Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paternal leave for undeserving man

258 replies

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 20:29

So, I often read these and think. “that can’t be true, it’s too unreasonable” but that REALLY IS the case here, or so I believe. Let me know if im
wrong.

I’ll not messaging to bitch or moan (however if you guys say I am being unreasonable then I’ll shut up about it!), more to get advice on what I need to do to draw attention to it.

Also, I never understand all the acronyms on here so if I do anything wrong I apologise!

Here goes…. I gave birth to a baby girl in Feb. It was after a brief 3 month fling with a guy. Didn’t go anywhere. No dramas. Informed him we were pregnant at 12 weeks and agreed to try to parent together (however he lives in Brighton, I’m in Manchester). I knew it would be me doing the work. No issues with that, just wanted my daughter to know who her dad is.

So…he works for NatWest, who, in Jan 2023, have given all men 6 months full pay paternity. Don’t get me wrong. This is a good thing for families and I totally support it. However, the father of my child is not here, he is not helping us on a day to day basis, he’s out on the beach with his mates having a whale of a summer at the expense of NatWest. Believe it or not, he has never asked me for my MAT B1, or the birth certificate, so I’ve no idea how NatWest even know he has a child!

It just seems like a crazy thing for a company to afford rights to their male colleagues that, I’m pretty sure their female colleagues don’t get (I’m sure they have to waddle in to HR with their MAT B1 to get Mat pay!)

I don’t know who to speak to to try to get them to look at this. I’m happy for parents to have the right to parental leave and I think it’s important for men to have this to support their families. But to allow anyone who “knocks up a girl” and refuses to take responsibility to also take 6 months full pay, plus accrued holiday, and a phased return to work, is an absolute abuse and a slap in the face to all of us that cope as single parents on Statutory Maternity!!!

I just don’t know what to do about what I feel is a complete injustice and a p** take of an important change in policy that should benefit families.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Doggymummar · 08/07/2023 21:58

I live in Brighton, just wondering what he is going to do when he is asked to bring the baby in?

tourdefrance · 08/07/2023 21:58

I would be tempted to inform NatWest HR department anonymously and without naming him.
So querying why paternity leave is available without the father having to supply any proof (eg matb1 certificate) as you are aware of an individual who has taken advantage of this policy while not living with the mother and suggest this policy is reviewed.

you are unlikely to get a reply but may make some people think.

minou123 · 08/07/2023 21:57

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:40

Thankyou! I think people think I’m just being bitter on here. I’m not! Just drawing attention to what feels unjust to women

No, I don't think you are bitter at all.

I get what you are trying to say.

Its mad when you think about it.
Women have to provide evidence, proof, documents, to prove they are having a baby, to claim Maternity Leave
Whereas all men have to do is just say/tick a box "im caring for a baby", and they get Paternity leave.

This isnt something I had realised before.

dinoice · 08/07/2023 21:52

I have only read your posts OP and will go back, so apologies if repeating.

How much if at all does he see her?

How do you know the terms of his leave?

Had he told you?

Whilst I absolutely agree with your outrage, I'm also cynical at the basis of it.

Six months sick pay? Stressed at new baby and no, and or little contact?

Sabbatical?

Career break?

Holiday bonus?

If he specifically told you I am on six months paternity pay, haha. That's a bit different and I agree with you is shocking.

kitsuneghost · 08/07/2023 21:50

Granted they could say you must have been married for at least 5 years and currently live together to qualify but that would entirely be up to the company. Even at that who is policing whether the time taken is being spent down the beach/at the golf course or changing nappies.

Emmamoo89 · 08/07/2023 21:50

Yanbu x

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 08/07/2023 21:50

Sierra26 · 08/07/2023 21:45

Most companies doing this are not reducing mat leave.

It may seem so on the surface but offering men more leave isn’t actually to enhance the rights of men. Most companies are doing it to help improve gender balance at work (particularly at senior levels) and to move away from the stereotype that women have to pause their careers while men get to continue at same pace.

If a father can take more time off it enables the mother to go back to work earlier, if she wishes/chooses, which is beneficial to her career (and might be financially better if she is the breadwinner).

It’s all about providing more flexibility and choice.

I say this having just written and launched a policy like this at my work, and this was our objective.

