Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for not wanting dad to take baby away

212 replies

Mama6x · 10/07/2023 22:10

My baby is 6 months old, breastfed and she's had a very difficult time we almost lost her at birth due to group b strep, seizures, sepsis and a stroke. My partner wants to take her away to go and stay with his Mums almost 2hrs away for about 4 days. I've said I am not ready to be apart from her yet and plus we are still breastfeeding. He told me I can just pump and he will give her formula. She's very attached to me needless to say and I am to her as I nearly lost her and suffered with PND which made me incredibly protective of her. I am still battling PND and I cannot imagine being apart from her. My partner has told me I am being selfish and unfair that I won't let him take baby to his Mums for days. I suggested he go and pick his mum up and she's welcome to stay here for a few days but he said no she won't want to do that. I tried to explain we are still breastfeeding, she won't want to be apart from me and it's not fair to dictate to me when I have to be away from my baby. He said she's 6 months old she's plenty old enough to be away from me and whether I like it or not he's taking her. I will do everything in my power to stop him taking her as I am NOT ready and I won't be for a while. We have a 2 year old son and he forced me to be apart from him before I was ready and took him to his Mums for 10 days it was the hardest 10 days of my life! I am not prepared to go through it again. I don't think I'm being unfair? Am I? I don't think my baby would want to be away from her mama yet as I am her main source of comfort, she only settles for me! He says I'm dictating and controlling what he does with her but if anything he's dictating to me because he says I don't have a choice and he WILL be taking her whether I'm ready or not. I feel so sad and I can't fathom being apart from her yet!

OP posts:
Unicorn34 · 11/07/2023 21:27

It's soon the school holidays. Either you all go or no-one does. This will bide you some time to get your ducks in a row. He isn't even thinking about your baby's needs, just his own. Sending a hug and support x

Acornsoup · 11/07/2023 20:58

Mooshamoo · 11/07/2023 08:13

The only thing I would like to add is- mums often think that they are more important to their baby than anyone else. And they think that the baby should be with them all time
.they feel like they own the baby.

Babies are human beings who benefit from seeing everyone.

When I was growing up my gran and my dad were equally important to me as my mum was. I didn't see my mum as being worth more than my gran or my dad.

I loved spending time with my granny.

Let your baby see other people.

That's because 'mums' care about what is best for the baby. What benefit do you think a six month old baby will get from being separate from DM for 4 days?

Separation anxiety, issues with bottle feeds, a parent that does not consider it's needs and a stranger. Sure that sounds ideal don't know why all the 'mums' don't do it. Don't event get me started on switching from breast to bottle and how that could go for 'Mum' or baby.

I hope you meant your advice kindly?

Mama6x · 11/07/2023 20:54

This has been asked a few times but yes he is on babys birth certificate. He has booked time off work to go and stay at his mums from this friday until next wednesday. He is taking our 2.5 year old with him and even that i am sad about because 5 days is such a long time. He gets 28 days holiday from work per year which resets in january. Hes now completely used up all of his 28 days holiday just going to stay at his mums. He usually goes alone for 1 week at a time while i stay home with the kids. Hes got no holiday left for the summer which kind of speaks volumes how valuable family time actually is to him. It seems all he cares about is himself and his mother. Im just so sad. I havent been able to eat properly because of the anxiety of the threats hes made about taking baby away

OP posts:
Beezknees · 11/07/2023 20:53

towriteyoumustlive · 11/07/2023 20:42

I would not be in a relationship with someone like that...

I'll no doubt get flamed for this but men are NOT equal parents in the first year of a baby's life. A mother will always have a much stronger bond due to carrying the baby and giving birth to it, then breastfeeding. It's an emotional attachment that cannot be undone.

I'm not saying men don't have any emotional attachment. It's just not the same at the beginning . A dads bond with the kids grows with age as kids spend time with them.

There is no way you should be made to be separated for 4 days from a breastfed baby. That's ridiculous.

I agree.

CherryGenoa · 11/07/2023 20:52

Goodness, I am glad to read that you are contacting your HV for advice. It’s abuse. Please also reach out to a friend or family member you can trust for support if you can.

