Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask... are holidays abroad with kids worth it?

109 replies

ImALittlePea · 10/07/2023 14:10

I'm currently fixated on going abroad in late September/early October with the family (myself, DH, 9yo and 2yo). I don't know why, really, but I'm desperate for the children to have the experiences that DH & I never had as kids of going to the A/I style resorts, planes etc. 9yo has been abroad once, before starting school and covid hit. 2yo has never left the country. We've done UK holidays - Airbnbs, holiday parks etc - all-in-all quite successful (and one only a couple of weeks ago - four nights in a holiday park along the south coast of England), but I can't shake the feeling of wanting to take them abroad.

But as I look at the packages and prices, I'm starting to second guess myself about whether it's really worth it. We have a modest budget with which I can find what seem to be packages that I'm happy with - a week of A/I in apartment style resorts with plenty/enough for kids to do, space for us to chill once they're in bed etc. But if we do spend the money and go away, we'll feel the pinch and have less freedom/leave from work over the long summer holidays.

Please help a holiday-hungry overthinker out!

YABU - holidays with kids are harder work than they're worth
YANBU - life is short and for living - holidays are always worth it

OP posts:
wwyd2021medicine · 10/07/2023 16:58

Took my DC to beach holidays abroad from a few months old and had super times 😊
I think SC rather than AI for smaller children though. I had SC apartments so that we could have slow mornings with breakfast and no rush to get dressed, DH and I could have cups of tea and a separate room to relax in while they napped in the afternoon. At night, again we could have drinks in the fridge and watch tv/ chat etc while they slept. It's much better than only having one room potentially in a hotel.
Ate lunch and evening meal out

Also, personally I think it's rubbish having a buffet until children can choose and carry their own meals. I loathe my meals going cold and I wouldn't have the patience to wait while they dithered over what to choose

QforCucumber · 10/07/2023 16:53

@summerfireplace Personally, for us it works because the kids have all day access to food of their choice, ice creams milkshakes etc and I don't have to cook any of it. The hotels we choose have splashparks and slides and play areas also craft and sports clubs for them, and are usually a couple of miles out of town so spend a day or 2 exploring getting the bus there too. DH and I both work FT long hours jobs so the 10 days of switching off and actually recharging are just what we need. Spending all day playing in the pool is exactly what ours love to do - the same as at Centre parcs, we were in the pools for 5 and 6 hours each day never bored of it.

TonTonMacoute · 10/07/2023 16:49

Agree that the 2 year old is the slightly problematic issue here.

The point of these resorts (presumably, I’ve never been on one) is that parents can get a bit of downtime while the DCs are happily doing supervised activities. All good!

A 2 yo will still probably want/need to be with parents most of the time, so you would still get a reduced childcare load and can be lazier.

If you live near an airport and it’s not too long a flight/transfer the other end, then go for it.

Ylvamoon · 10/07/2023 16:46

I've never done AI (and probably never will!)

But we have always been on holiday abroad with DC from baby. Never really had any major issues, except when DS was 9 months old and got really ill with a tummy bug. (Luckily the staff from our hotel was brilliant and very forgiving!)

I imagine AI would be a breeze compared to self catering & eating at local restaurants as DC can see the food and choose easily.

You have easy entertainment right at your doorstep so all you need to do is tag team to supervise the DC.

So yeah, go for it!

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 10/07/2023 16:35

Not at 2, in my experience. We have just done our first flight with DS4 (Disneyland Paris) and he was good as gold but having to entertain him at 6am in the hotel room until we could go for breakfast was a bit of a killer. When he was 2 he'd have been up in the night at least twice and would have needed naps in the afternoon. This was much more doable when it was a couple of chilled nights in the New Forest or Cornwall.

summerfireplace · 10/07/2023 16:29

I seem to be an outlier here but... I don't really understand the appeal of these kind of holidays with children. What can you/they do all day except eat and play in the pool, read if they're old enough? Play on a beach? That's all good for a day or two but I think it is more fun to stay in the UK and go somewhere where you can explore something different each day.

Before anyone shouts at me I realise that there must be more to it than I can see! Also some kids are probably much more into those activities than others. Mine have ASD and dyspraxia and swimming etc isn't something they'd enjoy for very long, they'd also hate the heat. I wouldn't be able to leave them at a kids club.

