Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if doing it alone is easier alone than more people like to admit?

116 replies

biancsa · 09/07/2023 20:10

I’m a mum to dd 4. My DH and I divorced when she was 20 months. He was a present and good dad to DD and so supportive of me. I do miss the family unit. However…

What surprised me was that parenting became ‘simpler’ for me when it was just me. Since the divorce I’ve been given the sad eyes a lot about how I’m coping alone as a single parent and I find it curious? Does anyone else find it easier?! I have a routine for DD that is never disturbed. The house can be messy but it’s all my mess so I still know where things are and nothing is ever moved. I don’t have to discuss what’s happening or what we are doing or factor another person in, so we just get on with it. We are never late to events or parties, we are organised and things run smoothly… much more so than when I had to share a house with exdh. Mealtimes are easy, nothing ever feels chaotic. I do miss exdh at times, in terms of discussing things about DD or just when i want an hour to myself, but day to day I definitely find life simpler to parent, even though he was very hands on. Is this just me? I was terrified of being single but motherhood really has been easier.

OP posts:
Blueey · 10/07/2023 11:10

I'm not a single parent but I definitely notice things run more smoothly when DH is away, and my single mum friends report similar to you. I think it's partly because when you're parenting alone you 1) Can set your own routines and plans without having to discuss with another adult and 2)You HAVE to just get things done yourself so you get on with chores and stuff more rather than hoping the other person does it, talking about who will do it etc. DH is a helpful and active parent but that means there is more negotiation, planning and discussion than is needed when I'm just 100% in charge.

I think it would get tiring having no time alone without kids though.

Diymesss · 10/07/2023 11:09

I find it easier on my own, but I do co-parent 50/50 which gives me a break that I never used to have.

My ex was away working a lot, but still had high expectations about how the house was and how the kids were cared for, with lots of lovely blame for me if things didn't meet those expectations - but always with the excuse for him that he was away, so it wasn't on him.

I could count on one hand in a fifteen year relationship the number of times I can remember him cooking for me, or cleaning the bathroom, or picking up the hoover, or putting a wash on. He was great at talking, great at expressing his opinion, but didn't want to do any of the daily grind of housework.

GrapeHyacinth · 10/07/2023 11:01

No, I much preferred it when dh was alive. I hate having full responsibility for everything with no one to share it with. If he was still alive but we were separated I'd find it easier as he'd still be sharing the responsibility.

liondreams · 10/07/2023 10:50

Single parent for 10+ years here. It goes in waves. Yes there are things that are a bit easier, but for the most part I would love to have a caring partner to share the load with, both emotionally, monetarily and practically. carrying everything alone is tough. Not being able to leave the house for 10 years without your kid is super hard (excepting school times!!). Just wish I had someone who would do a school run for me a couple of times a week, pay a bill or let me lean on them when I am run down and tired. There are some upsides: choosing own decor, cleaning own stuff and not someone else's. But on balance, now I would love a decent partner - I'm tired and weary of the solo burden.

RecycleMePlease · 10/07/2023 10:46

I agree - just not having an extra adult's mess is fantastic (although perhaps my feelings are coloured by the amount of mess ex produced).

The only bit I find hard is that there is no break - and even that's getting better now they're older - but still I can feel like I'm either working, 'on duty' for the kids, or cleaning the house - and if I take a moment I feel guilty because there's normally something I should be doing.

Also not being able to just pop out in the evenings is a pain - mine are old enough I can pop to the shops in the day, but I wouldn't leave them when it's dark.

Sheknowsnow · 10/07/2023 08:34

Yes I've found it easy, LP for 15 years. Not supposed to say that. We're all meant to be 'coping', 'surviving' etc. I actually hate those terms in relation to parenting. (that MN ad re surviving the holidays is annoying me, I bloody love the holidays!) It's never felt hard work to me, apart from the baby stage, that was hard work. Our home is peaceful and calm, always.
Saying all that I have one very easy going healthy child and no ex to contend with. I'm sure it's very different when multiple children are involved or children with sen.

Libelula21 · 10/07/2023 08:22

I’m a widow too, mother of a 6 year old.

I see both sides - somethings are easier, I’m free to throw us both in to play dates etc at weekends in a way my partner wouldn’t have liked.

