Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Internal job applicants grrr....

55 replies

NameChange245 · 11/07/2023 16:05

I'm in a job where, to make the leap to the next pay band is hard as 1. There a few posts nationally, and 2. Within my own organisation the 2 people in this role are not planning to leave any time in the next 10 years (and even if they were, there are others on my pay grade who'd go for the job and may get it ahead of me).

I have applied for jobs in this higher band elsewhere I the country 3 times in the last 3 years (that's how often they come up). The last two times the job went to an internal candidate. The most recent interview (last week) I got the distinct feeling an internal candidate had already been picked. I am waiting to hear if I have got the job but am 95% sure I haven't and an internal candidate has been safely secured the job since before my interview

AIBU to hate the fact that jobs who have already been ear marked for someone often have to been advertised externally? It's a waste of everyone's bloody time and money. I bought new clothes for the interview, wasted time preparing, travelled quite far (so had to take the whole day off for the interview). Not to mention the emotional toil (I loved the job spec, the panel, the role, everything! I realllly wanted this job!! and had the skills and experience)

I have been on the other foot as an interviewer, where I have a great employee wanting to step up, but have to go to the faff of advertising and interviewing just to select the candidate I had in mind all along. It's unfair on the external applicants and a big waste of time for them and me. It is pointless.

I work in the public sector and it worries me how much money is wasted needlessly advertising posts externally which are unlikely to go to an external.

Having been on both sides of the coin here, I just find that I hate the process so much! Why can't we have a process of promotion - so if someone is doing well we can step them up to the new pay band without the need to advertise and the person have to be interviewed against external applicants? It would save so much time and money, not to mention that it would mean when a job is advertised externally, external candidates do actually stand a chance.

Grrr... rant over!

OP posts:
SadKendall · 11/07/2023 16:25

Nordicrain · 11/07/2023 16:12

We have to advertise for all jobs - whether we've already found a candidate (internal or external) or not. It's company policy. We wouldn't though interview anyone else for it,that would be a waste of everyone's time.

Same. I completely agree it's shit op.

We have to advertise even if we're 99% sure we know who we would like to give the job to internally. And of course the internal candidate score as higher on interview on team fit/experience of systems/experience of process etc, because they've already been working along side us. I hate wasting externals time.

But we don't have a choice, it's company policy, even if it's wasting our time and the external candidates time.

We've asked to bypass the interviews on a few occasions as we already have our internal candidate we want to give it to, but we're not allowed to skip the process.

Wenfy · 11/07/2023 16:24

Bank of England did this to me. They already had the manager’s daughter in mind for a role (i know this as I met the daughter and the stupid girl admitted it during lunch). Having met the other candidates in the assessment stage I knew I was the best candidate. Then at the last stage of the interview process the manager (whose daughter it was) basically tried to question my experience for the role, then when that failed started cracking jokes about my wedding ring. It was so unprofessional it was a joke. I made a formal complaint but nothing was done with it.

KeepingMySpreadsheetUpToDate · 11/07/2023 16:17

omg. had exact same with BP. even went as far as getting me to pick a company car. was 100 years ago but never forgot the experience. apparantly they were using threat of me ie the external person to internal person re salary. @Inthesamesinkingboat

Nordicrain · 11/07/2023 16:12

We have to advertise for all jobs - whether we've already found a candidate (internal or external) or not. It's company policy. We wouldn't though interview anyone else for it,that would be a waste of everyone's time.

Inthesamesinkingboat · 11/07/2023 16:10

I had this with BP, saw my dream job, booked a hotel room the night before the interview took time off work. Was told I was their preferred candidate but they were giving it to an internal candidate as they already had established networks. I was livid. It was a colossal waste of time and money. They already had a candidate in mind- so much so that they wouldn’t even consider a better hire….

Swipe left for the next trending thread