I just imagine it being a week of supervising them doing a very limited range of activities that they'd quickly get bored of, in weather they would hate!

honeylulu · 10/07/2023 16:22

Depends partly on what sort of children you have and what your family vibe is. We went on holiday with our first when he was 2 and it was knackering. He ran off all the time and was too young for kids club. It was just about worth it as he was a really good sleeper and would have a long nap in the afternoon and sleep all night until at least 8am. The next year he was old enough for kids club and after that holidays were much better. Though when we had a second child she was much more biddable and less prone to running off so it was pretty much always fine. The other thing I'll say is that we really do like our space. We did a handful of holidays where we shared a room with one child (when we had only one and he was little) but after that we always got a suite or 2 bed apartment. Cramming 4 of us in one room was not something we would contemplate and I'd rather have no holiday at all. But last year we met a family in our resort who had five of them crammed into one room for 2 weeks, and they were having a brilliant time! So it's very individual!

NotAMug · 10/07/2023 16:07

We found either cruises or AI with lots of kids activities were always brilliant holidays with kids under about 11/12. Double check the age limits for activities as some only start from 3 yo onwards which can be a pain. Cruises amazing for very young ones, AI good for 5 up IMO but resorts like holiday villages do have lots for little ones going on.

Once my kids got a bit older they preferred cruises as there is more to do for their ages and neither like to just chill in the sun on a resort. They are fine if water sports available etc on AI type hols.

Bailem · 10/07/2023 16:04

But also as others said, it was hard work at times! Especially as our child wouldn't sleep/nap at all, on the go from 7.30am and was still up dancing at 10pm! 😆

Bailem · 10/07/2023 16:02

We've just got back from 10 days with our 3year old. The best memories made, our DD experienced lots of firsts (airport, aeroplane, little suitcase, making friends on holiday, mini disco) and she loved every minute.

Will she remember it? Nope but we will! I wasn't overly bothered about going, I love UK holidays and don't pine for sun,sea, abroad but I'm already looking for next year. Kids definitely make it for me.

BlowDryRat · 10/07/2023 15:52

Holidays with a young child are hard work but that's never stopped me taking my DC (although sometimes I've metaphorically torn my hair out while there!). I don't think YABU but I'd wait until your younger DC is 3. Then they'll be old enough for the kids club and you can get a few hours of peace.

givemushypeasachance · 10/07/2023 15:46

I'd say it depends how chill your two year old (and you as parents) are. If you have a two year old who is incredibly cranky if they don't get their nap at the precise time, who only sleeps with blackout blinds, white noise, being held till they fall asleep, who is very fussy about food, who gets overwhelmed by new places/noisy situations/crowds, and you find yourself very stressed trying to manage your way around those sorts of situations and upsets, then none of you are likely to enjoy it very much. It is parenting a toddler in an alien situation, without your home comforts, where you can't so easily make them beans on toast and sit them down in front of a couple of episodes of Paw Patrol to just get through a rough morning that started at 4:30am.

QforCucumber · 10/07/2023 15:35

Mine are 7 and 3, ds1 has been abroad 5 times, all between being 18 months and 4 years, then Covid hit and we haven't been away since yet, so DS2 has never experienced it - next one is a 2 week AI already booked for May next year and we all cannot wait, he will be almost 4 by then. It is absolutely worth every moment. DS1 still remembers the different places, he's been to Cyprus, and 2 of the Canary Islands (Tenerife twice) and Turkey. DH and I also love this type of holiday though which of course helps.

kraftyKitten · 10/07/2023 15:26

There was a couple with a crawling baby on holiday abroad . Delightful baby but they were constantly having to entertain chase after baby and could not relax or even have a drink. I could see it was a relief for the parents when the holiday came to an end .

I personally would not take children abroad on holiday until they were fully mobile and could talk and entertain themselves with toys and games . Imagine if the child got sick in countries where healthcare is not the greatest.

RonObvious · 10/07/2023 15:20

From the other side of it - some of my most vivid and fond childhood memories are of holidays abroad. I definitely think they are worth it, although we've only every managed to take our kids abroad the once. Hoping to do more in the future though!

curlywurlylover666 · 10/07/2023 15:17

Your post echoes my own thoughts. As a child we didn't have holidays, and certainly no trips abroad. We had day trips to the seaside and a few days out but no holidays and I really want mine to have that experience.

I love an abroad holiday, the sunshine and different holiday way of life. UK breaks just don't do it for me I'm afraid and although we've had some lovely breaks, they don't feel like a holiday to me.

Mine are little, they love anywhere we go and I did an abroad holiday when I had 1 child aged 18 months. She still needed a nap etc in the room in daytime and it was a different holiday to what I am used to but I still loved taking her. I think adjust your frame of what your holiday looked liked previously and you will have a fab time.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 15:10

My kids love a foreign beach holiday - they spend most of their time in the pool and having AI means no worry about paying for ice cream and drinks etc.

shivawn · 10/07/2023 15:10

I'm part of the holidays are always worth it school of thought. We're just back from 2 incredible weeks away and I'm absolutely dying to book another trip soon. Admittedly, I only have one child but he's 20 months old so a fairly difficult age and I'm 25 weeks pregnant with my next child.

We've been on many long haul and short haul trips at various ages from 3 months up and I've never regretted any of them. They get better the older my child gets because he gets more and more enjoyment from them and his joy is my joy. I would have thought your children were brilliant ages to travel with (spoken by someone with no experience of kids those ages!)

suburbophobe · 10/07/2023 15:06

Mine are 10 and 7 (so probably a bit easier than your youngest) and have never been on a plane, and I would love my son to have that experience before starting secondary school.

You could fly within Britain, i.e. up to Scotland or down south if you live there.

whoruntheworldgirls · 10/07/2023 15:01

We only ever do holidays abroad, she's 6 now and has always been great on them and enjoyed them. We love AI as gives plenty of options to choose from and a chance to try new things, we also look for a good pool with slides and a kids club.
Honestly we have loved every one of our holidays with her.

steppemum · 10/07/2023 14:54

we loved holidays in the sun.
We didn't do hotels, we did self catering so that we had flexibility.
We spent 2 weeks sitting round the pool with the kids swimming.
They all learnt to swim by just being in the water for 2 weeks.

We couldn't have done that in any holiday at home, so that is why I loved them.

They also loved seeing new stuff, trying new food etc etc

But in terms of cooking and work etc it was still hard work.

LadyJ2023 · 10/07/2023 14:48

Twins are 1 boy 3 and a teen and abroad is super fun nothing extra different to uk fun we had

creasedclothes · 10/07/2023 14:47

Seems like you can afford it so go this year, then you'll know whether it's worth it for your family.
It's no good me answering, it will always be worth it for me , because I love travelling.

mindutopia · 10/07/2023 14:47

I think holidays abroad with kids can definitely be worth it, but I think it depends what sort of holiday you are talking about and what your expectations are. Honestly, an AI resort that you pretty much don't leave, it probably doesn't make much difference to being in the UK, really. Except for the warmer weather. I went on those sorts of holidays as a child and while I definitely remember them as they were so novel and different from home, I can't say they were my best holiday memories as a child. Actually, my best holiday memories are of a local seaside holiday that we did every year.

I do think that going abroad can be worth it if YOU can make the most of it to do something YOU really want to do, or if your child is old enough to appreciate culture and food and seeing new places. For example, I took my youngest on a weekend city break in Spain as a baby - obviously, he has absolutely no memory of any of it, but I have a wonderful time. We did lots of fun (to me!) things and I enjoyed my time there with him. Similarly, I took my eldest to Italy when she was probably 6. She's 10 now and still says it was the best holiday she's ever had. She remembers it really fondly, but we did lots of really interesting things - restaurants out, museums, boat trips, cultural stuff - not just beach and pool (which we could have done at home really). So I think it can be worth it, but depends what you're after, and I don't think you have to do some big abroad holiday to 'make memories'. We go and stay at a beach hut near us every summer and my kids love that and talk about it all year long asking when we'll go back for this year. It's literally like a cabin with a compost loo and there's nothing there but a BBQ and the beach. It's great.

Pkhsvd · 10/07/2023 14:47

We’ve done UK self catering holidays which were nice but a bit of same routine, different place type thing and also abroad with all inclusive and I would definitely prefer abroad in a resort holiday. the trick is to not expect it to be like those type of holidays pre children so there isn’t the lounging by the pool but there’s a lot of time in the pool having fun. you have to relax about food because they may struggle and if they eat plain pasta and ice cream for a week then so be it as long as they’ve eaten.