Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think reading to pre school aged dc isn’t that important

113 replies

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:42

I was led to believe that reading was the most important thing (I love reading and my job involves writing in different styles for different audiences so I’m not anti reading). Dd1 would sit for hours looking at books. Dd2 would only engage in a book it it had pop ups or something tactile. As she got a bit older we tried introducing reading before bed and she wasn’t interested. By age 8 she saw reading as a punishment.

She’s currently predicted a 9 at gcse. Dd1 (the one who reads at every opportunity) is predicted an 8.

I’m not saying don’t read to dc but I’m saying, to anyone with young dc struggling to be the perfect mum… chill. Love them, have fun with them and let them be them.

OP posts:
Combusting · 11/07/2023 20:07

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 20:03

@LWTW i wish I could remember where dd2’s primary reports are because her teachers noted it. Why is it so hard to read a mum saying her dc hated being read to and you assume I’m lying. I have 3 dc and they are all very very different.

Hello.

you didn’t just post saying your DC hated reading.

you drew a causal relationship between reading and future attainment that absolutely defies evidence, and rigour, based on a sample of 1. My example Of 117 year old chain smoking Nan explains this clearly . People are quite rightly disputing your inference.

technotstarnotechstar · 11/07/2023 20:06

It's about spending time together. It helps early language development. It shows your child perspectives from lives different to their own, helping making them more open minded and empathetic from a young age by showing other people's experiences and thoughts.

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 20:06

We didn’t not read and then do nothing to fill that gap. We visited museums, went to the theatre from age 4, travelled. We found ways to engage Dd because all dc are different.

OP posts:
Scienceadvisory · 11/07/2023 20:05

But you did read to both your daughters when they were pre-school age so how can you say it's not important? Maybe if you hadn't read to your youngest when she was a toddler she wouldn't be predicted a 9 now, who knows?

CecilyP · 11/07/2023 20:05

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:58

Okay, I’m happy I’m wrong. Dd2 literally wouldn’t sit for reading. The picture being painted here seems to be lots of parents who had dc who loved it… I get it, that was my experience with dd1. I think we’ve been able to fill the gap with other activities but maybe dd is a fluke.

No it’s not a fluke. She liked books that involved some kind of activity. She built vocabulary by talking and listening. She’s obviously bright and had no difficulty learning to read at school. But the fiction for pleasure thing just wasn’t for her!

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 20:03

@LWTW i wish I could remember where dd2’s primary reports are because her teachers noted it. Why is it so hard to read a mum saying her dc hated being read to and you assume I’m lying. I have 3 dc and they are all very very different.

OP posts:
Wheredowe · 11/07/2023 20:03

It's not the end of the world if they refuse.

But it is important.

technotstarnotechstar · 11/07/2023 20:02

Getting a 9 at GCSE is not the sole reason reading to children early is recommended.

StefanosHill · 11/07/2023 20:02

Combusting · 11/07/2023 20:01

OP

It really shouldn’t be this hard to understand that an evidence base of numerous generations of population level data on attainment, enjoyment, and an array of benefits does not get even close to wiped out by your anecdote of 1.

it’s embarrassing really. Please think? It’s like saying “Me Nan never ate a single veg and smoked like a chimney and never got cancer and died happy ay 117, so… just don’t stress lol about vegetables or cigarettes”.

This

Combusting · 11/07/2023 20:01

OP

It really shouldn’t be this hard to understand that an evidence base of numerous generations of population level data on attainment, enjoyment, and an array of benefits does not get even close to wiped out by your anecdote of 1.

it’s embarrassing really. Please think? It’s like saying “Me Nan never ate a single veg and smoked like a chimney and never got cancer and died happy ay 117, so… just don’t stress lol about vegetables or cigarettes”.

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 20:01

@Blackbyrd you could have tried to explain that to dd2 when she was age 2-10 because she really didn’t see it that way. I’ve explained I did this with dd1 so I’m not anti reading… dd2 was and I stopped fighting it and stopped letting the peer pressure get to me and I’m happy I did. I have a confident, articulate daughter.

OP posts:
LWTW · 11/07/2023 20:01

Reading to children isn't just about learning to read. It exposes them to complex vocabulary, sentence structure and different styles if language. Audio books, comics, non-fiction books are all valid ways to enjoy reading and influence and improve children's writing too.

Reading aside- being able to sit and listen to a story from a young age is a great skill to develop in young children. As a teacher I am yet to meet a child who doesn't enjoy being read to.

BlissedOutCat · 11/07/2023 20:00

BlissedOutCat · 11/07/2023 19:46

YANVVVU

FFS
Fat fingers! YABVVVU

qbansopwt · 11/07/2023 20:00

Weird thread

YourNameGoesHere · 11/07/2023 19:59

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:58

Okay, I’m happy I’m wrong. Dd2 literally wouldn’t sit for reading. The picture being painted here seems to be lots of parents who had dc who loved it… I get it, that was my experience with dd1. I think we’ve been able to fill the gap with other activities but maybe dd is a fluke.

