Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving because he doesn't want more children- reasonable?

139 replies

Hansilo · 10/07/2023 08:16

I know you can leave any relationship for any reason, I'm just curious if others have been in this position because I feel utterly shit daily about it and I don't know what to do.

I met H when I was 24 and he was 30, I was childless he wasn't. I told him from the start I wanted at least one child which we did then have 2 years ago. He has been saying for a long time that when things are better in a few years financially, space wise (need to move to a bigger house ideally) etc.. that he'd be open to having another.

Until this weekend when that's all changed and he's decided he doesn't, he's going to get the snip and that's that. I've said I don't know how I feel about that because I do think I'd want another child in the future and I thought we were on the same page of 'we will see when the time comes' (I definitely don't want another right now but I do think I may in a few years time which I though, because he told me so, he was open to as well).

I don't know what to do. I don't want him to get the snip. I don't want that to just be it and the end of any discussions. Obviously it's his choice and I completely respect that but I don't know where that leaves me in terms of my own choice to stay or go.

Things are a bit rocky between us right now and there have been times I've wanted to leave for other completely unrelated reasons but this just feels like a very big thing.

I'm not even 30 yet and I now have to accept thats it for children if I stay.

H thinks its totally unreasonable to leave over it and it makes me a terrible person who doesn't love him very much if I could leave over that. He thinks I should be content with having one child and be grateful that I even have that at all because he already had DC when we met so he didn't "need" more children, he agreed "for me" (which he absolutely did not say at the time we TTC our LO).

I just feel lost. I don't know what to do for the right. Obviously I have a young DC to consider too.

I just feel like a lot in our relationship is his way or the highway and he is never willing to compromise or see it from anyone else's POV. I understand this is his way because he shouldn't be made to have a child he doesn't want but he can't even understand or accept that it is hard for me to come to terms with, or see it from my POV that whilst obviously I accept its his choice, I am still allowed to feel upset by it. He thinks I'm completely unreasonable for having any sort of feeling about it.

My head is screaming at me to just get out, there are issues outside of this one, but this just feels like the cherry on top. But I have my child to think about too.

OP posts:
Hansilo · 10/07/2023 09:54

Lavenderflower · 10/07/2023 09:45

Do you think he is misled you about wanting more children?

If he's genuinely now saying he only had our existing child for me then yes I assume he also knew he didn't want more from the start and just "gave me one" to keep me happy.

OP posts:
PrincessTigger · 10/07/2023 09:53

YANBU

SchoolShenanigans · 10/07/2023 09:53

It's not just only having one child, is it. It's the fact he's making a unanimous decision despite your reservations. He's gone back on what he said and doesn't care about the implications on you. He's had his kids, and that's that.

Add to that, you're having issues anyway.

I would see a therapist (for you, not as a couple). Talk through how you feel, allow yourself time and space to think through the full ramifications of your options and time for the emotion to settle.

You only live once, and if you can't get passed only having one child, then you're going to feel resentful and that will harm your relationship anyway. I think you need a safe space to properly explore the next few years and how you want them to be.

Caroparo52 · 10/07/2023 09:52

Sounds like the marriage isn't going to last op. Whatever reason you choose to end it you're not happy. The more children is just one if many reasons you're unhapoy. But it may be the straw which broke the camels back.
If you move on now in your life you will be opening up to a potential happy ever after. If you stay with DH you're stuck forever with
" if only ....."
You are already answering your own questions so stop and listen to yourself.
Good luck

Invisibleeye · 10/07/2023 09:51

My ex didn’t want children at all. It wasn’t until I was with him and facing a future without the possibility that I realised I did indeed want them. I knew that if I stayed in 10 years time we would resent each other massively as one of us would be in a situation we didn’t want (and it was much more likely to be me as I obviously couldn’t force him to have a child and had to respect that choice). So I ended it and it was awful. But I don’t regret it as it was the right thing and now I have a one year old with my fiancé and.. well it just worked out for the best all round. Do what you think is best for the happiness of yourself and your child.

aSofaNearYou · 10/07/2023 09:49

Hansilo · 10/07/2023 09:32

I do realise now, from what he says, that he likely did only have another child to keep me from leaving. But yes I think that is manipulative and misleading. And I don't think it's then fair to expect gratitude from me about it either.

If that's the case it's far worse than him just changing his mind, though. He knew you wanted kids and consciously put you in a position where you had to feel like, and be perceived by others, to have "broken up your DCs family" to have the life he always knew you wanted.

Bollindger · 10/07/2023 09:48

Your not happy and I think the child issue is just the final straw that is making you realise that he now isn't enough for you.
Always having to give up your wants to please someone else seems very sad.
Live your best life, for you not his best life.

Staggersaurus · 10/07/2023 09:46

Hypothetically roll the relationship forward a few years. If you stay and don’t have another baby, how will you cope with the feelings of resentment? If you stay and have another baby, how will you cope with his feelings of not actually wanting that other baby? The only way to stay in the relationship is to both get therapy, otherwise it’s going to eat away at both of you.

snufkinhat · 10/07/2023 09:45

Hansilo · 10/07/2023 09:27

I feel he lied to me or at least misled me about only having a child "for me" which he now likes to say yes. At no point when we were ttc our LO did he say I'm happy with what I have but I'll have another for you. He made out like he wanted another just as much as me and now acts like I owe him gratitude for "giving me one" when he already had children. I think that's very unfair yes. And no I don't feel like I owe him gratitude for having a child for me when he made out like it was what he wanted as well at the time.