But I also find it hard, and lonely. I’m not a self starter, so I find it hard to keep going with everything on my shoulders. The house is messier - which is ok, because I’m the only adult - but I’ve got in to some bad habits.

I find part time work and motherhood and home keeping really exhausting - I’m 48 so maybe age / perimenopause/ energy levels are an issue.

I get really lonely - WFH, out once in a blue moon, every weekend spent with a 6yo.

So yes, I get a lot of freedom, and it is easier. But it’s so all-in, I kind of feel my own life - in terms of love and projects and dreams - is over. :-/ Curing my low level internet addiction would be a start though!

EarringsandLipstick · 10/07/2023 08:12

Highdaysandholidays1 · 10/07/2023 06:03

Not easier for me. I have done weeks alone when the kids were little and he worked away which were just fine, but now I'm completely on my own (widow) I find when the teenage years were tricky, it was very hard to parent on my own, even just logistically if one teen goes out, crisis occurs, needs picking up. We had a lot of typical teenage troubles and that has been very hard emotionally to deal with and require a huge amount of emotional investment and time, and doing all that and working full-time and running a household is very tiring.

I'm sorry you lost your DH 💐

I completely understand and agree with you regarding the teen years.

nex18 · 10/07/2023 08:12

@biancsa embarrassment and self protection to begin with I think (he had an affair). I think the reason why he’d gradually checked out while we were together is because they didn’t need him as much for play and entertainment, as in they were developing their own friendships and interests. You’re right, they are amazing, thank you!

biancsa · 10/07/2023 08:03

MaxwellCat · 10/07/2023 08:01

Same here my oldest is autistic and hasn’t attended school for a year as they can’t meet her needs so she’s been with me 24/7 all day every day can’t go anywhere without her she has to come everywhere and I’m slowly losing the will to live and manage 3 other children alone. I can see how one child and generous maintenance payments would be easy though.

@MaxwellCat can you get any support from any services? That seems so hard to be left to manage alone when your dc cannot attend school which I assume also stops you being able to work? So you can’t have your own life either? I am angry on your behalf!

OP posts:
MaxwellCat · 10/07/2023 08:01

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/07/2023 01:44

No. Worst thing ever.

Try being a lone parent 365 days a year of dc with additional needs and no family. It's relentless. Quite sure it's knocked a fair few years off my own life expectancy.

Same here my oldest is autistic and hasn’t attended school for a year as they can’t meet her needs so she’s been with me 24/7 all day every day can’t go anywhere without her she has to come everywhere and I’m slowly losing the will to live and manage 3 other children alone. I can see how one child and generous maintenance payments would be easy though.

Coralsunset · 10/07/2023 08:01

I found it so much easier parenting alone. I have two DC and their dad saw them regularly and paid maintenance. A few arguments around co parenting apart, yes. However, far fewer than we were having living together.

In a way, he was the biggest, most annoying kid of all. The only thing I found difficult was looking after a big house alone with limited funds. Even small odd jobs are beyond me due to disability.

biancsa · 10/07/2023 07:58

@Passwordsarestressful also i guess I spend time with other adults at work? Then if I take dc out a friend often comes too. I try to meet friends for coffee over lunch breaks or just catch up over the phone. I find that side tricky to manage.

OP posts:
biancsa · 10/07/2023 07:56

@nex18 gosh why do you think he suddenly changed his attitude towards seeing them?! Some people (men) are truly dire aren’t they. Your kids sound fantastic!

OP posts:
biancsa · 10/07/2023 07:54

@thisisasurvivor j work four days and have maintenance of around 550. I spend my day off taking dc on a day out and try to do online shops etc.

OP posts:
nex18 · 10/07/2023 07:54

For me it was much easier without the resentment of exh being there but contributing very little. We eventually split up when the children were 10 and 13, they’re now 17 and 20.
I can split up our lives into 3 sections, when they were pre-school we did family activities and exh was involved although mainly with play than structure and routine.
By the time youngest was 4 exh had pretty much checked out, he’d always worked shifts but now he worked nearly every weekend, he would take care of the kids after school on his week days off but would often work extra shifts and expect me to organise alternative childcare, he sometimes had made dinner before I got home (but only fish fingers and chips type things). I took them to dance, football, swimming, gymnastics, I took time off if they were ill, I did all the life organisation and most of the housework. Fwiw I had worked FT since youngest was 2, when I’d changed jobs from shifts to M-F 9-5, I also earned more.
I have done the teenage years completely alone, exh does not contribute to their lives (except for through CMS who take directly from his wages), he doesn’t see them except a handful of times (he saw them about once a month for the first few months, now it’s only if they arrange it themselves, usually by visiting grandparents at the same time as he does). I have negotiated various A&E trips, first relationship breakups, GCSES x 2, A levels and off to uni x 1 (6th form options and thinking of next plans with second), learning to drive, coping with teen parties, drinking, vaping, emotional crisis, lift giving etc etc…
I have 2 well rounded, independent, resilient young adults who I am very proud of. I know I can take sole credit for their wonderfulness.

biancsa · 10/07/2023 07:52

@Passwordsarestressful your post has scared me a bit! I thought by 8 it would be easier? Why do you say that?

He doesn’t work locally so pays maintenance and sees dc ad hoc. I hate that but he won’t move on it.

OP posts:
Highdaysandholidays1 · 10/07/2023 06:03

Not easier for me. I have done weeks alone when the kids were little and he worked away which were just fine, but now I'm completely on my own (widow) I find when the teenage years were tricky, it was very hard to parent on my own, even just logistically if one teen goes out, crisis occurs, needs picking up. We had a lot of typical teenage troubles and that has been very hard emotionally to deal with and require a huge amount of emotional investment and time, and doing all that and working full-time and running a household is very tiring.

Simpsonsclouds · 10/07/2023 05:58

I guess it depends how many kids you have. I have 5. Teens now. Their father was an actively involved father when we were married and were a family unit .
Now, he never sees them. So it's just then and me.
I do not find it easier. Also financially it's extremely hard and not easier.
I can see however having a 4yr old would be. You know where they are and they go to bed.😁

Passwordsarestressful · 10/07/2023 05:56

I'm curious about a few things.
Do you get to go out a s spend time with just other adults ever?
Why does he take his child on day trips and nothing else? Is this the plan longer term? This behaviour doesn't match the man you described in OP really.
I would have been able to manage my DC solo at 4. I would've been destroyed doing it all alone by the time they were 8 and 10.

Lioney · 10/07/2023 05:46

I imagine with only 1 small dc it would be ok being a SP.

But I have 6 dc, only 4 at home now. Various additional needs.

No support or help.

Exdp doesn't see the dc regularly (his choice).
Never had them all by himself or overnight.
Never paid maintenance.

Yes my household is more organised, tidy & better run.

But in all honesty, the responsibility of doing everything, every day for years on end is utterly exhausting.
Financially I'm f*ed.

THisbackwithavengeance · 10/07/2023 05:21

I don't disagree.

But you don't mention if you work at all?

Being a single parent to one child on benefits and decent maintenance, having your rent and bills covered so can spend all day looking after child and nothing else = very easy.

Working full time with no or limited financial support from a third party albeit it DWP or DH and having to juggle childcare especially with multiple kids = very difficult

thisisasurvivor · 10/07/2023 05:14

Yes it did for me

As I was away from abuse

Safe in my own house

And knew my child was safe too as he didn't know where we were

Honestly getting out was weirdly one of the best days of my life

Not always plane sailing though

Also so people in my community look down on us as I'm a single parent
This makes me laugh 😂

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 10/07/2023 02:12

Single parenting is much easier than having a useless partner around, that's for sure.

With less money, I am actually able to budget better and afford more. With more activities I manage the juggling easier because I don't ever have the false hope that someone else will help and then bring let down.

I get no maintenance, DSs talk to their dad but he lives in another country so don't see him. So it is ALL on me, but it always was all on me even when we were together. Now I can just ignore him and get on with it, which is what makes it easier.

I moved closer to my family though, and now have their emotional support which is huge. Things like helping with food prep for a birthday party etc, so nice to have that support.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/07/2023 01:44

No. Worst thing ever.

Try being a lone parent 365 days a year of dc with additional needs and no family. It's relentless. Quite sure it's knocked a fair few years off my own life expectancy.