Beezknees · 11/07/2023 20:50

Mooshamoo · 11/07/2023 08:13

The only thing I would like to add is- mums often think that they are more important to their baby than anyone else. And they think that the baby should be with them all time
.they feel like they own the baby.

Babies are human beings who benefit from seeing everyone.

When I was growing up my gran and my dad were equally important to me as my mum was. I didn't see my mum as being worth more than my gran or my dad.

I loved spending time with my granny.

Let your baby see other people.

No. At 6 months old, a baby only needs their primary caregiver. And if granny wants to see the baby, she can come to the house to visit.

Acornsoup · 11/07/2023 20:47

Are you married and is he on the birth certificate?

Chestnutlover · 11/07/2023 20:44

I won’t be parted from my baby for longer than a couple of hours

Chestnutlover · 11/07/2023 20:43

Nope

towriteyoumustlive · 11/07/2023 20:42

I would not be in a relationship with someone like that...

I'll no doubt get flamed for this but men are NOT equal parents in the first year of a baby's life. A mother will always have a much stronger bond due to carrying the baby and giving birth to it, then breastfeeding. It's an emotional attachment that cannot be undone.

I'm not saying men don't have any emotional attachment. It's just not the same at the beginning . A dads bond with the kids grows with age as kids spend time with them.

There is no way you should be made to be separated for 4 days from a breastfed baby. That's ridiculous.

Acornsoup · 11/07/2023 20:42

Talk to you doctor as well as the HV about the domestic abuse. You can get help, they can help organise counselling to help with your mood and recognising the abuse. They will put it on your GP record which may be important going forward.

Given your current PND, his threats and that you have offered a solution to have his DM visit you he is being completely unreasonable. Why can't she come to you? Why can she wait until you are recovered from PND?

If he does take your baby without your consent personally I would end the relationship because he has no respect for you or what is best for the baby. This is just the start. Good luck op Daffodil

nocoolnamesleft · 11/07/2023 20:32

Bloody hell. he's deliberately trying to undermine your breastfeeding? He clearly doesn't give a flying fuck about the needs of your baby. Do you have anyone safe in real life that you can talk to?

PinkyFlamingo · 11/07/2023 19:38

Of course yanbu. But if he carries out his threat how can you physically stop him? Scary stuff.

aloris · 11/07/2023 19:28

"When I was growing up my gran and my dad were equally important to me as my mum was. I didn't see my mum as being worth more than my gran or my dad."

Whatever you may have perceived, it is almost certain that you needed your mother more than your grandmother. If your grandmother attended as much to your needs as your mother did, that would be a rather unusual situation, albeit not unheard of. Lots of kids do not appreciate, until they are separated from their mother or become an adult, how much of their survival and wellbeing depends on the invisible and unappreciated work that mothering entails.

MaPaSpa · 11/07/2023 19:27

Mama6x · 10/07/2023 22:18

I just wanted to add that I couldn't go with him as I have older children from a previous relationship that I need to be here for due to schools etc x

And they can’t stay with their father for a few days ? I don’t think he should dictate but I can’t imagine you would let him tell you, that you can’t take your baby away?

Grumpigal · 11/07/2023 19:25

He sounds like a prize A wanker. I really don’t know what to suggest because if he has parental rights then you can’t ring the police if he takes her. She is his child after all.

I absolutely agree he should not be taking her and he absolutely should not be making threats about it either. He honestly sounds abusive.

I actually think the only way you might be able to stop this is for you to either leave or instigate him leaving - not sure how possible thst is for you? But as others have said, if you leave and then say “go to court for access” he won’t get over nighters.

Hope your health worker can work out how to tackle this and I hope you can find a way to get out of this relationship.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 11/07/2023 19:25

Is he on the birth certificate and does he have parental rights.

aloris · 11/07/2023 19:24

Well, for the sake of argument, let's start from the assumption that he's an equal parent. That doesn't necessarily give him the right to force you to wean your baby off of breastmilk. As an equal parent, you have an equal say as him. By him removing the baby for 4 days he would essentially be dictating that you wean the baby , thus saying that he is MORE her parent than you are. Since (for the purposes of giving his position a fair hearing), you are equal parents, his argument doesn't work. Under the idea that you are equal parents, the current situation is the default and should continue as such. In other words, breastfeeding from the breast should continue until you BOTH agree it is ok to wean the baby off of breastfeeding. His sole say is insufficient since, as equal parents, your buy-in would also be needed.

