Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the age of consent should be 18?

33 replies

enemaofthestate · 09/07/2023 19:18

The discussions about a certain news story have got me thinking about the discrepancy between the fact indecent images of 16-17-year-olds are classed as children/illegal but those same children are above the age of consent in law.

So a grown man could be breaking the law by having an indecent photo of a 17-year-old girl, yet still legally be allowed to have a sexual relationship with her, despite the fact everyone can see it is inappropriate and wrong.

Surely if the law can recognise one is wrong then it should apply to both???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
1Gadfly · 19/09/2023 08:09

The law is there to protect children from adults. Children are not prosecuted for having sex with their peers. It would be v difficult to justify any prosecution of consenting children on public internet grounds.

JazbayGrapes · 10/07/2023 09:09

no. 16 is fair enough and it would be counterproductive to criminalize young lovers.

thing as selling nudes though - age should be increased to 21 at least.

Noicant · 10/07/2023 08:43

MeMyselfandI2 · 09/07/2023 20:10

I grew up in the western United States. The age of consent was 18, but realistically teenagers had sex all the time and there wasn’t prosecution of teenagers having sex with each other. Adults having sexual contact with teenagers was broken down in three categories: under 13, 14-15, and 16-17. These are statutory crimes which mean if the events are proven to have occurred there is no defense - the crime occurred and the penalty should be imposed.

Under 13, anyone over 18 is subject to criminal penalties.

14-15, anyone over 18 is subject to criminal penalties but the level of penalty is two tiered. If more than 4 years age difference one penalty and less than 4 years age difference another penalty.

16-17, a little more nuanced. If the person knows or reasonably should have known the minors age and is less than 9 years older than the minor one penalty. If more than 10 years older (full stop) than another penalty.

This seems to me to recognize teenagers need to be protected at different ages in different ways. The real problem is lack of reporting and failure to prosecute sometimes. But overall I think something similar to this is a good balance.

Sounds sensible

Doagooddeed · 10/07/2023 08:43

enemaofthestate · 09/07/2023 19:33

But what about older adults with younger people?

How can it be illegal for a 50-year-old man to possess an indecent photo of a 17-year-old girl… yet okay for him to be in a sexual relationship with the very same girl?

If we regard the first one as wrong then why not the second?

That is more what I’m thinking of rather than younger teens sleeping with each other.

One cannot state an age limit on who can sleep with a 16yo or even an 18yo.

I think the upper age limit on indecent images is probably due to the ability of older men to exploit younger people over the internet, few 16yo in real life would want to sleep with a 50yo,

Or knowing how the Govt has not been working over the last few years, the person who drafted the law, thought the age of consent was 18.

Gerrataere · 10/07/2023 08:29

I agree with others, it should be relative. No adult should be going near teenagers, but once they hit 16 the cries of ‘well it’s legal innit’ are deafening. Anyone 20+ looking for a sexual connection with someone still at school is an absolute red flag at best. It still leads to grooming but proving it is near impossible. Teenagers will do what teens do, and with each other shouldn’t be against the law. An adult (let’s face it, men in the majority) shouldn’t be anywhere near a teenager though.

LlynTegid · 10/07/2023 08:22

The age of consent should depend on the age of the other person in part. So two 16 year olds having a relationship fine, perhaps for 16 and 17 year olds the other person must be 21 or under.

winteriscoming2022 · 10/07/2023 07:53

I was 16, my boyfriend 21 when we first had sex. The majority of my friends had been sexually active since around 14. I went on to my marry my bf, were together twenty years and had two children. How on earth would changing the age of consent be a positive move? Having brought up numerous teenagers ( mine plus looking after them) I can assure you that the majority will become sexually active at around 16

PlatBilledDuckypuss · 10/07/2023 07:48

dressornot · 09/07/2023 19:22

Personally if there was a way of saying,

16+ but if one person is 16 or 17, then their partner may be no older than 18.

Otherwise 18+ for any ages.

I think that would be best

The Italians use this basis, I believe. There the age is 13.

SallyWD · 10/07/2023 07:43

No you would just criminalise the perfectly normal behaviour of plenty of 16 and 17 year olds.

Createausername1970 · 10/07/2023 07:25

Takoneko · 09/07/2023 19:51

@Createausername1970 I suspect that you’ve not been given the full picture. I work in child protection and cannot imagine police prosecuting a consensual sexual relationship between two teenagers in year 11 and year 13. There are highly likely to be other aggravating factors there. They don’t use the age of consent to prosecute consensual sex between young people of similar ages. For it to get to prosecution and sex offenders register then I’d guess that there is an issue around consent, whether that’s capacity (intoxication, SEND, other vulnerability that makes the younger girl less able to consent) or position of power (e.g. the 18 year old being employed by the school/ volunteering at a club etc.).

I thought this may have been the case, that there was more to it than I was being told. The person who told me was friends with the boys family, so I did wonder if it was an attempt to get one side of the story across, damage limitation, as the girl was from another area, apparently, so her side would be less known.

But as my son was younger than the lad in question and moved in totally different circles, I never heard this from anyone else. So if it was damage limitation, it didn't work because I now know something about this lad that I might have been otherwise unaware of.

But, as I have never heard it from anyone else, I am now wondering is it even true?

MeMyselfandI2 · 09/07/2023 20:10

I grew up in the western United States. The age of consent was 18, but realistically teenagers had sex all the time and there wasn’t prosecution of teenagers having sex with each other. Adults having sexual contact with teenagers was broken down in three categories: under 13, 14-15, and 16-17. These are statutory crimes which mean if the events are proven to have occurred there is no defense - the crime occurred and the penalty should be imposed.

Under 13, anyone over 18 is subject to criminal penalties.

