Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For regretting my wedding?

111 replies

Weddingregret · 10/07/2023 22:01

I don’t want to go too into detail as it could be outing.

My DH and I have been married for 6 years. We got married in a registry office, went for a meal and then a few of us went for a couple of drinks. Then we had a small honeymoon in the UK with our child.

Neither of us got to wear what we wanted (he wanted a kilt, but wore a suit and I got a secondhand dress from a vintage store). I didn’t even get my hair and makeup done properly, everything was rushed on the day and the person I hired to do my makeup was late and messed it up and I ended up with no time left to do my hair.

We did really want to get married because we wanted the marriage not the wedding, but now I feel like I regret not getting to experience a lot of these traditional/cliche things, such as getting to choose the cake, have a first dance, make speeches etc.
We also wanted to write our own vows but then decided to leave it as it was only a small wedding.

I feel sad sometimes that we didn’t have that. We have more income now and I keep wondering about some type of do over/vow renewal. I know these are frowned upon and people presume someone’s cheated etc. But I keep thinking that both our children could be there now, and we could have a proper honeymoon, write some vows and so on…

Am I being selfish? If not, any suggestions what we could do?

YABU - You’re being selfish, grow up and be happy with what you did.

YANBU - It’s normal to have regrets.

OP posts:
Polis · 11/07/2023 11:06

If you want to waste money on a fancy party that’s your choice,

If it gives her what she wants, it isn’t a waste of money.

FuckTheLemonsandBail · 11/07/2023 11:01

GwinCoch · 11/07/2023 10:57

I was about to say that we don’t all get married under a religious ceremony, I got married in 2005 and it wasn’t religious wording so it’s not a new concept!

So much judgement on vow renewal here - I have been to two and they were way markers - one was 25 years and the other was 40 - nothing to do with infidelity, just a redeclaration. Wouldn’t have occurred to me that anyone would be tutting and projecting their own narrative on to proceedings. People are gross sometimes.

I don't think people are tutting about vow renewals in general, just pointing out the regardless of what you say as the couple it's such an established thing to renew vows after an infidelity some people WILL absolutely suspect it.

OP might not be bothered by that suspicion at all but it's a bit naïve to pretend it isn't a thing so better that she's aware.

ProperChocolate · 11/07/2023 11:01

I didn’t know vow renewals were associated with cheating!

I know only one couple who've renewed their vows and it was because he cheated. Therefore vows were broken, remedy is to retake vows. All fixed.
Maybe.

FuckTheLemonsandBail · 11/07/2023 10:59

ButImNotOldEnough · 11/07/2023 10:51

@FuckTheLemonsandBail you realise not all vows are made religiously right? You also realise your inability to see that vow renewal does not equal cheating is rather narrow minded. The tone of your post comes across as furious that someone would differ in opinion to you and that says a lot more about you than the PP you’re replying to.

You realise that non-religious vows often contain promises to trust/respect the other person, which many people feel is betrayed during infidelity?

You also realise that your inability to see that vow renewal is commonly seen as in response to infidelity (not always, but commonly, see thread) doesn't negate that being true?

The tone of your post comes across as angry that someone would respond to an opinion with a different opinion and that says a lot more about you than me tbh 🤗

GwinCoch · 11/07/2023 10:57

ButImNotOldEnough · 11/07/2023 10:51

@FuckTheLemonsandBail you realise not all vows are made religiously right? You also realise your inability to see that vow renewal does not equal cheating is rather narrow minded. The tone of your post comes across as furious that someone would differ in opinion to you and that says a lot more about you than the PP you’re replying to.

I was about to say that we don’t all get married under a religious ceremony, I got married in 2005 and it wasn’t religious wording so it’s not a new concept!

So much judgement on vow renewal here - I have been to two and they were way markers - one was 25 years and the other was 40 - nothing to do with infidelity, just a redeclaration. Wouldn’t have occurred to me that anyone would be tutting and projecting their own narrative on to proceedings. People are gross sometimes.

