Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny shaming

439 replies

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

OP posts:
Raindropbattle · 12/07/2023 12:44

Commenting on people's bodies is sensitive and has so much potential for offense it's best avoided wherever possible. For example I was complimented on my weight loss/ appearance a few times during and after pregnancy because I had lost a lot of weight because of hyperemesis. My FIL even said to my DH that I'd needed to lose weight anyway. It was one of the worst times of my life and I felt the most unhealthy and miserable I'd ever been and got quite upset about being told I looked great when actually my face was sunken and I couldn't stop vomiting up water or anything I'd managed to eat a tiny bit of. I had no muscles or strength and was feeling really isolated as I'd been stuck in bed so much. It felt like people didn't care about my wellbeing and my looks are what they thought mattered, I'd always rather someone asked me how I was doing than commented on my figure.

Mble · 12/07/2023 12:43

In the past I’ve been told that I was too thin, too good looking, too young looking. I enjoyed every single one of those comments. Just take it as a compliment and don’t get offended, or don’t and feel bad about it. It is up to you.

NameChange245 · 12/07/2023 12:39

The best compliment I have ever had was when I over heard a conversation between two men (my age at the time, long time ago!) and one said they were quite attracted to me. The other said "oh no, not for me, she's way too skinny". For someone who always thought they were fat, hearing that someone thought I was skinny was the absolute best compliment I'd ever had!! Even though it wasn't meant as one!

Appreciate this is a bit messed up! But as someone who's always struggled with diets as always thought they were fat, being called skinny was truly my dream (won't happen again as I am quite big now!!) And still is!

It's all about perception. I'd love to be skinny. Id hate to be called fat. Some people would hate to be called skinny. Don't know many people who would dream of being called fat, but sure there are some

It's up to us how we react to comments. It's how we perceive them that matters. Don't like your reaction to a comment? Work on changing your reaction?

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 12:34

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 12:19

As we've established, a significant percentage of the population are overweight - obviously there'll be a lucrative diet industry. But that doesn't mean everyone who is thin is punishing themselves in order to be that way.

Honestly, I think you have some really deeply ingrained prejudice when it comes to thin women (I haven't heard you mention men). There's just no point me telling you that many many thin people just eat a fairly reasonable diet and exercise a bit but don't think very much about it because you've got an idea in your head that the only way to be thin bar a few vanishingly rare exceptions is to live off lettuce while claiming to eat burgers and pizzas every night or whatever. It's like me saying "well, people say they find it hard to lose weight but I just see overweight people living off donuts and burgers". It's offensive and just plain untrue in the vast majority of cases.

ComedyCook is not suggesting that at all, she is making the obvious point backed up by statistics that it is easier to put on weight than it is to lose it as is the propensity of 99% of the country! Of course there are variants in that but in the 99% of the population they are factual environmental factors! If you are the 1% then they will not be.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 12:34

maddening · 12/07/2023 12:30

Calories are not equal for all - just like the naturally thin there are people genetically, clinically and medically overweight beyond your simple just eat less and move more brigade - just like those that cannot put weight on easily there are those that can't lose it easily.

The bottom line is - do not comment on other people's bodies unless you are asked personally or professionally.

And "most overweight people" do not think as a single hive mind fwiw.

The poster I was replying to was the one who stated "most overweight people wanted to be a healthy weight", not me.

I agree, I don't think you should comment on anyone's body to them. I don't think it is one rule for fat and one rule for thin, people can be just as nasty in both directions.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 12:32

@Goldenbear making one comment about how older women in the office would refer to a pretty calorie heavy salad as "rabbit food" makes me "very health conscious"?
In what way is anything in my comment a judgemental remark when the people being judgemental are the ones referring to my lunch as rabbit good?
No clue what you are moaning about popcorn, I haven't mentioned it.

I mean, do you honestly think you are naturally thin

I have never said this, in fact I think ultimately everyone is under the same physiological conditions and will weight less if they eat less and weigh more if the at more.
I'm sure if I suddenly ate twice as much in a day I would be bigger. However that doesn't mean I obsessively go to the gym or count calories all day. I don't even own scales.
I just eat what I want and know what is a good portion for my body type.

I could lose weight quite easily under 40
Honestly I've heard countless versions of this and ultimately its just still diet and lifestyle but they don't want to acknowledge it.

People love to do this as a weird sort of one up mans-hip when you are thin.
'oh I was thin when I was 20 ... but now'
'oh I was thin too ... until I had kids!'
'oh I was thin until I hit 30'
'oh I was thin until I hit 40... it'll happen to you too'
Okay cook. None of those things have happened yet because having kids or hitting a certain age doesn't magically make you fat unless you overeat for your BMR, which ultimately goes down if you are less active. So if you hit 40 and become less active you will need to eat less. It doesn't mean you gain more based on your age.

maddening · 12/07/2023 12:30

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 12:07

It isn't objectively hard to eat less though. I thought most overweight people always go on about being happy with their size? If most overweight people wanted to get to a healthier weight then it isn't complicated to do it.

Calories are not equal for all - just like the naturally thin there are people genetically, clinically and medically overweight beyond your simple just eat less and move more brigade - just like those that cannot put weight on easily there are those that can't lose it easily.

The bottom line is - do not comment on other people's bodies unless you are asked personally or professionally.

And "most overweight people" do not think as a single hive mind fwiw.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 12:21

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:58

As her only lunch every day.

Honestly people used to make comments like this if I had a salad when I worked in a big office. A salad with loads of oil dressing, avocado, nuts, cheese, maybe some fish. Its telling that many people look at a meal like that and have the never to call it 'rabbit food' while moaning about being overweight.

You are depicting an image of being very health conscious especially when you make judgemental remarks like this. Your anecdote about the popcorn and coconut sugar or something like that. I mean, do you honestly think you are naturally thin. It sounds very much like your very good habits keep you thin. I could lose weight quite easily under 40 just but dropping eating a whole pizza or something like that, I would be thin and it was easily maintainable, I don't need to eat salads and healthy popcorn. I am a stone overweight in early 40s and it is no longer a question of stopping eating pizza, it is not that easy at all. It is certainly not as easy as piling on the pounds if I actually ate lots of calorie dense food and I am like many people who are in the same boat. I'm unsure why you are being insincere about this.

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 12:19

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:57

I knew one girl at uni who was very slim and genuinely ate a lot. The other thin women I know work at it and are careful with their food intake.

I mean look at the diet industry. It wouldn't be so lucrative if people found it easy to be thin.

As we've established, a significant percentage of the population are overweight - obviously there'll be a lucrative diet industry. But that doesn't mean everyone who is thin is punishing themselves in order to be that way.

Honestly, I think you have some really deeply ingrained prejudice when it comes to thin women (I haven't heard you mention men). There's just no point me telling you that many many thin people just eat a fairly reasonable diet and exercise a bit but don't think very much about it because you've got an idea in your head that the only way to be thin bar a few vanishingly rare exceptions is to live off lettuce while claiming to eat burgers and pizzas every night or whatever. It's like me saying "well, people say they find it hard to lose weight but I just see overweight people living off donuts and burgers". It's offensive and just plain untrue in the vast majority of cases.

AliceOlive · 12/07/2023 12:13

Suspect we all have different definitions of “very thin”.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 12:10

TheoTheopolis23 · 12/07/2023 11:38

You seem incredibly obtuse.

You are completely fixated a out this1% gene.

People are talking about the variants in the other 99% of people - who are not all overweight. You don't seem to be able to grasp that at all.

I absolutely do understand the variants in the 99% from fat to very thin but that doesn't take away the fact that the very thin in the 99% is attributed to environmental factors not their literal resistance to putting on weight. You seem to actually be the one that has difficulty comprehending this, maybe you want to believe that you are doing zero to stay very thin and of course that may be true but on the otherhand the probability of being in that 1% is unlikely. Anecdotally, I don't know any woman that is in the skinny percent and can eat as much as she wants and do little to no exercise. I just don't and that isn't particularly surprising as the chances are so slim. I do know very thin women that practice certain habits, that are mindful of eating habits, that exercise regularly or the other extreme because they have an eating disorder. They are the only very thin women I know.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 12:10

Have you never heard of the obesogenic society?

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 12:09

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 12:07

It isn't objectively hard to eat less though. I thought most overweight people always go on about being happy with their size? If most overweight people wanted to get to a healthier weight then it isn't complicated to do it.

Well the concept is not difficult to understand but in practice it clearly isn't that easy

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 12:07

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 12:05

That doesn't mean it is hard to not overeat

Most people would prefer to be a healthy weight than overweight yet they're not ..so they must find it hard.

It isn't objectively hard to eat less though. I thought most overweight people always go on about being happy with their size? If most overweight people wanted to get to a healthier weight then it isn't complicated to do it.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 12:05

That doesn't mean it is hard to not overeat

Most people would prefer to be a healthy weight than overweight yet they're not ..so they must find it hard.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 12:03

just how there are thin women out there who eat cheeseburgers, drink beer and don't do any exercise

And how strange it is that if you eat like that and don't put on weight you are seen as morally superior compared to someone who eats like that but is overweight.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 12:03

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:58

I didn't say everyone finds it hard work to be skinny, there's always outliers to every trend. But, the fact that the majority of the population is overweight tells us that most people don't struggle to put on weight.

I don't think the vast majority of people, skinny or overweight, struggle to put weight on.
Slimmer people are like that for the most part because they don't overeat compared to their BMR, most overweight people do overeat compared to their BMR. For the majority of society it is that simple. That doesn't mean it is hard to not overeat or that skinny people are consumed with this 'hard work' to not get fat.

People only struggle to lose weight because a, they are used to overeating and struggle to adjust to what their body actually needs at a more health size, b, start faddy diets which don't teach them a reasonable balance of nutrition and portion sizes so when they stop the fad they gain weight because they eat like they did before.

Goldenbear · 12/07/2023 12:01

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:29

But everyone's bodies are different. I genuinely find it hard to put on weight. Some of my friends and family are the opposite and find it very hard to lose weight. Many people are somewhere in between and don't really have to think about food very much. So it's possible to:

  • eat normally and struggle to lose weight
  • eat normally and struggle to gain weight
  • eat normally and more or less stay the same weight
Assumptions and personal comments about people who are either overweight or underweight are really unhelpful. Comments implying that being thin is 'hard work' and requires being 'very careful' just play into stereotypes

It's not stereotypes it is a fact as being very thin (as opposed to slim) would be very hard - hard for the 99% of people to achieve as unlike the 1% who don't have AKL gene they are not resistant to putting on weight. Being skinny in that context is a purposeful objective, it takes work to be underweight or environmental factors but you are Not naturally underweight. Whereas to be overweight doesn't take much effort at all for 99% of the population. They are not equal in their meaning.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 12:01

Finlesswonder · 12/07/2023 11:56

I don't believe for a second you ever saw a woman eating only iceberg lettuce

I did. She had a figure like a catwalk mode.

Finlesswonder · 12/07/2023 12:00

I think the narrative that thin women must not eat a lot exists so that the others can feel better about themselves, aka "she may be thin but I bet she's miserable and depriving herself constantly, so at least I win on that level".

It's like the other baffling trope, that rich people must be unhappy, "money doesn't buy you happiness", which I've always found so weird (disclaimer, I'm not wealthy at all). I mean, it may be annoying to think it, but there are probably a hell of a lot of rich people out there who are also very fulfilled and loved and living great lives, just how there are thin women out there who eat cheeseburgers, drink beer and don't do any exercise.

I'm sorry if that's depressing, but life isn't fair

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 12:00

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:58

As her only lunch every day.

Honestly people used to make comments like this if I had a salad when I worked in a big office. A salad with loads of oil dressing, avocado, nuts, cheese, maybe some fish. Its telling that many people look at a meal like that and have the never to call it 'rabbit food' while moaning about being overweight.

That's a proper meal. I mean she literally filled a tupperware box with plain shredded iceberg lettuce every day and ate it like that

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:58

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:56

It is not a fact that everyone finds it "hard work" to be skinny. Just because that was your experience doesn't make it reality.

I would argue that most of those 64% simply over eat and drive too much therefore leading sedentary lives. Controversial but not untrue. There is piles of research suggesting genes don't override a healthy diet so the vast majority of overweight people could lose weight with a normal healthy diet.

I didn't say everyone finds it hard work to be skinny, there's always outliers to every trend. But, the fact that the majority of the population is overweight tells us that most people don't struggle to put on weight.

Peacoffee · 12/07/2023 11:58

Finlesswonder · 12/07/2023 11:56

I don't believe for a second you ever saw a woman eating only iceberg lettuce

As her only lunch every day.

Honestly people used to make comments like this if I had a salad when I worked in a big office. A salad with loads of oil dressing, avocado, nuts, cheese, maybe some fish. Its telling that many people look at a meal like that and have the never to call it 'rabbit food' while moaning about being overweight.

Comedycook · 12/07/2023 11:57

Poseidensgrumpyneighbour · 12/07/2023 11:54

"Many thin women etc" and "I remember a woman I knew" who lived off iceberg lettuce. Like I say, stereotypes.

Do you really not know any thin people who eat normally?

I knew one girl at uni who was very slim and genuinely ate a lot. The other thin women I know work at it and are careful with their food intake.

I mean look at the diet industry. It wouldn't be so lucrative if people found it easy to be thin.

Finlesswonder · 12/07/2023 11:56

I don't believe for a second you ever saw a woman eating only iceberg lettuce