry. In my mind staying home was a lot safer than either of those scenarios (he is a gamer, he wasn't going to be getting into any trouble, he likely wouldn't move once he was settled into his game!)

We tested the smoke alarms and gave him a quick run through of what to do if there was something like a fire, and instructions not to open the door to anyone.

He was fine for the 90 mins we were gone

OMG12 · 12/07/2023 10:20

Neverinamonthofsundays · 11/07/2023 22:33

None of mine were alone for more than 15 mins at a time at 12 or under. I never understood others views on them being fine alone at such a young age as a house can burn down in 7 minutes. We are in Ireland so our kids do not start secondary school till 12-13 anyway but in their first year of secondary none of them were left alone for more than a quick tesco trip.

Eh??? What happens when both parents work and there’s no wrap around in secondary school.

If an 11 year old can’t manage to look after themselves for an hour or two without burning down the house because they tried to cook or didn’t know to get out the house , stick their fingers in a socket or to go to a neighbour in case of injury, how to call an ambulance etc, I would really wonder how they had been taught.

most kids round here walk themselves home from 10.

I wouldn’t leave a kid all day as they would likely be bored and lonely. But a few hours after school at 10-12 is fine. SEN notwithstanding

TeapotCollection · 12/07/2023 10:13

I’m happily child free but from a very big family and I agree this is going to vary enormously. I wouldn’t leave some of our extended family who are in their late teens alone!

SmartHome · 12/07/2023 10:13

I think it depends on the time period. I have 4 kids and they were all ok to be left alone for an hour or two occasionally while I went to the supermarket, say, by 9/10, but they all would have been upset/lonely if left all day while I was at work or in the evenings. I think 12+ is definitely about right for longer periods, or regularly.

By 14/15 they would barely notice ....

Natsku · 12/07/2023 10:09

When its saying extended periods and talking about the summer holidays I'd expect they mean they shouldn't be left all day every day during the summer holidays. That's not the ideal situation for under 12s so makes sense but if there's no childcare available what can parents do?

Tosire · 12/07/2023 09:36

I think 12 is a bit young to be left for a whole day during the summer holidays. I wouldn't leave a child under 14 for a whole day and even at 14 I'd rather not. Leaving for an hour or so, 12 seems reasonable. People are always asking what age is appropriate for this so they have issued guidelines suggesting no younger than 12. Fair enough.

StormShadow · 12/07/2023 09:35

Ponoka7 · 12/07/2023 08:46

It will be given as advice by children's centers and family support. If primary aged children are being left alone without good reason and the parents have been given this advice it can go on a CP/CIN plan for it to not happen. These aren't struggling working single parents that it will be used against. It's about primary children being protected.

I'm just not seeing how the NSPCC guidance is going to do anything in that situation that couldn't also happen without it. There obviously can be CIN without it after all. I agree it's unlikely to come up in instances where there isn't serious neglect, given the resource constraints SS operate under.

TolkiensFallow · 12/07/2023 09:24

I think this is also about leaving children responsible for other children. Yes an hour might be fine for a 10 year old but you do get some hopeless parents who then leave the 3 year old in the care of the 10 year old…and then the hour becomes a day and so on.

I remember a friend at school who had to stay off school if her younger siblings were unwell and look after them. She was about 11 and missed loads of school because of it.

Agapornis · 12/07/2023 09:20

Would be nice if the NSPCC started advocating for government-funded, well-run childcare.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 12/07/2023 08:54

It says under 12s shouldn’t be home alone for an extended period of time and that it should be assessed on a child by child basis. I read that as they think you can leave a 12 year old home for the day but probably not younger but that you could leave a younger one for a short period of time, presumably to build up to it being for a whole day. I don’t think you can go from never leaving them alone to leaving them for a whole day in one go.

Superdupes · 12/07/2023 08:54

Once they hit secondary school age surely getting to school on their own and staying home alone is pretty normal? Who's going to pay for child care for a secondary school age child? It might not be ideal them being home alone all day every day of the holidays though I guess but with the COL most people probably don't have much choice.

Catspyjamas17 · 12/07/2023 08:48

Sounds like you have it just right, OP.

gardendome · 12/07/2023 08:47

Oh FGS
I certainly wouldn't leave young kids and including young teens at home alone for hours during the holidays as that's neglectful.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 08:47

And grouping children together like that...6-12 year olds is just such nonsense. A six year old could be in year one at school and a 12 year old could be in year 8. Are they really saying that a year 8 child shouldn't be making their own way to school?

gardendome · 12/07/2023 08:46

I certainly wouldn't leave young kids and I concluded young teens in this home alone for hours during the holidays as that's neglectful.

I would certainly leave my particular dc at home for up to 1.5 hours if needed and have done so since they were 9.

I would certainly keep an extremely close eye on any internet and device activity whether they're home alone or not.

Teach them life skills, don't Molly coddle and apply common sense.

I'd absolutely hate to leave young dc by themselves for hours on end. Small chunks of time yes.

Equally 9+ year olds can walk to school and back provided it's not a complex route.

It's no use raising hapless offspring that can't handle basic things in life.

Ponoka7 · 12/07/2023 08:46

StormShadow · 12/07/2023 08:40

How would NSPCC guidelines be a tool for authorities to use in that situation?

It will be given as advice by children's centers and family support. If primary aged children are being left alone without good reason and the parents have been given this advice it can go on a CP/CIN plan for it to not happen. These aren't struggling working single parents that it will be used against. It's about primary children being protected.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 08:44

BumpyaDaisyevna · 12/07/2023 08:41

I think that's probably right.

I'd leave my 14 year old all day.

My y6 will be 12 in October. At present I'll leave him an hour or two and he walks home one day a week and is at home alone for an hour. (We speak on the phone). But if he has an inset day I arrange for him to go to my parents as it seems too long.

I guess it will change as he gets towards the end of y7

Well no because the guidance says that from age 6-12, children should not be walking to and from school alone.... therefore your 11 year old should not be doing that. I mean it's absolute nonsense but that's what they're saying.

MysteryBelle · 12/07/2023 08:42

CurlewKate · 12/07/2023 08:39

I think it's a good idea to have a guideline. It means that if children are being neglected or left alone in unsafe circumstances, the authorities have a tool to use to protect them. It's a bit like the rule that existed in the hall where I lived as a student. No male visitors after 11.00. We all knew that nothing would happen to us if we wanted a visitor to stay but the rule was there if we wanted a visitor to leave. Not sure if that makes sense- but I know what I mean!

CurfewKate

Ponoka7 · 12/07/2023 08:41

x2boys · 12/07/2023 08:22

Would that work though if a parent is negligent
Would they care what the NSPCC advises?

No but it stops the excuse that no-one around them told them that it's wrong, which then means that if something happens, the law around neglect can be used. Or if the police got involved, the guidance is there. It's that saying that was often used during Covid "the rules are for the obeyance of fools, and the guidance of wise men”.