Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel depressed about this?

83 replies

Stressful00 · 09/07/2023 21:18

I work at a nursery. Not through choice but not having much luck finding nanny work. I live quite rurally and before anyone says move, I'm not in a financial position to do that.
I feel really down tonight. On my FB feed there are people on benefits who are off on yet another mini break or who have bought a new car etc. I'm just living day to day. Working, going to appointments ( I have chronic conditions) and just being careful with money due to COL.
I sometimes wish I could pack it all in and go on the dole.

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 10/07/2023 23:15

JamSandle · 10/07/2023 23:10

Yes, I know a few people who pretend to be separated to claim benefits. They've always been quite open about it. I remember saying to my parents why don't we report it and them telling me to mind my own business basically.

Yes it's very widespread. I used to have a work colleague who did this. had lived with partner for several years and had youngest child together but he officially lived at his mums. She was getting benefits for four kids as a lone parent ( in the days when you could get more than two) and child maintenance from three different dads for her other kids. Then partner working and unofficially living with her. I hope she got caught and someone reported her.

XenoBitch · 10/07/2023 23:15

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 23:13

Caring for people is laudable but it's something that doesn't need UC to do it. That's a choice being made and it's being subsidized by taxpayers. This country is in a real mess. Basic rate tax is going to have to go up, and UC and benefits need a lot of changes. We don't have enough money to pay teachers or doctors apparently but we can pay UC. That's ridiculous and needs changing. The evidence is there is a core of people who never get off claiming it.

Spoken like someone who does not know what UC actually pays.
If you lose your job tomorrow, you will have a huge shock at the pittance you will be entitled to.

Jojobees · 10/07/2023 23:14

We get Uc, I work full time for the NHS. We are going to Greece in 2 weeks.

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 23:13

Caring for people is laudable but it's something that doesn't need UC to do it. That's a choice being made and it's being subsidized by taxpayers. This country is in a real mess. Basic rate tax is going to have to go up, and UC and benefits need a lot of changes. We don't have enough money to pay teachers or doctors apparently but we can pay UC. That's ridiculous and needs changing. The evidence is there is a core of people who never get off claiming it.

JamSandle · 10/07/2023 23:10

Moreorlessmentallystable · 10/07/2023 21:09

I have seen often people pretending not to be married or living together so they can keep claiming benefits separately, people cutting hours so they don't lose on benefits, and of course people working cash in hand and keeping quiet about it ...people are not very shy about it and unfortunately social media shows a lot, families that you know are in receipt of benefits yet the parents have money to go out drinking and to concerts, but the kids have to be subsidized for school meals, uniforms, school trips? To me that is wrong. I would feel awful using tax payer money for my kids but yet spending on myself.

Yes, I know a few people who pretend to be separated to claim benefits. They've always been quite open about it. I remember saying to my parents why don't we report it and them telling me to mind my own business basically.

Babyroobs · 10/07/2023 23:07

skire · 10/07/2023 23:02

When claiming UC, the claimant is always financially better off working.

In theory yes you are better off but many continue to stay in part time work only because they are not better enough off to make it worth their while when all things are considered like childcare costs ( a portion of which still need to be paid for after Uc have paid for most of it), costs of travel to work, work clothes etc.

SchoolShenanigans · 10/07/2023 23:07

I find this really strange. Why would you want to be sat around doing fuck all with your life? Yes, you work hard for a low salary, but at least you have purpose. Your day is busy, your time flies and you get to spend your day with gorgeous little ones and (hopefully) lovely colleagues.

I don't envy those out of work at all. That's no way to live.

I know times are tight but it won't always be that way. And at least you have pride that you do an extremely useful, valuable job.

XenoBitch · 10/07/2023 23:06

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 23:03

The point is if you are on UC you don't contribute to society financially for tax. OP is right to be annoyed.

How much do you have to earn to actually contribute socially too?
What about people who save the taxpayer a ton by being a carer?
There are so many ways to contribute to society without it being financial.