Bur you've said yourself she did sit and listen when it was a tactile book is it's not that she wouldn't engage it's just he had a preference to a certain type of book.

CecilyP · 11/07/2023 19:58

Yes being able to read is really important. Reading fiction for pleasure is a hobby like any other!

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:58

Okay, I’m happy I’m wrong. Dd2 literally wouldn’t sit for reading. The picture being painted here seems to be lots of parents who had dc who loved it… I get it, that was my experience with dd1. I think we’ve been able to fill the gap with other activities but maybe dd is a fluke.

OP posts:
Blackbyrd · 11/07/2023 19:57

Absolute rubbish. There is nothing nicer for a young child than to have the undivided attention of their parent and to enjoy a picture or story book together. It encourages a lifelong interest in learning, teaching a child how to look, listen and concentrate on even a basic story. There is always a suitable story format for every child

CecilyP · 11/07/2023 19:56

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 11/07/2023 19:47

I read to my dd from in the womb and so did my husband. As a result she grew up with that routine and a love of books

But many others don’t! Reading to a yet to be born child seems a bit extreme- like someone reading to you with your head underwater. However all children like a story and you can read more complex things to your own children than they’d be able to concentrate on at school or pre-school, so all good!

Read regularly to DS but he’s not much of a reader. Will take a book to relieve the boredom of a beach holiday but that’s about it!

RedLem0nade · 11/07/2023 19:56

I think it’s lovely for closeness and one-on-one time and winding down before sleep. I treasure being able to read to my children. I really do.

My DD2 isn’t as keen on me reading to her as DD1 is. She prefers reading to me! But I always make sure to read her a chapter of whatever the current “mummy” book is once she’s read me her little story book.

I think it’s so valuable in helping her understand new words, intonation and pronunciation. It also communicates the rhythm of speech and the flow of a story better than her reading to herself (she’s still young). There’s a music and a magic to being read to that allows children to stretch their imaginations too I think.

But mostly it’s nice to hunt out books that I know will spark her interest, and she has come to associate that little period of me reading to her with cuddles and calm.

I could go on (and on and on)- but reading to children is about so much more than their score in English exams years hence.

I know so much of parenting can be used as a stick to beat us with and I am very much of the “do what’s best for you and your family” school of parenting but I don’t think anyone can deny the value of reading to children.

RegainingTheWill2023 · 11/07/2023 19:56

It's pretty unusual to find a child who actively dislikes stories and books to some degree. You say yourself that your dd2 enjoyed tactile, activity books.
Hearing stories in the early years is a great way to support language development, social interaction, empathy etc. etc. The end goal isn't necessarily to produce an 'avid reader'.
It sounds like you got waylaid by this for dd2. I'm wondering how dd2 came to see reading as a punishment unless there was a focus on that skill rather than pleasure?
My dd has never read for pleasure but loved being read to and loves audiobooks. She's dyslexic so reading was a massive effort. But she gained immensely from the experiences of listening to stories and looking at books without any pressure to read.

TomatoSandwiches · 11/07/2023 19:55

YABU

Reading to children isn't the same as making them read, one of mine didn't want to sit and read but I memorised stories and poems to " read " to them at Bath time.

Reading to your child IS very important, you are wrong.

Needmorelego · 11/07/2023 19:54

Reading is important.
As in being able to read and understand what something says and means.
Reading stories isn’t necessarily vital.
Some people just don’t like stories/novels. Don’t want to read them, don’t want to listen to them.
What is more important to be able to read -
Danger Warning Signs ?
Legal Documents ?
Instructions on medications ?
Harry Potter ?
If a child doesn’t want to sit and listen to/read a story then in the big scheme of things it’s not massively important.

VivaVivaa · 11/07/2023 19:53

I appreciate the sentiment as I can’t get 3 yo DS sat down long enough to do bloody anything read a book and it weighs heavy on my conscience. But overall I think there is pretty strong evidence for the benefit of reading to little kids. I agree with your last paragraph about letting them be them, you definitely can’t force things like reading…but I think your title is wrong
i’m afraid.

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:53

@Freshair1 but it’s not quality time if your dc hates it! I loved reading with dd1 - lovely, special times. She will still snuggle in bed and read next to me while I read at the age of 16. Dd2 reads a bit now but not a huge amount. Her vocabulary is excellent, her SATs were all greater depth. She’s just not interested in reading for fun. She has other interests - plays 2 instruments and is suddenly very academic. You can provide enrichment in a way dc enjoy it without stressing about what they don’t enjoy.

OP posts: