Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think reading to pre school aged dc isn’t that important

113 replies

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:42

I was led to believe that reading was the most important thing (I love reading and my job involves writing in different styles for different audiences so I’m not anti reading). Dd1 would sit for hours looking at books. Dd2 would only engage in a book it it had pop ups or something tactile. As she got a bit older we tried introducing reading before bed and she wasn’t interested. By age 8 she saw reading as a punishment.

She’s currently predicted a 9 at gcse. Dd1 (the one who reads at every opportunity) is predicted an 8.

I’m not saying don’t read to dc but I’m saying, to anyone with young dc struggling to be the perfect mum… chill. Love them, have fun with them and let them be them.

OP posts:
Chocolateatanyio · 12/07/2023 14:46

DS2 doesn’t like to read and though I tried many many books his spelling and vocabulary is nowhere near as good as his brothers who loved reading . Neither of them are predicted high grades for English (6 I think ) ( they are very science/ maths kids ) . Would have been a whole lot worse if I’d not kept trying !

dizzydizzydizzy · 12/07/2023 14:44

DD1 got amazing GCSE and A Level results. I put down a lot of her success to love of reading. Obviously it's not the mountain to die on but IMHO it is worth putting effort into fostering a love of reading from birth onwards.

TeenLifeMum · 12/07/2023 14:42

Oh and as I said - I loved snuggling and reading with dd1 - totally get that, but it’s not the same with a dc who doesn’t want to. That idyllic picture becomes a source of upset because it was not achievable.

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 12/07/2023 14:40

@Esmereldapawpatrol I will never forget DD's teacher saying to me that teachers can just tell the children that have been read to from a young age.

That is the thing though, you wouldn’t look at dd1 and dd2 and be able to identify dd2 hasn’t read much. She has a photographic memory and absorbs information from museums, theatre performances and TV (horrible histories has featured heavily) but not books. I guess I should really say that reading skills come in many forms and it’s more important to know your dc and work to their interests than sit and read. Even then, many posters are saying I should have sat and read and that dd2 works have liked that… I tried, she didn’t, yet I’m not believed.

OP posts:
FunnysInLaJardin · 12/07/2023 14:03

YANBU

My 2 DS's were read to when they were little but have grown up to be fairly disinterested in reading.

There seems to be rather an obsession about reading at especially primary school and IMO there are so many other things for children to do if they are not particularly interested in reading.

Obviously they are able to read and DS1 passed both English papers at GCSE with DS2 predicted to do the same.

Esmereldapawpatrol · 12/07/2023 13:52

YABU.

I think it is well documented that being read to is as important as the child reading themselves. Sounds like you have done that even though your DC were interested in different types of books.

I will never forget DD's teacher saying to me that teachers can just tell the children that have been read to from a young age.

When DC were little snuggling up and reading was (and still is when we have time due to clubs) my favourite time of day. Both love to read and I feel it's such an important thing to nurture, it opens up whole new worlds.

YukoandHiro · 12/07/2023 13:42

It's incredibly important.

In fact most of a child's life chances are set for them in the first 1,000 days of life. Things like reading for widened vocabulary and understanding how language works is a huge part of that.

RegainingTheWill2023 · 12/07/2023 13:41

CecilyP · 12/07/2023 07:41

Most children enjoy all those things. OPs DD2 did not. OP doesn’t have to justify her post to say her DD has done really well academically despite this aversion. It might reassure some other parents with similar small children.

But the OP didn't make a reassuring post for parents of children who are like her dc2, she made a sweeping statement that reading to preschool dc isn't that important.
Which is both inaccurate and unhelpful.

hopsalong · 12/07/2023 07:50

I don't think that either of the activities you have described (looking at books for hours or only engaging with pop ups) has much to do with being READ TO, which is mostly an aural activity even with a picture book.

That's the part that's very important, I think. We have so many opportunities through screens to learn by looking and very few to learn through hearing. My DC find it far harder to memorise a short poem or lines for assembly than people of my generation did, and I think it's important to practise that. Not least because some of us get to the point in middle age where our eyesight is poor and audiobooks can be a great pleasure.

CecilyP · 12/07/2023 07:41

Most children enjoy all those things. OPs DD2 did not. OP doesn’t have to justify her post to say her DD has done really well academically despite this aversion. It might reassure some other parents with similar small children.

Windblownwife · 12/07/2023 07:35

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:42

I was led to believe that reading was the most important thing (I love reading and my job involves writing in different styles for different audiences so I’m not anti reading). Dd1 would sit for hours looking at books. Dd2 would only engage in a book it it had pop ups or something tactile. As she got a bit older we tried introducing reading before bed and she wasn’t interested. By age 8 she saw reading as a punishment.

She’s currently predicted a 9 at gcse. Dd1 (the one who reads at every opportunity) is predicted an 8.

I’m not saying don’t read to dc but I’m saying, to anyone with young dc struggling to be the perfect mum… chill. Love them, have fun with them and let them be them.