OP thinks people on benefits are rolling in it. She is welcome to claim and find out the truth.

skire · 10/07/2023 23:06

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 23:03

The point is if you are on UC you don't contribute to society financially for tax. OP is right to be annoyed.

41% of UC claimants are in work.

Babyroobs · 10/07/2023 23:05

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 23:03

The point is if you are on UC you don't contribute to society financially for tax. OP is right to be annoyed.

Many people on Uc do pay tax but yes they are likely to be net contributors .

Annaishere · 10/07/2023 23:04

They can be annoyed but I can’t help it

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 23:03

The point is if you are on UC you don't contribute to society financially for tax. OP is right to be annoyed.

skire · 10/07/2023 23:02

When claiming UC, the claimant is always financially better off working.

Mademetoxic · 10/07/2023 23:02

XenoBitch · 10/07/2023 22:57

If you don't qualify for the "free" stuff, or any benefits, then blame the system. Bashing people who rightfully claim benefits wont help you at all. It just makes you look like a Daily Mail reading asshole.

🙄

Which is why the system needs a complete overhaul.

Why should people who work and do not qualify for anything, who are getting not much more than people who are on benefits have to pay for everything, prescriptions, eye tests/glasses etc... List goes on.

The whole system needs a complete overhaul and needs to be reviewed.

Annaishere · 10/07/2023 23:00

Mademetoxic · 10/07/2023 22:55

What about people who work full time who have housing costs to pay for out of all this?
Who have rent/mortgages, have to pay for healthcare/glasses because they do not qualify for it being 'free'

The whole system needs a complete overhaul.

Yes there are genuine people on benefits, but if you're not entitled to anything it can seem like some people are 'better off' on benefits.

My rent isn’t free I pay it with UC

XenoBitch · 10/07/2023 22:57

Mademetoxic · 10/07/2023 22:55

What about people who work full time who have housing costs to pay for out of all this?
Who have rent/mortgages, have to pay for healthcare/glasses because they do not qualify for it being 'free'

The whole system needs a complete overhaul.

Yes there are genuine people on benefits, but if you're not entitled to anything it can seem like some people are 'better off' on benefits.

If you don't qualify for the "free" stuff, or any benefits, then blame the system. Bashing people who rightfully claim benefits wont help you at all. It just makes you look like a Daily Mail reading asshole.

Tryingoworkitout79 · 10/07/2023 22:55

I don't think you are BU to feel that way at all OP! And I actually also think some of the other posters have been quite harsh.
We often have these thoughts as it feels like an injustice (the way the system can work that is); it doesn't necessarily mean you're going to quit, but you're allowed to be frustrated that some people (it sounds like just a couple though?!) are -as you say- going on luxury holidays and generally appear to have more cash but not working.
The system is a bit crap in all honesty. When my youngest was a baby and I didn't work, I'm sure I had more money than when I went back to work part time when she was about 1, then by the time I was full time when she turned 3, it felt like I had even less!

That said, we didn't have expensive holidays back then and I've only just applied for a passport for DD and she's 5.

Mademetoxic · 10/07/2023 22:55

XenoBitch · 10/07/2023 21:09

Its a lot? PP has £1000 to live off for everything. They are also on the sickness element, which means they have been assessed and considered too poorly to work. I am sure they wish they could work, and that there was proper support out there to help them do so.

I am not sure of the exact figures but a very large percentage of people claiming UC do actually work. Blame shit wages, zero hours contracts, and the cost of living for the need fo people that work to be topped up by taxpayers (which we all are).,

What about people who work full time who have housing costs to pay for out of all this?
Who have rent/mortgages, have to pay for healthcare/glasses because they do not qualify for it being 'free'

The whole system needs a complete overhaul.

Yes there are genuine people on benefits, but if you're not entitled to anything it can seem like some people are 'better off' on benefits.

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 22:54

Bollocks. It means one pays for the other, and the other does nowt

XenoBitch · 10/07/2023 22:52

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 22:43

The person who says it is not sustainable is right. Guess who will be paying more in tax? That will be basic rate taxpayers because you cannot get anything near the amounts from the 10 percent of people who actually contribute tax (ie those who actually pay more in tax than they will get back).