I was just about to write something very similar, but you wrote it much better than I could. I’ve also recently helped to put a policy in place at my work too. Its ultimate objective is to benefit women. At our workplace fathers do have to provide a copy of the MatB1 though

Sierra26 · 08/07/2023 21:48

rwalker · 08/07/2023 21:43

I don’t see how companies could police this he’s become a dad so he’s in titled to it

I think this is more an you’ve had a baby with practically a stranger and it’s not working out well

Near impossible to police, but a discretionary policy like this can come with any conditions the employer wants it to have - eg confirm baby lives with you and if not explain the setup. At minimum it should say something about playing an active role to help deter the majority of potential manipulators.

MrsElsa · 08/07/2023 21:47

Definitely blow the whistle. There is no way he is complying with the HR policy there! They would be very interested to know how dishonest he's being.

But it depends if you have the CMS sorted, of course it can take ages to get the wage garnishing set up and that's arguably more important as goes to the welfare of your DC.

Blossomtoes · 08/07/2023 21:46

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:40

Thankyou! I think people think I’m just being bitter on here. I’m not! Just drawing attention to what feels unjust to women

But it’s not unjust to women. No woman is being affected by it, not even you because he was never going to step up and be any kind of father, was he?

Sierra26 · 08/07/2023 21:45

Kingdedede · 08/07/2023 21:12

I’m pretty sure that in order to cover the costs of the paternity leave the maternity pay was cut there to cover the costs so once again women lose out for men’s ‘rights’.

Most companies doing this are not reducing mat leave.

It may seem so on the surface but offering men more leave isn’t actually to enhance the rights of men. Most companies are doing it to help improve gender balance at work (particularly at senior levels) and to move away from the stereotype that women have to pause their careers while men get to continue at same pace.

If a father can take more time off it enables the mother to go back to work earlier, if she wishes/chooses, which is beneficial to her career (and might be financially better if she is the breadwinner).

It’s all about providing more flexibility and choice.

I say this having just written and launched a policy like this at my work, and this was our objective.

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 21:45

WonderfulUsername · 08/07/2023 21:41

To be honest I find your choice of language almost as crass as the father of your baby's behaviour.

"Knocks up a girl"?
"Knocks up his girlfriend"?

Either way, as crass as his behaviour is it doesn't affect you.

Agree. OP is bitter over her absent ex and that’s fair enough, but she’s focusing on dragging down a whole system which is beneficial for the majority just because she’s in a shit situation.
At the end of the day her ex having paternity leave doesn’t impact her at all, it doesn’t change her finances, it doesn’t leave her worse off, it doesn’t affect her leave. It just winds her up that he’s enjoying himself and she’s stuck with a baby, but she’s focusing on totally the wrong thing.

rwalker · 08/07/2023 21:43

I don’t see how companies could police this he’s become a dad so he’s in titled to it

I think this is more an you’ve had a baby with practically a stranger and it’s not working out well

Backstreets · 08/07/2023 21:43

You almost have to admire the brass neck of him

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 21:42

LolaSmiles · 08/07/2023 21:41

I'm amazed it's been approved because there's only so much shared parental/maternity leave that can be taken, at least that was the case when I had mine

For DH to take his leave, I had to outline when I was curtailing mine.

I voted YABU (even though he sounds like an arse) because I can't see how this has been signed off for him to take that much on full pay without you having to give up some of your leave entitlement.

It’s paternity leave, not shared parental leave.
Shared parental leave is a zero sum game in total, enhanced maternity and paternity are independent of each other.

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:42

LolaSmiles · 08/07/2023 21:41

I'm amazed it's been approved because there's only so much shared parental/maternity leave that can be taken, at least that was the case when I had mine

For DH to take his leave, I had to outline when I was curtailing mine.

I voted YABU (even though he sounds like an arse) because I can't see how this has been signed off for him to take that much on full pay without you having to give up some of your leave entitlement.

Mate…neither can I!!!!

OP posts:
WonderfulUsername · 08/07/2023 21:41

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:13

if this kind of thing is rolled out to all
companies then I find it an affront to women. Any guy who knocks up his girlfriend and refuses to take responsibility gets the added bonus of 6 months off work? I have a daughter. I don’t want her to live in that world!

To be honest I find your choice of language almost as crass as the father of your baby's behaviour.

