Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paternal leave for undeserving man

258 replies

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 20:29

So, I often read these and think. “that can’t be true, it’s too unreasonable” but that REALLY IS the case here, or so I believe. Let me know if im
wrong.

I’ll not messaging to bitch or moan (however if you guys say I am being unreasonable then I’ll shut up about it!), more to get advice on what I need to do to draw attention to it.

Also, I never understand all the acronyms on here so if I do anything wrong I apologise!

Here goes…. I gave birth to a baby girl in Feb. It was after a brief 3 month fling with a guy. Didn’t go anywhere. No dramas. Informed him we were pregnant at 12 weeks and agreed to try to parent together (however he lives in Brighton, I’m in Manchester). I knew it would be me doing the work. No issues with that, just wanted my daughter to know who her dad is.

So…he works for NatWest, who, in Jan 2023, have given all men 6 months full pay paternity. Don’t get me wrong. This is a good thing for families and I totally support it. However, the father of my child is not here, he is not helping us on a day to day basis, he’s out on the beach with his mates having a whale of a summer at the expense of NatWest. Believe it or not, he has never asked me for my MAT B1, or the birth certificate, so I’ve no idea how NatWest even know he has a child!

It just seems like a crazy thing for a company to afford rights to their male colleagues that, I’m pretty sure their female colleagues don’t get (I’m sure they have to waddle in to HR with their MAT B1 to get Mat pay!)

I don’t know who to speak to to try to get them to look at this. I’m happy for parents to have the right to parental leave and I think it’s important for men to have this to support their families. But to allow anyone who “knocks up a girl” and refuses to take responsibility to also take 6 months full pay, plus accrued holiday, and a phased return to work, is an absolute abuse and a slap in the face to all of us that cope as single parents on Statutory Maternity!!!

I just don’t know what to do about what I feel is a complete injustice and a p** take of an important change in policy that should benefit families.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Mapples · 08/07/2023 22:40

Festivecheer26 · 08/07/2023 22:38

@Mapples oh yes definitely, but I can’t see that improving any time soon

But surely the answer isn't to hope companies remove these progressive policies? For a woman who has a decent father this could really benefit them as a family, so it does also affect women and the focus surely shouldn't be on the minority who might abuse it.

Festivecheer26 · 08/07/2023 22:38

@Mapples oh yes definitely, but I can’t see that improving any time soon

Mapples · 08/07/2023 22:35

Festivecheer26 · 08/07/2023 22:32

This exact policy has been a massive bugbear of mine recently (don’t work for NatWest but am in financial services in an area with a big NW office so have a few peers/ friends employed there). Apparently Aviva, Fidelity and Aberdeen all have similar policies.

OP I’m with you. I do get that this type of policy is ultimately supposed to help women and must be much more inclusive in the case of same sex relationships. However, the vast majority of employers are so out of step with this approach (I’d be entitled to 6 weeks full pay then SMP, men at my firm get 2 weeks pat leave, my husband’s employer also only offers 2 weeks pat leave) it just feels like a slap in the face to women everywhere else.

I hadn’t appreciated the point re the Mat B1 forms so it’s all the more galling that it’s so easily open to abuse.

I used the NatWest example to try petition my employer to review our policies but got nowhere. It does really piss me off that there are men out there working for these institutions on already very good salary and bonus packages for what they do, getting 6 months off fully paid and able to phase their return, while so many women receive very little in the way of maternity pay/ allowances. Don’t get me wrong, 2 weeks isn’t enough for a pat leave so I’m pleased for them that they are supported in taking more time out, but 6 months fully paid is an outrage.

The issue surely is that some women have crap enhanced maternity packages rather than fathers having paid time off?

Doggymummar · 08/07/2023 22:34

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 22:10

There are many jobs for banks that aren’t in branch. Banks have huge offices across the country.

Yes my partner and I work for a bank in Canary Wharf, there are no bank HQs intown that I am aware of.

Festivecheer26 · 08/07/2023 22:32

This exact policy has been a massive bugbear of mine recently (don’t work for NatWest but am in financial services in an area with a big NW office so have a few peers/ friends employed there). Apparently Aviva, Fidelity and Aberdeen all have similar policies.

OP I’m with you. I do get that this type of policy is ultimately supposed to help women and must be much more inclusive in the case of same sex relationships. However, the vast majority of employers are so out of step with this approach (I’d be entitled to 6 weeks full pay then SMP, men at my firm get 2 weeks pat leave, my husband’s employer also only offers 2 weeks pat leave) it just feels like a slap in the face to women everywhere else.

I hadn’t appreciated the point re the Mat B1 forms so it’s all the more galling that it’s so easily open to abuse.

I used the NatWest example to try petition my employer to review our policies but got nowhere. It does really piss me off that there are men out there working for these institutions on already very good salary and bonus packages for what they do, getting 6 months off fully paid and able to phase their return, while so many women receive very little in the way of maternity pay/ allowances. Don’t get me wrong, 2 weeks isn’t enough for a pat leave so I’m pleased for them that they are supported in taking more time out, but 6 months fully paid is an outrage.

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 22:23

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 08/07/2023 22:22

If it makes you feel any better, him having taken the leave might make it more equal for a female colleague who has taken maternity leave when they both in the future go for promotion.

Actually yes! That is one benefit!!!! Thanks!

OP posts:
StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 22:22

kitsuneghost · 08/07/2023 22:21

The dad could live with her and have been married to her for 10 years and still do the same.

Exactly. So should still be reported.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 08/07/2023 22:22

If it makes you feel any better, him having taken the leave might make it more equal for a female colleague who has taken maternity leave when they both in the future go for promotion.

kitsuneghost · 08/07/2023 22:21

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 22:13

Because the Dad has fraudulently taken ‘paternity leave’ (i’e to help look after/bond/help with his child) and instead, he’s sat down on a beach probably thinking “what child”, offering no help whatsoever while enjoying his full pay.

The dad could live with her and have been married to her for 10 years and still do the same.

pontipinemum · 08/07/2023 22:21

You're right he should have had to prove he was becoming a father. I'm in Ireland for my husband to get statutory paternity benefit for 2 weeks he needed my details. So the least Natwest should be looking for is the maternity form, what is to stop another fella saying he's having a baby and taking 6 months off!!

Has he spent any time with you and your daughter? Is he paying his part?

WeWereInParis · 08/07/2023 22:21

Are you sure this is happening? You have to give up your mat leave for him to take paternity leave usually - and the work need you to sign it over to him via a signed form.

A company can introduce whatever paternity (or maternity) leave they want. They can give new parents 5 years off fully paid if they decide to.
Shared parental leave is split between the mother and the father.

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 22:20

LolaSmiles · 08/07/2023 22:17

It’s paternity leave, not shared parental leave.
Shared parental leave is a zero sum game in total, enhanced maternity and paternity are independent of each other
Thank you for the clarification. Things have obviously stared changing.

Sierra26 thank you for your posts and explanation of how things are changing. This should be a step on the right direction for sex equality at work if done right and fairly.

It’s not really things changing. Maternity leave and paternity leave both predate shared parental leave the the minimum for everything is statutory. If a company only offer minimum paternity it’s 2 weeks, but if the couple want the father to have more time they can use shared parental leave. It still exists but it’s a different type of leave.

LolaSmiles · 08/07/2023 22:17

It’s paternity leave, not shared parental leave.
Shared parental leave is a zero sum game in total, enhanced maternity and paternity are independent of each other
Thank you for the clarification. Things have obviously stared changing.

Sierra26 thank you for your posts and explanation of how things are changing. This should be a step on the right direction for sex equality at work if done right and fairly.

Quiverer · 08/07/2023 22:15

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 21:13

if this kind of thing is rolled out to all
companies then I find it an affront to women. Any guy who knocks up his girlfriend and refuses to take responsibility gets the added bonus of 6 months off work? I have a daughter. I don’t want her to live in that world!

There is no way this will happen in all companies. The vast majority cannot afford it.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/07/2023 22:15

You keep saying that your not bitter, but yeah you’re bitter. This really has no impact on you or fairness to your daughter.

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 22:13

Mapples · 08/07/2023 20:59

Why though?

Because the Dad has fraudulently taken ‘paternity leave’ (i’e to help look after/bond/help with his child) and instead, he’s sat down on a beach probably thinking “what child”, offering no help whatsoever while enjoying his full pay.

Dolma · 08/07/2023 22:13

minou123 · 08/07/2023 21:36

I think @Singlemum19802023 is onto something here.

I agree with the premise that just because men more leave doesn't mean women get less.

BUT actually there is an imbalance between maternity and paternity.

In order to claim Maternity, women must provide proof, such as MATB1 or a letter from thier doctor

To claim Paternity, men do not have to provide proof.
Some companies may ask men for a MATB1, but some won't.
But all companies will ask women for proof, and all women have to provide it.

Essentially what I'm saying is, men can just literally say "im caring for a baby" and that's all they have to do fur Paternity.
Whereas women, have to provide evidence for Maternity.

I hope I'm making sense 😁

The MATB1 is needed for maternity pay, not leave. No proof is needed for maternity leave.

The proof for pay is needed because HMRC requires employers to keep it as evidence of pregnancy, as employers can reclaim SMP from HMRC. HMRC doesn't require any equivalent evidence to be kept for paternity leave (even though SPP is also reclaimed from HMRC), simply because the sums involved are a lot lower. There's a lot more potential for fraud from employers reclaiming SMP than SPP, as the most that could be fraudulently claimed from SPP is about £350.

The requirements for claiming paternity leave are actually more onerous than for maternity leave, as a father can be required to certify that they have responsibility for the child's upbringing and will be using the time to care for the child. No equivalent requirement for maternity leave.

nevynevster · 08/07/2023 22:12

I agree it seems very odd but honestly I don't think you need to worry because it's going to be awkward as hell for him when he goes back to work and everyone asks about the paternity leave and the baby and all that. He's going to have to make it up or fess up.
If the policy doesn't cater for absent parents (and may not have been something that was thought of) then he's entitled to this, however unfair.
You may want to ask him for some extra contributions towards the baby costs however, given he's not been commuting etc.!

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 22:10

Doggymummar · 08/07/2023 22:01

https://www.theargus.co.uk/news/23426513.brighton-natwest-one-80-branches-close-country/

You sure he's not been made redundant, pretty sure this is the last branch.

There are many jobs for banks that aren’t in branch. Banks have huge offices across the country.

MsCactus · 08/07/2023 22:09

Are you sure this is happening? You have to give up your mat leave for him to take paternity leave usually - and the work need you to sign it over to him via a signed form.

Has he faked your signature? If so he's defrauding the company. All very strange. The parental leave stays with the child, and it's a year all in - so if he takes six months you can only take six too. But you'd need to sign over your leave to him for him to take it

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/07/2023 22:06

It's so so odd that they haven't even asked for proof of parenting. I'll bet they don't just take womens word for it when they want mat leave

Theunamedcat · 08/07/2023 22:04

Is he even on the birth certificate? Has he seen her at all? Ever?

Dacadactyl · 08/07/2023 22:03

I wouldn't grass him up personally. I'd try to keep things on an even keel between you, give that he's your child's father.