Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hospital visitors 24/7 for non-native speakers

157 replies

mfhtoeh · 08/07/2023 20:25

My first AIBU but I’m curious as I think this could go both ways.

I’m in hospital on a ladies bay.
Visiting hours are 11am-7pm (minus restricted meal times).
There’s an elderly-ish lady that doesn’t speak English. She currently has 3 of her children with her (8.30pm) and her daughter and son have asked to remain on the ward with her 24/7. They asked for 2 blow up mattresses but were told no, but it was ok to stay in these circumstances.

I understand the language barrier is challenging. It also helps the nurses them being here to care for her.

However they talk alllll day and night. They don’t stop talking. The son uses the ladies only toilet etc. They also have the radio on at times.

Grumpy me just wants some peace and quiet. I want to sleep.

—

YABU - the lady needs her family

YANBU - you should be able to have privacy & peace and quiet outside of visiting hours and men using the ladies patient only toilets is unacceptable.
—

NB: She’s sick but not dying.

OP posts:
Delatron · 09/07/2023 15:19

I think that’s enough now. You have to look after yourself and get some rest. The nurses won’t help, so speak to one of them and say you’d like to speak to the Ward manager and could you also fill in a PALS complaint. They may actually do something then.

I’d be politely asking for their names and be seen writing things down.

All you are asking for is for them to implement their own rules. There’s no need to have all these people and noise 24/7z

loislovesstewie · 09/07/2023 15:12

I really don't understand this, many years ago my child was on the children's ward, A whole multi-generational family came in with a toddler, crowding around the bed. They were told that either mum or dad could stay, mum stayed the rest ,about 8 or 9 of them, went. It's just unacceptable to have s0 many people, making noise and being thoughtless.

zerofuchsgivenTBH · 09/07/2023 15:10

Do you have headphones? Access to a nice soothing audiobook? Or guided meditation.
I understand all too well how shitty thryoid issues can make you feel.

jeaux90 · 09/07/2023 15:03

I thinks it's bloody ridiculous to enable this behaviour. There are women in that ward trying to recover. The male relative needs to be told not to use the female bathroom.

I'd go above the ward Manager and you have absolutely every reason to given the disturbance and phone use.

widowtwankywashroom · 09/07/2023 14:59

Ask the staff to contact the site manager

mfhtoeh · 09/07/2023 14:57

FYI as, well, I’m bored and have nothing better to do lol

Nothing has changed. They’re still packed in like sardines and using other patients chairs. They seem to have carte Blanche to do what they like.

I’ve mentioned that it’s noisy and he’s using the toilet etc. to another nurse. No change. They haven’t said anything to them :/

It’s an acute medical unit.

They want to do another test on her, but she took meds she shouldn’t have so couldn’t do them today. She won’t give them her meds

I’m somewhat of a frequent flier on the AMU ward, usually whilst waiting for a bed on a proper ward due to lots of significant medical problems. Some of the nurses recognise me. I can’t afford to be labelled problematic.

I’ve got thyrotoxicosis / thyroid storm this time and have waves of lots of symptoms including being emotional/anxious (symptom) and am not myself.

OP posts:
crosstalk · 09/07/2023 14:52

@TheOccupier Not true. The older non-English speaking woman may be typical of a generation where women could work despite not speaking English eg Fifties to Seventies Britain where we still had cotton and woollen mills and a garment industry. Or she could be like many English-speaking women eg not a taxpayer herself but married to one just like my grandma. Or part of the 40% of UK adults who don't pay tax most of whom are native born English speakers. Or one of the legal immigrants arriving in the UK.

I still sympathise with the OP - as hospital staff have already said in PPs, sick people need rest and sleep and not have toilets occupied by the opposite sex. It could be that the only person confident enough in English is her male relative which is why he is around but there can be problems as also pointed out with an unofficial translator.

So OP needs to speak to a more senior member of staff or to PALS. At least to get the noise down, the right toilets used, a ban on alarms/loud speaker on phone/radio.

Mammajay · 09/07/2023 14:38

Greybeard. Yes I'd want a relative ..but not one who made my stay better at the cost of making other people miserable. And not more than one!!

Mammajay · 09/07/2023 14:33

This ridiculous and very unfair on you. As you are unwell,can someone complain on your behalf. I would be looking for someone higher up to speak to in person if you were my adult daughter, wife etc. Please let us know how you get on. I am feeling very cross on your behalf!

HushHushDarling · 09/07/2023 14:31

OP honestly I'd shout over the curtain. I did this, similar situation. Just said 'can you keep it down please there are other patients here trying to sleep'

Feel for you, it's shit and they're being arseholes. Hopefully she will be discharged soon. The other patients will be getting the hump too no doubt.

Teajenny7 · 09/07/2023 14:27

I have an adult DC with learning difficulties. I have stayed on wards with her. Some I have been allowed to use patient toilet as no visitor toilets. Some I have been told to find a toilet outside the ward. Rather daunting wondering around empty corridors looking for a toilet in the middle of the the night. As a menopausal women I need to pee at night. Then have to ring the bell to get back on the ward. Having spent over 3 weeks there I would have loved Dad to have been able to stay but didn't think it was appropriate. I am needed to explain things to DC in simple language and manage anxieties. Sleeping on a chair is exhausting.
I learnt a lot being fit and well on a ward.
Hope you get some rest. I would say to the Sister or Ward Manager that you need rest and the noise is too much and that you feel uncomfortable with a man there when you are trying to sleep. The whole family don't have to be there at the same time.

ohtowinthelottery · 09/07/2023 14:25

My DH has stayed on a female ward with our severely disabled DD (when she was alive) when I wasn't able to stay with her. She required 24/7 care/supervision which the hospital couldn't/wouldn't provide. Where possible they put DD in a side room but this was not always possible. No way would he have had his phone on noise or been chatting out of hours though. The family in your ward are just inconsiderate and need to be told to be quiet.

Jesseweneedtocook · 09/07/2023 14:13

The lot of them sound like inconsiderate bellends op. Of course you're not unreasonable to ask for a stop to be put to this. Not to mention that there's a bloke on the ladies only ward and using your toilet. I'm shocked the nurses haven't already made him leave. Language barrier or not this is such an invasion of your personal space and your right to peace and quiet, you're unwell too!!

wonkylegs · 09/07/2023 14:07

When my mum was in hospital at the beginning of the year, they generally allowed one of us to stay with her outside of visiting hours as she has Alzheimer's, is very difficult to understand and nearly non verbal and cannot feed herself. She was very confused by the whole experience so it was very difficult. They didn't have the staff to keep an eye on her and feed her so they were happy with this arrangement. However we were quiet, respectful and made mum less of an issue (she made a lot of noise without us, was agitated and lashed out if people she didn't know 'helped' her) we didn't stay all night generally until she fell asleep and then back in the morning.

Andylion · 09/07/2023 13:56

, the son is on his way. I said that’s loud too & he uses the toilet.Nurse shrugged & said ‘there’s a language barrier isn’t there, there’s nothing we can do’.

if the son is there to facilitate communication he can bloody well understand “use the public bathroom”.

Toadstoolfairygarden · 09/07/2023 13:48

Definitely keep on complaining to the staff- in fact I would be badgering them to do something about this!You are unwell and need rest!
It is not racist to ask people to be quiet and abide by the rules.

I had a similar situation when I was an antenatal patient- early labouring (didn't know that at the time) at 34 weeks; in complete agony and alone/scared.
The man who was accompanying his none English speaking wife watched videos on his phone all night, laughing so loudly at whatever he found so funny. I eventually shouted at 3am "will you just shut the fuck up "
You'll get to a point where you will crack and it isn't fair.

TheOccupier · 09/07/2023 13:43

Clearly a lot of people here have the privilege of not needing to rely on the NHS to keep them alive, and/or luxury of living in areas where they aren't constantly struggling to access medical treatment because the system's overloaded, in part because people with no entitlement to it abuse it. If you speak NO English at all it's very unlikely that you have ever made a significant contribution to the economy. Those who think there's no such thing as NHS tourism are woefully naive. The least these people can do is be grateful and considerate when getting excellent healthcare free of charge.

Drop the phone in the nearest water jug if it rings again tonight.

widowtwankywashroom · 09/07/2023 13:24

Don't sit there and stew, ask to speak to the site manager now.
They will be duty matrons on site who will be able to sort this out

HumanBurrito · 09/07/2023 13:15

There is a lot of scope for cultural misunderstandings in hospital and healthcare settings. It's always best to use a trained interpreter:

https://www.healthaffairs.org/content/forefront/language-culture-and-medical-tragedy-case-willie-ramirez

jotunn · 09/07/2023 13:08

Greybeardy · 09/07/2023 13:02

Out of interest, what would the gentle folk of mumsnet want if they became ill abroad in a country where they didn’t speak the local language? It’s a very much less likely scenario given that most of the world seems to have been expected to learn our language of course, but I bet quite a few of the ‘kick the rellies out’ brigade would want an relative to translate for them if it were them in hospital instead.

The hospital will be aware of the rules re translating services but you don’t need a professional translator for normal conversational stuff.

I did become ill abroad - in Italy if that matters. I spoke very little Italian - enough to ask for train and museum tickets. My friend was travelling with me and spoke a bit more. She was allowed to visit during visiting hours only and the same with my mum when she arrived.

There were some words I picked up very quickly - I rapidly learned the Italian for pain, blood, vomit, bucket and morphine but apart from short bursts of visiting time when my friend would visit and do translation I was on my own for the 10 days I was there.

Greybeardy · 09/07/2023 13:02

Out of interest, what would the gentle folk of mumsnet want if they became ill abroad in a country where they didn’t speak the local language? It’s a very much less likely scenario given that most of the world seems to have been expected to learn our language of course, but I bet quite a few of the ‘kick the rellies out’ brigade would want an relative to translate for them if it were them in hospital instead.

The hospital will be aware of the rules re translating services but you don’t need a professional translator for normal conversational stuff.

sugarrosepetal · 09/07/2023 12:49

Those who shout the loudest are the first to be heard. Start making as much fuss as possible, they'll soon get something sorted. At the very least if they are so adamant on the family being allowed to be in, they should be moving her to a side room so as not to disturb anyone else's recovery.

HumanBurrito · 09/07/2023 12:40

Also, don't use random hospital staff to interpret either. Look up the story if Willy Ramirez: an interpreting mistake by a random untrained hospital staff member left him paraplegic and cost the hospital $73 million in damages.

AlfietheSchnauzer · 09/07/2023 12:36

They probably know somebody working there. I've witnessed that happen before myself

HumanBurrito · 09/07/2023 12:29

Relying on family to interpret is bad practice. Imagine relying on a husband to interpret questions about a wife's sexual history or a child to tell thrir parent their cancer is terminal. The hospital should be providing an interpreter.