Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny shaming

439 replies

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

OP posts:
Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:56

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:52

Of course it does. Or do you think some of the people in the 64% of the adult population who are overweight or obese have purposefully tried really hard to be that way? Its a statistic. Its fact. You can't actually argue against it.

It is not a fact that everyone finds it "hard work" to be skinny. Just because that was your experience doesn't make it reality.

I would argue that most of those 64% simply over eat and drive too much therefore leading sedentary lives. Controversial but not untrue. There is piles of research suggesting genes don't override a healthy diet so the vast majority of overweight people could lose weight with a normal healthy diet.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:54

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:49

Well many thin women don't actually want to admit to working hard at it because they fear they will come across as vain. I remember a woman I knew who always said she was naturally thin....her lunch was iceberg lettuce. No dressing. Every single day. We'd all be naturally thin if we ate like that. But it gives, dare I say it, cool girl status. Oh I look good and I'm thin but I'm not vain and don't even have to try.

"Many thin women etc" and "I remember a woman I knew" who lived off iceberg lettuce. Like I say, stereotypes.

Do you really not know any thin people who eat normally?

Beezknees · 12/07/2023 11:54

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:49

Well many thin women don't actually want to admit to working hard at it because they fear they will come across as vain. I remember a woman I knew who always said she was naturally thin....her lunch was iceberg lettuce. No dressing. Every single day. We'd all be naturally thin if we ate like that. But it gives, dare I say it, cool girl status. Oh I look good and I'm thin but I'm not vain and don't even have to try.

I don't think it's that. It's probably because if they say they work out and eat well fat people will take it as a dig at them.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:52

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:47

Thats not the same as suggesting everyone finds it hard work to not be overweight just because you did.

Of course it does. Or do you think some of the people in the 64% of the adult population who are overweight or obese have purposefully tried really hard to be that way? Its a statistic. Its fact. You can't actually argue against it.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:49

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:45

At no point did I say the majority struggle to put on weight. But I also don't believe the majority of thin people work terribly hard at it and are always "very careful". Suggesting that, as I say, is just reinforcing negative stereotypes about thinness being boring/neurotic/self-obsessed/vain etc

Well many thin women don't actually want to admit to working hard at it because they fear they will come across as vain. I remember a woman I knew who always said she was naturally thin....her lunch was iceberg lettuce. No dressing. Every single day. We'd all be naturally thin if we ate like that. But it gives, dare I say it, cool girl status. Oh I look good and I'm thin but I'm not vain and don't even have to try.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:47

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:38

About 64% of the UK adult population is overweight or obese...so clearly majority of people don't struggle to put on weight. Thats just a statistic....not an opinion

Thats not the same as suggesting everyone finds it hard work to not be overweight just because you did.

Verv · 12/07/2023 11:46

Could it just be a poorly worded way of saying

"in order to demonstrate moving and handling it would be useful to use someone larger because moving someone small is easier and im trying to show you what to do in a circumstance that you are more likely to find yourself in"

?

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:45

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:33

Considering how much of the population is overweight or obese, I'd say vast majority of people don't struggle to put on weight.

At no point did I say the majority struggle to put on weight. But I also don't believe the majority of thin people work terribly hard at it and are always "very careful". Suggesting that, as I say, is just reinforcing negative stereotypes about thinness being boring/neurotic/self-obsessed/vain etc

AliceOlive · 12/07/2023 11:40

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 11:21

What, if someone said this to me I wouldn't think it was an insult. I think it's funny that you have made the assumption that I would not know what that is like- I have been complimented on my skinniness and looks guess what even when I was at the upper end of BMI (I know what you are thinking, unbelievable) in 40s and still get compliments. Chatted up loads in my 20s and 30s, can't say it felt that bad/good I was indifferent about it, a bit annoying sometimes when I was a bar person. My DH complimented me on my face after about 10 mins of chatting to him. I'm still with him 16 years later, I honestly didn't think to myself he is coming from a bad place.

Did your husband say “I wish I looked like you?”

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:38

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:36

You seem to think your experience is the rule of the land and no one could possibly differ.

You found it incredibly hard work to not put weight on, you find it worse to if an insult is about being fat rather than skinny.

Your experience is not universal.

About 64% of the UK adult population is overweight or obese...so clearly majority of people don't struggle to put on weight. Thats just a statistic....not an opinion

TheoTheopolis23 · 12/07/2023 11:38

Goldenbear · 11/07/2023 22:52

The fallacy, I mean you can review the research yourself. The 1% is those out of the 44,000 sample size didn't have this gene. It isn't a fallacy it is a fact that this what they found.

You seem incredibly obtuse.

You are completely fixated a out this1% gene.

People are talking about the variants in the other 99% of people - who are not all overweight. You don't seem to be able to grasp that at all.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:36

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:12

Absolute nonsense. I've been thin before. It was hard work and I had to be very careful not to put weight on.

You seem to think your experience is the rule of the land and no one could possibly differ.

You found it incredibly hard work to not put weight on, you find it worse to if an insult is about being fat rather than skinny.

Your experience is not universal.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:33

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:29

But everyone's bodies are different. I genuinely find it hard to put on weight. Some of my friends and family are the opposite and find it very hard to lose weight. Many people are somewhere in between and don't really have to think about food very much. So it's possible to:

  • eat normally and struggle to lose weight
  • eat normally and struggle to gain weight
  • eat normally and more or less stay the same weight
Assumptions and personal comments about people who are either overweight or underweight are really unhelpful. Comments implying that being thin is 'hard work' and requires being 'very careful' just play into stereotypes

Considering how much of the population is overweight or obese, I'd say vast majority of people don't struggle to put on weight.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:29

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:12

Absolute nonsense. I've been thin before. It was hard work and I had to be very careful not to put weight on.

But everyone's bodies are different. I genuinely find it hard to put on weight. Some of my friends and family are the opposite and find it very hard to lose weight. Many people are somewhere in between and don't really have to think about food very much. So it's possible to:

  • eat normally and struggle to lose weight
  • eat normally and struggle to gain weight
  • eat normally and more or less stay the same weight
Assumptions and personal comments about people who are either overweight or underweight are really unhelpful. Comments implying that being thin is 'hard work' and requires being 'very careful' just play into stereotypes
Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 11:26

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:19

Well, I guess we'll have to agree to differ. Have to admit I'd never come across the Skinny food Co who I've just looked up. I mean, they do make a point of saying on their website: "When we say Skinny, we’re talking about our food. Skinny because of the sugar we take away. Skinny because of the calories we reduce down to virtually zero. That’s the only Skinny we care about."

But I'm sure you'll say that's just talk / box ticking etc, and maybe that's right. I still think that in the context of marketing products skinny is generally shorthand for low in calories. I honestly don't think people drink 'skinny beer' because they aspiring to be skinny any more than people buying 'fat bastard burritos' etc...

But I 100% stand by the statement that describing someone as skinny is not a compliment whereas slim is.

I'm not suggesting they are wanting to be skinny, well even if they are they are not realists as mostly not attainable by 99% of us. But the word doesn't have all these negative connotations when it comes to weight, if it did why not just use 'slim' you still haven't suggested why the word is chosen at all? You say because it is used to explain the low calorie element but slim can be used.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 11:21

AliceOlive · 12/07/2023 11:09

It sounds like a passive-aggressive comment and the woman whose body was being discussed wasn’t putting up with it.

It’s never nice when someone says things like “I wish I was like…” about someone standing right there It never comes from a good place. It never feels good to hear it.

What, if someone said this to me I wouldn't think it was an insult. I think it's funny that you have made the assumption that I would not know what that is like- I have been complimented on my skinniness and looks guess what even when I was at the upper end of BMI (I know what you are thinking, unbelievable) in 40s and still get compliments. Chatted up loads in my 20s and 30s, can't say it felt that bad/good I was indifferent about it, a bit annoying sometimes when I was a bar person. My DH complimented me on my face after about 10 mins of chatting to him. I'm still with him 16 years later, I honestly didn't think to myself he is coming from a bad place.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:19

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:55

It is absolutely not just about the calories the drink contains, if it was, surely it would be marketed with another name, it isn't like there aren't any to chose from, I mean if slim is categorically better than skinny as you arguing why not choose slim. When you are marketing a product it is not just about a literal description, it's the aspirational elements that are going to sell many of them. There is Skinny Food co, there is 'Skinny lager', 'Skinny cow ice cream', if it was an offensive word, that no one saw as a compliment then I'm not sure why you would think any of these products would sell. After all it makes you think of being 'skinny' if you buy this food and drink and who wants to be that 🙄im sorry but this is disingenuous.

Well, I guess we'll have to agree to differ. Have to admit I'd never come across the Skinny food Co who I've just looked up. I mean, they do make a point of saying on their website: "When we say Skinny, we’re talking about our food. Skinny because of the sugar we take away. Skinny because of the calories we reduce down to virtually zero. That’s the only Skinny we care about."

But I'm sure you'll say that's just talk / box ticking etc, and maybe that's right. I still think that in the context of marketing products skinny is generally shorthand for low in calories. I honestly don't think people drink 'skinny beer' because they aspiring to be skinny any more than people buying 'fat bastard burritos' etc...

But I 100% stand by the statement that describing someone as skinny is not a compliment whereas slim is.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:12

WorldCuppa · 12/07/2023 11:00

I agree OP. Also as a slim person it’s very hard to put on weight, whereas if you’re fat you just need to cut down on the calories

Absolute nonsense. I've been thin before. It was hard work and I had to be very careful not to put weight on.

AliceOlive · 12/07/2023 11:09

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 09:34

It was a throw away comment, she was getting a coffee befor a meeting, the colleague wasn't skinny she is slim. She definitely wasn't looking for a motivational talk. The thin colleague had totally misjudged and was really just trying to tell her how easy it is, except it isn't and her explanation did in all honesty sound like a very boring existence.

It sounds like a passive-aggressive comment and the woman whose body was being discussed wasn’t putting up with it.

It’s never nice when someone says things like “I wish I was like…” about someone standing right there It never comes from a good place. It never feels good to hear it.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 11:09

WorldCuppa · 12/07/2023 11:00

I agree OP. Also as a slim person it’s very hard to put on weight, whereas if you’re fat you just need to cut down on the calories

Well yes if you are one of the 1% that have an absence of the ALK gene that is resistant to weight gain but if you are like 99% of us it is actually very easy to put on weight and a lot harder to lose it!

WorldCuppa · 12/07/2023 11:00

I agree OP. Also as a slim person it’s very hard to put on weight, whereas if you’re fat you just need to cut down on the calories

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:55

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 10:29

Not a relevant comparison. In that context, skinny is a reflection of the calories in it. I agree with much of what you've said above but the idea that 'skinny' is universally a compliment is nuts. "You're looking a bit skinny", "skinny bitch" etc The implication is that you're just skin on bone. Def not flattering. People, as a compliment, might say "ooh you look lovely and slim" - they'd never say "ooh you look lovely and skinny".

It is absolutely not just about the calories the drink contains, if it was, surely it would be marketed with another name, it isn't like there aren't any to chose from, I mean if slim is categorically better than skinny as you arguing why not choose slim. When you are marketing a product it is not just about a literal description, it's the aspirational elements that are going to sell many of them. There is Skinny Food co, there is 'Skinny lager', 'Skinny cow ice cream', if it was an offensive word, that no one saw as a compliment then I'm not sure why you would think any of these products would sell. After all it makes you think of being 'skinny' if you buy this food and drink and who wants to be that 🙄im sorry but this is disingenuous.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 10:32

https://www.thefreedictionary.com/skinny

a. Having very little bodily flesh or fat, often unattractively so; very thin.

skinny

Definition, Synonyms, Translations of skinny by The Free Dictionary

https://www.thefreedictionary.com/skinny

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 10:29

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:23

I don't agree, I don't think in any way you can say that is an absolute and it is offensive. 'Skinny' has positive connotations and is desired hence why it is used in marketing products e.g 'Skinny Latte' why not call it 'slim Latte' if what you are saying is true pretty poor marketing choice, not going to sell many of the there is no desirability around the word.

Not a relevant comparison. In that context, skinny is a reflection of the calories in it. I agree with much of what you've said above but the idea that 'skinny' is universally a compliment is nuts. "You're looking a bit skinny", "skinny bitch" etc The implication is that you're just skin on bone. Def not flattering. People, as a compliment, might say "ooh you look lovely and slim" - they'd never say "ooh you look lovely and skinny".

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 10:23

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 10:15

There is totally a difference between the adjectives skinny and slim. The latter is a compliment, the former definitely isn't and comes with all sorts of implications

I don't agree, I don't think in any way you can say that is an absolute and it is offensive. 'Skinny' has positive connotations and is desired hence why it is used in marketing products e.g 'Skinny Latte' why not call it 'slim Latte' if what you are saying is true pretty poor marketing choice, not going to sell many of the there is no desirability around the word.

Swipe left for the next trending thread