Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skinny shaming

439 replies

Bobski123 · 10/07/2023 20:40

I was doing some moving and handling training for part of my job. The trainer required a volunteer, I offered and she said "Oh no not you, you're far too skinny."
She then chose a larger lady.
I get it's supposed to be some sort of compliment because being thin is 'desirable'.
However if she'd said "Not you, you're far too fat." She'd possibly be out of a job by now.
However it's ok to say the opposite.
I should've responded really.
It's like that meme going around with a picture of Sophia Loren and the caption "I'd rather eat pizza and drink wine than be a size 0."
A few of my colleagues posted it and I just think, yawn. They aren't mutually exclusive, ok, size 0 is very small but the point is you can enjoy pizza, wine whatever and still remain slim. I'm just over it.

OP posts:
Bobski123 · 11/07/2023 08:46

We are sorry you've suffered fat shaming, it's wrong. But how dare you tell us that we have no right to feel upset about shaming in the other way, and almost implying that we should accept it. Disgusting attitude.

OP posts:
NomDe · 11/07/2023 08:46

Darkmodeison · 11/07/2023 08:41

It was me that said I was called a bag of bones, honestly how dare you try and undermine how awful it made me feel. I felt like a freak and I still do sometimes, honest to god you have no idea...

Love how this poster, in the same breath as insisting only fat-shaming is bad, also made a bitchy comment about someone being bigger than they think they are. 🫤

Darkmodeison · 11/07/2023 08:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It was me that said I was called a bag of bones, honestly how dare you try and undermine how awful it made me feel. I felt like a freak and I still do sometimes, honest to god you have no idea...

M340 · 11/07/2023 08:40

Peacoffee · 10/07/2023 21:35

God do fat people really think they hold the monopoly on being insulted or having someone be rude about their size?

’bag of bones’
’real men love curves’
’looks like a little boy’
’eat a burger?’
’you must be anorexic’

These are all insulting comments said to purposely be insulting.

Exactly!

Body shaming is body shaming.

Don't be greedy here claiming that being Insulted because you're too fat is worse than being insulted because you're too skinny.

It's probably because most fat people don't want to be fat, so the easy option is to victimise themselves and think it's okay to body shame a skinny person as they have it easier.

Whatever your weight, you shouldn't be body shamed. It's not just for fat people.

snoopysaunt · 11/07/2023 08:36

If you are giving correct manual handling training, your weight should be immaterial surely?

Itsallsostressful · 11/07/2023 08:33

LorraineInSpain · 10/07/2023 21:32

If it was manual handling training, perhaps they needed someone over a certain weight to actually train people to do it properly? I know those of us who were larger were always approached to be evacuation chair “riders” because they needed to make sure that the volunteers could use the chair for anyone who needed it.

So it might have been practical, not “skinny shaming”.

They could have phrased it differently then....something like 'sorry you'd be too light'. That would have been better

NomDe · 11/07/2023 08:27

chocolatemademefat · 11/07/2023 08:18

Try obesity for a week and tell me being skinny bothers you. 🤷🏼‍♀️

It’s not about whether being ‘underweight’ bothers someone more than being ‘overweight’ bothers someone else, it’s about the fact that commenting on other people’s bodies is inappropriate and unpleasant, whoever the person is and whatever you think of their body.

Anything else is just legitimising body-shaming in general.

snoopysaunt · 11/07/2023 08:24

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/07/2023 20:47

There'll never be a meme saying 'I'd rather live on lettuce and water than be a size 20."

Because the entire weight of the media is set up that way, you don't need memes.

No one should comment but there is massive evidence that thinner people get treated better most of the time. It's all a bit, "my diamond shoes are uncomfortable".

Isn't it more like "my trainers are worn out because I run most days and go to the gym to keep my weight healthy"

I don't care if people want to be fat but don't kid yourself that people who are not generally work at it, except for circumstances where they can't which is obviously different. But because I want to be a size 10 and feel better for it, should I be made to feel that I am the freak?

Wobblybobble · 11/07/2023 08:23

People feel like it’s okay because this is more socially aspirational than fat, but it is never okay to comment on someone else’s looks, especially if it’s a negative comment.

One of the most hurtful comments I’ve ever received happened at a public pool when a friend and I took our children together. It went along the lines of, “Wow, you’re like my niece who is also really skinny but doesn’t do much exercise. I guess even skinny people can be flabby and have cellulite!”

Like, what??

chocolatemademefat · 11/07/2023 08:18

Try obesity for a week and tell me being skinny bothers you. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Sunsetandsunrise · 11/07/2023 08:13

NannyGythaOgg · 10/07/2023 22:45

It is, to me, a bit like white privilege or male privilege. (I have the first but not the second)

When you are white you don't realise the challenges facing non white people

When you are male, you don't realise the challenges women face

When you have only ever been slim you don't realise the challenges overweight people face

I've been slim and I've been very overweight. I've had negative comments when slim but nothing like the judgement and negativity I have got from men, women, medical people and just in general I got when I was big.

It's not nice, none of us has the right to judge others (walk a mile in my shoes) but I can pretty well guarantee that the comments you get are either jealousy or an acknowledgement that you don't have the issues (both living and judging) that overweight people do. Especially those who are very overweight.

Exactly this. I’ve been fat and skinny and it’s a no-brainer about what group gets the most toxicity and negativity which literally impact their life.

IkeaMeatballGravy · 11/07/2023 08:12

Looks beginning to fade at mid 30s!? That's a sad outlook, have you been made to feel insecure by a certain type of shitty man?

Not at all, when I mean looks, I mean youthful looks. I'm starting to get lines that weren't there before, my chin is starting to sag, pregnancy has left reminders on my body. But I'm embracing the changes, I won't go under the knife or get fillers etc. I'm happy with the way I am.

ShiteRider · 11/07/2023 08:11

Peacoffee · 11/07/2023 07:16

Maybe the reason you get called a cunt isn’t because you are fat…

😂😂😂. Very eloquent

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 08:02

Sweetashunni · 11/07/2023 00:12

I suffered a series of personal tragedies as a teen, I was naturally slim but the pain and sorrow made it very hard for me to eat and I became very very thin. I remember a friend frogmarching me to our school canteen and watching over me as I ate a plate of macaroni cheese because she was so worried I was starving myself to death. People made constant comments, including teachers, about how ill I looked and it just made a shit time even worse. I felt very weak and tired and would’ve loved nothing more than to click my fingers and gain a couple of stone but it just wasn’t happening. I really wish people would realise skinny shaming isn’t a backhanded compliment, it can be really hurtful. The Duchess of Cambridge thread the other day was vile and full of nasty little comments which clearly posters felt entitled to make as ‘it’s not as bad this way round’.

Totally agree with this.
As mentioned above, I’ve always been slim and when I am anxious or depressed, I lose my appetite and can’t eat. I then worry about the weight loss which makes me feel worse. And then people comment on it which makes me feel worse.
Youre just trying to get through to day, because you’re having a really tough time and Tracey or whoever from the office is like “you could do with eating more, you’re way too skinny”
And I’m like “yeah thanks Tracey, just dealing with a separation from my emotionally abusive husband but I’ll get on that next”
🤦‍♀️

FuckOffTom · 11/07/2023 07:57

Haven’t RTFT but I completely agree OP!
I’ve always been slim and by god have I had some nasty comments
made at me practically my whole life. I’m not even underweight - I’m 5’7” and about 9 and a half stone and yet have to hear things like

“You are way too skinny”
”you need a few hot meals”
“you gonna throw that up after you’ve eaten it?”

And yet I’ve never heard a bad word said to the face of an overweight person (although I’m not disputing that it happens)

Just stop commenting on people’s appearances, unless it’s a simple “you look nice” ?!!

Peacoffee · 11/07/2023 07:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Maybe the reason you get called a cunt isn’t because you are fat…

iloveeverykindofcat · 11/07/2023 06:28

I find it pretty shocking that anyone would comment on someone's body in a public setting, let alone a work setting. I thought that was pretty clearly unacceptable by now.

So, I have ARFID, and the upshot is that I was a chubby kid/teen and then became underweight as an adult (both can be a result of a limited range of safe foods). When I was younger, there was definitely more comment on my body. Nowadays it seems to be pretty unacceptable either way, as it should be. The only person who ocassionally might comment is my mother, who will say things like 'you like thin and tired' - a bit blunt, but it comes from a place of concern for my mental health, so I try not to take it badly. If someone at a work event commented on my body I'd be gobsmacked, and they'd probably be facing a disciplinary.

Anyotherdude · 11/07/2023 06:18

“There'll never be a meme saying 'I'd rather live on lettuce and water than be a size 20."
That’s where you are wrong. Kate Moss was crucified in the press some years ago when she wore a T-shirt with the slogan “Nothing tastes as good as skinny feels”
YANBU though - the trainer was rude. You can be both skinny and strong, or fat and strong, but she was implying you were a weakling because of your size.

Nordicrain · 11/07/2023 06:16

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/07/2023 20:47

There'll never be a meme saying 'I'd rather live on lettuce and water than be a size 20."

Because the entire weight of the media is set up that way, you don't need memes.

No one should comment but there is massive evidence that thinner people get treated better most of the time. It's all a bit, "my diamond shoes are uncomfortable".

Exactly. No memes are saying it because it's more or less being pushed as real diet advice. Fasting diets, ultra low calorie diets, etc.

And the Sophia Loren one is to hit back at diet culture, surely. Most people can't stay a size 0 and eat pizza and wine, that's just fact, and the post is the social media push back to all the pressure to do that. If you can, well done.

Look OP, the comment calling you skinny was rude. It's not ok to body shame anyone, or a specific body type, with you 100%. But otherwise I think you are trying to find offense where there is none.

ShiteRider · 11/07/2023 06:10

EggWind · 10/07/2023 22:51

It frustrates me that so many women think lifting heavy weights will make you bulky. In reality, being sedentary is more likely to have this effect IME. We just don't have enough testosterone to get jacked like men do.

I know this is not the point of the thread but most weights workouts do make me bulky. I’m an hourglass shape naturally but when I do weights I lose my waist and my thighs bet bigger. I’ve discovered that Pilates and Barre won’t do that to me so stick with that.

I’ve been told so many times that it won’t happen but every time it does.

QueefQueen80s · 11/07/2023 00:23

IkeaMeatballGravy · 10/07/2023 21:56

I was very slim in my late teens/early 20's, but I was very unaware of my figure and looks. I was an anxious mess at the time so any comments about my body really hit me hard and disappointingly it was often other women who were the nastiest.

I'm in my mid 30s, very overweight and my looks are beginning to fade. The difference being that age and experience have bought confidence I didn't have before. I have had comments about my size, but I honestly couldn't give a shit.

Skinny shaming is absolutely as bad as fat shaming, but it seems to be more socially acceptable to skinny shame someone. It's never OK to make comments about someone's body, you never know how it may hurt someone.

Looks beginning to fade at mid 30s!? That's a sad outlook, have you been made to feel insecure by a certain type of shitty man?

Sweetashunni · 11/07/2023 00:12

I suffered a series of personal tragedies as a teen, I was naturally slim but the pain and sorrow made it very hard for me to eat and I became very very thin. I remember a friend frogmarching me to our school canteen and watching over me as I ate a plate of macaroni cheese because she was so worried I was starving myself to death. People made constant comments, including teachers, about how ill I looked and it just made a shit time even worse. I felt very weak and tired and would’ve loved nothing more than to click my fingers and gain a couple of stone but it just wasn’t happening. I really wish people would realise skinny shaming isn’t a backhanded compliment, it can be really hurtful. The Duchess of Cambridge thread the other day was vile and full of nasty little comments which clearly posters felt entitled to make as ‘it’s not as bad this way round’.

SheilaWilde · 11/07/2023 00:07

Skinny shaming is not ok.
It's rude, it's ignorant and it's hurtful. But this thread is a case in point that many people think it's ok because their goal is to be 'skinny'.
I have a BMI of about 15. I weight just over 6st. I have always been 'underweight' and I have always been called names. As a child and as an adult. I don't exercise, I seem to eat a fair amount but I find it very, very hard to put on weight. I'm constantly on a reverse diet - I count calories to try and make sure I eat enough. I aim to eat more than to just 'maintain' so I can add weight but it's really difficult. What I eat at work is scrutinised (by overweight people) - 'that's your third bar of chocolate today/ how can you eat all of those chips/is that another bag of crisps?'. It's constant and it's hurtful. I wear baggy clothes because if I wear something that fits I get comment after comment after comment on my size all .... day .... long.
I wouldn't dream of saying to someone 'is that your 4th bar of chocolate Susan?' to someone who's overweight because I'm not rude.

TheoTheopolis23 · 10/07/2023 23:58

Back on the calorific but not hard to eat front - bananas and peanut butter (and possibly chocolate spread) .... They can go in smoothies, on toast, in pancakes, in porridge, you can make bananas sushi by wrapping them in a tortilla wrap etc.

TheoTheopolis23 · 10/07/2023 23:55

As I was paying the man at the next self-checkout said 'what's the point love, you're only going to sick it up anyway'.

Just when you think you've heard about out the stupidest, nastiest wanker in here; someone goes one "better".