Same idea for taking your baby away for 4 days. If you are equal parents: he says he can take the baby, you say he cannot. What gives him the right to overrule you? Since you are equal parents, he cannot overrule you, as your wishes have equal weight as his. In other words, there's no natural right for him to go against your wishes and remove your baby from your joint household for any length of time. Again, the default situation here would be that the baby remain in the household with you both.

[Also, pumped milk will not hold the baby over for 4 days and your milk supply will be greatly affected by the end of that period. You'll also suffer great discomfort from not having baby to the breast for 4 days and it puts you at risk of mastitis.

Wheredowe · 11/07/2023 19:18

Mooshamoo · 11/07/2023 08:13

The only thing I would like to add is- mums often think that they are more important to their baby than anyone else. And they think that the baby should be with them all time
.they feel like they own the baby.

Babies are human beings who benefit from seeing everyone.

When I was growing up my gran and my dad were equally important to me as my mum was. I didn't see my mum as being worth more than my gran or my dad.

I loved spending time with my granny.

Let your baby see other people.

This is bollocks, respectfully.

FictionalCharacter · 11/07/2023 19:16

Mama6x · 11/07/2023 19:01

Thank you all so much for taking the time to comment. Its really helped me and there have been some hard pills to swallow. I think the people who said they think he is trying to stop the breastfeeding and have her on formula are bang on. He has never been very supportive of me breastfeeding. I made it very clear from the get go I was going to breastfeed as I have done with all my other children too. He still went ahead and bought loads of bottles, electric steriliser during my pregnancy and bulk bought tubs of formula after we came home from the hospital. Whenever she'd grumble for a feed he would say "i'll make her a bottle" and id say why? Im feeding her? He still does it. Says he will make her a bottle when I am literally feeding her. Hes also said she doesnt get enough from me even though her weight gain has been consistently amazing. So yes i think part of taking her away would be to try and sabotage breastfeeding too

That's what he's doing then. And his mother plans to help him do it. Despicable.

Wheredowe · 11/07/2023 19:16

This man sounds like an abusive git. If you separated, you would not have to give him overnights at this stage. I would happily lock the door and call the police if he doesn't leave for his mother's house without the baby, should it come to a situation where he's trying to take him/her.

You really need out of this.

Ghostgirl77 · 11/07/2023 19:10

YADNBU and he is not your “partner” if he is behaving like this with no respect for your feelings. He sounds very controlling and is probably jealous of the bond you have with the baby through breastfeeding as he is having to play second fiddle.

Mama6x · 11/07/2023 19:01

Thank you all so much for taking the time to comment. Its really helped me and there have been some hard pills to swallow. I think the people who said they think he is trying to stop the breastfeeding and have her on formula are bang on. He has never been very supportive of me breastfeeding. I made it very clear from the get go I was going to breastfeed as I have done with all my other children too. He still went ahead and bought loads of bottles, electric steriliser during my pregnancy and bulk bought tubs of formula after we came home from the hospital. Whenever she'd grumble for a feed he would say "i'll make her a bottle" and id say why? Im feeding her? He still does it. Says he will make her a bottle when I am literally feeding her. Hes also said she doesnt get enough from me even though her weight gain has been consistently amazing. So yes i think part of taking her away would be to try and sabotage breastfeeding too

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 11/07/2023 12:41

Mooshamoo · 11/07/2023 08:13

The only thing I would like to add is- mums often think that they are more important to their baby than anyone else. And they think that the baby should be with them all time
.they feel like they own the baby.

Babies are human beings who benefit from seeing everyone.

When I was growing up my gran and my dad were equally important to me as my mum was. I didn't see my mum as being worth more than my gran or my dad.

I loved spending time with my granny.

Let your baby see other people.

You clearly know nothing about breastfeeding. An EBF baby will not just happily take a bottle of formula. It will become distressed, hungry and thirsty.

Your opinion here is completely unhelpful and irrelevant.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 11/07/2023 12:38

This is horrific! No way should a baby be taken off its mother in this way. Please speak to the HV and get this stopped. Dreadful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread