Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think reading to pre school aged dc isn’t that important

113 replies

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:42

I was led to believe that reading was the most important thing (I love reading and my job involves writing in different styles for different audiences so I’m not anti reading). Dd1 would sit for hours looking at books. Dd2 would only engage in a book it it had pop ups or something tactile. As she got a bit older we tried introducing reading before bed and she wasn’t interested. By age 8 she saw reading as a punishment.

She’s currently predicted a 9 at gcse. Dd1 (the one who reads at every opportunity) is predicted an 8.

I’m not saying don’t read to dc but I’m saying, to anyone with young dc struggling to be the perfect mum… chill. Love them, have fun with them and let them be them.

OP posts:
ThePastKnocks · 11/07/2023 21:31

It's so important, for one to one time, to get them to wind down for sleep. Picking their own books to read and making up their own stories might have helped and definitely helps children's attention. I have a very active child, books are a useful tool.

It opens up areas of the brain that help them study, etc. GCSEs might have been fine but what about when they have to read out of choice in college and uni where it's not required but a choice to be in education? Many find that change difficult.

TheBitchOfTheVicar · 11/07/2023 21:21

@WonderingWanda do you have a link to that research please, it's perfect for a project I'm working on?

Wenfy · 11/07/2023 21:17

To be frank, GCSEs don’t require much reading. A child can get a 9 through being quick, a good memoriser, and able to apply what they’ve been taught by their teacher. Reading skills come into their own when they start needing to do it for their own research - so A Level (depending on subject) and degree level.

Superdupes · 11/07/2023 21:12

Yes but I'd guess your child is from a well off and well educated family, has inherited her parents intelligence, was spoken to and engaged with a lot as a child and has had a huge amount of opportunities that a child from a deprived back ground with poorly educated parents might not.

Apart from speaking to your child as much as possible and keeping them safe fed and happy I don't think there is much that has more value than reading to a child and listening to them read.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 11/07/2023 21:09

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:58

Okay, I’m happy I’m wrong. Dd2 literally wouldn’t sit for reading. The picture being painted here seems to be lots of parents who had dc who loved it… I get it, that was my experience with dd1. I think we’ve been able to fill the gap with other activities but maybe dd is a fluke.

My youngest son would grab the book and sit on it when he was about 3. Then he found one book he loved and it had to be read over and over. Just that one.
He learnt to read quickly and fluently but still wasn't interested in books.
Now late 20s, very good career. He owns just 5 books. I love reading and so does his sister. Other siblings can take or leave it. All different I suppose.

Isitthathardtobekind · 11/07/2023 21:07

This is extremely poor advice and goes against all research. Also confused as the title says thinking that reading ‘to’ a pre-schooler isn’t important, but then you go on to talk about not forcing children to read. These are two different things.

Absolutely read to pre school children- the impact is huge. Continue to read to them through school. If they really aren’t keen on reading themselves, they will benefit from someone reading aloud to them.

Soontobe60 · 11/07/2023 21:01

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:49

@Daisywishes yes, but forcing a dc to read who hates it is not good. Many people have dc who don’t like reading.

I’m not saying it’s not important, just not the single most important thing and if your dc hates it then you can support literacy without reading hundreds of books when little. Supporting imagination then reading coming in later.

Reading TO a child is not the same as making the child read to you though.
by sharing books with children from a very young age, it encourages all sorts of skills, not least spending quality time with someone they love - ie a parent. Listening to stories is how children internalise the skill of story writing, expands language, develops their imaginations and so much more.

OnSense · 11/07/2023 20:59

The posters saying is statistically insignificant are right but that doesn't matter as statistics don't usually tell the full story that's why any decent researchers will collect both numeric and qualitative data to analyse. What the OP says can be helpful and useful food for thought to some parents. Not all kids fit into the same mould. She has done right by her dc by being responsive and showing an interest in her dc. Generally the mother's level of education is a good predictor for success. Oh and keep them away from highly addictive games and programmes. Don't get a tablet, you'll mess up their eye sight and attention span.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 11/07/2023 20:58

*readers

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 11/07/2023 20:57

I think it is important, but probably not solely responsible for how well they’ll read at 16.

both mine liked being read to, but dd1 was very quick to pick up reading on primary and got a very high score at SATs. By y11 English lit was her weakest subject and she really didn’t enjoy it.
dd2 liked being read to but hated reading in primary. I don’t think she finished a book at all until she was probably about 11. Then at secondary she developed a love of reading and has been selected to join an advanced group where they work at A level level.

I read to them both the same as small kids. But isn’t reading to little kids more about language development, concentration skills, enjoying a quiet activity together etc than actually making them good reeders?

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/07/2023 20:52

I can't agree with this. I think the vast majority of children get some value out of being read to.

It won't necessarily mean they will go on to be professional novelists or even novel readers and it won't automatically correlate with GCSE/A'level results. But that doesn't mean there isn't a benefit.

It's not just about the material read, it's about the ritual, the time spent together talking, demonstrating an enjoyment of books. Some children will enjoy it more than others but I don't think its ever a waste of time.

OnSense · 11/07/2023 20:48

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:53

@Freshair1 but it’s not quality time if your dc hates it! I loved reading with dd1 - lovely, special times. She will still snuggle in bed and read next to me while I read at the age of 16. Dd2 reads a bit now but not a huge amount. Her vocabulary is excellent, her SATs were all greater depth. She’s just not interested in reading for fun. She has other interests - plays 2 instruments and is suddenly very academic. You can provide enrichment in a way dc enjoy it without stressing about what they don’t enjoy.

YANBU.

