Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny shaming

439 replies

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

OP posts:
Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 09:14

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 09:04

It is rude and no doubt you felt shit being spoken to like that...but we live in a world where from childhood we hear the message of...

Fat is ugly, fat is bad, fat is disgusting

Lose weight

Be thin, be thinner, thin is beautiful, thin is better

Therefore someone saying ugh, you're too fat comes with so much more baggage than someone saying ugh, you're too thin.

I agree that was true when I was a kid in the 80s. There was definitely some horrible fat shaming in the playground (particularly from the 'popular' kids). And the thin is beautiful culture was totally prevalent in the 90s. But my impression from my own DC (who are teens now) is that there isn't much of that happening in their schools. I heard of one fat shaming comment a few years back and everyone was up in arms about it, which is as it should be. There are many more role models of different sizes and the people that the young people I know look up to and think of as attractive and cool are certainly not all skinny.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:11

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 08:59

I don't even know what that it.

But if you look at the celebrity world...it's totally true. Skinny celebrities telling us all that they love takeaways and wine and stay slim by running round after their kids. Meanwhile in the real world, I've only got fatter when I've eaten takeaways.

Don't know what it is and yet you've basically quoted the cool girl line word for word multiple times. Or did you just read someone else comment it before and memorise it without realising what it was?

You seriously don't think someone can drink wine and eat takeways and remain slim/skinny/whatever you want to call it?

All you are doing is adding to this BS rhetoric that you must be neurotic and obsessed with food and exercise to be skinny.

I'm skinny and have no problem drinking wine or eating takeaways and not gaining weight. Is that not the real world? Am I a work of fiction?

You gain weight based on what you eat over the course of a week and how much energy you burn. These comments like 'oh i just look at a takeway or a bar or chocolate and gain weight' are nonsense. You gain weight if you consume too much. It isn't witchcraft.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 09:10

Darkmodeison · 12/07/2023 09:00

Oh god yes, the men saying you're too thin and should eat more 🤬. Too thin for what?? A woman I vaguely knew at a show asked me outright if I was anorexic in front of two strangers, Christ I was mortified. Makes you feel like a freak and I promise with all my heart it did not make me feel good, quite the opposite.

Exactly - endless comments about 'eating more cake' and how being thin as you get older is ageing etc. There's an underlying implication that you're vain and boring. Or people will sigh and say "I just like to enjoy life" as if you're not capable of having fun if you're skinny. I don't know anyone who would make personal comments about someone being overweight. Who knows maybe they say horrible things behind closed doors but, thankfully, I don't think it's socially acceptable to have a go about people's weight in public now if they are overweight. Hopefully we'll get to a point soon where people don't feel the need to comment on anyone's appearance in that way.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 09:04

Darkmodeison · 12/07/2023 09:00

Oh god yes, the men saying you're too thin and should eat more 🤬. Too thin for what?? A woman I vaguely knew at a show asked me outright if I was anorexic in front of two strangers, Christ I was mortified. Makes you feel like a freak and I promise with all my heart it did not make me feel good, quite the opposite.

It is rude and no doubt you felt shit being spoken to like that...but we live in a world where from childhood we hear the message of...

Fat is ugly, fat is bad, fat is disgusting

Lose weight

Be thin, be thinner, thin is beautiful, thin is better

Therefore someone saying ugh, you're too fat comes with so much more baggage than someone saying ugh, you're too thin.

Darkmodeison · 12/07/2023 09:00

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 08:36

I’m underweight - it doesn’t suit me and I’m actively trying to gain weight but nothing sticks. I find the comments pretty offensive. I’ve had people say to me at a party that I look anorexic - massively embarrassing and fortunately my kids were too young to clock it. I’ve had colleagues pinch my arms and tell me I need to eat more / or ask me in really patronising tones if I’m OK etc…

i think comments towards bigger women are totally awful too and I know that larger friends can feel self-conscious even enjoying food in public because they feel they will be judged, which is terrible. I do think that is changing though and certainly where I live, people are far less likely to comment / be unpleasant towards someone who is overweight whereas the same is not yet true for people who are underweight. I think it often prompts all sorts of assumptions about mental health and a joyless / puritanical outlook. I’m really glad I no longer work somewhere where people are rude enough to comment on my weight.

