Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
FOJN · 12/07/2023 17:34

16% of voting posters think OP is BU. That's an awful lots of child abuse apologists on a parenting website mainly visited by women.

Who TF are you and WTF is wrong with you?

The people who either do this or endorse it make me want to vomit.

HorseyMel · 12/07/2023 16:32

The first photo looks a bit like Orlando Bloom

Helleofabore · 12/07/2023 15:50

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 12/07/2023 15:43

@Helleofabore

Thanks so much for your leg work on this thread and pretty much any other I see you on. 👏

x

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 12/07/2023 15:43

@Helleofabore

Thanks so much for your leg work on this thread and pretty much any other I see you on. 👏

DogbertMcDogglesworth · 12/07/2023 15:36

In fact, I'll go one further and say that it takes the piss out of women.
Why? Because most women who breastfeed do so because they want to nourish their child, but equally, the poor mum may encounter problems along the way from getting the child to latch to cracked sore nipples and being bloody tired.
Then we have the mum's who, despite their best efforts, can't breastfeed for various reasons, which is very upsetting for them.
Yet here we are with a bloke with a baby clamped to his nipples.
How do you think that makes those poor mum's feel? Nothing like rubbing salt into a wound get!
But, you know, who cares, it's only women!
It's taking the piss and it's sickening.

DogbertMcDogglesworth · 12/07/2023 15:29

Issania87 · 12/07/2023 13:22

An issue with the breastfeeding? I mean, it is certainly strange but then breastfeeding is a womanly thing to do and they want to be women so...

But think this is abuse and a fetish? No. Several birth born females would both enjoy nipple play and breastfeed their babies. They aren't linked.

I'm not producing breast milk and my breastfeeding days are finished by over 25 years.
Now, if I ' breastfed ' a baby today, what would that say about me?
Is there a difference between me doing that today and a transman? No, there isn't.
Dress it up how you like, but for me a man putting a child to his chest in such a way is tantamount to child sexual abuse in my mind.
Just the same as it would be if I did the same to a baby today.

Helleofabore · 12/07/2023 15:12

Women are delivering nutritionally balanced food that does not contain unknown chemicals and delivers enough, usually, for that infant's full requirements. They are feeding their child, that is their number one priority. To be fair, if a woman was using their child as a sexual encounter as the focus of their breastfeeding, then I would be very concerned with that as well.

They might find it stimulating. However, I remember being so fucking tired from getting up on demand that there was no way that I was even thinking erotic thoughts. Or maybe that slips people's mind, particularly if they had a straight forward delivery and one of those magic children that sleep through early. I mean the mastitis and the painful exploding breasts (again, not something a male will get because they produce so little milk).... yeah... that was really erotic stuff.

But hey ho! A rare few women find it 'erotic' so therefore it is perfectly fine for any male to use an infant for their own needs.

I am not sure people ever think this through.

Verv · 12/07/2023 14:51

They are absolutely linked.

Females may well enjoy nipple play, as it is an erogenous zone for many.

What separates motherhood from fetish is that regardless of nipple sensation, females are not males LARPing womanhood or motherhood and weaponising an infant to validate their identities.

Issania87 · 12/07/2023 13:22

An issue with the breastfeeding? I mean, it is certainly strange but then breastfeeding is a womanly thing to do and they want to be women so...

But think this is abuse and a fetish? No. Several birth born females would both enjoy nipple play and breastfeed their babies. They aren't linked.

Helleofabore · 10/07/2023 22:09

I am appalled what some women will overlook for the sake of centering male people’s needs before infants and any female person.

It is really eye opening. Yet, those women feel they are righteous.

It just goes to show what happens when some people lack the need to critically think through these issues.

FelineGood76 · 10/07/2023 20:54

Also, female breastfeeding enables mothers to release precisely the correct nutritional and fat content at the correct time in an infants growth cycle. As well as maternal antibodies.
Not remotely the same as a sweaty moob excreting God knows what.
I have no hesitation in saying anyone defending this is a brain dead handmaiden of the highest order.
With a questionable moral compass.

Nanny0gg · 10/07/2023 20:02

Seeitsayitsalted · 10/07/2023 10:34

From the La Leche league

”can trans women produce breast milk? Of course, but they need to follow the correct method to develop their breasts so as to induce lactation. To do so, they need to use the same hormones naturally released during a woman's pregnancy to develop their breasts. Once they do so they can often produce enough milk to cover between 25% and 75% of a baby's nutritional needs.”

Most breastfeeding mothers cover 100% of a baby's nutritional needs before it needs to go onto solids.

So if it's only 25% it absolutely is not for the benefit of the child

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/07/2023 19:36

FelineGood76 · 10/07/2023 19:33

There is NO peer reviewed study with a decent population that examined milk composition of males with galactorrhoea. Not one.
Anyone defending this is talking HORSESHIT. What the fuck is in your head that you are defending a MAN sticking his nipple in the mouth of an infant based purely on a feeing his head? Take a good look at yourself and ask how the hell you got to this point.
No benefit to the child. NONE.
AND THE LA-LECHE LEAGUE ARE TOTALLY CAPTURED BY STONEWALL. They do not provide unbiased impartial advice, and anyone taking their "science" as fact, is a brainwashed moron.

I know - I couldn't believe how captured La Leche were.

FelineGood76 · 10/07/2023 19:33

There is NO peer reviewed study with a decent population that examined milk composition of males with galactorrhoea. Not one.
Anyone defending this is talking HORSESHIT. What the fuck is in your head that you are defending a MAN sticking his nipple in the mouth of an infant based purely on a feeing his head? Take a good look at yourself and ask how the hell you got to this point.
No benefit to the child. NONE.
AND THE LA-LECHE LEAGUE ARE TOTALLY CAPTURED BY STONEWALL. They do not provide unbiased impartial advice, and anyone taking their "science" as fact, is a brainwashed moron.

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/07/2023 19:30

Helleofabore · 10/07/2023 16:25

I hope that the infants will be followed up for the duration of their lives.

This is yet another uncontrolled experiment for the benefit of the TRAs. We have no idea what the long term implications are for these babies, but that doesn't matter as long as the short-term thrills for the men involved are present.

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/07/2023 19:27

Seeitsayitsalted · 10/07/2023 10:24

Yes. He is

It is not remotely like breast milk.

"Spontaneous production of milk not associated with childbirth, known as galactorrhea, can occur in human males and females, but in males, due to lack of maturation of mammary glands during puberty, this fluid does not produce the necessary nutrients to sustain an infant."

Mammary glands/ milk ducts are modified sweat glands. Men who "feed" their babies like this are filling their little tummies with chemically induced SWEAT.

ArabeIIaScott · 10/07/2023 18:57

Lolapusht · 10/07/2023 16:41

@Helleofabore you are amazing!

Seconded.

MrsElsa · 10/07/2023 18:03

Male in t shirt and trousers puts nipple into baby's mouth = child abuse. Male in dress/wearing lipstick and on a number of drugs does the same = brave and stunning.

Make it make sense

TheKeatingFive · 10/07/2023 17:26

Adopters in the UK do not do this. Ever. I'm sick of adopters being used as a means to validate this or any other males decision to put his drug induced nipple secretions in a child's mouth. This does not happen in adoption in the UK.

It doesn't happen with adopters in the US either as the drugs are not licensed for this

Lolapusht · 10/07/2023 16:41

@Helleofabore you are amazing!

Jason Sudeikis Yes GIF by Apple TV+
nothingcomestonothing · 10/07/2023 16:35

PinkyU · 10/07/2023 09:35

Do you feel the same way about everyone who uses induced lactation?

People with IGT
People with traumatic births
People with pph
People with prem or sick babies
Adoptive parents
Same sex parents

Adopters in the UK do not do this. Ever. I'm sick of adopters being used as a means to validate this or any other males decision to put his drug induced nipple secretions in a child's mouth. This does not happen in adoption in the UK.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/07/2023 16:34

Sterling work on this thread, @Helleofabore

Helleofabore · 10/07/2023 16:32

Seeitsayitsalted · 10/07/2023 10:57

Those drugs are to stimulate the hormones to produce the milk

There is no transfer to the milk produced

it’s almost like you don’t think research is done before shit like this happens

The 'milk' has not tested for a range of other chemicals, including testosterone. In fact, the one study is from a male who took no drugs to stimulate the lactation, the lactation being a side effect of a medical condition.

So, you are here advocating that an unknown substance is absolutely fine to be fed to an infant?