Ooh, YABVU.
Reading with your child not only supports reading skills and academic development, but also, and more importantly, promoting and ensuring emotional development through:
A sense of togetherness,
A sense of well-being and safety - which will be more accessible throughout life,
Benefitting from your closeness, your voice, your heartbeat,
Sharing and enjoying together,
Learning other skills and benefits alongside ie the joy of taking turns to say words or turn pages, to get things right, to notice and experience the benefits of finding rhythm in the reading, rhyming words and sounds, onomatopoeia, just the stories! Please don't encourage parents not to bother reading with their child! I'm sure your DC did benefit from any time you did spent reading with them. And your experience of their academic development as a whole is not enough to justify your post 😔

Freshair1 · 12/07/2023 07:00

Reading isn't just about books. I read 3 little pigs to mine and then followed it up with a masterpiece (I think) of a story which I made up. '3 little pigs and Kevin McCloud.' Just telling that story elicited responses about how it was similar to the previous book. Literacy isn't just physical books, it's the talking and the articulation of ideas. I am a teacher and nothing brings more satisfaction than a previously reluctant reader being engrossed by a new story.

booksandbrooks · 11/07/2023 23:07

One of my kids massively preferred reference , recipes and books at the preschool age. Let's of kids atleses and encyclopaedias and the like. Then joke books. Later it was ninjago magazines and pokemon books.

Reading with your kids doesn't have to mean stories and it can be active - following recipes and instructions. Looking at pictures in atlases. Let's face it Biff, Chip and Kipper are pretty dull, although they're are better kids books available these days.

bridgetjonesmassivepants · 11/07/2023 22:21

Don't often post on here but this has made me really angry. The most important thing that you can do for your child's education (assuming a stable, loving home) is to read to your child and to have them read to you. It's so basic. The more your child reads the cleverer they are likely to be. The more words they are exposed to the better their vocab.

Why wouldn't you read? Why wouldn't you want to widen your child's options? Probably because you just can't be arsed to read to them.

TheMoth · 11/07/2023 22:17

Both my parents read to me when I was v little. My grandfather,a man who worked physical jobs am his life, used to make up stories for us. My dad, who wasn't that interested in parenting on the whole, went through a phase of bringing home books after work for us. Kids' books- Wombkes or thomas t tank etc.
My gran used to go to the library with a bag full of books.
My dad used to turn the telly off to read- which meant we couldn't watch the telly either.
Mum used to read anything and everything.

We grew up in a culture of reading and talking about books- even just a 'ey, this book is bloody brilliant' or 'they're making a film out of x'.

I read to mine, or made up stories, for as long as we could all tolerate it for. Even when all I wanted to do was sit silently, in the dark, or i knew all my work was waiting for me. I sang quite often too. They remember bits, but mainly sitting all together in the big bed, with a book.

I had 1 reader and one not so. Currently neither reads, but their vocab, writing style and general knowledge is good and maybe they'll come back to it. They see me reading and going to the library. Dh occasionally. But I think a world of instant gratification makes it harder to develop the stamina to read. Think I was 35 before I gave myself permission NOT to finish a book.

Agree with a pp who says you can get by at gcse even as a non reader. But you can tell the difference at A level.

Coleslawclara · 11/07/2023 22:05

Possibly the most ill informed OP I’ve ever read on here. Actually finding it hard to believe this isn’t some GF having a laugh 🙄

Blamethecat57 · 11/07/2023 22:01

I read to all 3 of mine,as did their Dad.
The thing that I really think improves and inspires is seeing a parent reading.
Mine get told to leave me alone.. need to finish this chapter.
Don't worry they are all old enough to cope. But it's been in their lives. Mum reads. And enjoys it.

Kiwiandstrawberries · 11/07/2023 21:59

I just read books with my three and the youngest just wasn’t interested. He is now earning a huge amount as a a graduate and his vocabulary is eye watering! I am well educated but I genuinely have to google some of his words!!

Newuser75 · 11/07/2023 21:53

I recently read something that had the average amount of words a preschooler knew if they weren't read to at all, were read one book a day, two books a day, up to give books a day. The difference in the amount of words was amazing.

My 4 year old has been read to daily since birth. We have been told he has a great vocabulary for his age.

My 10 year old we still read to now. He enjoys it and so do we.

I don't think it's all about making them
Intelligent or good at reading although I'm sure it helps. Reading to a child opens up new worlds in their imagination, gives them a place to escape to. Teaches them about new topics and emotions. Makes them
See things from different peoples perspective. In my opinion it's essential!!

xyz111 · 11/07/2023 21:51

I read to my son from when he was a baby and we read every single night (he's nearly 6). He loves it and I hope he continues to read when he's older

Bimblesalong · 11/07/2023 21:50

Reading to preschool and school aged children is essential for language development and the development of comprehension skills. It’s one of the foundations of learning. Good vocabulary development is based on a wide exposure to different genres, with children also learning to understand the rhythms and structures of language.

The new govt reading paper is out today and this is a key tenet, with an emphasis on story telling and reading to children in school as well as at home. They need the foundations to take off and you will be nurturing their love of stories, facts and language by reading to them.

A sound vocabulary is a good predictor of academic success too.

BeverlyHa · 11/07/2023 21:40

Storytelling is the magic of life and how we really are on the inside of us....at deepest level. All we learn is through words. My paternal grandma told me a story about a magic book with very old, almost burned edges which survived a fire few generations down the line and she has it hidden in her house. She would say that each story she is telling me and fairy tale comes from this book. This created in me a life long journey of hungering to read, write, create and use my imagination which helped me on so many levels .....you decide

Samlewis96 · 11/07/2023 21:40

TeenLifeMum · 11/07/2023 19:49

@Daisywishes yes, but forcing a dc to read who hates it is not good. Many people have dc who don’t like reading.

I’m not saying it’s not important, just not the single most important thing and if your dc hates it then you can support literacy without reading hundreds of books when little. Supporting imagination then reading coming in later.

But you can read TO them