Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give pocket money??

140 replies

hecktoe · 10/07/2023 20:01

2 DCs 14 and 17. Oldest has a weekend job and uses money to buy clothes, fund his socialising.
I give them £18 each a week for lunches. I buy any clothes they need and they generally don't go without. I expect them to do their share about the house to help... tidy bedrooms, load/empty washer, set table, etc.
14 year old complaining that he wants paid for these tasks but I refuse to, my point being that he needs to contribute to the family running of the house. I have offered to pay him for other jobs -wash car etc but he's less than keen!! His point is that he has no money to do anything because I don't give pocket money. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blossomtoes · 11/07/2023 13:08

rookiemere · 11/07/2023 12:34

Another thought about using Christmas and birthday money in lieu of pocket money is that if I was the aunt or whoever giving that money it's meant to be for fun extra stuff in lieu of a gift. I'd be a bit annoyed if I learned that was being used instead of providing the child with pocket money.

That’s such a good point. I’d be really cross if I was essentially subsidising the parents. We stopped giving money to a child in our family when we discovered they never saw it because it was being siphoned into their savings account. They get vouchers now.

travelallthetime · 11/07/2023 13:02

My son get £50 a month on pay day. If he wants sweets/pop/going out with friends/new trainers when he doesnt needs them etc then its up to him to pay for them. We pay for all toiletries, clothes he needs, clubs, lunches etc but if he is going to maccies with friends its up to him to pay. He wants a job but gcse year is coming up and i would rather pay him to revise (the £50 pocket money) than him take time out to work.

rookiemere · 11/07/2023 12:34

Another thought about using Christmas and birthday money in lieu of pocket money is that if I was the aunt or whoever giving that money it's meant to be for fun extra stuff in lieu of a gift. I'd be a bit annoyed if I learned that was being used instead of providing the child with pocket money.

Snugglemonkey · 11/07/2023 12:27

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/07/2023 01:16

and if I offered an allowance and expected her to buy clothes and toiletries etc with it, she would blow it on crap.

Yes, and that would teach her an important lesson. Like it taught mine, years ago.

You're going to send your child out into the world in the next few years with no skills.

Just like riding a bike or leaning to do anything, there is an element of failure along the way. What do you think is going to magically happen at 18 to make sure she won't get into debt buying crap?

Definitely this.

Snugglemonkey · 11/07/2023 12:23

babbscrabbs · 10/07/2023 23:29

£10 a week for a 6yo is equally nuts IMO!

We give age per month at the moment but it will go up once they are teens.

I don't see how. He buys a magazine and sweets and saves £5.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 11/07/2023 07:56

We give pocket money because it is an important part of learning to manage your own money, use bank accounts, budgeting and saving. Our DCs also had part time jobs as soon as they were old enough as they soon realised that pocket money is not enough to cover everything they wanted to do.

EarringsandLipstick · 11/07/2023 07:46

If I offered an allowance and expected her to buy clothes and toiletries etc with it, she would blow it on crap.

That's the whole point.

There isn't one right way - each family will have their own dynamics.

But not giving a teen any budgeted amount that they are expected to manage in some agreed way is silly.

With your 16 yo, she can come & ask you for money whenever she wants to do stuff. So there is no planning or budgeting needed by her!

Equally you say she'd blow it - but doing this a few times & not having money for going out etc would help her learn! My 14 yo, very different to his 16 yo sister, got quite upset that his pocket money wasn't covering repeated trips to Spar, where he was spending €8 - €10 a time! I had to explain the choices he had in this regard - he found it all a bit painful but the penny is dropping more (plus with a limited budget that limits the amount of crap he can buy). If I was paying each time it would be for me to manage plus a task to work out when to say yes / no.

rookiemere · 11/07/2023 07:42

You said you give £18 a week for lunches, is there an option to make their own and keep that money? we tried that with DS for a while to show him the markup on the school meals and how far the money goes if you make your own instead.

Vettrianofan · 11/07/2023 07:17

One of mine has had to wait a few years but has just bought his own console to be like his friends - with his own savings (separate account from his pocket money allowance). We don't buy them stuff just because they want it. They have to learn about the value of money. So far my secondary aged DC have done well on this life lesson. My eldest used his savings for buying his own PC a few years ago. It can be done.

They aren't materialistic kids and don't care about labels/branded stuff thankfully. If they did it would probably mean they would blow all their savings and/or pocket money.

timegoingtooquickly · 11/07/2023 06:29

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/07/2023 01:16

and if I offered an allowance and expected her to buy clothes and toiletries etc with it, she would blow it on crap.

Yes, and that would teach her an important lesson. Like it taught mine, years ago.

You're going to send your child out into the world in the next few years with no skills.

Just like riding a bike or leaning to do anything, there is an element of failure along the way. What do you think is going to magically happen at 18 to make sure she won't get into debt buying crap?

Yes this @MrsTerryPratchett .

I found before the were told to use their pocket money if we were out and they asked for something I'd say no problem, you've got money. That definitely focused whether they wanted to buy it or not 🤣. Usually it was not!

OP allow your children budget skills

PandaG · 11/07/2023 03:52

Totally agree with Kookaburra - by giving set pocket money per month DC cost us less than giving money each time they wanted to go to cinema/ Costa/buy nail varnish etc. Wasn't tied to chores, as pp have said we all muck in as part of the family. We did however make school lunches part of pocket money - there was always enough in at home to make a packed lunch, including specific ingredients/treats they requested, so if they chose to buy a school dinner that came out of pocket money. They also had to buy clothes they wanted rather than needed (or they were birthday presents or we split the cost if they wanted branded we paid the basic cost and they added the extra). Presents for friends' birthdays we paid half and they paid half. All of the above helped them to budget - 12 yo DS blew all his pocket money on cinema, Macdonald's and a coke in the cinema at the beginning of the Easter holidays. 11 years later he has saved a house deposit and is looking to buy only one year post graduating.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 11/07/2023 01:45

I gave my DSs pocket money for years, older one got slightly more at the beginning but ended up evening it out.

They learned to budget really well. They now have part time jobs (recently) and they have both said they no longer need the pocket money, although I have told them that if i in the fortnight (they and I get paid fortnightly) they haven't had shifts and don't get paid I will still give them their pocket money.

They both sued their pocket money in different ways, one to socialise, the other for online games, but both saved a fair proportion. Their choice entirely how they used it, and actually it ended up costing me LESS because I didn't get the constant requests for games, pizza with friends, etc. they budgeted it out of their money. Win win!

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/07/2023 01:16

and if I offered an allowance and expected her to buy clothes and toiletries etc with it, she would blow it on crap.

Yes, and that would teach her an important lesson. Like it taught mine, years ago.

You're going to send your child out into the world in the next few years with no skills.

Just like riding a bike or leaning to do anything, there is an element of failure along the way. What do you think is going to magically happen at 18 to make sure she won't get into debt buying crap?

timegoingtooquickly · 11/07/2023 01:02

Greydogs123 · 10/07/2023 20:20

I think as you didn’t give pocket money to the oldest then it’s fine to not give to youngest. Keep reiterating that if they need money they can do actual jobs to help out or go and fine a job, such as a paper round.

But the time the eldest was 14 it was lock down so they didn't need money.

My children are the same age and have money for extra clothes, lip balm and meeting friends.

Cakeorchocolate · 11/07/2023 00:16

I think it would be more unreasonable if you did give the 14yo pocket money when you didn't your eldest.

You've offered a way for him to earn money, he refuses. It would be wrong to go oh OK then here you go anyway ££.

YANBU.

I wanted spending money when I was 14, I got a job.

User68253 · 11/07/2023 00:09

I don't give mine pocket money either OP. My eldest is 16. I do pay for school lunches because she can't be bothered to make packed lunches and complained about everything I packed. I pay for her phone contract. If she is going out with friends I often give her a fiver or tenner to get lunch or pay for bus fair. She's never had to miss out on something because she has no money. But she isn't money motivated and I can't afford pocket money just for the sake of it, and if I offered an allowance and expected her to buy clothes and toiletries etc with it, she would blow it on crap.

SamanthaCaine · 11/07/2023 00:02

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 23:52

Local papers still get delivered as do papers from the newsagents.

Not here they don’t. The local paper’s online only and there are no newsagents left.

Newsflash. Where you live doesn't represent life around the UK.

Besides, papers aren't the only avenue for kids to earn money. Kids just need to be keen to look, which in itself is a valuable life skill to develop at a young age.

multivac · 10/07/2023 23:57

Not here they don’t. The local paper’s online only and there are no newsagents left.*

Gosh. It's almost like places are sometimes... different!

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 23:52

Local papers still get delivered as do papers from the newsagents.

Not here they don’t. The local paper’s online only and there are no newsagents left.

SamanthaCaine · 10/07/2023 23:32

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 10/07/2023 22:04

I’m loving all the ‘get them to get a paper round’ suggestions! How to show you have zero knowledge of kids / the world today!

I think you're making the mistake of looking at your immediate vicinity and thinking the rest of the country is the same.

babbscrabbs · 10/07/2023 23:29

Snugglemonkey · 10/07/2023 21:27

I am surprised you this too. My 6 year old gets £10 a week.

£10 a week for a 6yo is equally nuts IMO!

We give age per month at the moment but it will go up once they are teens.

SamanthaCaine · 10/07/2023 23:26

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 21:25

God these paper rounds must be amazing. Remind me what year this is - still 1980 in some places obviously.

Seriously. Sounds like you're living under a rock.

Mine are young adults now but they both did paper rounds from 13 until they could get better paid work. Local papers still get delivered as do papers from the newsagents. Customers are mostly older people but there's still loads of them about, last time I checked. This paid about £40/month so about the levels of pocket money quoted here.

Like the OP we never gave pocket money, despite us being relatively well off. It's interesting the opinions here but personally, I don't think you truly understand the value of money until you exchange sweat and energy for an hourly rate. Both their work ethic and money management is excellent.

@hecktoe My youngest hated her paper round so got a job in a restaurant at 14. It's possible but takes some resilience to find one that will let children of that age work. It all character building though. They're limited to certain tasks and hours but it's perfectly legal and with tips, she was streaks ahead of her peers financially and also in terms of work experience/soft skills.

Vettrianofan · 10/07/2023 22:37

hecktoe · 10/07/2023 22:08

Yes of course, as I've said he doesn't go without.

Ah. You basically operate the same way I do then. The only difference is that I give them a nominal amount of cash to save or spend as they see fit.

I don't think you are miserable, btw. You are making sure they don't miss out by getting money for treats as and when. It's not that different from £50 approx. pocket money per month.

budgiegirl · 10/07/2023 22:28

hecktoe · 10/07/2023 22:08

Yes of course, as I've said he doesn't go without.

Well, isn't that just the same thing as giving him pocket money? Except that he doesn't learn how to budget?

HeddaGarbled · 10/07/2023 22:27

Managing their own money is a life lesson best learned when they are safe at home: learning how to make it last, save up for things they want, the consequences of frittering it away etc. They won’t learn how to manage a budget/income if they aren’t allowed a regular amount of money and some freedom to manage it themselves. University or first job is too late for that important skill development.