Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's uni costs

753 replies

WarriorWalrus · 10/07/2023 11:26

DD1 is 17, 18 at the start of August. DH and I can't agree on what costs we should be covering while she is at uni and what she should budget for herself.
Due to our income DD only qualifies for the most basic maintenance loan. We have savings for her, so it won't be out of our monthly income (though I intend to keep putting money into her savings while she is at uni). Her grandparents have offered to pay for her accommodation (£350 a week).
So far we haven't figure out how much her monthly allowance from us will be, but we disagree on what this should cover. DH thinks the amount we set should cover everything, food, clothes, socialising, club fees, holidays etc.
I think food, socialising and day to day clothes sure, but she plans to join one of the sports teams so I think we should pay for the initial registration cost and kit costs, allow her to use money from the savings for travel, she currently gets private coaching in her sport, I think we should pay for this to continue at uni (I know she wants it to) and step in with extra money for more expensive clothes for events or such.
We don't want her to and she doesn't intend to get a job (Uni, Socialising, Sport and extra work to help future career should take up most of her time). But we do want to teach her to budget.
AIBU to think the additional things should be covered by us, anyone with Uni aged kids got a rough idea of how much she will need monthly?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Splishsploshsplash · 11/07/2023 23:59

Dear god. Of course she can get a job, even if it’s to save like mad during uni holidays. And she needs to budget for herself. You are treating her like she is ten.

j1307 · 11/07/2023 23:52

Having graduated a LSE last year I think I'm in a position to clear up some things here:

  • Accommodation: £350pw is extremely expensive, even by London standards. For central London £220pw (uncatered, shared bathroom), £260pw (catered, shared bathroom) are reasonable. Add £20 for per week for a private bathroom.
  • First year hall choice is very important with regards to socialising. Going for the most expensive hall will mean ending up with a crowd of extremely wealthy international students with no clue about what normal life looks like (I had a friend in one of those halls who in her first week had to explain to someone who to press a button on a lift since they were used to butlers in their home country). Being in a hall like this will involve hanging out with people who will have a very expensive when it comes to eating out or going out partying.
  • Food, Going out & everything else: London is expensive, no question. Having food provided by the uni on campus will be £5-£6, cooking a large meal with protein won't be much cheaper (I'm a rower so my perspective on how much food you need for a meal might be a bit skewed for this). Overall, I don't think £10 per day on food would be crazy, that's £70 per week. If she gets £500 per month that would be £125 per week, which would be wholly sufficient to cover that plus everything else she will incur. As a student you know how to budget. The tube racks up quickly, walking and cycling (if confident, though the infrastructure in London is getting very good in places) are your friends. No, you don't need £50 for a night out in London. As a student in general you go clubbing during the week, as the weekend prices are crazy. Buying tickets in advance, they'll be between £5-£10. Pre-drinking with the friends/ sports team will mean no need to buy drinks in a club. Every uni will also have its own bar with cheap pints and often its own club night with cheap entry and drinks.
  • Part-time work: For jobs after uni, summer internship (summer before graduating) are invaluable and depending on the sector can be extremely well paid (banks pay pro-rata on entry-level salaries, so many of my friends made £12k in 12 weeks in investment banking roles). Any part time work experience you get will be good, the more skilled it is though the better (office job over bartending since you can always lever that in a job interview and CV). In the later stages of the degree and with good grades research assistantships for professors are very attractive (did them both at LSE and Kings for about £18 per hour) and look great on the CV. Unis tend to have career portal through which I (and many of my friends) found part-time office jobs. However, I'd advise not doing more than 10 hours per week. I started off with 20 and that was way too many. My work was quite flexible, so I tended to do 7-9am in the office every day, before heading to campus.
  • Time: The first year of your daughter's course in particular will not be insanely demanding. Unis know that students take time to adjust and a lot of time is spent to bring everyone from where different backgrounds up to the same level. Even with high-level sports, there should be enough time for socialising and part-time work. I had friends who rowed for University of London (about 12 training sessions a week, many out in Chiswick) even during their last years of their degrees. One of the skills to learn in uni is how to organise your own time (and money).
  • To conclude, £500 after accommodation is paid is plenty even in London if you do live like most students (though many students in her hall will likely live a different lifestyle). There should be enough time for uni, socialising, sports and part time work, in particular in the first year.
Margrethe · 11/07/2023 23:37

Reading this thread, I worry we are giving too little. We pay for DD’s rent and utilities. She gets the minimum maintenance loan. She has a part time job as a barrista during term time and pulls pints during the summer. I am very pleased for her to work and feel that the money she earns is relevant snd makes a difference. However, I don’t want to put her under undue pressure. Now wondering, if we should give her an extra £100 month.

notwavingbutdrowning1 · 11/07/2023 22:58

Some people weren't very well off but their child did get grants and bursaries and loan and whatever...

Staggering ignorance of the system here. Grants and bursaries are by no means the norm. What does 'whatever' mean?

Icecreammonster · 11/07/2023 22:39

I would never have expected my parents to pay for socialising. I’m not even sure they paid for rent after Halls. I always had at least one job and usually two. I understand wanting to contribute to most other things but would suggest you encourage her to get a job. Some jobs are really nice and help build relationships outside of Uni and experience of being part of a team etc. A lot of young people at that age are working full time! It’s not a big ask really as you’re enabling her to study to work I assume in her chosen profession, and be independent which is a luxury many young people will never have. She needs to understand that.

Purplemoon123 · 11/07/2023 22:21

sixthvestibule · 11/07/2023 19:46

Much though I hate to say it, it will pay off to subsidise her as much as possible. I’m from a thoroughly working class background, worked my ass off through uni, went without, scraped by until I got a very prestigious job on pure merit. And I just lost it because I’m not as representative as my colleagues, i.e. I need better makeup, haircuts, nails and clothes I can’t afford, and speak more like an upper class lady. Fuck that. Subsidise the hell out of the girl so she doesn’t have to face this shit.

Oh, my good lord!!! I know the feeling, though; similar background to you, just finished uni, worked through it, and got top marks; I managed to get a job in a good company that is like a safe space for working-class people, but 'some' employers are ultimately exclusionary. I refused to apply for grad schemes too!! Hope it's not in the same industry as me :/

WarriorWalrus · 11/07/2023 22:17

Mamabear2424 · 11/07/2023 21:52

£350 a week for the accomodation?? That cant be right, my dd in London and that's £220 a week , you must have that wrong, Id say if you are financing her, 70 a week? for food and going out only!

I’m sure someone posted a link with the options at her uni, proving that £350 whilst the most expensive is a thing.

OP posts:
Cornishclio · 11/07/2023 22:14

Haven't you been told what the parental contribution is? I would give her that with maybe a bit extra if the sport is expensive. We have the parental contribution and that with their loan and holiday job money covered their outgoings.

I personally feel she needs to learn to budget or she will be dreadful with money as an adult and a large socialising\personal spends allowance sends the wrong message especially if she is not being expected to do paid work. Both my DDs did work in the holidays and presumably there is no reason she can't do that?

Mamai90 · 11/07/2023 22:10

When my sister went to uni my parents paid for her accommodation, and energy bills and then they gave her the equivalent to what an adult would get if on benefits that she could use for travel, phone, food and socialising. She was better off than most of her friends who had to get part time jobs but she was still a skint student who had to manage on a budget.

squirelnutkin11 · 11/07/2023 22:07

Christ op, l am shocked by the vitriol on here...
shame on you for being financially comfortable,
shame on you for making sure your own child doesn't have to give up her sport to prove her financial independence,
Shame on you for being willing to let her make her own choices on location
shame on you for letting her GPs help with choosing her accomodation..God forbid!

Surely you should only let her wear a hair shirt and struggle her hardest like the very poorest student...

MrsRachelDanvers · 11/07/2023 22:03

PurpleButterflyWings · 11/07/2023 21:49

This ... ^ Some people are absolutely awful on here ... Funny thing is, I don't really know anybody like that in real life. Everyone I know whose kids who went to university supported them, took them there, helped them pack and unpack, helped them start up their new little flat (or halls room,) and bought everything they needed for their kitchen and bathroom and whatever, and filled their cupboard with food. And then went and got them for the summer holidays and supported them through the summer holidays (and let them go travelling if they wanted,) and then took them back to uni.

Some people weren't very well off but their child did get grants and bursaries and loan and whatever...

What they did do, was their the best to support the young adult child ...

Some people act on here like the second a child turns 18 years old that they should just be kicked out into the cold and the snow and never ever be let back into the house again ... And the parents that DO end up letting their child stay have strict rules, and they do exactly what they're told - and contribute to all the washing and cooking and cleaning, and pay £500 a month to stay - and be bloody grateful they've got a roof over their head!

Not everybody turns into a fully fledged responsible adult on their bloody 18th birthday - or even one or two years into being at uni ... It makes wonder why some people have children to be honest with you.

I think you’re being very binary here. Most parents want to support their kids but have different views on what support means. If you throw everything you can at them to ensure they never have to make choices or plan their own life, it all gets taken care of-that raises entitled brats whatever their background. My friend is married to a wealthy guy-when their kid said he wanted to travel, they said great idea, how you going to pay for it. They could’ve easily given him the money many times over but he worked a ski season cleaning chalets and cooking as well as having fun and then evenings and weekends in holidays in a local gadtropub. Those experiences helped build his character far more than giving him a cheque.

Creamteasandbumblebees · 11/07/2023 22:02

Uni life is supposed to be about struggle and it's what will set apart those that have struggled from those that have been handed privilege on a plate.
There is nothing in the world like achieving something when you've had to work and strive for it, it teaches grit and determination. There is also no better bonding experience with your Uni mates than struggling together, believe it or no but it's those moments of struggle that you look back on with the fondest of memories.
I'm not saying don't help her out but when she gets her degree how do you expect her to fare in the cut throat job market without any real life experience? How will she learn to budget if you are there to pick up the bill? How will she learn to prioritise or meet deadlines if she hasn't had to juggle her degree with a job?
Give her the chance to struggle a bit, let her make her own mistakes, give her the opportunity to work hard and achieve something great for herself.

Mamabear2424 · 11/07/2023 21:55

id get her to work tbh as having everything paid for by mummy and daddy wont do her any favours in the real world.

Mamabear2424 · 11/07/2023 21:52

£350 a week for the accomodation?? That cant be right, my dd in London and that's £220 a week , you must have that wrong, Id say if you are financing her, 70 a week? for food and going out only!

PurpleButterflyWings · 11/07/2023 21:49

baffledcoconut · 11/07/2023 21:11

People are being very unkind. Parents wanting their children to be comfortable and supported? What a shocker.

This ... ^ Some people are absolutely awful on here ... Funny thing is, I don't really know anybody like that in real life. Everyone I know whose kids who went to university supported them, took them there, helped them pack and unpack, helped them start up their new little flat (or halls room,) and bought everything they needed for their kitchen and bathroom and whatever, and filled their cupboard with food. And then went and got them for the summer holidays and supported them through the summer holidays (and let them go travelling if they wanted,) and then took them back to uni.

Some people weren't very well off but their child did get grants and bursaries and loan and whatever...

What they did do, was their the best to support the young adult child ...

Some people act on here like the second a child turns 18 years old that they should just be kicked out into the cold and the snow and never ever be let back into the house again ... And the parents that DO end up letting their child stay have strict rules, and they do exactly what they're told - and contribute to all the washing and cooking and cleaning, and pay £500 a month to stay - and be bloody grateful they've got a roof over their head!

Not everybody turns into a fully fledged responsible adult on their bloody 18th birthday - or even one or two years into being at uni ... It makes wonder why some people have children to be honest with you.

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 11/07/2023 21:38

WarriorWalrus · 10/07/2023 15:46

I know the cost of the accommodation is staggering to some point. Several people have posted links showing the options at DDs uni, confirming that while it is the most expensive, £350 for ensuite room with shared kitchen is a thing in London!!
I was not involved in the accommodation, my parents paid for nephews accommodation throughout his BSc and Masters, he is just due to finish now, admittedly a cheaper city but none the less. If DD does the 3 years BA then a year masters she will be finishing as her sister is ready to start, clearly this is something my parents are happy to do, and they selected, where, cost etc. with DD and are fine with it.