Your dds is doing great and you did right not forcing the issue and letting her chose what she is interested in. You don't have to justify yourself. It's clear that you are a loving, intelligent, educated and involved mum, which is giving your dc the best possible start.

I 100% agree that forcing books on someone who isn't too bothered creates a negative experience. We are also lucky to live in an era where you can get information by other means.

It's always a good call to worry less about the little difficulties they have.

You and your dds are doing great OP, well done!

TrustPenguins · 11/07/2023 20:46

TimeToRecover · 11/07/2023 20:39

Reading to your children and with them is really really important

100% agree

Grumpigal · 11/07/2023 20:43

JaninaDuszejko · 11/07/2023 19:44

I'm not sure that's a statistically significant sample.

🤣.

exactly - one anecdotal account does not balance off the actual evidence that reading with and to children is one of, if not the
most beneficial thing you can do for them (I mean outside of keeping them safe, clean and fed!)

I agree with your sentiment OP but we shouldn’t be telling parents “if your DC doesn’t want to do this important thing then just don’t stress about it bc it’ll all be fine and won’t matter long term” - because a lot of things will matter if you don’t do them

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 20:41

@Kitcaterpillar not the easiest thing if the dc throws a tantrum at the thought. In the same way a dc might hate the slide in the park because it’s high, dd2 had no desire to look at books. She generally destroyed them.

OP posts:
TimeToRecover · 11/07/2023 20:39

Reading to your children and with them is really really important

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 11/07/2023 20:38

Clickbait title that has very little to do with the OP's actual point that it doesn't matter what you do to nurture pre-schoolers, so long as you do nurture the little individuals.

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 20:38

@YourNameGoesHere okay, I didn’t explain fully. She’d lift flaps briefly but not engage in the story and saw reading as a punishment eg. Me: “oooh shall we choose a book to read?” Dd2 - lays on floor crying nooooo like I’d suggested the worst imaginable thing.

Summary - I had a toddler/primary age Dd who disliked reading and I felt like I was failing her due to pressure re the importance of reading but with hindsight I wish I hadn’t stressed it because there are other ways to give Dd enriched learning that suited her.

I have just had her school report and that triggered me thinking “why was I so worried?!”Society makes us stress and feel like failures when our dc don’t fit the guide book. Even on this thread people are saying “all dc love being read to!” Yet I know this isn’t true, but just my Dd.

OP posts:
WonderingWanda · 11/07/2023 20:30

Op it's part of a wider picture and the guidance to read with your children is especially important for children from a lower socio-economic background who also miss out on other opportunities and encouragment.

There are numerous studies which show the relationship between reading and educational outcomes. It's great that your dd has done well despite not wanting to read or being read. This is because she has been raised in a home where many of the other positive influences will likely have been in place, for example you mention music lessons, maybe you have a positive view of education or have a degree. When parents from poor backgrounds read with their children and view school and education positively children do well. When they don't and parents have a suspicious, negative or disrespecful attitude towards education children have worse outcomes. I'll post some screen grabs from a report by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation which illustrate what I am trying to explain.

Reading is pushed so hard because it's very easy for parents on a lower income to do. Reading to your child teaches them to love books so that when the struggle to begin to read they will have the resilience to persevere.

I teach a large number of teenagers who are taking gcse with reading ages still at primary level. They cannot access the exam questions and will have poor outcomes, please don't think that reading isn't important.

To think reading to pre school aged dc isn’t that important
To think reading to pre school aged dc isn’t that important
Kitcaterpillar · 11/07/2023 20:14

I think the research says it is actually the single most important thing you can do for your child in terms of educational attainment through the early/primary years.

It's also one of the absolute easiest things you can do to achieve 'perfect mum' status.

CecilyP · 11/07/2023 20:13

VivaVivaa · 11/07/2023 19:53

I appreciate the sentiment as I can’t get 3 yo DS sat down long enough to do bloody anything read a book and it weighs heavy on my conscience. But overall I think there is pretty strong evidence for the benefit of reading to little kids. I agree with your last paragraph about letting them be them, you definitely can’t force things like reading…but I think your title is wrong
i’m afraid.

There is absolutely no need to feel bad about it; he sound very active but will get there in his own time!

Lazydaisydaydream · 11/07/2023 20:11

Some children start school and they don’t even know which way to hold a book and turn the pages. They have no books at home, are never read to.
Sharing books with your children (in any form) has been shown to be massively beneficial to children’s learning and language development. So you don’t need to sit and read a story they aren’t interested in, but any sharing of books and stories helps!

noglow · 11/07/2023 20:09

It's not all about the gcse Grades though is it. If they can read they learn so much and it can bring them so much joy

YourNameGoesHere · 11/07/2023 20:08

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 20:06

We didn’t not read and then do nothing to fill that gap. We visited museums, went to the theatre from age 4, travelled. We found ways to engage Dd because all dc are different.

But you also read to her. You say she didn't like it as much as her siblings but you still read to her so it's silly think she's got to where she is without being read to.

If you hadn't actually read to her she may well have done just as well but evidence supports that she would probably not have done as well and that she did better because you did read to her.

CecilyP · 11/07/2023 20:08

Combusting · 11/07/2023 20:01

OP

It really shouldn’t be this hard to understand that an evidence base of numerous generations of population level data on attainment, enjoyment, and an array of benefits does not get even close to wiped out by your anecdote of 1.

it’s embarrassing really. Please think? It’s like saying “Me Nan never ate a single veg and smoked like a chimney and never got cancer and died happy ay 117, so… just don’t stress lol about vegetables or cigarettes”.

I disagree. It’s nothing like that.