Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paternal leave for undeserving man

258 replies

Singlemum19802023 · 08/07/2023 20:29

So, I often read these and think. “that can’t be true, it’s too unreasonable” but that REALLY IS the case here, or so I believe. Let me know if im
wrong.

I’ll not messaging to bitch or moan (however if you guys say I am being unreasonable then I’ll shut up about it!), more to get advice on what I need to do to draw attention to it.

Also, I never understand all the acronyms on here so if I do anything wrong I apologise!

Here goes…. I gave birth to a baby girl in Feb. It was after a brief 3 month fling with a guy. Didn’t go anywhere. No dramas. Informed him we were pregnant at 12 weeks and agreed to try to parent together (however he lives in Brighton, I’m in Manchester). I knew it would be me doing the work. No issues with that, just wanted my daughter to know who her dad is.

So…he works for NatWest, who, in Jan 2023, have given all men 6 months full pay paternity. Don’t get me wrong. This is a good thing for families and I totally support it. However, the father of my child is not here, he is not helping us on a day to day basis, he’s out on the beach with his mates having a whale of a summer at the expense of NatWest. Believe it or not, he has never asked me for my MAT B1, or the birth certificate, so I’ve no idea how NatWest even know he has a child!

It just seems like a crazy thing for a company to afford rights to their male colleagues that, I’m pretty sure their female colleagues don’t get (I’m sure they have to waddle in to HR with their MAT B1 to get Mat pay!)

I don’t know who to speak to to try to get them to look at this. I’m happy for parents to have the right to parental leave and I think it’s important for men to have this to support their families. But to allow anyone who “knocks up a girl” and refuses to take responsibility to also take 6 months full pay, plus accrued holiday, and a phased return to work, is an absolute abuse and a slap in the face to all of us that cope as single parents on Statutory Maternity!!!

I just don’t know what to do about what I feel is a complete injustice and a p** take of an important change in policy that should benefit families.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Singlemum19802023 · 10/07/2023 20:25

The blame! 😂😂

OP posts:
SofiaSoFar · 10/07/2023 17:44

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 15:57

I suspect you were on very dodgy ground there unless your policy was very detailed and specific.

It blows my mind that there are constant complaints about men not doing enough and not parenting their kids then, when a huge organisation introduces a policy to encourage that, there’s so much disapproval of it.

I agree.

People are falling over themselves to encourage OP to report him to his employer and it's clear that it's because they're apoplectic that a man - a bloody man! - might be getting something he may not be morally entitled to in their eyes. And remember, we don't know what their policy is so how on earth people are deciding it's "fraud", god only knows.

If it was a thread about someone claiming benefits, or was taking time off sick when they're not, there'd be reams upon reams of replies telling OP to keep her nose out and that she can't possibly know the facts, etc., etc.

But no, because it's a male (I won't say man as he doesn't appear to be much of one) sailing extremely close to the wind with his company's policy on leave - which, again, none of us here know the details of - he simply must be reported because it's somehow an appalling sleight on the whole of womankind if he gets to benefit.

And before anyone piles on with cries of "won't someone think of the poor mens!" and that I'm "an apologist" for whatever type of man would do this, I'm not in any way defending him.

He sounds like an absolute arse and is in no way worthy of being called a father if he thinks this is ok. It's fine by me if he's made to hang his head in shame live on the 10 o'clock news for his profligacy with his employer's cash, but if their policy is lacking nuance to prevent this sort of piss-taking then more fool them.

drpet49 · 10/07/2023 17:06

I find it unbelievable that a large company like NatWest would not ask for the MatB1 form. Very unlikely.

ThatFraggle · 10/07/2023 16:44

Wenfy · 10/07/2023 16:37

This is fraud. Having worked for Natwest I know for a fact that they require evidence of the baby. Seems like this guy’s manager isn’t following process. You absolutely need to report this.

Or maybe he's one of the type of men who have multiple babies, close in age with different women, and he has given A birth cert. Just not OP's.

OP would be within her rights to say, "It has come to my awareness that your employe John Smith has taken paternity leave. Though he is the father of my child born on X date, per his own request, he has not met the child or been involved in any aspect of her care. I last saw him in September 2022. I do not know if this paternity leave relates to a different child or whether your policy allows for leave to be taken by fathers who have no contact with the child, but I wanted to be sure you have accurate information."

Wenfy · 10/07/2023 16:37

This is fraud. Having worked for Natwest I know for a fact that they require evidence of the baby. Seems like this guy’s manager isn’t following process. You absolutely need to report this.

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 16:35

Naunet · 10/07/2023 16:07

Not really, paternity leave isn’t holiday entitlement.

The policies are great, but no, there shouldn’t be room for it to be abused like this.

Obviously it isn’t holiday entitlement but unless the policy is very specific, I doubt an employer would get away with doing what yours did if it went to an employment tribunal. Do you think women who take a year’s maternity leave don’t go on holiday in that time?

Sissynova · 10/07/2023 16:28

Naunet · 10/07/2023 15:51

Maternity leave is to recover from birth first of all, men don’t really have that worry, do they? Then there’s breast feeding and childcare. Men are simply there to help the mother and care for their baby as and when they can, so totally different situation.

It seems to me like this is basically becoming a reward scheme for men who managed to get a woman pregnant, no need to actually use that leave for the purpose intended, just go on a little holiday and reward yourself for how amazing your dick is.

If that was the case basically no women would be able to take maternity leave either since most babies are FF by 6 week, and men are perfectly able to look after a baby too. You also are entitled to the same amount of maternity leave if you had a baby via a surrogate and obviously recovering from birth doesn’t apply there.

Paternity leave is a reward a scheme because you now know of 2 men who abused it. Lol okay.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 10/07/2023 16:14

Blinkingheckythump · 08/07/2023 20:51

I think it's like pouring salt in the wound for you, but, women who are surrogates get 9 months mat leave despite not having the baby to care for too, so in that case it's very similar I guess? So I'm not really sure how I feel about it

Er, you do know that maternity leave is for the mother too - a pregnant woman doesn’t just “ carry” a child even if she’s a surrogate. She grows that baby from a 2 cell organism to 7-8lb of living flesh and bones from her own body. There’s no magic feeding tube going straight to the baby from what she ingests. The babies nourishment and essential chemicals needed to create bones, brains, skin, heart , liver and everything comes out brought the mothers bloodstream from the leaching out of her chemicals, fat and protein . It is a parasitic relationship . And one that biologically takes a minimum of 6 months to recover - latest research shows abdominal muscle take 2 years to recover from where they split during pregnancy. Ligaments, tendons etc can also take months to regain their strength from pregnancy hormones that make them more stretchy. Women are still entitled to free dentistry for up to 12 months after birth, as it is proven through epidemiological studies that womens teeth and gums don’t recover sufficiently for 12 months.

and then the women still has to birth that baby even if she is a surrogate . And bring a surrogate doesn’t protect her from birth injuries or c- section op’s can take months to heal from

being a surrogate doesn’t protect you from PND either

don’t be so fucking ridiculous

Naunet · 10/07/2023 16:07

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 15:57

I suspect you were on very dodgy ground there unless your policy was very detailed and specific.

It blows my mind that there are constant complaints about men not doing enough and not parenting their kids then, when a huge organisation introduces a policy to encourage that, there’s so much disapproval of it.

Not really, paternity leave isn’t holiday entitlement.

The policies are great, but no, there shouldn’t be room for it to be abused like this.

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 15:57

Naunet · 10/07/2023 15:47

I used to work in HR 10 years ago. We had a male member of staff take his paternity leave except he went on holiday rather than actually helping the mother. He was stupid enough to post pictures on Facebook. He was told the company would no longer pay for his paternity as he was abusing the system.

I suspect you were on very dodgy ground there unless your policy was very detailed and specific.

It blows my mind that there are constant complaints about men not doing enough and not parenting their kids then, when a huge organisation introduces a policy to encourage that, there’s so much disapproval of it.

Naunet · 10/07/2023 15:51

Sissynova · 10/07/2023 08:55

It isn't being dressed up as something that is supposed to help women though. Of course paternity leave is for men, why is that wrong?
Are you suggesting maternity leave is just to help men?
Men need to bond with their babies and establish a family life with a young baby just as women do.
The more places that voluntarily offer enhanced leave for men and women then the more pressure there is for statutory to improve as society progresses.
Genuinely no idea what your issue is. The actions of one man have no baring on society's need for parental leave in all forms.

Maternity leave is to recover from birth first of all, men don’t really have that worry, do they? Then there’s breast feeding and childcare. Men are simply there to help the mother and care for their baby as and when they can, so totally different situation.

It seems to me like this is basically becoming a reward scheme for men who managed to get a woman pregnant, no need to actually use that leave for the purpose intended, just go on a little holiday and reward yourself for how amazing your dick is.

Naunet · 10/07/2023 15:47

I used to work in HR 10 years ago. We had a male member of staff take his paternity leave except he went on holiday rather than actually helping the mother. He was stupid enough to post pictures on Facebook. He was told the company would no longer pay for his paternity as he was abusing the system.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/07/2023 15:20

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 15:09

Well she has to take 50% of the blame, surely?

50% of the blame for what? She had a baby, and she's now looking after that baby. What's she "guilty" of?

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 15:09

noglow · 10/07/2023 15:08

That's it..blame the woman..

Well she has to take 50% of the blame, surely?

noglow · 10/07/2023 15:08

chezpopbang · 10/07/2023 11:57

I wouldn't call it an affront to women. And maybe that woman should take a little more responsibility with her ability to have children. If you are using a dual form of contraception the likelihood of getting pregnant is near impossible.

That's it..blame the woman..

Singlemum19802023 · 10/07/2023 15:07

Actually after 12 rounds of chemo I was told I wouldn’t be able to have children so please don’t try to insinuate that i’m irresponsible for conceiving accidentally.

OP posts:
3BSHKATS · 10/07/2023 12:33

chezpopbang · 10/07/2023 11:57

I wouldn't call it an affront to women. And maybe that woman should take a little more responsibility with her ability to have children. If you are using a dual form of contraception the likelihood of getting pregnant is near impossible.

Of course it’s the woman’s fault

chezpopbang · 10/07/2023 11:57

I wouldn't call it an affront to women. And maybe that woman should take a little more responsibility with her ability to have children. If you are using a dual form of contraception the likelihood of getting pregnant is near impossible.

chezpopbang · 10/07/2023 11:55

The problem is they have to have one rule for all and this is the result of trying to give time to involved parents. It's a disgrace he hasn't made the effort to spend time with his child during this time. Not a lot you can do about it though. If you go to the company I doubt it will make any difference they can't tell him how he should be spending his time off. I'm sure people in his work will know the situation; If he's all over SM with it. I doubt they will be impressed, I'm sure there will have been private conversations about it but nothing will be done. I would just try to let it go and move on

Festivecheer26 · 10/07/2023 11:01

(not that I’m suggesting they shouldn’t cover this cost, it’s the fact that it’s taken years for women to get this level of paid leave despite the fact it’s less costly that gets me)

Festivecheer26 · 10/07/2023 10:50

@Blossomtoes they’ll be able to claim the statutory amounts for both mat and pat leave back, so they’ll get more of the cost of a mat leave covered by the gov than a pat leave.

If you look at their pay gap reporting (tried to attach a photo but can’t get it to work), women tend to occupy the lower paid roles, so the average male employee will be on a higher salary than the average female.

So, the business is covering more of the cost of their more expensive employees leave.

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2023 09:58

It seems that they’re happy to spend more facilitating pat leave for their male employees than they are mat leave for their female staff.

I’m failing to see the logic in this. Both are entitled to six months on full pay so it’s a universal benefit for new parents. Can you explain your thought process?

Festivecheer26 · 10/07/2023 09:43

@Sissynova I’m probably just taking it too personally as a female who’s worked in the FS sector for too long!

It just really frustrates me that we’ve taken a long time to get to a position where a number of employers in this space offer women 6 months fully paid mat leave (don’t know when NatWest introduced, seems to be 2021 from what I found online but perhaps someone else can confirm) but only a short while later men are getting the same. Yes it’s a good thing for those male staff eligible and their families, but the cynic in me wonders about the decision making process, especially when they are a predominantly male organisation at senior levels. It seems that they’re happy to spend more facilitating pat leave for their male employees than they are mat leave for their female staff.

As for benefitting women and society - this is cited in their press release re the policy and their gender pay gap reporting. In my view, if large institutions really want to influence culture change across the sector then they could consider things like only partnering with suppliers, advisors, auditors etc that share their family friendly values.

As I say, probably taking too much of an interest in this as an issue and have derailed the thread - apologies!

NamelessNancy · 10/07/2023 09:12

Not really the point I know but I wish this "we were pregnant" nonsense would stop. Particularly in a case like this where the father isn't even involving himself.

JayWayney · 10/07/2023 09:09

Sissynova · 09/07/2023 14:08

Men having access to better paternity leave does absolutely nothing to negatively impact woman and only positively helps individual women and society as a whole.

Better paternity leave greatly helps women in recruitment and promotion. Whilst fertile women are seen as less secure members of the workforce due to the possibility of pregnancy and the ensuing maternity leave, they are not chosen for many opportunities. Now more and more men are having paternity leave, we have more employers have less reason to reject a woman on grounds of possible fertility. Of course this happens, although no one would be stupid enough to put that down as a reason for the rejection.