Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny shaming

439 replies

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:47

Peacoffee · 11/07/2023 20:43

Im not misunderstanding, much more than 1% of the population are slim or not classed as overweight. So if only 1% of people can eat what they like and not gain weight then it’s proof that the vast majority of skinny people manage it not through fluke but through diet and exercise.
The rest who are overweight would only find it hard to lose weight if they continued to eat what they like rather than only what their body needs.

No no no, 1% are skinny not slim. It is not only 1% that are not overweight - deary me!

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:46

If you can control it and do something about it why would you not make yourself happy by doing those tiny tweaks 🤔

Peacoffee · 11/07/2023 20:43

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:40

No, I think you have misunderstood the research, only 1% of the population does not have the AlK Gene, with that genetic make up, you can eat whatever you like. 99% of us have the ALK Gene which leads to the propensity for weight gain if not mindful of diet and exercise. If you are the 99% with the ALK Gene then you won't be resistant to weight gain and you certainly will find it exponentially hard to achieve the opposite - skinniness.

Im not misunderstanding, much more than 1% of the population are slim or not classed as overweight. So if only 1% of people can eat what they like and not gain weight then it’s proof that the vast majority of skinny people manage it not through fluke but through diet and exercise.
The rest who are overweight would only find it hard to lose weight if they continued to eat what they like rather than only what their body needs.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:43

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 20:38

No, actually, I think you are quite a bit younger. Both because you gave a year, and because you seem to lack the level of empathy that most of us develop by a certain age.

So yes, your opinion of my experience is very much like mansplaining. Because you can't seem to fathom that how you feel about a thing is not how everyone feels. Nor that the "common" feeling has nothing at all to do with how any one individual experiences life. Nor that because one person might be able to exercise, eat less and lose weight means it's ok to judge everyone by that same standard.

It seems like you are saying skinny is better and more desirable so therefore let's punish everyone who is skinny equally. And screw the people who are uncomfortable with it, whether than can control it or not. 'cause skinny. Ok to punch up, right?

And this is quite in line with how a 40 year old teacher probably felt when barking openly at a 14 year old girl about her body in front of her peers. And also how the person speaking to the OP felt. "Fuck her, she's not fat!"

That's quite a misreading of my posts you have there and considering the Motherland example was there to show the common held view of thinness being prized, I think you are being disingenuous.

I really don't know how you have come to the conclusions you have - bizarre and defensive!

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:40

Peacoffee · 11/07/2023 20:32

@Goldenbear It is only 1% of the country that can eat what they like without any exercise, that's very small and includes both sexes so if you are in the 99% of this aesthetic you are insulted to be labelled as it but it is totally within your powers to change with limited efforts, i.e eat high calorific food and don't exercise as much.

And it’s only a small number of people with an actual metabolic disorder or on medication that makes them hold weight so it’s totally within their powers to change too, just eat less calorific foods and exercise more.
So no excuse for anyone to be offended then according to you.

No, I think you have misunderstood the research, only 1% of the population does not have the AlK Gene, with that genetic make up, you can eat whatever you like. 99% of us have the ALK Gene which leads to the propensity for weight gain if not mindful of diet and exercise. If you are the 99% with the ALK Gene then you won't be resistant to weight gain and you certainly will find it exponentially hard to achieve the opposite - skinniness.

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 20:38

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:27

IME as most of us belong to the 99% of people that don't have a skinny Gene, where we have to purposefully aim for skinny, I think a more common feeling is to not mind having that affirmation via such a comment. I'm talking about my youth though and I get the impression I'm older than you so perhaps as that was the aesthetic aim, it wasn't taken as badly, if at all.

I am failing to see how my opinion a s woman is like a man telling you something, it is disingenuous to not really understand why being fat is more of an insult. It is only 1% of the country that can eat what they like without any exercise, that's very small and includes both sexes so if you are in the 99% of this aesthetic you are insulted to be labelled as it but it is totally within your powers to change with limited efforts, i.e eat high calorific food and don't exercise as much.

No, actually, I think you are quite a bit younger. Both because you gave a year, and because you seem to lack the level of empathy that most of us develop by a certain age.

So yes, your opinion of my experience is very much like mansplaining. Because you can't seem to fathom that how you feel about a thing is not how everyone feels. Nor that the "common" feeling has nothing at all to do with how any one individual experiences life. Nor that because one person might be able to exercise, eat less and lose weight means it's ok to judge everyone by that same standard.

It seems like you are saying skinny is better and more desirable so therefore let's punish everyone who is skinny equally. And screw the people who are uncomfortable with it, whether than can control it or not. 'cause skinny. Ok to punch up, right?

And this is quite in line with how a 40 year old teacher probably felt when barking openly at a 14 year old girl about her body in front of her peers. And also how the person speaking to the OP felt. "Fuck her, she's not fat!"

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 20:37

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:32

The point is surely the commonality of that thought, that's why it is 'funny'. It is not Comedycook writing Motherland (unless it is). For comedy to work in sitcoms the audience it has to be a fairly commonly understood point of view. I mean, in my family, DH and I will refer to our early 40's fatness, we are not fat, probably a stone overweight but it is a joke that has some mutual significance, it is the same amongst our friends. Never in front of the DC but that's for obvious reasons.

Thanks for explaining it more eloquently than I did! As you may have guessed, I'm not one of the motherland script writers 😂

Peacoffee · 11/07/2023 20:32

@Goldenbear It is only 1% of the country that can eat what they like without any exercise, that's very small and includes both sexes so if you are in the 99% of this aesthetic you are insulted to be labelled as it but it is totally within your powers to change with limited efforts, i.e eat high calorific food and don't exercise as much.

And it’s only a small number of people with an actual metabolic disorder or on medication that makes them hold weight so it’s totally within their powers to change too, just eat less calorific foods and exercise more.
So no excuse for anyone to be offended then according to you.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:32

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 20:26

Well you've totally misunderstood the gag

The point is surely the commonality of that thought, that's why it is 'funny'. It is not Comedycook writing Motherland (unless it is). For comedy to work in sitcoms the audience it has to be a fairly commonly understood point of view. I mean, in my family, DH and I will refer to our early 40's fatness, we are not fat, probably a stone overweight but it is a joke that has some mutual significance, it is the same amongst our friends. Never in front of the DC but that's for obvious reasons.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:27

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 20:13

It's really quite off though for you to reply to someone telling you they felt humiliated by something with essentially saying "I would have liked it."

Is your purpose to tell the people having these experience that they should like it?

IME as most of us belong to the 99% of people that don't have a skinny Gene, where we have to purposefully aim for skinny, I think a more common feeling is to not mind having that affirmation via such a comment. I'm talking about my youth though and I get the impression I'm older than you so perhaps as that was the aesthetic aim, it wasn't taken as badly, if at all.

I am failing to see how my opinion a s woman is like a man telling you something, it is disingenuous to not really understand why being fat is more of an insult. It is only 1% of the country that can eat what they like without any exercise, that's very small and includes both sexes so if you are in the 99% of this aesthetic you are insulted to be labelled as it but it is totally within your powers to change with limited efforts, i.e eat high calorific food and don't exercise as much.

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 20:26

NomDe · 11/07/2023 20:17

Well, some people definitely do have disordered thinking around food and weight. Are you suggesting that everyone should be pleased then about being told they look dangerously ill?

Well you've totally misunderstood the gag

NomDe · 11/07/2023 20:17

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:54

Because Amanda takes being told she looks dangerously thin as a compliment. Why? Because being thin is viewed as a really positive achievement generally

Well, some people definitely do have disordered thinking around food and weight. Are you suggesting that everyone should be pleased then about being told they look dangerously ill?

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 20:13

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:59

It definitely wasn't a healthy one but as like many of my friends at 16- about late 20s, when you share houses with others an uni or just hang around with your friends a lot at 16, none of us was 'naturally thin' we weren't that 1%, everyone I knew had some kind of disordered eating so would have not been offended by that comment. We were 16 mid 90s though and definitely good to be skinny like Kate Moss and alternative/indie girls wanted to look skinny.

It's really quite off though for you to reply to someone telling you they felt humiliated by something with essentially saying "I would have liked it."

Is your purpose to tell the people having these experience that they should like it?

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:13

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:54

Because Amanda takes being told she looks dangerously thin as a compliment. Why? Because being thin is viewed as a really positive achievement generally

Yes, absolutely, that's the joke. The idea that you never really be too thin.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 20:12

M340 · 11/07/2023 19:35

Well.. in most cases being fat is caused by being greedy with food and not moving about enough. The cow but is irrelevant though.

Also, if someone's a skinny bitch, they live of lettuce leaves apparently. (As is bitch irrelevant.)

Works both ways.

But no, it doesn't because unless you are the 1% of the population you will be purposely adapting your diet i.e plenty of low calorific food or exercising to maintain the metabolism of a skinny person. Conversely, if you don't make some of those adjustments and are in the 99% of the population who doesn't have the skinny Gene, the weight will pile on at a very quick rate just from eating food. All it takes to be overweight is just eating food without any mindfulness as to exercise and type of food. What it takes to be skinny not slim, skinny, is extraordinary efforts over exercise and food intake, if you are like most of the 99% of the population. The ease with which 99% put on weight is not equal to that same population forcing themselves to be skinny(unless you are in the 1%) It is not comparable and it is disingenuous to say the efforts are equal they are not.

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:59

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 19:47

I’m not sure what your feelings have to do with mine?

Its like men constantly telling women that they couldn’t possibly be cold because they aren’t cold themselves.

I think your reaction wasn’t the healthy one, actually.

It definitely wasn't a healthy one but as like many of my friends at 16- about late 20s, when you share houses with others an uni or just hang around with your friends a lot at 16, none of us was 'naturally thin' we weren't that 1%, everyone I knew had some kind of disordered eating so would have not been offended by that comment. We were 16 mid 90s though and definitely good to be skinny like Kate Moss and alternative/indie girls wanted to look skinny.

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:54

Because Amanda takes being told she looks dangerously thin as a compliment. Why? Because being thin is viewed as a really positive achievement generally

NomDe · 11/07/2023 19:52

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:51

Has anyone seen that episode of motherland where Liz wants to get into Amanda's good books so goes up to her at the café and says, have you lost weight? Have you been ill? You look dangerously thin! And Amanda is like, ah, thanks and is absolutely thrilled.

And??

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:51

Has anyone seen that episode of motherland where Liz wants to get into Amanda's good books so goes up to her at the café and says, have you lost weight? Have you been ill? You look dangerously thin! And Amanda is like, ah, thanks and is absolutely thrilled.

AliceOlive · 11/07/2023 19:47

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 19:19

Like I said I had that reaction from a family member about being cold and needing a thicker jumper but I didn't care I was probably quite pleased.

I’m not sure what your feelings have to do with mine?

Its like men constantly telling women that they couldn’t possibly be cold because they aren’t cold themselves.

I think your reaction wasn’t the healthy one, actually.

NomDe · 11/07/2023 19:45

I guess the real enemy here is the commodification of women’s bodies!!

Bingo

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:39

M340 · 11/07/2023 19:35

Well.. in most cases being fat is caused by being greedy with food and not moving about enough. The cow but is irrelevant though.

Also, if someone's a skinny bitch, they live of lettuce leaves apparently. (As is bitch irrelevant.)

Works both ways.

Ok, so you say greedy. What about people who comfort eat after a traumatic event or turn to food when their mental health is on the floor? Some people struggle to eat in these situations, others eat too much. But anyway, being greedy with food is not actually a moral failing. Many people see being thin as a moral win. Its very odd. Its just food...some people eat more of it than others. As for not moving much or exercising...again, it's not immoral to not like exercise. I'd rather read a book than go for a run. Its just what I prefer.

M340 · 11/07/2023 19:35

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:28

Because if someone calls you a fat cow...they're not just saying you're fat. They're insinuating that your greedy and lazy too.

Well.. in most cases being fat is caused by being greedy with food and not moving about enough. The cow but is irrelevant though.

Also, if someone's a skinny bitch, they live of lettuce leaves apparently. (As is bitch irrelevant.)

Works both ways.

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:32

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:29

Yes, I can see your point. And as you say, neither of us can know how the other one would feel!

I don’t know if this is relevant but, at the time, JLo was all the rage and everyone wanted her curves. The boys were all only interested in “women with tits” and people like me would get referred to as “ironing board” or I would get told I looked like a boy. So I still felt the societal pressure. I believed I was ugly 🤷‍♀️

I guess the real enemy here is the commodification of women’s bodies!!

Yes it's totally shit...and I'd have boys tell me I had big tits....they always have something to say don't they?!

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 19:29

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 19:26

I can see that it's upsetting for sure. Its rude to comment on people's weight. I also can't know how you feel and vice versa...but you must know that our society sees thin as better than fat, therefore when you are insulted, yes it's a personal insult but it's not loaded with all the crap we've been fed by society about how grotesque it is to be fat.

Yes, I can see your point. And as you say, neither of us can know how the other one would feel!

I don’t know if this is relevant but, at the time, JLo was all the rage and everyone wanted her curves. The boys were all only interested in “women with tits” and people like me would get referred to as “ironing board” or I would get told I looked like a boy. So I still felt the societal pressure. I believed I was ugly 🤷‍♀️

I guess the real enemy here is the commodification of women’s bodies!!