Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone sponsors a child

56 replies

Bellavida99 · 10/07/2023 20:05

I just saw an advert where you can sponsor a specific girl abroad and get letters from them etc. it sounds great and really worthwhile but for some reason I’ve not heard of this before so would love to hear if it’s legit etc. thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Starlightstarbright2 · 11/07/2023 10:58

We did a child through action aid same age as my Ds. Tbh I encouraged him to write but it was really hard mentioning our real life without material wealth.

I also had numerous arguments with action aid that they wouldn’t talk to me only Ds as he was a minor . We did it for about 10 years .

we have talked about it since - neither of us felt anything like we had done anything positive or even if we know the child actually benefited

zingally · 11/07/2023 10:39

When I was a teenager we sponsored a child. I think she was from Uganda and about 8 when we started... We'd write to her, and get a handwritten letter from her in response, with a translation. It was obviously hand-written by a child, but we were always a bit doubtful about the translation. It just didn't sound like stuff a kid would say, cultural differences aside. We expected to hear things about her friends, family, what was happening at school. But it was never that. We started to wonder if the kids were just given a generic text to copy. After about 3 years contact dried up. We kept going a bit longer, but then stopped donating.

marcopront · 11/07/2023 10:27

Milliways · 10/07/2023 21:18

Check out East Meru community school in Facebook, it’s in Tanzania. We have personal connections so know it’s an amazing benefit to the whole community. They take the poorest local children and give them a free education, daily hot meal, uniform etc and the whole community is involved. Local people make the uniforms and even the shoes. The new library is used by secondary pupils and all the children in the holidays.
There is no religious bias.
We get reports and photos and school newsletters, and you can email enquiries and get personal responses.
we also sponsor a child through one of the major charities but I love hearing the East Meru updates.

I wonder if I know you.
I know the people involved in it as well.

PomPomChatton · 11/07/2023 09:54

Bellavida99 · 10/07/2023 20:52

Thanks everyone really interesting to hear everyone’s views. It was Plan I saw the advert for but I’ll look at others too. I think it would be lovely to actually hear from the child you sponsor but I did wonder about inequality etc. if not every child in a neighbourhood is sponsored so it makes perfect sense the money is used for projects in that area rather than the specific child. I’m still in 2 minds if this type of giving does more good than giving to the huge charities it’s the type of thing it’s almost impossible to quantify. The advert I saw was particularly about sponsoring girls to help them stay in education, not be forced into child marriage, FGM etc. but I’m not sure how monthly donations specifically help with these issues. It’s so difficult. And I’ll definitely look into the salary sacrifice giving for this as I know we can do it with some charities.

But this type of giving is to huge charities. Plan and World Vision are a couple of the biggest in that field. Child sponsorship is just a method to encourage you to give. And being big their overheads can be split across many programmes and countries and they can leverage extra funding that is not accessible to smaller charities. Big does not equal bad.

Plan do great work in the field of girls' education, gender empowerment etc. Obviously not perfect, but no one is. In terms of how money can protect girls from child marriage and FGM, the single biggest thing we can do is give girls an education. Money can help with school fees, uniforms, books, school meals. And on a school level, adequate latrines so girls don't need to stay at home when on their period, facilities so they can continue at school when pregnant. There's so much that can be done.

I always think the best way to give is to find a charity that resonates with you and your values. Everyone has an opinion about what is best but that's different for different people.

caringcarer · 11/07/2023 09:45

@Peony654, I know exactly where it is. It's in Ibanda Provence in SW Uganda. My niece's friend has been there to visit and taken my sponsor child gifts from me.

Oncemoreunderthebridge · 11/07/2023 09:41

I used to do this through a big charity but, like some pps, gave up as I felt uneasy about the whole thing and also wary of big charities. Looking around for something else but in the meantime I am giving every now and again to local charities where I can see what they do.

Peony654 · 11/07/2023 09:39

caringcarer · 11/07/2023 09:35

I sponsor an African boy through Kafunjo Community. It is a large African orphanage and you sponsor a child. It costs £25 a month and you get regular photos of the child and a monthly newsletter. Once a year they say they would be happy for donations for school uniforms for children and I send an additional £25 that month but no pressure to do so. There's then a whole orphanage photo of all children wearing new uniforms. £25 a month seems to cover their food and they all need stationery to attend school. I've never been but I do know a person who sponsors a child at Kafunjo and has been to Africa to visit this child because she took a few gifts for the child I sponsor for me and I sent lots of exercise books and pens for all children.

Case in point - you don’t even know the country where the orphanage is…. Africa is a massive continent

Peony654 · 11/07/2023 09:37

ComtesseDeSpair · 10/07/2023 20:11

Personally, I’m quite uncomfortable with the idea of some poor kid in a developing country being strong-armed by whichever charity to write to their benevolent sponsor. There’s a very transactional nature and unequal power dynamic to it, so I prefer to give to project-based work or micro-investment.

This.
Have a look at the charity Give Directly - giving money is so much more effective and empowering. And the sponsorship isn’t going directly to an actual child - that would be impossible to administer, and the letters won’t be from them

caringcarer · 11/07/2023 09:35

I sponsor an African boy through Kafunjo Community. It is a large African orphanage and you sponsor a child. It costs £25 a month and you get regular photos of the child and a monthly newsletter. Once a year they say they would be happy for donations for school uniforms for children and I send an additional £25 that month but no pressure to do so. There's then a whole orphanage photo of all children wearing new uniforms. £25 a month seems to cover their food and they all need stationery to attend school. I've never been but I do know a person who sponsors a child at Kafunjo and has been to Africa to visit this child because she took a few gifts for the child I sponsor for me and I sent lots of exercise books and pens for all children.

TheBirdintheCave · 11/07/2023 08:29

My mother in law sponsored a girl in India all the way through school and nursing college :)

captainsandyscrew · 11/07/2023 08:26

I worked for Plan for a short time about 15 years ago and was shocked by how little of the donors funds went to the projects/kids (about 35%) vs how much was used to run the charity. Most people I saw working there were lazy and ineffective and in my opinion it was ran very poorly - I was used to working in the private sector and no business would have survived their shareholders if it was ran this way! Really put me off charitable giving tbh. Now I save money allocated for charity for either friends/family fundraising at an event (I.e a run) or smaller charities such as Girl vs Cancer, First Days, Bowelbabe. I feel smaller charities are more accountable and transparent about where donors money goes and that it makes more of a difference

Brefugee · 11/07/2023 08:25

Yes agreed. Just donate to a reputable charity

like Oxfam?

TBH if you're concerned about FGM i think looking up Hibo Wadere and seeing what she recommends would be good.

Big charities have huge overheads - I'm not entirely sure you get enough "bang for your buck" as it were, even while i recognise that having professionals running it gives it a better chance, business wise, of surviving and getting access to corporate funding.

Small charities tend to be very focussed on either a village, a country, a school, whatever, and really know what is needed on the ground.

Plan strikes me as one of the better ones, I'm with World Vision but we'll stop soon as our circumstances have changed. Unfortunately. I will most likely continue my volunteer work with local charities.

Brefugee · 11/07/2023 08:19

In retrospect, I wish I hadn't done the sponsored child thing. It seems a lot of pressure on one kid to have to send you letters and photos in return for their village getting funding.

in our case it is a short thing once a year (christmas) which usually consists of a drawing they've done, and a few form questions answered (and then translated) such as: what do you like at school (football usually) have you had all your health checks: yes and not much more. It's not onerous. But i do have vague "white saviour" feelings. And then i remember that Honduras is (or was) the murder capital of the world and that any and all money that can help his village is useful.

Kyliealwayshadthebestdisco · 11/07/2023 00:32

I sponsor kids through Compassion U.K. and don’t think they’re being strong-armed into anything! I suspect once every few months or so if they haven’t written a letter someone sits down with them to help them write one just as a courtesy to the person who is often funding their education etc. I don’t think that’s a crazy power dynamic. I have to write to them too! I’ve had some kids who clearly aren’t writers and just want to go off ASAP and play football and the letter is basically 2 lines of - hi, hope you are well, I like football ok I’m off to play it now bye! And others who spend ages writing loads about themselves and what’s going on with them. So I don’t think they make them sit there and write for more than a few minutes every few months if they’re not into it!

greenthumb13 · 10/07/2023 23:47

ComtesseDeSpair · 10/07/2023 20:11

Personally, I’m quite uncomfortable with the idea of some poor kid in a developing country being strong-armed by whichever charity to write to their benevolent sponsor. There’s a very transactional nature and unequal power dynamic to it, so I prefer to give to project-based work or micro-investment.

Yes agreed. Just donate to a reputable charity

Nevermind31 · 10/07/2023 23:38

I Sponsor a Child through Plan - I think I am on the third one now (one aged out, one moved away). I like their focus on education for the community and focus on children’s rights, especially for girls.
you don’t get their details, and they don’t get your details. I don’t actually exchange letters anymore, but I do like to get the community updates.

Curledupwithabook · 10/07/2023 23:15

I have sponsored several children through Plan. Exchanged a few letters, not many and only very light info, very short, as others have said - a bit about what it's like in their country, I'd tell them about ours etc (one child was fascinated to hear that we had snow etc)
Re one, as he hit teenage years I had a letter from plan to say that they were switching my sponsorship to another child as he no longer wanted to have photos shared. I took that as a good sign that they take the childs views into account.
There's very clear guidance - no extra requests are allowed, no gifts are allowed, and photos need to be sensitive eg not highlighting a big contrast in living standards (no posing next to a Merc etc)

I think for a lot of children it's just nice to receive a letter. Sometimes I'd have a letter response from the mum or aunt and they were interested to know why I sponsered, what work I did etc.

More frequently than letters I'd receive updates from the charity about the work they were doing in the community, which was usually about providing more access to education, or helping fund say, farming equipment which would mean less labour required so children could stay in school instead of having to work etc.

WhatADrabCarpet · 10/07/2023 22:37

ComtesseDeSpair · 10/07/2023 20:11

Personally, I’m quite uncomfortable with the idea of some poor kid in a developing country being strong-armed by whichever charity to write to their benevolent sponsor. There’s a very transactional nature and unequal power dynamic to it, so I prefer to give to project-based work or micro-investment.

I agree.

Some years ago , through a charity, I was invited to befriend a girl.
I became inundated with requests from her to fund this, or support that, that it became , financially untenable.
As soon as I refused, the letters and updates ceased.

These things are often scammy.

Mummyratbag · 10/07/2023 22:13

I sponsored a girl in Paraguay through Plan. We got annual updates with a short letter. We were allowed to send small gifts, but not too much as it would cause resentment. This was about 20 odd years ago. After a few years she "aged out" and they wanted me to sponsor a new child, but I was out of work and stopped. It was a nice thing to do. I hope she never felt pressured or used by the charity.

bellsbuss · 10/07/2023 21:56

I've done it for the last 15 years , a girl in Africa. I get letters and photos , DH thinks it's a scam

gogomoto · 10/07/2023 21:55

I sponsored a girl through secondary school, I then met her a few years later after she graduated nursing school and moved to the U.K., she is now a senior practice nurse at a gp's. Kind of nice to know we not only helped her but also her family (she sends money home I know) but slightly disappointed she left her country when the desperately need more healthcare professionals. We exchange Christmas cards and the occasional important news email these days

ColdHandsHotHead · 10/07/2023 21:42

Sorry lendwithcare.org

ColdHandsHotHead · 10/07/2023 21:41

There is a scheme called Lend With Care through which you can lend money to adults in the third world. It’s at lendwithcare.com

ColdHandsHotHead · 10/07/2023 21:40

I sponsored a boy in Egypt through Plan. It ended when he was 18 but tbh I lost interest some time earlier when his parents took him out of school. I mean it was none of my business but he would have little future with no education.

RamblingFar · 10/07/2023 21:38

I sponsored through Compassion before. It's possible to go and visit the child, so they definitely exist. I never visited my Compassion children though.

I also sponsored a child through a school I helped to build. When I went out 6 years later to work at the school again, I got to see him again at the school.

My ex also sponsored a child at a village we were working in. We also got to visit their home.

Usually the money goes into a central pot for the village, school or community. That also helps to ensure the child gets schooling and basic healthcare though. Usually you can send extra gifts and letters for the child personally too. Some of them you can visit, depending on the charity. I'd only visit if I was already in the area though, otherwise I'd feel it more beneficial to send extra money instead. Two of the children were from areas I was working in, so it was great to see their houses, schools and villages and the charities in action.