OP is right to be angry. Her wages are kept low by part timers on UC and UC claims. Employers rely on it.

Sorry, but I claim UC (LCWRA), and what OP earns has absolute fuck all to do with the amount I claim.

Blowing out someone else's candle doesn't make yours shine any brighter.

Anxioys · 10/07/2023 22:43

The person who says it is not sustainable is right. Guess who will be paying more in tax? That will be basic rate taxpayers because you cannot get anything near the amounts from the 10 percent of people who actually contribute tax (ie those who actually pay more in tax than they will get back).

OP is right to be angry. Her wages are kept low by part timers on UC and UC claims. Employers rely on it.

yipeeyiyay · 10/07/2023 22:42

Curtains70 · 10/07/2023 16:37

If you genuinely believe you will be better off on the dole then just do it.

Or do you actually know that's bullshit?

There is someone unthread stating that they have no financial worries and holiday in the canaries. Other posts from social workers saying their claimants drive better cars than they do so....

Babyroobs · 10/07/2023 22:35

Moreorlessmentallystable · 10/07/2023 21:50

It's not a lot to live on but it's a lot if so many are on benefits! I absolutely agree with you shit wages are to blame. Benefits and min wage went up 10% yet most companies would not dream of increasing mid tier wages by 10%! I don't know the solution I just know the current situation is not sustainable...I believe someon on musmnet quoted that 40% of people of working age in the UK take more off the system (in benefits) that they contribute so no wonder why there is not enough in the budget for quality healthcare ,education, etc

£1000 a month is nothing compared to what some will be getting in places where rents are sky high and those claiming lot in childcare costs. For most this money is just going straight out again to pay for these things. However I do agree, I absolutely don't see how the amounts being paid are sustainable in the longer term as more and more people become reliant on them. The number of people making claims for PIP ( disability benefit for people under state pension age) has also massively increased since covid, maybe due to mental health issues, long covid etc. It isn't sustainable unless tax revenue increases a lot. Add into this an ageing population and all the benefits that go with that and I do think we have a ticking time bomb. The government needs to start thinking of workable solutions like more social housing, better mental health care and intervention etc to address this ticking time bomb. I sometimes feel I am biased as I work in helping people to access benefits but some of the amounts people are getting are huge. I frequently help older people to claim benefits and one recent example of a case is where an older couple were both granted a disability benefit which then entitled them to claim pension credit with various premiums added on. By the time their benefits were sorted they were getting an extra £1600 a month on top of state pensions. This is a regular thing in my line of work and yes you can argue that they qualify for that amount because they are both disabled and more likely to need to pay for care but it is still a huge amount just for one couple and replicated thousands of times over.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 10/07/2023 21:50

XenoBitch · 10/07/2023 21:09

Its a lot? PP has £1000 to live off for everything. They are also on the sickness element, which means they have been assessed and considered too poorly to work. I am sure they wish they could work, and that there was proper support out there to help them do so.

I am not sure of the exact figures but a very large percentage of people claiming UC do actually work. Blame shit wages, zero hours contracts, and the cost of living for the need fo people that work to be topped up by taxpayers (which we all are).,

It's not a lot to live on but it's a lot if so many are on benefits! I absolutely agree with you shit wages are to blame. Benefits and min wage went up 10% yet most companies would not dream of increasing mid tier wages by 10%! I don't know the solution I just know the current situation is not sustainable...I believe someon on musmnet quoted that 40% of people of working age in the UK take more off the system (in benefits) that they contribute so no wonder why there is not enough in the budget for quality healthcare ,education, etc

Annaishere · 10/07/2023 21:23

@Moreorlessmentallystable and @XenoBitch to clarify in total I get over a thousand per month because I get about a £270 child element/Child benefits but those really do all go on my son, especially needing to pay £140 per month on his travelling expenses. I don’t think it’s a very low income and I am fairly ok financially, but before I claimed the sickness element I did really struggle. I still don’t have a cooker or freezer. I would love to work but I just can’t see a way forward until I get my health issues sorted out better