Where is the colostrum? Where is the direct interaction with that male's body responding directly to the needs of the infant in how that secretion is formulated?

Are you absolutely confident that no other drugs that these male people are taking has any other unexpected side effects and are being secreted into that infant? Do you?

Or are you just perfectly happy for an infant to be experimented on for the sake of a male who may or may not have a fetish? Because .... reasons....

Helleofabore · 10/07/2023 16:20

Helleofabore · 10/07/2023 15:51

I shall post some relevant links here. Because males breastfeeding infants has been discussed often on MN.

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2161151-transgender-woman-is-first-to-be-able-to-breastfeed-her-baby/?utm_source=rakuten&utm_medium=affiliate&utm_campaign=2116208:Skimlinks.com&utm_content=10&ranMID=47192&ranEAID=TnL5HPStwNw&ranSiteID=TnL5HPStwNw-uOWyW0a0EHFcOxL5MmCf5Q&utm_source=rakuten&utm_medium=affiliate&utm_campaign=2116208:Skimlinks.com&utm_content=10&ranMID=47192&ranEAID=TnL5HPStwNw&ranSiteID=TnL5HPStwNw-eFdm05QNJngWSRNMPW32yA#ixzz6f2Pil0Ik

“However, the woman’s breastmilk has not been assessed yet, so we don’t know if it has the same mix of components as in milk from new gestational mothers. This means the practice cannot yet be recommended, says Madeline Deutsch at the University of California, San Francisco. She says she can see the potential benefits of breastfeeding, but that the long-term impact of this milk on the baby – including on subtle measures like IQ – is unknown.”

“Deutsch herself is a transgender woman with a six-month-old baby who is currently being breastfed by Deutsch’s wife, who was the gestational mother. “I am very sad not to be able to breastfeed her and at the same time I did not consider doing this for the above reasons,” she says.”

This was February 2018. I have not seen anything to prove that any in-depth studies have been released since to counter this expert's opinion. And there has been plenty of other threads since this that where these studies would have been posted by activist posters.

So, there we have it. A transitioned male, Associate Professor, Family Community Medicine, is telling the world that this is not advisable until further research.

This comes from that link too:

“After three months of treatment, this increased to 227 grams of breast milk per day. Once the baby was born, she was able to exclusively breastfeed the infant for six weeks – during which time a paediatrician confirmed the baby was growing and developing normally and healthily.”

“Although significant, this is below the average of around 500 grams that a baby consumes by the time the it is 5 days old. After six weeks, the woman supplemented her breastfeeding with formula.”

Just* *for clarity, the baby was fed exclusively for six weeks from the secretions from the male. And therefore was being undernourished, because this male insisted on doing this.... this was NOT in the interest of the infant at all.

Here is a doctor's view on male feeding.

https://lascapigliata.com/2018/03/26/analysis-of-study-of-induced-lactation-in-trans-identified-man/

"On presentation, the patient was on a gender-affirming regimen that included spironolactone (a heart medication used in this case as an androgen blocker), estradiol, micronised progesterone and “occasional” clonazepam and zolpidem for panic disorder and insomnia."

"At initial appointment, the patient had gynaecomastia (abnormally enlarged breasts in a man, Tanner stage V) that was likely a side effect of spironolactone and cross-sex hormones he was taking."

"Interestingly, it’s unclear what was the patient’s serum testosterone level, because two markedly different results were given, one in the body of text – 256 ng/dL – and another in the results table 1. – 20.52 ng/dL."

"This is problematic not only because it constitutes a glaring inconsistency within the report, but also because the higher result indicates that the patient had male testosterone levels. Considering that the study reported no further testosterone data, indicating that they didn’t measure his testosterone level at any other point in the study, and that 75% of trans-identified men on spironolactone fail to reach testosterone level in the female range, and those who augment the treatment with estradiol have variable response, there is no reliable evidence that adequate androgen blockade was achieved, even though authors claimed that androgen blockade was an important part of the regimen."

And it goes on.....

Well worth a read

Analysis of the experiment of induced lactation in a transwoman

Please read the updated version of this article HERE Recently a case study was reported, where a doctor and a nurse at a clinic used a cocktail of medications to enable a transwoman to fulfill his …

https://lascapigliata.com/2018/03/26/analysis-of-study-of-induced-lactation-in-trans-identified-man/