Oh god yes, the men saying you're too thin and should eat more 🤬. Too thin for what?? A woman I vaguely knew at a show asked me outright if I was anorexic in front of two strangers, Christ I was mortified. Makes you feel like a freak and I promise with all my heart it did not make me feel good, quite the opposite.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 08:59

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 08:57

So do you take all your life experience from gone girl? Are you aware its trash fiction?

I don't even know what that it.

But if you look at the celebrity world...it's totally true. Skinny celebrities telling us all that they love takeaways and wine and stay slim by running round after their kids. Meanwhile in the real world, I've only got fatter when I've eaten takeaways.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 08:57

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 08:54

Yes I hear it all the time. Men saying how cool it is if a woman loves pigging out on the sofa with him eating pizza...yet he also expects her to be thin and attractive. They also say they love the no make up look but you should also look stunning at all times. Oh and they don't want women who are high maintenance but also want to date women who look high maintenance. Its the expectation on women that you should be all things at all times. Its an impossible standard.

So do you take all your life experience from gone girl? Are you aware its trash fiction?

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 08:54

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 07:46

The post wasn’t to you though, it was the the poster hashing out the “cool girl” shit in a way to patronise women for being the thin and make it seem like they must be absolutely obsessed with their weight at all times, while trying to appear normal eating a burger and then probably not eating the rest of the time. It’s misogynistic bullshit that’s only ever aimed at women by other women.
Do skinny men get called “cool guys” for pretending to eat what they want and not get fat? Of course not.

Yes I hear it all the time. Men saying how cool it is if a woman loves pigging out on the sofa with him eating pizza...yet he also expects her to be thin and attractive. They also say they love the no make up look but you should also look stunning at all times. Oh and they don't want women who are high maintenance but also want to date women who look high maintenance. Its the expectation on women that you should be all things at all times. Its an impossible standard.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 08:36

I’m underweight - it doesn’t suit me and I’m actively trying to gain weight but nothing sticks. I find the comments pretty offensive. I’ve had people say to me at a party that I look anorexic - massively embarrassing and fortunately my kids were too young to clock it. I’ve had colleagues pinch my arms and tell me I need to eat more / or ask me in really patronising tones if I’m OK etc…

i think comments towards bigger women are totally awful too and I know that larger friends can feel self-conscious even enjoying food in public because they feel they will be judged, which is terrible. I do think that is changing though and certainly where I live, people are far less likely to comment / be unpleasant towards someone who is overweight whereas the same is not yet true for people who are underweight. I think it often prompts all sorts of assumptions about mental health and a joyless / puritanical outlook. I’m really glad I no longer work somewhere where people are rude enough to comment on my weight.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 08:18

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 07:46

The post wasn’t to you though, it was the the poster hashing out the “cool girl” shit in a way to patronise women for being the thin and make it seem like they must be absolutely obsessed with their weight at all times, while trying to appear normal eating a burger and then probably not eating the rest of the time. It’s misogynistic bullshit that’s only ever aimed at women by other women.
Do skinny men get called “cool guys” for pretending to eat what they want and not get fat? Of course not.

But ComedyCook is right that does happen. My DD's friend's Mum's anecdote about fish and chips was exactly that, she told me to explain how the fish and chip man asked how such a small women could have a large fish and chips. My DH was there at the time and showed his surprise as said they are nice and men but barely speak to you when you are buying fish and chips. He said to me afterwards that it appeared rubbish to make me feel shit as it is well known from her husband that he is desperate for her to eat something. It is all really sad tbh.

It isn't the same for men, my DS is naturally skinny and doesn't want to be he wants muscle, it is not something that is desirable for a 16 year old boy

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 08:08

FuckOffTom · 12/07/2023 07:23

I think I’m the same as you, although slightly larger. When I was younger, I certainly couldn’t put weight on no matter how hard I tried. As I’ve gotten older, I’ve filled out a little more. I stay around a size 8/10 - I don’t calorie count, I move around a bit but nowhere near as much as I should. I enjoy my food but probably do naturally eat only what I need.

My point here is, that people who are very underweight or are overweight/obese (barring genetics and medical etc) do not have a healthy relationship with food. And do you know what? It’s not their fault! Emotional eating/emotional undereating, our ‘feast/famine’ cycles, being poor, being abused etc etc - so many factors contribute and it’s really hard because we all need food! It’s not like being disordered around alcohol where you can (with great difficulty) just give it up.

And so, do not take away from other people’s experiences. They all hurt equally. The real culprits here are the cunts that see fit to comment on how we look - lie we ‘owe’ them pretty.

I don't know how old you are as I think that makes a difference, equally height makes a difference, I mean my family member is size 6 but she is a small build and 5ft 1. I have Scandinavian heritage and have fairly broad shoulders, pretty flat chest and my weight hangs in a completely different way. I visited Denmark with MIL, was constantly been spoken to in Danish and my MiL was not and commented on size wise how British she felt as everyone was bigger, not in an overweight way as my MIL is overweight but in build. My point is a size 6 isn't something that would be attainable or as easy to achieve as it may be for my small SIL for example.

Finlesswonder · 12/07/2023 07:57

To be fair the word skinny is thrown around all the time when actually what people mean is slim. I think we've become so used to pumped up gym or surgery bodies, and a generally larger population, that people have forgotten what a naturally slender body looks like.

I'm not slim or slender, I actually am skinny, and gangly too, and let me tell you it's not pleasant, and even before "real curves" became a thing it wasn't pleasant. Flashbacks to the nineties and early 2000s and having guys make chicken sounds out the window to me as I walked down the street, faux concern about my eating from other women, just generally being made to feel like your body is unattractive, wrong, and weird.

Once I was in a seminar and asked a lecturer a question, and she said (it was completely irrelevant to the question): "You should eat more". The entire room was basically stunned.

I don't know why it seems to be OK to put skinny women's bodies under the microscope like this, but it is. You are fighting a losing battle here though OP, as you are up against women who struggle to keep weight off and have their own complexes to deal with - for whatever reason though, they don't seem to understand its the flip side of the same coin, and they don't extend their empathy to skinny women.

Noicant · 12/07/2023 07:52

I just wish people would shut up about other peoples body sizes. I would never tell someone they are fat or thin. It’s really unnecessary to comment on someones physical appearance, they know! They live in their own body!

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 07:48

@FuckOffTom to be fair I’m saying I’m sure I can’t eat unlimited amounts and not gain weight. By default I don’t overeat and live a relatively active life that just involves lots of walking about but if I ate more and decided to start driving everywhere I’m sure I would get heavier, but it’s not a conscious effort to not do that.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 07:46

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 07:32

'Triggered' how ridiculous and arrogant. Yes, most slim people I know don't go to the gym 5 x a week but some do and the others certainly will factor in purposeful exercise, equally they eat well but all of them without exception eat mindfully. They don't not eat junk but it is limited to stay thin, none of them could and don't eat as much junk as they want. I am equally referencing people that are slim but not size 6. I have one family member in 40s size 6 and it is a very considered diet and exercise as she has time to go to classes as she doesn't work. She has never been big but certainly does think about it all which is fine. You do realise that anyone over size 6 is not fat don't you?

The post wasn’t to you though, it was the the poster hashing out the “cool girl” shit in a way to patronise women for being the thin and make it seem like they must be absolutely obsessed with their weight at all times, while trying to appear normal eating a burger and then probably not eating the rest of the time. It’s misogynistic bullshit that’s only ever aimed at women by other women.
Do skinny men get called “cool guys” for pretending to eat what they want and not get fat? Of course not.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 07:32

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 06:54

You just sound triggered by people being skinny.
I wouldn’t say “I can whatever and not gain weight” so anyone because I can’t imagine having a conversation like that in real life but I’ve also never been more than a size 6 in my life other than about 2 months PP when I had size 8 jeans. I don’t try really hard and I’m not careful about what I eat though. Calories are never on my mind, I don’t go to the gym 5 days a week, I eat plenty of junk in moderation. I just naturally eat around the amount my body needs and not more than that. Most people I know who don’t struggle with their weight are also like that and it isn’t some impossible task to not be fat.
I actually find the “cool girl” thing purposely patronising. People love to make skinny women out to be uptight, neurotic, obsessed with their weight etc. I guess it makes them feel better, there’s this assumption that skinny women don’t live their life to the full or enjoy themselves.