Whichwaytooo · 11/07/2023 10:57

To be honest, I had the big expensive wedding with all the trimmings, and I regret the money spent now.
The lead in was so stressful and the day went so quickly. My £££ dress has been in the loft for 12 years. I keep thinking that it could have significantly reduced the mortgage or been a deposit in due course for the DC.
I think yours sounds lovely.
Why not have an anniversary celebration if you’d like a party and speeches?

BarrelOfOtters · 11/07/2023 10:53

If you fancy a party - have a party. And if you want a vow renewal have that too. Buy a dress, have a posh night away - have a day about you. Why not?

ButImNotOldEnough · 11/07/2023 10:51

@FuckTheLemonsandBail you realise not all vows are made religiously right? You also realise your inability to see that vow renewal does not equal cheating is rather narrow minded. The tone of your post comes across as furious that someone would differ in opinion to you and that says a lot more about you than the PP you’re replying to.

ButImNotOldEnough · 11/07/2023 10:49

If you want to waste money on a fancy party that’s your choice, but essentially that’s what a wedding/vow renewal is. Never heard of a vow renewal meaning cheating before - my grandparents did this on one of their big wedding anniversaries (think it was the 50 years one)

FuckTheLemonsandBail · 11/07/2023 10:34

HappyBinosaur · 11/07/2023 09:16

and yes, people might suspect infidelity

this sentence sums up my first post about how cross and sad this attitude makes me.

How sad and cynical that you’d assume this, especially about people you know and love. Particularly if they offer another reason.

I am so please my role exposes me to a completely different side to both weddings and vow renewals than the ones I read about on MN.

It's not really an MN thing to associate renewals with infidelity, it's a society thing. Ask 50 people on the street and I guarantee if they've heard of the idea of a renewal the vast majority will know that it tends to be something couples do after cheating.

As a vicar you clearly meet many people doing renewals so your view is a little biased in that case, you see loads of them so clearly a proportion will be couples who are doing it for reasons other than infidelity, but the average person who doesn't deliver ceremonies definitely thinks that.

Think about it logically, as a vicar (if you genuinely are one): when you do a marriage ceremony, do the vows have a built in expiration date? No. They're usually explicitly 'til death do us part', that's the whole point of a vow, it's permanent unless someone dies or you go through legal dissolution. So there's no reason to 'renew' something that is permanent by default. It doesn't make any sense... unless the vow/promise was broken. Then you make it again at a renewal.

If you are a vicar I'm quite frankly saddened by your judgment towards other people's views (and the dominant view, in society not just on MN) about vow renewals. If it makes you 'cross' that there's a wider interpretation of them than yours that says something about you tbh.

ChristmasCwtch · 11/07/2023 09:46

Over the years we’ve had big, catered, free bar birthday and Christmas parties and an extravagant wedding. With hindsight (and age), it really was all a big waste of money.

I’ve now stopping hosting these types of events after covid. Very few people do similar, so now we have smaller gatherings with friends who reciprocate in terms of hospitality.

I do understand feeling wedding disappointment though. I got talked into a particular style of dress (elegant, silk, plain). It was nice, but totally different to the big, poofy, sparkly dress I wish I’d had. I also forgot to order a wedding cake. No idea how 🤦🏼‍♀️🙈🤪

Peony654 · 11/07/2023 09:45

I didn’t know vow renewals were associated with cheating!
why not have a milestone wedding anniversary party with a vow renewal, speeches etc? Sounds like you had the wedding you could at the time, and most important it was about being married.

TheModHatter · 11/07/2023 09:44

Have a 10 year Anniversary celebration?

Prettypaisleyslippers · 11/07/2023 09:40

Choose a date, big birthday or 10th anniversary, book a venue, have a party. If you want to wear a wedding dress then maybe consider taking the kids to an Indian Ocean beach and do a sunset vow renewal, then the party on your return?

snufkinhat · 11/07/2023 09:25

Aprilx · 11/07/2023 07:46

I think you should accept that you made the best decision at the time. But now it feels like you are trying to go back in time, but whatever you do, it is not going to feel like the wedding you wish you had, mainly because most people will know it is not a wedding, including you and some may even be slightly bemused as to what is expected.

At this point, I would just wait and do a big tenth anniversary party,

This. I don't think you should try and do your wedding again, you've been married for 6 years and no matter what you do, the feeling will not be quite the same and your guests know it's not your wedding.

That doesn't mean you can't have an amazing party celebrating your marriage though - just do it in a more genuine way. A big anniversary party is a lovely idea and you can all dress up and celebrate your years together.

BonusHole · 11/07/2023 09:22

I got married in a registry office, just two witnesses, I wore a cream skirt suit that I bought off the market for £15. Afterwards we just went home as I had a 3 month old baby that my mother was looking after, got home, had a few sandwiches and cake and that was it, normal life resumed. I did not want a wedding, just wanted to be married. I have never even thought about renewing vows or anything, as mentioned they are meant to last forever. I can hardly remember the day now to be honest, I was 19 years old and it was over 36 years ago now! 😂

SquashPenguin · 11/07/2023 09:19

I never knew people thought that about vow renewals, I thought people just had them as excuse for a big piss up 😆

Big weddings IMO are a waste of money. You put all that effort into planning everything and on the day you remember none of it. I’m speaking from experience and then I got divorced a year later. Genuinely no one cares about centre pieces/ favours/ coat hangers with “bridesmaid” scrawled on it. The best weddings are the one where the couple enjoy themselves. It’s not about putting on a show for everyone else.

Go for a renewal if it gives you the chance for another party, nothing wrong with that!

HappyBinosaur · 11/07/2023 09:16

and yes, people might suspect infidelity

this sentence sums up my first post about how cross and sad this attitude makes me.

How sad and cynical that you’d assume this, especially about people you know and love. Particularly if they offer another reason.

I am so please my role exposes me to a completely different side to both weddings and vow renewals than the ones I read about on MN.

ProperChocolate · 11/07/2023 09:14

My wedding was pretty much like yours OP. Register office, dress I already had.
Dinner for 12 friends and relatives in a local restaurant. Cost barely anything.

I don't regret it at all because it's what I wanted and would still want.

HappyBinosaur · 11/07/2023 09:13

People aren’t going to be excited for a vow renewal, they aren’t going to make the effort and they don’t really mean anything.

this isn’t true for all people and your opinion that they don’t mean anything is entirely subjective (and wrong in my experience as someone who conducts these sorts of services).

TheBellsToll · 11/07/2023 09:11

Have a big anniversary party. Get glammed up.

I am of the ‘vow renewals are daft’ camp - they don’t expire and need renewing, and yes, people might suspect infidelity.

HappyBinosaur · 11/07/2023 09:11

The attitude towards vow renewals on MN makes me sad and a bit annoyed.
I am a vicar and have done a few vow renewal services, often at a significant anniversary (20 or 25 years etc) or for other reasons such as OP’s reason or after an illness or challenging period.
I have mostly done low key services but I did do one larger service with a reception style do afterwards.

I’m sure that infidelity is one reason but it’s one of many and the silly/bitchy MN assumption that this is the case takes away from the many couples who do this for other reasons. Also, if a couple genuinely want to recommit after infidelity then that could potentially be supported by people, not just sneered at. Each couples’ circumstances are unique to them.

Porageeater · 11/07/2023 09:04

I’ve never heard of any shade for vow renewals although I’ve never actually known anyone who had one either. I feel like people would understand because you did it small and would like to now have a bigger celebration. I’d be on board with this if you were my friend or relative. Any excuse for a party!

Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 11/07/2023 09:02

Why not have a lovely holiday abroad and renew your vows there with just the 4 if you. You can then spend the money on enjoying a holiday together as well. Could still get new pics done etc x

PeachesOnTheBeaches · 11/07/2023 09:00

YANBU. I would have felt the same. If we couldn’t have had the traditional white fairytale wedding I would have waited until we could, because it’s not something you can ever do again.

People aren’t going to be excited for a vow renewal, they aren’t going to make the effort and they don’t really mean anything.

Unfortunately the day is done, so it’s best to remember it for the good parts and not try and do it again because you can’t.