Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny shaming

439 replies

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

OP posts:
Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 10:17

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:00

I said a larger woman as in larger than the slim colleague.

Not technical terms no but culturally I think we all no there is a difference between skinny and slim. Again, why protest at this notion.

You described her as overweight.

"the overweight women looked taken a back as she just wanted a coffee."

Is there a difference between overweight and fat?

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 10:15

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:00

I said a larger woman as in larger than the slim colleague.

Not technical terms no but culturally I think we all no there is a difference between skinny and slim. Again, why protest at this notion.

There is totally a difference between the adjectives skinny and slim. The latter is a compliment, the former definitely isn't and comes with all sorts of implications

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:15

Fimofriend · 12/07/2023 10:02

You get much more abuse from women when you are skinny than when you are fat whereas men appear to be equally nasty to fat and skinny women.

When I was underweight I usually knew when female class mates, coworkers etc went on a diet. Because then they pretty much wanted to kill me. Especially if they saw me eating my huge lunch.
I never commented on anyone's weight and we got along well when they weren't on a diet. I did distance myself from some of them while or after their diets, though. Some comments are unforgivable and when someone shows me who they are, I believe them.

Some of them lost quite a lot of their friends due to their behaviour while on a diet.

I think this is slightly paranoid, I mean do you really think that women on mass are so jealous of your 'big lunch' so all women, whatever age are thinking, 'what a bitch she is with her big lunch'. Yeah right. Reinforcing sexist stereotypes about women there really aren't you.

Bobski123 · 12/07/2023 10:12

I was very slim at 18 and I got so many whines of 'It's not fair!!' from friends. I wasn't doing anything special, I was just 18. I'm still slim now, but 1st heavier than when I was that age.

OP posts:
Fimofriend · 12/07/2023 10:02

You get much more abuse from women when you are skinny than when you are fat whereas men appear to be equally nasty to fat and skinny women.

When I was underweight I usually knew when female class mates, coworkers etc went on a diet. Because then they pretty much wanted to kill me. Especially if they saw me eating my huge lunch.
I never commented on anyone's weight and we got along well when they weren't on a diet. I did distance myself from some of them while or after their diets, though. Some comments are unforgivable and when someone shows me who they are, I believe them.

Some of them lost quite a lot of their friends due to their behaviour while on a diet.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:00

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:57

@Goldenbear You're being pretty finicky with your wording if you are claiming "overweight" isn't "fat".

Fat, skinny and slim are not technical terms. Most people would describe overweight as fat, you aren't only fat if you are 300lbs.

I said a larger woman as in larger than the slim colleague.

Not technical terms no but culturally I think we all no there is a difference between skinny and slim. Again, why protest at this notion.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:57

@Goldenbear You're being pretty finicky with your wording if you are claiming "overweight" isn't "fat".

Fat, skinny and slim are not technical terms. Most people would describe overweight as fat, you aren't only fat if you are 300lbs.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:56

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:37

This is the point though, apparently it is fine to discuss weight and make "throwaway comments" on someone else's body if you are fat, if you aren't and discuss weight then all of a sudden it's offensive.

Your overweight colleague should learn what is acceptable in the workplace. "I was I was skinny like X" is just unnecessary conversation at work.

And there it is again, of course the thin person had a 'very boring existence' because she can run 5k and doesn't overeat. Only fat people are vivacious, fun and live life. Yawn.

The colleague isn't skinny she is slim, it is a compliment and the slim colleague certainly took it as such and do you know why that is because despite your protestations, slim is desirable and overweight or even well covered is not.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:52

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:37

This is the point though, apparently it is fine to discuss weight and make "throwaway comments" on someone else's body if you are fat, if you aren't and discuss weight then all of a sudden it's offensive.

Your overweight colleague should learn what is acceptable in the workplace. "I was I was skinny like X" is just unnecessary conversation at work.

And there it is again, of course the thin person had a 'very boring existence' because she can run 5k and doesn't overeat. Only fat people are vivacious, fun and live life. Yawn.

She isn't skinny she's slim like 99% of us who do have the ALK gene she isn't naturally weight resistant, she was describing all the behaviour and purposeful things she does like 99% of us would have to do to be slim. Not everyone who does not do this stuff is fat though, the colleague wasn't fat I would say like most of us at the other end of the acceptable weight, like most of us who find it easy to put on weight with only small poor choices, she was just bigger than the slim colleague. Yes, the slim colleague did describe a very dull obsessive existence but probably didn't realise. My DD'S friends Mum is the same, she definitely doesn't realise it but the way she lives is much more focused on diet, exercise and going to bed very early to avoid eating I would imagine. Lots of cake making for other people but never eating it yourself. On the other hand sister in law doesn't deprive herself in her mind but behaviour like having your main meal at lunchtime not drinking, one chocolate for a treat a day are her living her life but obviously the purpose is to maintain healthy to low weight. If she didn't behave like this she would put on weight like 99% of us do easily.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:37

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:34

It was a throw away comment, she was getting a coffee befor a meeting, the colleague wasn't skinny she is slim. She definitely wasn't looking for a motivational talk. The thin colleague had totally misjudged and was really just trying to tell her how easy it is, except it isn't and her explanation did in all honesty sound like a very boring existence.

This is the point though, apparently it is fine to discuss weight and make "throwaway comments" on someone else's body if you are fat, if you aren't and discuss weight then all of a sudden it's offensive.

Your overweight colleague should learn what is acceptable in the workplace. "I was I was skinny like X" is just unnecessary conversation at work.

And there it is again, of course the thin person had a 'very boring existence' because she can run 5k and doesn't overeat. Only fat people are vivacious, fun and live life. Yawn.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:34

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:24

@Goldenbear The only comment I did hear at work was at the coffee making area where a larger women was lamenting the fact that she was loosing weight at such as slow rate and wishes she could look like her very slim colleague. The very slim colleague then proceeded to advise her how she could look like her with coach to 5k and macros talk(boring!), I was a real person al trainer style lecture and the overweight women looked taken a back as she just wanted a coffee. A male colleague picked up on this and commented, 'if only it was that easy'.

So a person complained that she wishes she looked like a particular skinny person, that skinny person then offers up advice on what she does for her lifestyle and is lamented over being "boring" and apparently out of line given how taken aback the overweight woman as she innocently "just wanted a coffee" even though she was the one who brought up losing weight and the skinny colleagues body specifically?

It was a throw away comment, she was getting a coffee befor a meeting, the colleague wasn't skinny she is slim. She definitely wasn't looking for a motivational talk. The thin colleague had totally misjudged and was really just trying to tell her how easy it is, except it isn't and her explanation did in all honesty sound like a very boring existence.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 09:33

Finlesswonder · 12/07/2023 09:30

Therefore someone saying ugh, you're too fat comes with so much more baggage than someone saying ugh, you're too thin.

That's not true.
The assumption if you're fat is that you're greedy or lazy.
The assumption if you're skinny is that you have MH problems, an eating disorder, or are overly concerned with your image

Yes, you said it far more succinctly than me!

PeaceGoodMercutio · 12/07/2023 09:32

It should be offensive to call a woman "skinny" in the same way it would be to say a man or a dog is "skinny" i.e too thin, but it isn't because of the way society is structured.
Women are taught implicitly and explicitly to shrink themselves in every sense possible; we physically see this in terms of the societal preoccupation with women being thin.
Women are rewarded for following the rules, and being thin is one of those rules.

Finlesswonder · 12/07/2023 09:30

Therefore someone saying ugh, you're too fat comes with so much more baggage than someone saying ugh, you're too thin.

That's not true.
The assumption if you're fat is that you're greedy or lazy.
The assumption if you're skinny is that you have MH problems, an eating disorder, or are overly concerned with your image

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:29

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:24

Yes, of course you can eat takeaway and drink wine as my SIL does once a week and is tiny. Like my DD's friend's Mum with disordered eating whose husband is incredibly stressed about it, she won't do this unless she has sufficiently exercised. With the fish and chips she hadn't managed to eat for 36hrs apparently, totally slipped her mind apparently 😐so she got this large takeaway. My SIL will eat a healthy takeaway without starving herself but she will eat small portions and would have gone for a run at least 3x that week. She is not excessive but it is disingenuous to say this is not purposeful as it is!

And you stated that you would put on weight if you didn't eat healthy most of the time and exercise whereas as my 16 year old son regularly eats a wrap, a double Whopper meal, chicken nuggets and cheese bites on the side in one sitting and then will want food again that is a big serving for dinner that is quite apart from all the snacks and he still doesn't put on weight, he doesn't do any purposeful exercise most days other than walking to a bus stop, occasionally playing football but now he has finished school that has happened. This is naturally skinny not what you are describing.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 09:29

Not sure why my comment further up came out all huge and bold. Didn't mean to shout!!

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 09:26

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:17

I mean I'm not doubting you but I know quite a few people, I'm in quite a few friendship groups, go to a workplace that is large and I've literally not herd anyone say these incredibly rude things to skinny people and the frankly shocking pinching of the arm skin, I can't believe how bold you'd have to be to do that.

The only comment I did hear at work was at the coffee making area where a larger women was lamenting the fact that she was loosing weight at such as slow rate and wishes she could look like her very slim colleague. The very slim colleague then proceeded to advise her how she could look like her with coach to 5k and macros talk(boring!), I was a real person al trainer style lecture and the overweight women looked taken a back as she just wanted a coffee. A male colleague picked up on this and commented, 'if only it was that easy'.

Right - well I guess a lot of it is to do with work culture, where you are in the country etc and, as I say, where I work now, it's very different and no-one would dream of making rude comments. People do talk about the diets they are on and a few are looking to lose weight but thankfully no-one sees fit to jump in and lecture them on their carb-free / couch to 5k success etc. But it's a small, supportive workplace and I can imagine it might not be the norm.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 09:26

I couldn't tell you what Z list celebrities answer about their diet, or how much they weigh

I do because it affects people's perceptions. So for a young woman who is struggling with her weight and hears thin celebrities say they eat loads and never go to the gym gives an unrealistic expectation and leaves an average person with a sense of failure. Why can they eat lots, never exercise and stay so thin and I can't? Also in terms of men, they are given the warped idea that therefore any woman who is not thin must be totally gluttonous..In reality, even small things such as a biscuit with your tea, an extra roast potato on your dinner can easily up your calories and see you creep into the overweight category.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:24

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:11

Don't know what it is and yet you've basically quoted the cool girl line word for word multiple times. Or did you just read someone else comment it before and memorise it without realising what it was?

You seriously don't think someone can drink wine and eat takeways and remain slim/skinny/whatever you want to call it?

All you are doing is adding to this BS rhetoric that you must be neurotic and obsessed with food and exercise to be skinny.

I'm skinny and have no problem drinking wine or eating takeaways and not gaining weight. Is that not the real world? Am I a work of fiction?

You gain weight based on what you eat over the course of a week and how much energy you burn. These comments like 'oh i just look at a takeway or a bar or chocolate and gain weight' are nonsense. You gain weight if you consume too much. It isn't witchcraft.

Yes, of course you can eat takeaway and drink wine as my SIL does once a week and is tiny. Like my DD's friend's Mum with disordered eating whose husband is incredibly stressed about it, she won't do this unless she has sufficiently exercised. With the fish and chips she hadn't managed to eat for 36hrs apparently, totally slipped her mind apparently 😐so she got this large takeaway. My SIL will eat a healthy takeaway without starving herself but she will eat small portions and would have gone for a run at least 3x that week. She is not excessive but it is disingenuous to say this is not purposeful as it is!

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:24

@Goldenbear The only comment I did hear at work was at the coffee making area where a larger women was lamenting the fact that she was loosing weight at such as slow rate and wishes she could look like her very slim colleague. The very slim colleague then proceeded to advise her how she could look like her with coach to 5k and macros talk(boring!), I was a real person al trainer style lecture and the overweight women looked taken a back as she just wanted a coffee. A male colleague picked up on this and commented, 'if only it was that easy'.

So a person complained that she wishes she looked like a particular skinny person, that skinny person then offers up advice on what she does for her lifestyle and is lamented over being "boring" and apparently out of line given how taken aback the overweight woman as she innocently "just wanted a coffee" even though she was the one who brought up losing weight and the skinny colleagues body specifically?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/07/2023 09:22

From experience, it may well stem from jealousy.

I only found out months after she started the rumour, that a so-called friend had been telling everyone I was anorexic.

I was* a size ten, certainly not painfully thin, and had never had an eating disorder - I just had a small appetite.
She was several sizes bigger and permanently on a diet she never stuck to.

Apparently she’d based it on the fact that I declined biscuits at her house (probably custard creams which I never liked anyway).

*NB was, I’m an awful lot older and somewhat fatter now.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:21

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 09:15

Well most people if they regularly ate takeaways and had bottle of wine a night would put on weight. One non greasy takeaway a month and a glass of wine a week won't.

But I'm talking extremes....very thin celebrities who apparently love pigging out. Its just not true. They are in reality being very careful with their diet. Its why I actually quite like Gwyneth Paltrow for being honest about what she eats.

Who is claiming to eat a takeway and a bottle of wine every night though?

You don't think that is an inference you are making because you hear someone say they have some wine and a takeway? If I say I drink wine and eat takeaways I obviously don't mean they sustain my entire life. Surely that is obvious?

Who even reads celebrity weight gossip in 2023?

Honestly your life would be much happier if you didn't read the daily mail sidebar or trash magazines.

I couldn't tell you what Z list celebrities answer about their diet, or how much they weigh.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 09:20

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 09:15

Well most people if they regularly ate takeaways and had bottle of wine a night would put on weight. One non greasy takeaway a month and a glass of wine a week won't.

But I'm talking extremes....very thin celebrities who apparently love pigging out. Its just not true. They are in reality being very careful with their diet. Its why I actually quite like Gwyneth Paltrow for being honest about what she eats.

Yes, agreed - I think it's problematic also to assume that everyone reacts the same to food. It would take a hell of a lot of takeaways for me to gain weight but I'm not the norm. I have plenty of friends who are extremely careful what they eat and yet still struggle to keep down to whatever is considered a healthy bmi. So neither assumptions i.e. that overweight people are surviving of takeaways and beer or that underweight people are counting out the number of almonds they eat for lunch are helpful

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:17

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 09:10

Exactly - endless comments about 'eating more cake' and how being thin as you get older is ageing etc. There's an underlying implication that you're vain and boring. Or people will sigh and say "I just like to enjoy life" as if you're not capable of having fun if you're skinny. I don't know anyone who would make personal comments about someone being overweight. Who knows maybe they say horrible things behind closed doors but, thankfully, I don't think it's socially acceptable to have a go about people's weight in public now if they are overweight. Hopefully we'll get to a point soon where people don't feel the need to comment on anyone's appearance in that way.

I mean I'm not doubting you but I know quite a few people, I'm in quite a few friendship groups, go to a workplace that is large and I've literally not herd anyone say these incredibly rude things to skinny people and the frankly shocking pinching of the arm skin, I can't believe how bold you'd have to be to do that.

The only comment I did hear at work was at the coffee making area where a larger women was lamenting the fact that she was loosing weight at such as slow rate and wishes she could look like her very slim colleague. The very slim colleague then proceeded to advise her how she could look like her with coach to 5k and macros talk(boring!), I was a real person al trainer style lecture and the overweight women looked taken a back as she just wanted a coffee. A male colleague picked up on this and commented, 'if only it was that easy'.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 09:15

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 09:11

Don't know what it is and yet you've basically quoted the cool girl line word for word multiple times. Or did you just read someone else comment it before and memorise it without realising what it was?

You seriously don't think someone can drink wine and eat takeways and remain slim/skinny/whatever you want to call it?

All you are doing is adding to this BS rhetoric that you must be neurotic and obsessed with food and exercise to be skinny.

I'm skinny and have no problem drinking wine or eating takeaways and not gaining weight. Is that not the real world? Am I a work of fiction?

You gain weight based on what you eat over the course of a week and how much energy you burn. These comments like 'oh i just look at a takeway or a bar or chocolate and gain weight' are nonsense. You gain weight if you consume too much. It isn't witchcraft.

Well most people if they regularly ate takeaways and had bottle of wine a night would put on weight. One non greasy takeaway a month and a glass of wine a week won't.

But I'm talking extremes....very thin celebrities who apparently love pigging out. Its just not true. They are in reality being very careful with their diet. Its why I actually quite like Gwyneth Paltrow for being honest about what she eats.