I think you need to just walk away from this awful dynamic rather than trying to get him to behave/ feel a certain way or say a certain thing or agree with you. You will never succeed. Just go.

80s · 10/07/2023 09:45

He thinks you are unreasonable, irrational and unpleasant, and you think he's manipulative, inconsiderate and lacking respect. And you say it's not just because of the child situation.

Wouldn't be a good idea to have another child with him anyway.

If you leave, don't make it about this issue.

Lavenderflower · 10/07/2023 09:45

Do you think he is misled you about wanting more children?

snufkinhat · 10/07/2023 09:44

Hansilo · 10/07/2023 08:27

I don't think he's selfish or unreasonable for deciding to have no more children, I think he's unreasonable not to have a bit of compassion about how I feel about that.

More reason to leave him, really.

You can't make him feel compassion, you just have to accept that he doesn't and walk away.

loislovesstewie · 10/07/2023 09:40

It's not about having another child, you say there are other issues and it's all his way or the highway. For me that would be enough. Better to leave now , not become a person who can't have an opinion and live with a person who can't compromise .

Karatema · 10/07/2023 09:37

A friend has just had her 5th child and her DH had the snip 3 years ago. Off her own bat she arranged for a dna test, because she didn't want her DH suspecting it wasn't his, it is. So it's possible but rare.

It would have been a dealbreaker for me not to have 2 but wasn't when my DH said no to a 3rd.
You have to way up the pros and cons.

tweener · 10/07/2023 09:36

Hansilo · 10/07/2023 09:27

I feel he lied to me or at least misled me about only having a child "for me" which he now likes to say yes. At no point when we were ttc our LO did he say I'm happy with what I have but I'll have another for you. He made out like he wanted another just as much as me and now acts like I owe him gratitude for "giving me one" when he already had children. I think that's very unfair yes. And no I don't feel like I owe him gratitude for having a child for me when he made out like it was what he wanted as well at the time.

I didn't comment on him saying he was only having a child to please you, that in itself seems like he's rewriting history to fit his current narrative. I was just commenting on the fact you said he lied, and as someone who wanted enough children to have a football team at one point I can understand changing your mind. I would say though, you sound angry about the situation (I'm not judging this) and when we get angry in this way we lose respect for the other person, we feel betrayed and hurt. I think unless both are willing to look at therapy together these sorts of feelings tend to fester and breed resentment so it may be that the way he's made you feel has meant the end of the relationship anyway.

Hansilo · 10/07/2023 09:32

I do realise now, from what he says, that he likely did only have another child to keep me from leaving. But yes I think that is manipulative and misleading. And I don't think it's then fair to expect gratitude from me about it either.

OP posts:
Switcher · 10/07/2023 09:30

He's not necessarily wrong not to want more kids, but he's being a manipulative twat about it, which is the more relevant part. What else is he going to turn around on you like that? I would leave.

Greeneyedmonster · 10/07/2023 09:30

I think the relationship is already over. I imagine though he is the type of man who will have another child with a new partner just to spite you.

aSofaNearYou · 10/07/2023 09:29

Stravaig · 10/07/2023 09:25

Do his older two children not spend any regular time with their father in your home? You don't seem to feel you also have two step-children, as well as your biological child.

Stupid argument, it's not remotely the same. My DP himself didn't feel fulfilled as a parent by being a NRP to his son, why on Earth would I?

Hazelnuttella · 10/07/2023 09:29

I think I’d have a hard time being with someone who completely dismisses my feelings/ right to have feelings.

I’d say there’s absolutely no guarantee about having another child if you did leave, but that doesn’t seem to be your only motivation.

Ansjovis · 10/07/2023 09:29

Think about it this way: imagine that you leave him and for whatever reason you don't manage to find someone else to have another child with. Really think about what your life would look like. Are you still happy that you made the decision to leave?

If this were the only reason you were unhappy I could see that being a decision you would live to regret but if there are other issues in the relationship it is not the same situation.

MsRosley · 10/07/2023 09:28

OP, I would leave him because he's intractable and manipulative. Refusing to work through issues in a constructive manner and always having to have his own way is tacit bullying.

Hansilo · 10/07/2023 09:27

tweener · 10/07/2023 09:25

Do you believe he lied to you?
Being open to more children at the time doesn't mean he's beholden to feeling that way forever. He already had children, maybe the newborn and toddler stage has made him realise he's passed all that and doesn't want to do it again.

Just as if you'd been open to more kids and changed your mind after having one, which you're entitled to.

I feel he lied to me or at least misled me about only having a child "for me" which he now likes to say yes. At no point when we were ttc our LO did he say I'm happy with what I have but I'll have another for you. He made out like he wanted another just as much as me and now acts like I owe him gratitude for "giving me one" when he already had children. I think that's very unfair yes. And no I don't feel like I owe him gratitude for having a child for me when he made out like it was what he wanted as well at the time.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 10/07/2023 09:27

OP the relationship is in trouble, you do not want another baby with him.

Listen to your gut, not him.

He is domineering and always right.

Start organising yourself to leave, let him have the snip.

Get out while you are young.

Crikeyalmighty · 10/07/2023 09:27

Unfortunately given he already has 2 children from previous situation- I do understand how he feels. , a lot of men these days have one eye too on the level of payments 'if things go wrong' - only you can decide if it's a dealbreaker- but no guarantee either that this will happen with someone else