Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny shaming

439 replies

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

OP posts:
Anaemiafog · 11/07/2023 19:29

Allmyghosts · 10/07/2023 21:13

All the skinny people complaining should be forced to wear a Susan Boyle suit for a month.

I sincerely hope that's a joke Try being 40kg and tube fed and tell me how funny those comments are.

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:28

Because if someone calls you a fat cow...they're not just saying you're fat. They're insinuating that your greedy and lazy too.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:26

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:21

Yes exactly and this has to be to do with a)the beauty associated with being thin and b) the hard work needed to get to that point if you are part of the 99% of the population who can put weight on easily.

Should explain that better, it is admirable somehow as you are seen as someone with amazing willpower and determined, all characteristics people admire.

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:26

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:19

I don’t think it’s fair to diminish someone else’s experience though is it? I’m absolutely not trying to diminish yours, I hate that people have seen fit to mock you because of your weight. Can’t you se why I might have been just as upset when people mocked mine?

I can see that it's upsetting for sure. Its rude to comment on people's weight. I also can't know how you feel and vice versa...but you must know that our society sees thin as better than fat, therefore when you are insulted, yes it's a personal insult but it's not loaded with all the crap we've been fed by society about how grotesque it is to be fat.

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:22

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:13

Actually is 1 percent it was a study of the genetic profiles of 44,000 between between the ages of 20-44 and only 1 percent had no ALK gene. They had metabolic rate that meant that could whatever and however much they liked, absolutely zero exercise and didn't put on any weight.

I'm unsure why you are reading my comments in that way that way that upsets you as I literally said in PP it is never acceptable or polite if you have been brought up properly rather than dragged up to make any remarks about appearance. So no, I wouldn't say this to someone grieving but grieving is an environmental factor that will alter it is not an absence of this gene. I am curious as to why you would be unhappy about being skinny but no that it is absolutely in your control much more easily than an overweight person as for 99% of us it is easy to put on weight as opposed to loosing it!

Ok. I must admit that I’ve never looked at the data. Nor have I compared it with data on factors for obesity. I mean, if it’s just a numbers game then I would agree that at a population level, it must be easier to put weight on than lose it because we are a heavy population.

I also agree with your PP about it being impolite and unkind to comment on someone’s weight in a disparaging manner

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:21

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:17

I'm not going to say it's not hurtful or inappropriate...but I can't see how in a society that says thin is good, fat is bad, that the insult can be felt exactly the same.

Yes exactly and this has to be to do with a)the beauty associated with being thin and b) the hard work needed to get to that point if you are part of the 99% of the population who can put weight on easily.

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:20

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:17

By the way I'm not doubting you are in the 1% so no need to be defensive. My son is like this and his friends comment on the amount he can eat and not out weight on with no exercise, often lots of rubbish if he is out so 3 x big burgers at burger king or something like that with cheese bites on the side then be hungry 2 hours later. It is exhausting and expensive trying to keep him full but he is a 16 year old boy and I'm sure many are like him, DH was like that not now in early 40s.

My apologies, didn’t mean to come off as defensive

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:19

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:17

I'm not going to say it's not hurtful or inappropriate...but I can't see how in a society that says thin is good, fat is bad, that the insult can be felt exactly the same.

I don’t think it’s fair to diminish someone else’s experience though is it? I’m absolutely not trying to diminish yours, I hate that people have seen fit to mock you because of your weight. Can’t you se why I might have been just as upset when people mocked mine?

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:19

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 19:14

A teacher went off on me in high school in front of the class; “you’re too pale, you’re too skinny, you don’t look healthy. You look anemic.” All because I said during a discussion that I liked having an extra blanket on my bed.

It was humiliating.

My uncle put it in a context that helped: is she malicious or ignorant? Most people that act this way are just stupid.

Like I said I had that reaction from a family member about being cold and needing a thicker jumper but I didn't care I was probably quite pleased.

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:17

I'm not going to say it's not hurtful or inappropriate...but I can't see how in a society that says thin is good, fat is bad, that the insult can be felt exactly the same.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:17

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:02

This is the same as saying to someone who is being fat shamed

“Well, yeah it’s shit that you got called a fat cunt and people yelled insults at you from across the canteen, but if you’re not happy with it could always eat less and lose weight. Why would you stay that way if it makes you unhappy?”

I don’t know where you’re getting the 6% from but I absolutely was in that group when I was younger.

Likewise, if someone was to shout nasty comments to someone who was say, grieving, and were skinny because of it, would you say the same thing to them?

By the way I'm not doubting you are in the 1% so no need to be defensive. My son is like this and his friends comment on the amount he can eat and not out weight on with no exercise, often lots of rubbish if he is out so 3 x big burgers at burger king or something like that with cheese bites on the side then be hungry 2 hours later. It is exhausting and expensive trying to keep him full but he is a 16 year old boy and I'm sure many are like him, DH was like that not now in early 40s.

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 19:14

A teacher went off on me in high school in front of the class; “you’re too pale, you’re too skinny, you don’t look healthy. You look anemic.” All because I said during a discussion that I liked having an extra blanket on my bed.

It was humiliating.

My uncle put it in a context that helped: is she malicious or ignorant? Most people that act this way are just stupid.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:13

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:02

This is the same as saying to someone who is being fat shamed

“Well, yeah it’s shit that you got called a fat cunt and people yelled insults at you from across the canteen, but if you’re not happy with it could always eat less and lose weight. Why would you stay that way if it makes you unhappy?”

I don’t know where you’re getting the 6% from but I absolutely was in that group when I was younger.

Likewise, if someone was to shout nasty comments to someone who was say, grieving, and were skinny because of it, would you say the same thing to them?

Actually is 1 percent it was a study of the genetic profiles of 44,000 between between the ages of 20-44 and only 1 percent had no ALK gene. They had metabolic rate that meant that could whatever and however much they liked, absolutely zero exercise and didn't put on any weight.

I'm unsure why you are reading my comments in that way that way that upsets you as I literally said in PP it is never acceptable or polite if you have been brought up properly rather than dragged up to make any remarks about appearance. So no, I wouldn't say this to someone grieving but grieving is an environmental factor that will alter it is not an absence of this gene. I am curious as to why you would be unhappy about being skinny but no that it is absolutely in your control much more easily than an overweight person as for 99% of us it is easy to put on weight as opposed to loosing it!

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 19:07

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 15:11

No but when you look at extreme ends of the spectrum, very thin people, by the very nature of being physically small, display a vulnerability that extremely large people don't.... however both can be equally as mentally vulnerable if that makes sense.

Absolutely.

maddening · 11/07/2023 19:06

Yabu to make a skinny shaming thread that conpares fat people- the fat people get enough shit in this world.

Yanbu in that no-one should be talking about other people's size and making comments on that - but have your thread without making it slim vs fat. This is rude person vs slim

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:02

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 18:52

Well obviously if you are in possession of those rare genes then I obviously was not directing my post to that 6%. Equally, I stated if someone is unhappy about it, why stay unhappy why not just do the thing to not make you skinny - eat calories to compensate for your exercise. A poster stated on here that they are not happy about it but they are a marathon runner so the implication is you can do something about it then. Why be skinny if unhappy about it? If it is a choice like it is for 94% of the population who don't possess the skinny genes.

This is the same as saying to someone who is being fat shamed

“Well, yeah it’s shit that you got called a fat cunt and people yelled insults at you from across the canteen, but if you’re not happy with it could always eat less and lose weight. Why would you stay that way if it makes you unhappy?”

I don’t know where you’re getting the 6% from but I absolutely was in that group when I was younger.

Likewise, if someone was to shout nasty comments to someone who was say, grieving, and were skinny because of it, would you say the same thing to them?

kayserah · 11/07/2023 18:58

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

What was the task that you volunteered for? Surely for effective M&H technique able bodies people of all strengths and sizes should be able to achieve it?

it’s a trainer and teacher issue more than a skinny shaming issue in my opinion.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 18:58

Actually, I've got that wrong apparently it is only 1% so small a population of people.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 18:56

So to add this is 94% of the population that can easily put on weight as it is so much easier a goal than being skinny. If you don't have skinny genes highly likely as only 6% of population, are unhappy about being skinny, then eat some food you'll soon put weight on and feel happier about it. That's obviously only if unhappy. It goes without saying that you don't comment on anyone's appearance.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 18:52

NomDe · 11/07/2023 18:34

Well yeah but some people are?

And what if you are perfectly happy as you are and yet –gasp – still don’t want rude comments from other people about your shape or appearance?

Well obviously if you are in possession of those rare genes then I obviously was not directing my post to that 6%. Equally, I stated if someone is unhappy about it, why stay unhappy why not just do the thing to not make you skinny - eat calories to compensate for your exercise. A poster stated on here that they are not happy about it but they are a marathon runner so the implication is you can do something about it then. Why be skinny if unhappy about it? If it is a choice like it is for 94% of the population who don't possess the skinny genes.

NomDe · 11/07/2023 18:34

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 18:29

But then that is down to the individual, I was around 19 when I told by my Dad's Business partner who skinny I looked. I didn't actually get upset, I was pleased. I got told by a family member that when I complained about being cold it was because I had no fat on me. Again, in my mind better than actually having that fat on me. It did put a few doubts in my head but it wasn't as bad as being called fat which had happened 3 years prior at a family wedding by an old person to my Gran, in front of me. No one liked this woman but she was right I was overweight, not fat but overweight. So you see I felt I had won the control when I had the opposite comments in late teens.

Like I said on a PP only 6% of the population is naturally skinny i.e no lifestyle choices has any affect on their weight. This figure includes men so I have to say it is hard to understand if you are skinny due to marathon running for example then why not eat some donuts or healthy calories and replace and add to the calories you are losing with exercise. You don't have to remain skinny in those circumstances you choose to do it. An external factor like someone dying is still just that, I know as that made me lose weight in mid 20s. But as soon I stopped mourning I put the weight back on. No one should be skinny shamed absolutely not but separately if you are not happy being skinny then you can change that if you are not part of the naturally skinny 6% genes.

Well yeah but some people are?

And what if you are perfectly happy as you are and yet –gasp – still don’t want rude comments from other people about your shape or appearance?

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 18:31

And other external factors causing the weight loss to skinny are often temporary like illness or mourning a loved one. I was ill during my second pregnancy and was quite thin as a result.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 18:29

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 16:23

I don’t disagree with most of what you’re saying. Yes, societal context does make a difference.

But I was young at that time, about 19/20? I was extremely socially anxious and had no confidence myself. I didn’t walk away from that experience thinking “fuck her, she is just jealous” I walked away from it (and many other comments) determined to cover myself up as much as possible, try not to be in crowds of people and eat incredibly unhealthy food to try and put on a few pounds. I wasn’t even ‘underweight’ medically.

The point I keep trying to make is, neither is worse than the other. They’re both shit.

But then that is down to the individual, I was around 19 when I told by my Dad's Business partner who skinny I looked. I didn't actually get upset, I was pleased. I got told by a family member that when I complained about being cold it was because I had no fat on me. Again, in my mind better than actually having that fat on me. It did put a few doubts in my head but it wasn't as bad as being called fat which had happened 3 years prior at a family wedding by an old person to my Gran, in front of me. No one liked this woman but she was right I was overweight, not fat but overweight. So you see I felt I had won the control when I had the opposite comments in late teens.

Like I said on a PP only 6% of the population is naturally skinny i.e no lifestyle choices has any affect on their weight. This figure includes men so I have to say it is hard to understand if you are skinny due to marathon running for example then why not eat some donuts or healthy calories and replace and add to the calories you are losing with exercise. You don't have to remain skinny in those circumstances you choose to do it. An external factor like someone dying is still just that, I know as that made me lose weight in mid 20s. But as soon I stopped mourning I put the weight back on. No one should be skinny shamed absolutely not but separately if you are not happy being skinny then you can change that if you are not part of the naturally skinny 6% genes.

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 16:23

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 14:54

But the wider societal context is key. We are fed an endless loop of messaging from childhood that thin is best. It is seen as desirable and aspirational. Everywhere you look, articles on how to lose weight, adverts showing you weight loss products. Its incessant. Yes, some people may say unpleasant remarks and it's not nice but you are aware that it actually comes from a place of admiration/jealousy. When you are verbally abused for being fat, you know, because society has fed you the message, that it's because you are unattractive, lazy, grotesque.

Both are unpleasant but it is different.

I don’t disagree with most of what you’re saying. Yes, societal context does make a difference.

But I was young at that time, about 19/20? I was extremely socially anxious and had no confidence myself. I didn’t walk away from that experience thinking “fuck her, she is just jealous” I walked away from it (and many other comments) determined to cover myself up as much as possible, try not to be in crowds of people and eat incredibly unhealthy food to try and put on a few pounds. I wasn’t even ‘underweight’ medically.

The point I keep trying to make is, neither is worse than the other. They’re both shit.

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 15:11

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 15:08

Such an awful experience. But cruel people are never kind or if they are, it’s not sincere. They weren’t neglectful because of your weight; that’s who they are as people.

No but when you look at extreme ends of the spectrum, very thin people, by the very nature of being physically small, display a vulnerability that extremely large people don't.... however both can be equally as mentally vulnerable if that makes sense.