14-15, anyone over 18 is subject to criminal penalties but the level of penalty is two tiered. If more than 4 years age difference one penalty and less than 4 years age difference another penalty.

16-17, a little more nuanced. If the person knows or reasonably should have known the minors age and is less than 9 years older than the minor one penalty. If more than 10 years older (full stop) than another penalty.

This seems to me to recognize teenagers need to be protected at different ages in different ways. The real problem is lack of reporting and failure to prosecute sometimes. But overall I think something similar to this is a good balance.

Takoneko · 09/07/2023 19:51

@Createausername1970 I suspect that you’ve not been given the full picture. I work in child protection and cannot imagine police prosecuting a consensual sexual relationship between two teenagers in year 11 and year 13. There are highly likely to be other aggravating factors there. They don’t use the age of consent to prosecute consensual sex between young people of similar ages. For it to get to prosecution and sex offenders register then I’d guess that there is an issue around consent, whether that’s capacity (intoxication, SEND, other vulnerability that makes the younger girl less able to consent) or position of power (e.g. the 18 year old being employed by the school/ volunteering at a club etc.).

lljkk · 09/07/2023 19:49

yabu

bellac11 · 09/07/2023 19:43

Createausername1970 · 09/07/2023 19:39

I like this idea.

And also make the sex offence laws in line with this. I am aware of a 18 year old boy who, so I am told, ended up on the sex offenders register for having sex with a 15 year old. She was a summer born, all her friends were 16, she told boy she was 16.

If this is true, a 18 year old is not exactly a sexual predator by having sex with a girl he thought was 16.

In my experience that would only turn out like that if the girl later said, I didnt consent properly/at all/was coerced and pushed a prosecution

The police really are not interested (and shouldnt be) in 15 year olds having sex with their 18 year old partners.

bellac11 · 09/07/2023 19:41

There are lots of countries who have the law whereby at 15, its not illegal if the person is 2 years older, or at 17, if the other person is 2 years younger etc etc

So it can be done.

There wont be any perfect law, there will always be anomalies or loop holes but at the moment it doesnt make sense for a 15 year old with a 17 year old is considered as not being able to give consent when of course they can and do and the police wont be interested a peep if its reported as consensual.

Createausername1970 · 09/07/2023 19:39

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/07/2023 19:29

No. Instead I would put in much stricter rules about age gaps, e.g. two 15 year olds could be legal, a 30 year old and a 17 year old should not be legal. And much better education about needing enthusiastic consent, not just the lack of a "no".

I like this idea.

And also make the sex offence laws in line with this. I am aware of a 18 year old boy who, so I am told, ended up on the sex offenders register for having sex with a 15 year old. She was a summer born, all her friends were 16, she told boy she was 16.

If this is true, a 18 year old is not exactly a sexual predator by having sex with a girl he thought was 16.

CoalCraft · 09/07/2023 19:38

Personally I think there's nothing wrong with two 16/17 year olds having sex, but a 16 yo and a 35 yo? No. So I'd say the law should be that 16/17 year olds can have sex, but with someone no more than 3 years older than themselves.

Takoneko · 09/07/2023 19:37

The age of consent is not about policing teenagers having sex with one another. Its purpose is to protect children from predatory adults. I agree with raising it to 18. At the moment any person under 18 is subject to child protection laws, despite being over the age of consent. It creates a weird legal grey area and confusion in the minds of the public.

There are lots of situations in which sexual relationships with 16 and 17 year olds can already be considered illegal and prosecute. Making the age of consent 18 would be much more logical and clearer. That doesn’t mean we would start prosecuting 19 year olds having sex with 17 year olds. Just like we don’t currently prosecute 17 year olds who have sex with 15 year olds.

The law should protect 16 and 17 year old children from predatory adults who are at a significantly different developmental stage to them. They are still children and deserve the same protection as 15 year olds. It isn’t about banning them from sex with similarly aged children and young adults.

Ponderingwindow · 09/07/2023 19:36

The age of consent for sexual contact should be relative. While it isn’t ideal for two 14 year olds to have sex, it should not be illegal. It also shouldn’t be illegal for two 17 year olds to have sex. Yet it absolutely should be illegal for a 50 year old to have sexual contact with either a 14 or a 17 year old.

the problem isn’t just age, it is a difference in maturity and power in the relationship.

if I were writing the law I would allow for an age window for minors for consent and only allow open consent when all parties are 18+.

enemaofthestate · 09/07/2023 19:33

firef1y · 09/07/2023 19:20

Well seeing as teenagers under the age of 16 are having sex and having babies what good do you really think changing the age of consent to 18 would be???

All it would mean is that there are even more People having underage sex

But what about older adults with younger people?

How can it be illegal for a 50-year-old man to possess an indecent photo of a 17-year-old girl… yet okay for him to be in a sexual relationship with the very same girl?

If we regard the first one as wrong then why not the second?

That is more what I’m thinking of rather than younger teens sleeping with each other.

OP posts:
EsmeSusanOgg · 09/07/2023 19:31

The age of consent was always more about protecting young people from predatory adults, rather than normal teenage experimentation with peers. I wonder how that could be reflected in law. Two 17 year olds messing about is normal. But a 35 year old sleeping with a 16 year old is all kinds of ick.

AndTheSurveySays · 09/07/2023 19:30

It's not about degreasing teenage sex but about putting barriers in place to stop grown adults having sex with under 18s.

DrPsy · 09/07/2023 19:29

Yes, I agree OP

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/07/2023 19:29

No. Instead I would put in much stricter rules about age gaps, e.g. two 15 year olds could be legal, a 30 year old and a 17 year old should not be legal. And much better education about needing enthusiastic consent, not just the lack of a "no".

Hankunamatata · 09/07/2023 19:28

Increasing legal age won't stop teens having sex