"Knocks up a girl"?
"Knocks up his girlfriend"?

Either way, as crass as his behaviour is it doesn't affect you.

LolaSmiles · 08/07/2023 21:41

I'm amazed it's been approved because there's only so much shared parental/maternity leave that can be taken, at least that was the case when I had mine

For DH to take his leave, I had to outline when I was curtailing mine.

I voted YABU (even though he sounds like an arse) because I can't see how this has been signed off for him to take that much on full pay without you having to give up some of your leave entitlement.

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:40

minou123 · 08/07/2023 21:36

I think @Singlemum19802023 is onto something here.

I agree with the premise that just because men more leave doesn't mean women get less.

BUT actually there is an imbalance between maternity and paternity.

In order to claim Maternity, women must provide proof, such as MATB1 or a letter from thier doctor

To claim Paternity, men do not have to provide proof.
Some companies may ask men for a MATB1, but some won't.
But all companies will ask women for proof, and all women have to provide it.

Essentially what I'm saying is, men can just literally say "im caring for a baby" and that's all they have to do fur Paternity.
Whereas women, have to provide evidence for Maternity.

I hope I'm making sense 😁

Thankyou! I think people think I’m just being bitter on here. I’m not! Just drawing attention to what feels unjust to women

OP posts:
Mble · 08/07/2023 21:38

He is doing his bit for equality in the workplace. Men like him will make women seem a better bet for employers as men can potentially father multiple children throughout their working life

Mapples · 08/07/2023 21:37

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:30

It doesn’t affect me directly. However I worry that if this particular way of doing things is seen as the way to do it then it will be taken advantage of more and more by men, and I’m that vein affecting the rights of all
women, and also costing us all more money. Nat west get their money from us after all.

I mean a lot of companies don't offer anything above the legal minimum for maternity leave, I honestly can't see them clamouring to provide parental leave. A better use of energy is probably to lobby the gov to raise min maternity leave pay for all women. It does sometimes work, after tireless campaigning for example mums who have premature babies can have extended mat leave, so good luck OP!

minou123 · 08/07/2023 21:36

I think @Singlemum19802023 is onto something here.

I agree with the premise that just because men more leave doesn't mean women get less.

BUT actually there is an imbalance between maternity and paternity.

In order to claim Maternity, women must provide proof, such as MATB1 or a letter from thier doctor

To claim Paternity, men do not have to provide proof.
Some companies may ask men for a MATB1, but some won't.
But all companies will ask women for proof, and all women have to provide it.

Essentially what I'm saying is, men can just literally say "im caring for a baby" and that's all they have to do fur Paternity.
Whereas women, have to provide evidence for Maternity.

I hope I'm making sense 😁

kitsuneghost · 08/07/2023 21:35

3BSHKATS · 08/07/2023 21:14

These paternity rights have been fought for for years in order to support women giving birth. For some sperm donor to be so entitled to claim it is disgusting.

you realise there are females whove given birth who don’t get as much time off in the world with the newborns. The patriarchy strikes again. And who is the 1st to defend it, the cool girl gang

Well get your shit together and focus on campaigning for better maternity conditions instead of bitching about entitled men and the patriarchy. Him taking his entitled time off is not affecting whether a company in another country gives adequate time off for new mothers.

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:34

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 21:32

This is just a very odd stance. So paternity leave should never improve because some men are dickheads?
What about women who take maternity leave but their baby has a nanny?

The majority of men, women, and families benefit from better paternity leave. The number of men who abuse it is going to be tiny.

Your ex being shit doesn’t mean no other men should have this or that NatWest should change their policy.

Okay. Thanks for your opinion. I’ll take your comments on board.

OP posts:
Sissynova · 08/07/2023 21:32

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:13

if this kind of thing is rolled out to all
companies then I find it an affront to women. Any guy who knocks up his girlfriend and refuses to take responsibility gets the added bonus of 6 months off work? I have a daughter. I don’t want her to live in that world!

This is just a very odd stance. So paternity leave should never improve because some men are dickheads?
What about women who take maternity leave but their baby has a nanny?

The majority of men, women, and families benefit from better paternity leave. The number of men who abuse it is going to be tiny.

Your ex being shit doesn’t mean no other men should have this or that NatWest should change their policy.