Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if this is why some people find parenting easier?

117 replies

rtpp · 09/07/2023 19:42

Is it just the temperament of the baby? Or is it less selfish people find the transition easier?

I am on one side of coping and my close friend is on the other and it baffles me as to why this is.

OP posts:
Tinybrother · 09/07/2023 20:17

rtpp · 09/07/2023 20:11

@Thegreatbigbarrieroflondon i always wondered this! I’ve never gone for a wee with my dc there unless in a shopping centre.

I was always fine with my 1yos following me everywhere, including to the loo. It’s kind of what they are supposed to do. Didn’t stop them being independent etc when older. It was all fine.

Hollyppp · 09/07/2023 20:16

I think baby temperament plus a HUGE part (other factors do play a part but much less so).

people with easy first babies often have an AHA moment about their friends when they have a ‘trickier’ second baby eg more fussy. Lots of my friends have had bad sleepers second time round whereas they had unicorn babies first time (and thought it was just their excellent parenting making their baby happy)

Rockfordpeach · 09/07/2023 20:16

I think there are lots of factors that affect this. My eldest DD was a breeze, slept amazingly, calm temperament, non demanding etc.
My youngest did not sleep for three years and is very clingy and demanding. He was also premature and I had a huge amount of anxiety and PTSD in relation to that which clearly affected things. He was exclusively breastfed and DD was formula fed.

Now she's a teen shes my hard child and my DS is the easy one

TeenLifeMum · 09/07/2023 20:16

I think implying people struggle are more selfish and that’s where the problem lies is a horrible and totally incorrect statement. Smug parents with chilled babies then thinking they’re less selfish than their struggling friends is dickish.

Ginola2345 · 09/07/2023 20:16

Its a lot of variables mums health, babies health, both getting a good nights sleep, both temperaments, relationship with babies dad, wider support networks, other factors, such as age of mum, standards of housework, any pets or other children to care for, health of parents and parents in law and extra pressure here or expectation to provide care, visitors to entertain, organisation etc etc.

DS was a brilliant easy baby but handwork when he got to school and easy as a teenager. DD was very handwork and demanding as a baby but a very easy toddler and child until she turned 12 or 13. She is 18 and still hard work.

Enjoy it while you can OP and try not to be judgemental the shoe could easily be on the other foot soon enough.

AuntieJune · 09/07/2023 20:15

All the above plus isolation is a key factor.

I live in a city, in a fairly close knit community. I could take DC to baby groups, parks, soft play, museums, child friendly cafes etc etc. As they've grown, friends are nearby so can do playdates a lot as we're all on neighbouring streets.

Compare to friends who live in a village 20m ish away - there are way fewer opportunities to observe other parents. You can't discuss problems or absorb ideas about what you do or don't want to do with your own kids. There's one pub and it's not child friendly. It's a harder experience because it's more isolated.

LividHot · 09/07/2023 20:15

Some people just take for granted:

Babies that sleep
Babies that take bottles
Babies that will be put down
Free grandparent childcare
Family who take their kids out all the time
Kids who aren't car sick
Kids who get in the car seat or pram first time
Kids that sleep all night in their own bed
Money to pay for stuff
Partners who aren't abusive fuckin twats

Sadly I am not these people 😅🫣😳😳
But life is getting gradually easier, as DC gets older, and now I'm divorcing his dad .

TeenLifeMum · 09/07/2023 20:15

Dd 1 had colic and cried all the time. She was 12 weeks old the first time she slept 3 solid hours in a row and I woke feeling rested (then panicked she’d died). No family to help. I struggled. I’d read every book and was prepared but turned out Dd hadn’t read the books and had her own plans.

dtds 1-2 - twins plus toddler so exhausting and constant but they were premature and slept, woke, fed, slept. Far easier to cope when you’ve had sleep.

Cherryana · 09/07/2023 20:14

It’s never one thing but a combination.

  • I did GF method and so always slept which made a massive difference to my day to day.
-Lowish expectations about what I could do in a day. -Cast iron routine for misbehaviour with a script I would follow, and logical consequences that I always followed through - took reactions and emotions out of it AND meant the kids knew I meant what I said. That made parenting easy and meant that most of the time stuff was/is low level things. -On the same page as my husband and he is a helpful husband most of the time. -Always accepted childcare help eg grandparents and childminder. Never felt I had to do it all.
AngelinaFibres · 09/07/2023 20:14

My SIL had a very chilled first baby. She found breast feeding a breeze, produced lots of milk and the baby slept for hours. She started a business advising women in deprived area of London on how to have a perfect baby too. Her second baby had extreme reflux, tongue tie, hated breast feeding and slept for ten minutes then woke and screamed for hours. She lived in a lovely area of London, had a husband who adored her and didn't need to worry about anything. She was absolutely exhausted. She was also a lot less smug. She got lucky with her first baby and not so lucky with her second.

BitOutOfPractice · 09/07/2023 20:12

@MaxwellCat i bet you’re not a shit patent. Really, I’d bet quite a lot of money. All you can do is your best and I just know that that is enough. 💐

EmeraldFox · 09/07/2023 20:12

I think previous experience and expectations are a big factor.

I had a tongue tied baby so breastfeeding wasn't easy at first. DV in the fourth trimester so I had to leave. Wouldn't be put down awake for five months. However, I was a young mother and had practically been a third parent to a sibling until I had my own. I think it may be harder for first time older parents after having 15+ years of freedom.

thecatsthecats · 09/07/2023 20:12

Newnamenewname109870 · 09/07/2023 19:55

Baby temperament. People really underestimate how diffirent they can be! And that actually your perfect advice won’t work.

Also mother temperament like if you’re very anxious and worried about being perfect you often find it harder.

This!

My twin niece and nephew were the perfect example. She was a watch and think baby, and he was a cry if you think about looking elsewhere baby.

rtpp · 09/07/2023 20:11

Thegreatbigbarrieroflondon · 09/07/2023 20:01

Some people make life harder for themselves. My neighbour complains her 1 year old follows her relentlessly round the house and when I suggested a stair gate she was astounded. I mean I never, ever had a toddler follow me for a piss and I had three of them.

@Thegreatbigbarrieroflondon i always wondered this! I’ve never gone for a wee with my dc there unless in a shopping centre.

OP posts:
IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 09/07/2023 20:10

Me and my best friend were on vastly different sides at the same time in our lives age-wise with similarly difficult babies. But one coped like it was all a breeze and one had crippling PND. These are the reasons I can identify where we differed:

1- different temperaments of husbands (as well as different ages of husbands). One had a significantly older husband who was quite highly strung, one had a younger husband who was pretty chill (maybe too chill sometimes!)

2- different family attitudes to mental health. One had a family with quite open MH issues who talked about stuff, one had a buttoned up family with no MH issues ever acknowledged or discussed.

3- different lengths of relationship. One had been married over 12 years and were an incredibly established couple, very used to their dynamic. One had been married a year and only known her husband 2.5 years, less established and with less defined rules.

4- different family support/kids in family already. Vastly differing situations here for us both.

5- different general dispositions. One quite nervy and already had established links with MH help, one very much never having had MH issues before.

Probably other factors, but those are the main ones. I wonder if you can guess which of us had PND and which didn't, as what I've detailed above doesn't entirely fall with the one you'd think would have trouble for all categories. Showing it's a combination of factors.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 09/07/2023 20:08

Loads of circumstantial things (finances, how much partner pulls weight, health, family support, friendship networks, to name but a few) but yes - temperament of the baby plays a huge part.

I had an ‘easy’ baby first time and I patted myself on the back for being such a naturally superb parent. I wondered why other people complained about babies and parenting being hard and concluded that it must be because they just weren’t as good at it as I was.

Then I had my second one and… well. Pride comes before a fall and all that. Let’s just say it turned out my superb parenting was 99% luck.

JudgeRudy · 09/07/2023 20:07

I'm sure the baby's temperament and the parents personalities make a huge difference, as does what else you're having to cope with at the same time eg additional children, financial stresses, relationship problems etc.
I think it's very hard to define selfish. If one of your 'selfish' traits was to eg have a bedroom in complete darkness and quiet to sleep, then that person might struggle more. If you're used to going running for an hour everyday parenting might be hard, but are you actually selfish? If you're vain or have body issues and now have a deflated balloon of a belly and thin hair and spots that's gonna impact more on you than the tomboy who has spent the last 5 years in leggings and TShirt.
Parenthood is a bit of a leveller. Things like PND of special needs doesn't discriminate snd can affect us all.

SoGiveMeCoffeeAndTV · 09/07/2023 20:06

Anecdotally, I find my friends who find parenting easy have huge amounts of support. My friend who loves being a mum has her mum on hand pretty much all the time, has a nanny and a really supportive husband.

I find parenting hard. I have 3 under 5 and I am done in. My family live far away, my husband works away a lot. Most of the time it’s just me and the kids. I love them but I’ve lost who I am. I wish I could enjoy being a parent but I don’t have it in me.

technotstarnotechstar · 09/07/2023 20:06

I think it's a combination of baby temperament and adult personality. I have noticed that those I know who struggled most were the ones who had not really had to deal with anything challenging in their life yet.If your life has always been easy, having to keep going when things are hard is more of a shock to the system. I also noticed more married people struggle than single people, perhaps there is an element of choice too. If you have always had lots of support, you know you can step back and not cope and that others will take over and give you a break. Those who are solo by choice have to keep going so they just do.

MargaretThursday · 09/07/2023 20:05

Temperament of the baby, but also temperament of the mum/dad too.

My #1 came out knowing how to sleep and eat, which made both nights and breastfeeding really easy.
#2 didn't know either, but I was far more relaxed about it than if she'd been my #1 because I knew I couldn't do anything about it.

I also love the baby stage, which helps.

uhtredsonofuhtred1 · 09/07/2023 20:03

I've got 4 children. The first 2 were lovely babies. Slept amazingly from birth, only cried when they wanted something, teething was no problem at all, healthy, had lots of weekend help from my parents. Money was tight but never an issue. Husband was ok (!!) I mean he wasn't abusive or horrible, just left it up to me a lot. So I coped excellently, I was happy, relaxed, made lots of new mum friends, had such a great few years.

3rd child - oh my god!! She's since been diagnosed autistic which might explain a lot. She screamed literally all day most days. If someone else made eye contact with her she would scream as though she was hurt. No one else at all could hold her or feed her. She needed to be constantly rocked and stood up with. From 2 days old until about 7 months old she was such a difficult baby. It genuinely near drove me to breaking point. My mum died and my dad moved away. I had a horrible abusive partner. I think this all fed into the already awful time I was having to be honest.

SouthLondonMum22 · 09/07/2023 20:03

I think a major factor I largely find it easier than some is that I don't have a shit husband. He does his fair share so not everything is left to me be it changing nappies or doing the laundry.

The other one is that my baby is an excellent sleeper.

Yellowlegobrick · 09/07/2023 20:03

Its a mix of about 25 things!

Temperament of baby
Supportive partner
Supportive family
How prepared/realistic you were
Your own temperament
Money (ime everything is easier when you have the choice to pay to make some issues go away)
A bit of luck (eg having a doctor or hv who spots reflux, a friend who helps you bf)

I do think there's an element, i wouldnt say "how selfish you are" but more whether you were at a stage in life etc to be ready for the sacrifices parenting involves. For some people they grieve their pre-baby lifestyle, figure etc more than perhaps others do.

Straightsidedcircle · 09/07/2023 20:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LaMaG · 09/07/2023 20:02

Ultraviolet85 · 09/07/2023 19:58

Temperament of baby is a huge one and complete luck of the draw. It’s easy to be a super chill parent and breeze through it when baby feeds and sleeps well. Compared with a strung out mum who is dealing with a baby who has silent reflux, barely sleeps and doesn’t stop crying. I have had both!

Agree! I know no one who is sufficiently mentally capable of dealing with a colicky screaming baby without becoming stressed. Mine wasn't a screamer but never slept and I had DP but no other support. Took over 3 years for a night sleep and it took a very serious toll on our lives. I would challenge anyone to cope with what we had, and that's with a healthy mother and baby, nice house and job security so on balance we were lucky.