'Triggered' how ridiculous and arrogant. Yes, most slim people I know don't go to the gym 5 x a week but some do and the others certainly will factor in purposeful exercise, equally they eat well but all of them without exception eat mindfully. They don't not eat junk but it is limited to stay thin, none of them could and don't eat as much junk as they want. I am equally referencing people that are slim but not size 6. I have one family member in 40s size 6 and it is a very considered diet and exercise as she has time to go to classes as she doesn't work. She has never been big but certainly does think about it all which is fine. You do realise that anyone over size 6 is not fat don't you?

FuckOffTom · 12/07/2023 07:23

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 06:54

You just sound triggered by people being skinny.
I wouldn’t say “I can whatever and not gain weight” so anyone because I can’t imagine having a conversation like that in real life but I’ve also never been more than a size 6 in my life other than about 2 months PP when I had size 8 jeans. I don’t try really hard and I’m not careful about what I eat though. Calories are never on my mind, I don’t go to the gym 5 days a week, I eat plenty of junk in moderation. I just naturally eat around the amount my body needs and not more than that. Most people I know who don’t struggle with their weight are also like that and it isn’t some impossible task to not be fat.
I actually find the “cool girl” thing purposely patronising. People love to make skinny women out to be uptight, neurotic, obsessed with their weight etc. I guess it makes them feel better, there’s this assumption that skinny women don’t live their life to the full or enjoy themselves.

I think I’m the same as you, although slightly larger. When I was younger, I certainly couldn’t put weight on no matter how hard I tried. As I’ve gotten older, I’ve filled out a little more. I stay around a size 8/10 - I don’t calorie count, I move around a bit but nowhere near as much as I should. I enjoy my food but probably do naturally eat only what I need.

My point here is, that people who are very underweight or are overweight/obese (barring genetics and medical etc) do not have a healthy relationship with food. And do you know what? It’s not their fault! Emotional eating/emotional undereating, our ‘feast/famine’ cycles, being poor, being abused etc etc - so many factors contribute and it’s really hard because we all need food! It’s not like being disordered around alcohol where you can (with great difficulty) just give it up.

And so, do not take away from other people’s experiences. They all hurt equally. The real culprits here are the cunts that see fit to comment on how we look - lie we ‘owe’ them pretty.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 07:18

AliceOlive · 12/07/2023 03:09

I’m honestly so tired of you banging on about your statistics that I can’t be bothered to try and understand what you are saying any longer.

This thread was started by a human being who was insulted by someone commenting on her size.

All your other 99% of humans are irrelevant here. There are real people involved, not just statistics.

If you need support for your specific feelings, you’ll get it from many of us by making a thread of your own.

I am unsure why you are so offended by statistics. I am questioning the spirit of this thread as I don't like the insincerity.

I am early 40s like many I am a stone overweight, I don't like this but it is a factual thing for me so I am able to solve the issue like I am doing. I don't have 'issues' anymore than literally everyone I know, including men where we will all joke about middle age spread. So as tempting as your passive aggressive offer is, no, I will decline strangers' help from the internet of whom a vast majority will have disordered eating. When I speak of my thoughts around the comments about being cold not being offensive, I'm referencing my teens and early 20s, I found all my friends thought like me - I am being honest about a period in my life. I apologise if you are offended by my honesty but I'm not going to pretend it was otherwise as I would like any young women reading this to think she isn't imagining that society's perception is favourable to 'skinny' and that it is a kind of brainwashing and to be 'skinny' not an average weight is mostly unattainable. You see that is why the statistics(facts) are important. If you are confused by them that is not really my problem.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 06:54

Comedycook · 11/07/2023 22:31

Yes but my point is that saying you are naturally skinny and don't out on weight is just a fashionable, socially acceptable thing to say. Not many women actually seem to admit that they are very careful with their food consumption. It's a bit "cool girl" if you know what I mean. Like men who say they love a woman who enjoys her food but she must be a size 6... Oh and doesn't wear make up but looks glam all the time. It's just more unobtainable shit that women have to achieve

You just sound triggered by people being skinny.
I wouldn’t say “I can whatever and not gain weight” so anyone because I can’t imagine having a conversation like that in real life but I’ve also never been more than a size 6 in my life other than about 2 months PP when I had size 8 jeans. I don’t try really hard and I’m not careful about what I eat though. Calories are never on my mind, I don’t go to the gym 5 days a week, I eat plenty of junk in moderation. I just naturally eat around the amount my body needs and not more than that. Most people I know who don’t struggle with their weight are also like that and it isn’t some impossible task to not be fat.
I actually find the “cool girl” thing purposely patronising. People love to make skinny women out to be uptight, neurotic, obsessed with their weight etc. I guess it makes them feel better, there’s this assumption that skinny women don’t live their life to the full or enjoy themselves.

RatatouilleAndFeta · 12/07/2023 06:45

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:45

Yes it's true unfortunately that people are very negative towards overweight people. However words like anorexic/bulimic are also thrown around, people are told 'you need to eat!' and are still shamed.
There'll never be a meme saying 'I'd rather live on lettuce and water than be a size 20."

Kate Moss "nothing tastes as good as skinny feels" ?

AliceOlive · 12/07/2023 03:09

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 22:09

The insincerity is beyond annoying and actually not very helpful for people with disordered eating whether that be over eating or underrating. Let's all pretend that people who are skinny or underweight all fall under that 1% of naturally thin except we all know this is bollox, it's the faux shock at this suggestion, the talking in riddles. That is not toutamount to saying, all skinny people should be attacked, yes I definitely think I should attack my son about this 🙄

I’m honestly so tired of you banging on about your statistics that I can’t be bothered to try and understand what you are saying any longer.

This thread was started by a human being who was insulted by someone commenting on her size.

All your other 99% of humans are irrelevant here. There are real people involved, not just statistics.

If you need support for your specific feelings, you’ll get it from many of us by making a thread of your own.

eastegg · 11/07/2023 23:34

SemperIdem · 11/07/2023 23:13

Two sides of the same coin.

Which is why I led with people shouldn’t pass comment on the appearance of others.

If you think it’s two sides of the same coin (which is basically what I think it is), can you explain what you meant by the second paragraph of the post I was responding to, the ‘But…..whereas’ one? Because it looked to me like you were saying they are two different things and comments to skinny people aren’t as bad.

Were you not saying that?

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 23:15

eastegg · 11/07/2023 23:04

Jealousy and malice are incredibly close cousins are they not?

I think this is at the heart of it really. Skinny shaming is considered ok because skinny is desirable therefore the emotions behind shaming can’t be truly negative/spiteful etc. Of course they can!

But if skinny is 'desirable' then you are already at an advantage ahead of the overweight crowd as being overweight is not desirable. So when you are overweight it is the double negative- it is 'not' desirable and people are telling you so. Shit all round really.

SemperIdem · 11/07/2023 23:13

eastegg · 11/07/2023 23:04

Jealousy and malice are incredibly close cousins are they not?

I think this is at the heart of it really. Skinny shaming is considered ok because skinny is desirable therefore the emotions behind shaming can’t be truly negative/spiteful etc. Of course they can!

Two sides of the same coin.

Which is why I led with people shouldn’t pass comment on the appearance of others.

eastegg · 11/07/2023 23:04

SemperIdem · 10/07/2023 21:35

No people shouldn’t comment on the appearance of others. Life would be easier and more pleasant if people didn’t feel entitled to pass comment.

But almost every time, “you’re so skinny” comments come from jealousy, whereas “you’re so fat” comments come from a place of malice.

Being thin is the beauty standard, being fat is not.

Jealousy and malice are incredibly close cousins are they not?

I think this is at the heart of it really. Skinny shaming is considered ok because skinny is desirable therefore the emotions behind shaming can’t be truly negative/spiteful etc. Of course they can!