@WarriorWalrus I don’t understand how earlier you said your children don’t come from a privileged upbringing when their grandparents are so financially well off that they can pay for (what sounds like) all of their grandchildren’s university rent in entirety. This to me is the very definition of privileged upbringing.

baffledcoconut · 11/07/2023 21:11

People are being very unkind. Parents wanting their children to be comfortable and supported? What a shocker.

Ginola2345 · 11/07/2023 20:58

She sounds like an absolute pampered princess who is being well and truly indulged by her parents and grandparents!!

My DS was in last year at a top 5 prestigious Uni for only about £120-£130 a week albeit self catering and sharing a bathroom with one other and a kitchen and living space with 11 others.

He is a member of his College gym, two sports clubs and has socialised himself silly for a heck of a lot less than you are proposing to give your DD. But then he budgeted, cooked his own meals from scratch (going back to halls for lunch) and shopped at Aldi and Lidl not Waitrose.

In the real world most students parents cover them for basic living costs (if they are able to) and its up to the students to prioritise whether they want to shop frugally and spend time cooking then have a good social life, hardly by any new clothes (make do with what they have), have pre drinks with friends and nights out in College bars etc. Most can’t afford the most expensive accommodation, indulge in private training and have almost limitless spending money for clothes, full on socialising and lengthy holidays all funded by parents. Most have to work most of the holidays to pay for basics and or extras at Uni.

Janey331 · 11/07/2023 20:45

'DD' is going to get the shock of her life once she has to start 'adulting' for herself. Parents are doing her absolutely no favours at all.

Kaiserchief · 11/07/2023 20:43

£500 is loads! Skewed view here maybe as I left home before uni (I took a year out) and paid my own way through. I worked full time for a year and saved up then worked full time during uni holidays.

Commonsenseisnotthatcommon1 · 11/07/2023 20:40

Wow I can see that you think by providing everything for your daughter and making life "easier" for her at university will benefit her but I would resist the urge to give her the life of riley.
I went to university (a long time ago) and received a full student loan and maintenance grant. My BA course was in design so I also had to build a portfolio and gain relevant work experience. I still managed to work 25 hours per week (over Friday, Saturday, Sunday) and get a 1st class degree, leading straight into a job in a very competitive industry. This is not a stealth boast. My parents instilled a strong work ethic in me - I've worked since I was 16 in various part time jobs. By working I gained transferable skills; communication, time management, team building, ability to manage my own finances, understanding the value of money, how to build relationships, manage conflict.
All of which gave me a massive edge in getting my foot in the door.

My friends that didn't work whilst at university and were from privileged backgrounds struggled to find work and when they did they found they didn't have the right attitude to fit in and succeed and seemed to fall behind. At work I've had to deal with plenty of spoilt graduates starting out in their profession and complaining after a month that they haven't been promoted or that they can only afford 2 holidays this year instead of 3, or they want more money. Its unbearable.
Don't make life too easy for your daughter. It won't do her any favours in the long run.

Chestnutlover · 11/07/2023 20:32

A flat share might be cheaper. I rented a room in a lovely flat in central london and was charged 200 per week when I was a student

GloryBees · 11/07/2023 20:26

There will definitely be a reasonable proportion who are set up like your DD. It does sound like working in term time will be difficult. You presumably all agreed on her going to London.

one of the many reasons I work so hard now is that my kids will be fully subsidised through university and leave with zero debts. It is a great gift to be lucky enough to give.

BLT24 · 11/07/2023 20:23

If the 350 is for halls that usually includes all bills so she won’t have to pay for any accommodation costs except some cleaning products?

Id allow her to live on 500 a month but maybe allow her to order food/toiletries/household essentials online each week with a set budget that you pay for. If she wants to travel or do anything else extravagant whilst at uni she needs to learn to save some of that 500 or get a job (she should have time in the holidays there are off Uni nearly 1/3 of the year!)

Gobimanchurian · 11/07/2023 20:22

My DD gets basic maintenance loan and we pay her rent. That's £1500/term, roughly £100 /week for food, clothes, socialising, buses etc. She works in the holidays.

She has saved over £2k during her first year to pay for a couple of mini breaks/holidays. Second year she'll pay utilities in her rented house £100/month).

It's a balance between making her responsible for budgeting vs having her struggle. I do understand London cost of living & transport is super expensive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread